Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Gary P Chapin on July 31, 2012, 03:10:33 PM
-
Inspired by the front matter in the La Chavannée tunebook, I've been thinking about ornamentation in this trad world of ours.
http://accordeonaire.blogspot.com/2012/07/about-ornamentation-aka-twiddly-bits.html
I'd love to know what all you think. This has been an area of anxiety for me for years and decades.
Thanks,
-
I think ornamentation should be used thoughtfully, so the performer uses it for a musical purpose. The best explanation I've heard is from Stewart Hardy who says that "ornamentation should serve the groove" and anyone who knows Stu will be able to hear him saying that.
-
for wha its worth I think ornementation should be used sparingly and discretely and only when it genuinely adds something worthwhile to a tune.
Never just to exhibit a degree of technical smartarseness! (exept perhaps in the privacy of ones own dwelling!)
Theres many a cracking tune been well and truly buggered up by over ornementation.
george
-
I fully concur with George's comments, ornamentation is meant to enhance the tune and not compete with it. I have have heard players who no doubt have learnt a technically tricky ornament and then proceed to play it at every available opportunity; which is all you end up hearing. To my mind music is about entertaining and enjoyment, not a display of technique. I recently came back from an Irish music festival, where they must have had tuition of some sort because a group of players came into the pub and proceeded to play a tune they had learnt. In their midst was a guitar player, who obviously could play, and he proceeded to up the tempo till one by one the others dropped out, very reminiscent of the "bop" era. A macho display is not music, which is perhaps how some people see the use of ornaments.
On another note, I still haven't picked up a box yet, but I did manage to play my brother-in-law's Maugein, needless to say I'm hooked. Who knows, when I return from France in a few weeks time I might have one in tow; fingers crossed !
Ian
-
I would highly recommend John Kirkpatrick's DVD, "How to play the English melodeon", on which there is a whole section dealing with ornamentation. Inspiring!
-
I now find that ornamentation comes naturally to me, especially little twiddles (a la JK and other English players) and just clipping the note below (a la Saul Rose and occasionally Andy Cutting). I find it very hard to play a tune straight sometimes!
-
I now find that ornamentation comes naturally to me, especially little twiddles (a la JK and other English players) and just clipping the note below (a la Saul Rose and occasionally Andy Cutting). I find it very hard to play a tune straight sometimes!
any tips on how to make this come so naturally?
-
About the only ornamentation I've done thus far is accidentally hitting the next-door button in addition to the one I was aiming at. However, due to the nature of the melodeon this harmonises and I'm trying to make it sound like I mean to do it. :D
-
I now find that ornamentation comes naturally to me, especially little twiddles (a la JK and other English players) and just clipping the note below (a la Saul Rose and occasionally Andy Cutting). I find it very hard to play a tune straight sometimes!
any tips on how to make this come so naturally?
("you're not going to like this...") - Practice! Very little in music happens entirely by accident. *
Also, I've just noticed the "clipping the note below" thing in some melodeon players recently- not something I've ever done much.
*PS - OK, Strig's posted a felicitous exception ;D
-
been well and truly buggered up
Having been in Texas for over 10 years I really miss the British ornamented language. Makes me homesick...Y'all :(
-
I now find that ornamentation comes naturally to me
This happened to me with whistle and flute, but I'd been playing woodwinds since age ten.
I would highly recommend John Kirkpatrick's DVD, "How to play the English melodeon", on which there is a whole section dealing with ornamentation. Inspiring!
I got this sometime ago. I'll give it a watch this afternoon. Thanks for reminding me.
-
Ahem! ::) from the tune book mentioned in the initial post ;)
All the tunes transcribed in this collection have been recorded by la Chavannée
Notation has been deliberately stripped of all ornament, and of various variations. Obviously, only beginners would then play these melodies 'as written' - for [other musicians] that would be sheer nonsense. One of the great strengths of Traditional Music has properly been a constant re-birth of its underlying melodies, nourished within the format of their associated dances. Musical notation has only a small role in this. It's all about interpretation
There's a CBA player who plays Canal in October at Embraud with lots of swing (too much to my ear), Andy Cutting played it there in '97 or so - very differently from Fred with some really cute extended arpeggios at the end. I've never dared try CinO, but have take liberties with one of Chavanée's bourrée sets. "aucun probleme"
been well and truly buggered up
Having been in Texas for over 10 years I really miss the British ornamented language. Makes me homesick...Y'all :(
Know what you mean 8) What with globalisation and the internet Texans doing the Olympics here have to listen to prosaic Americanisms like " he's well Donald Ducked!" ::) as some unlucky road race sprinter "'as a nasty tumble off 'is Dick van Dyke" :o ... well, at least it make them feel in Rome :|glug
-
I think the degree and type of ornamentation depends on three things: (a) the type of music that is being played, (b) whether one is playing solo or with other musicians and (c) what sounds good to the player.
(a) The importance of the type of music can be illustrated by comparing, say, Cajun music with the dance music of the Yorkshire Dales. The former sounds flat without lots of ornamentation and just doesn't sound Cajun. The latter seems to sound best when played in the simple 'stripped down' way employed by traditional musicians from that area, such as Kit White.
(b) Employing a lot of ornamentation when playing with others can sound muddy, whereas minimising the ornamentation makes the music sound crisper and the musicians sound more together.
(c) We all hear music differently and what seems good to one person will not appeal to another. When playing solo, I think it is up to the individual to play what sounds best to him or her. If you enjoy the sound you are making, you are more likely to play confidently and well. For some people, this will involve a lot of ornamentation; for others, it may involve very little. Chacun à son goût.
-
About the only ornamentation I've done thus far is accidentally hitting the next-door button in addition to the one I was aiming at.
funny thing is that what one one person thinks of as ornementation can be seen by another as just normal playing.
I frequently 'hit the next door button' and have never considered it to be ornementation - just 'thickening the soup' a wee bit. Its particularly useful for waltzes and very particularly useful when playing at the sqeeky end!
Stinguelo - forget the 'by accident' and do it 'on purpose'!
george ;)
-
I would highly recommend John Kirkpatrick's DVD, "How to play the English melodeon", on which there is a whole section dealing with ornamentation. Inspiring!
Just got here from The Music Room. Took nearly 3 weeks. Well worth the wait though. It is excellent.
Stephen