Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Tania on August 04, 2012, 04:54:30 PM
-
Hi everyone,
I'm new to this board. I've been a casual piano player for a while, and picked up a piano accordion and was playing that for fun for a while - but it's enormous and heavy, so about a month ago I decided to buy a Hohner Panther to see if the diatonic would be a better choice of me. Here (http://www.youtube.com/user/taniawithaneye) is my YouTube page if you're interested at all in seeing my progress.
Mostly I've been learning Norteños, because it's the easiest thing to find on YouTube, as well as I've been practicing my scales.
However, I really like playing with the basses, and the Mex songs generally don't. I was wondering where I could find some other resources for playing the three-row, what other types could be transferred over? For example, I'd be interested in learning Irish accordion styles, but I keep seeing "B/C" around the forum, so I imagine the rows are B and C? Since my accordion is GCF, I'd have G/C or C/F, which wouldn't transpose the same. I'd be interested in playing one-row music, because I could play it in three keys. Anything I could learn on this thing, I'd be really interested! I really like folk music and polka and pretty much anything traditionally played on an accordion.
If anyone could point me in the right direction, it would really help out a lot!
-
Hi Tania & welcome to melnet. It might be ana idea to give us some idea of your location as there may be somebody in your part of the world able to help or advise.
I you learn the basic scale on the C row in both octaves and try a few tunes just using that row you will be able to play the same ineither G, C or F simply by doing the same thing but on the appropriate row. This is of course the basis of all one row playing although the sound maybe a bit different as most one row boxes are 4 voice and yours is only 2 voice. As to playing Irish music quite a bit of it is in G & can be done 'on the row'
Using the G & C rows would give you the same scope as a GC box that is frequently used for French music.
george
-
Thanks! Actually, I started playing with one of those toy accordions for a couple of days before I got this one, so I figured out how to do a scale in one row! Haven't learned any tunes in one row yet, though.
I'm in Chicago. There is one accordion store/repair shop in Chicago, so that's at least a good thing. Besides that, I've never really seen or met anyone else who plays one.
I would be interested in playing GC French music though. I'm sure I would be able to play any other tuning that has two rows a fifth apart; it would be transposed, but still the same song.
How do most people learn songs? I have a pretty good ear, and I know how to read music, but very slowly. I feel like notes are less important than positions on the diatonic, though.
-
I would be interested in playing GC French music though. I'm sure I would be able to play any other tuning that has two rows a fifth apart; it would be transposed, but still the same song.
Tania,
I also play GCF and play French music. You can use any of the French lesson books, Milleret/Pignol or the Trad Series, and you could approach it in two ways:
1. Treat your C/F rows and corresponding basses AS IF they are the G/C rows in the books/tablature.
Or
2. Learn on the G/C rows with one change: whenever the tune/instruction calls for a pulled F chord (and therefore pulled treble notes) you will play a pressed F bass/chord and find the pressed treble notes. Essentially this will lead you to play across all three rows during F chords.
Either way, what you want to do with that box is very do-able, and it will be a lot of fun. At the beginning, learning tunes from tablature is great because it will instruct you, indirectly, in chord and bellows direction choices, and how they relate to phrasing.
Cheers,
Andy
-
Sounds great! Sorry for my ignorance, but where would I find these instruction books and tablatures?
-
Check out the Button Box website http://www.buttonbox.com/ they have a lot of music books and tutorials.
-
For singing - work out the right hand chords and accompany, more or less as you would on guitar. As you advance you will "extend" the chords, or link them with bits of melody or scale. Basically let the song do it's thing and underpin it, trying for a light style.
The left end chords tend to be a bit heavy for song, and IMHO playing right end melody in concert with your song is 1. dull 2. actually very hard to accomplish.
In due course the knowledge of the chords hidden amongst all those right end buttons (loads on a 3 row!) will help you do things with melodies too ;)
-
I'm sorry - what exactly do you mean by right/left end chords/melodies? Right and left hand? Would you recommend playing both at the same time and singing or just one side?
Are there any good songs for beginner/intermediate? Polkas, waltzes, folk song, I don't know...I don't even know where to start looking yet. I'm going to be lurking these forums a lot.
-
Just found your Youtubes - you're doing pretty well. You are playing 2 note (tonic+note 3 of the scale) chord there already. Slip a third finger next to the second and you have standard melodeon chords - 1+3+5. They are what is set up on the left end, but you can generally play them right end more softly, ad expressively. It won't sound so TexMex - that may, or may not be what you want.
You can also experiment with notes picked from 2 or even 3 rows at a time and you will find other chords - often nice minors. Your piano should help you in this. Once you've found a nice set suitable for say C or G key .. you could sing against them. I tend to lay down a 'pavement' of chords, one per bar, and let my voice do the work. Often you can get a nice double chord effect with a rock of the bellows
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nHQ0km0JVbk
Pete Coe is a master at this - note flash stuff between verses - but much 'flatter' inside them.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wRA7zPoel2k
Liam Robinson of this parish is also well respected - a slight more melodic style
http://chrisryall.net/music/downandout.mp3 [download]
Yours truly - mix of chords and twiddles on a blues This is a taster of where you might go if you want to sing - basically it's based on chords.
Texmex is not to far away but different in style. Lots and lots of other ways to explore - depends what you like. It's a fun instrument :|glug
-
This helps a lot. I will definitely check out those videos when I get off work. I like the Tex Mex style, but it's definitely not the only style I want to play...it just happens to be the easiest thing for me to find and learn rapidly. I'd be interested in singing with the accordion, too.
Basically, I just want to be able to be at any family event and just play around. There's a program called Senor Maestro that gives all the chords, thirds, fifths, triads, and scales that you can do on the accordion. Sevenths, everything. It's hard to get used to after knowing the piano for so long, but I've actually learned a LOT more about music theory since I took up the diatonic.
-
The three-row quint system is sometimes called the "International System", for good reason.
Tex-Mex music is great, for sure (also check out some sub-species, such as Waila, Conjunto, and Norteno). But there are many other options on the three-row. Many of the Latin American traditions use the three-row. It crops up everywhere from Mexico south, and the musical styles are often very different. Three-row music also shows up in the Zydeco, and to a lesser extent the Cajun traditions. Head north, and there's a three-row tradition amongst some of the native peoples of Arctic Canada. In the same neighbourhood there are some fine players of the three-row in Quebec (Francois -- AKA "Quebecois" here --- is a good resource for information on this music). A bunch of the squeezers around Southern Europe and the Mediterranean use three-rows -- known as the "Concertina" in Portugal, just to keep things complicated. Italian and French styles incorporate a lot of three-row playing.
Finally there are the folks who are just out there on their own journeys, defying easy categorization. For example there's a bloke up in Norway called Jarle Fjeldheim who plays his own compositions, in the style of traditional Norwegian tunes, reinterpreted in a Tex-Mex manner, using an Italian three-row. Check this link: http://www.rootsworld.com/freereed/2002/fjeldheim.shtml (http://www.rootsworld.com/freereed/2002/fjeldheim.shtml).
It's a great instrument. Have a good time!
-
Or you can play it like its 3 one rows !
-
Or you can play it like its 3 one rows !
Well, you play it like three one-rows. Honest, some nights I can hear you from my house.
Sets my foot tapping every time.
-
Ive found this thread very interesting, as i think i need to open my eyes to the wider possibilitys of a three row, and be able to add variation to my playing. Nice playing Tania keep up the good work !
-
Why not stick to the " 3 one row method'' on the ADG which to me sounds great. You could then get a proper 3 row as well i.e. the one we won't mention but which gives easy access to all 12 major keys whilst only requiring the learning of 5 scales so to do! 7 keys come entirely free of charge!
george >:E
-
Thanks for opening up my eyes to new methods of playing! I'm definitely gonna try to learn some one-row songs...being able to play one-row in three keys sounds pretty cool. And it would definitely help me learn the fundamentals of the accordion. (Right now I'm blindly playing...slowly learning the fundamentals as I go along!)
Which would the 'proper' 3 row be, one that has the club setup?
-
Tania,
The club system is a whole different kettle of fish. It's a specific variant of the 2.5 row box with some peculiarities all its own, such as one button that plays the same note in both directions (gleichton). The layout was developed in Germany in the 1920s, or thereabouts, for accordion clubs to use, hence the name. The "regular" three-row system is quint tuned, and shows up in key combinations like G/C/F, E/A/D, and A/D/G. There is also the "British Chromatic" three-row in B/C/C# that George mentioned above.
Some of the folks that use the quint system, such as the Tex-Mex musicians, do a lot of cross-rowing. That is, they play tunes by jumping between the rows to find the notes of a scale, rather than pushing and pulling along the rows http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KDVpy3A-XYM&feature=fvwrel (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KDVpy3A-XYM&feature=fvwrel). They also often ditch the bass notes, to simplify things a bit.
Other musicians tend to play tunes by going up and down the rows to find the notes, as if the instrument were a one-row. That style is well suited to some kinds of music. I joked that Gypsylad can sound like three one-rows at once. That was a bit of an exaggeration. However, that on-the-row style playing gives lots of volume, and a brilliant bounce and lift to the tunes http://soundcloud.com/gypsylad/toons (http://soundcloud.com/gypsylad/toons).
It's a very versatile instrument!
-
I'd say the 'proper' variants are
1. Rows a 5th apart - ADG or GCF (by convention, outside to inside) -"natural" but many duplications
2. Rows a semitone apart - eg BCC# "British" - as per Jimmy Shand, John Kirkpatrick, George of this parish
3. French system - basically a G/C two row. Inner row is 'accidentals' = 4 missed notes + (important) A/G reversed
You can also get "French" layout in other keys - eg D/G+accs (E/D reversed) - better for UK repertoire
some 'improper' variants
4. C#/D/G - a camel as I say - but works! I also have am F#/G/C ::)
5. Pignol/Milleret G/{C but with a G#}*/accidentals (*3rd mode of A harmonic minor)
The last one is completely 'chromatic' on pull, popular in S France
.. there will be others :|glug
-
<Pedant Warning>
I'd say the 'proper' variants are
1. Rows a 5th apart - ADG or GCF (by convention, outside to inside) -"natural" but many duplications
From the outside to inside, these rows are a fourth apart. ;) They should be called 'quad'-tuned boxes not 'quint' boxes, as I often have to remind people!
</Pedant Warning>
-
A nice advantage of the 'quint' or 'quad' tuned (depends on which way you're headed) box is that you can, if desired, play tunes along the row with bellows in and out, melodeon style; or in many cases play across rows in one bellows direction for smooth passages and runs. Sometimes both styles can be blended into the same tune, which can add interest. I really like my three rows (:)
-
<Pedant Warning>
From the outside to inside, these rows are a fourth apart. ;) They should be called 'quad'-tuned boxes not 'quint' boxes, as I often have to remind people!
</Pedant Warning>
... just throw him a bone occasionally! Perfectly harmless ;D Ahem! it's the same thing ;)
D [4 scale-note interval] G [5 scale-note interval] D [4 scale-note interval] .. G etc etc
Like ::) some other things in life .. musical scales ... er, go round in circles :Ph
-
Wow...it's really interesting just how many types of button accordions there are. One problem I do have is just how many duplicates you get with the three row GCF. I understand the concept of why they're there, but after playing a piano for so long, I feel like I'm wasting space that could better be utilized. Also since there's just so many different types of accordions, it's just so hard to find tutorials online that can be transferred over to specifically the one I have. (Except all the Norteño and Tex-Mex ones). Like if I found a B/C Irish accordion tutorial, I wouldn't be able to use it.
Another style I've been looking into is Vallenato - which is a Colombian folk music on the three row that uses basses, unlike Norteño and the like.
It shouldn't be too hard to find some one row information. Looking forward to starting that. If you look at the "Elephant Gun" song on my YouTube, it's my attempt to transfer a song I know on the piano over to the accordion.
-
<Pedant Warning>
I'd say the 'proper' variants are
1. Rows a 5th apart - ADG or GCF (by convention, outside to inside) -"natural" but many duplications
From the outside to inside, these rows are a fourth apart. ;) They should be called 'quad'-tuned boxes not 'quint' boxes, as I often have to remind people!
</Pedant Warning>
Steve, I've had the same thought, but have also wondered if it has to do with the basses/chords, i.e. D/A = "fifth." (Even though that would be silly -- since a one-row box would then also be a "quint", as would most semi-tone boxes... but we have seen sillier naming conventions...)
-
One problem I do have is just how many duplicates you get with the three row GCF. I understand the concept of why they're there, but after playing a piano for so long, I feel like I'm wasting space that could better be utilized.
Thus, the Perrone system here:
http://melodeonminutes.blogspot.com/2011/04/marc-perrones-3-row-layout.html (http://melodeonminutes.blogspot.com/2011/04/marc-perrones-3-row-layout.html)
Disadvantage: you can no longer play "one row style" on either of the inside rows. Advantage: ah, Perrone!
-
<Pedant Warning>
From the outside to inside, these rows are a fourth apart. ;) They should be called 'quad'-tuned boxes not 'quint' boxes, as I often have to remind people!
</Pedant Warning>
... just throw him a bone occasionally! Perfectly harmless ;D Ahem! it's the same thing ;)
D [4 scale-note interval] G [5 scale-note interval] D [4 scale-note interval] .. G etc etc
Like ::) some other things in life .. musical scales ... er, go round in circles :Ph
Think that is exactly Steve's point:
As the box is D/G it is D [4 scale-note interval] G ie quad tuned
If it were G/D it would be G [5 scale-note interval] D ie quint tuned
-
One problem I do have is just how many duplicates you get with the three row GCF.
I wouldn't lose too much sleep on that. You probably have favourite keys on piano and there may be black notes that rarely get touched - depending on what you play. Folk melodeon is the same and a "quad" ::) GCF will probably cover all the keys (with their relative and dorian minors) for your local session. The basses will also tend to work well against right end. Should your local musicians like other keys - a different one may be better - ie a ADG here in Britain.
But if you want to "blues" your tunes, or (step further) "jazz" them, a full chromatic range or close to that is needed - but that only needs to be "on the pull" in practice.
"French" G/C/accs or equivalent => 10/12 notes on pull
B/C/C# => 11/12 on pull (think there's no pull G?)
Pignol system => all 12 are there, but you've lost "one row" play on the C row
So it depends what you want to play. For songs frankly you basically need accessible chords and to pick a comfortable key. Diatonic melodeon is always a compromise. In the end - make a strategic choice, learn it well, stick to it, enjoy :|glug
[edit] Thanks Lester (http://images4.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb57886/runescape/images/a/ac/Bone_club.png) - the word I used was "apart" ;)
-
<Pedant Warning>
From the outside to inside, these rows are a fourth apart. ;) They should be called 'quad'-tuned boxes not 'quint' boxes, as I often have to remind people!
</Pedant Warning>
... just throw him a bone occasionally! Perfectly harmless ;D Ahem! it's the same thing ;)
D [4 scale-note interval] G [5 scale-note interval] D [4 scale-note interval] .. G etc etc
Like ::) some other things in life .. musical scales ... er, go round in circles :Ph
Think that is exactly Steve's point:
As the box is D/G it is D [4 scale-note interval] G ie quad tuned
If it were G/D it would be G [5 scale-note interval] D ie quint tuned
Thank you Lester! It was indeed exactly my point.
As any fule kno, musical intervals are reckoned by the distance from the lower note to the higher note. So in the case of a D/G melodeon, the D-row is the lower of the two pitches, the G-row the higher. So we count from the push tonic button on the D-row to the equivalent button on the G-row and of course the interval is a fourth.
In contrast, anglo concertinas are, by convention, named by the lower pitched middle row first (or the outer row in a two-row anglo) moving inwards towards the higher pitched row nearest the wrist. So we have may have a C/G anglo or a G/D anglo. The musical interval between equivalent buttons on these rows is indeed a fifth.
So anglo concertinas may rightfully be called 'quint' boxes and melodeons are 'quad' boxes.
Right - going back in to gnaw on my bone now. ;)
-
I understand the concept of why they're there, but after playing a piano for so long, I feel like I'm wasting space that could better be utilized.
Also, consider that a 41 key piano accordion has...41 notes. But a 31 button Corona has 62 notes. Not quite a waste. Some are duplicates and some are favored for certain keys, and arranged in an intuitive order for the way much music (especially Folk) is structured. That is probably why many of us are attracted to melodeons. However, it would be fun to experiment with other systems, though.... :||:
-
Agree with JW entirely. My Gaillard is fair weight 4.7kg, but the Oakwood plays in G or D (need to tap into bass for low D) over 3 octaves, can get at most other common keys and all the diatonics apart from Ab (which it hates!) at festivals. I can support it's weight its on one little finger.
Try that with a PA :Ph
-
Thanks for all the insight guys! I love this forum already. :)
I know on the Reyes Forum (a popular forum for Tejano and Norteño accordion that I also lurk) they use a tab system...can I find tabs here, too?
-
Hi Tania,
I started with a Hohner Panther GCF too. Here's the link below to Bernard Loffet (French accordion maker) site homepage. Scroll down to find the link Music & tablatures for melodion (diatonic accordion) for music in standard notation and tablature on the same music sheet. Scroll down the page to have an explanation in English. Further down you'll find the tabaltures and sound files. Most tunes are French folk, but there are also tunes from Ireland, Quebec, etc.
Happy boxing!
http://diato.org/tablat.htm
-
Wow! That's so useful. Exactly what I was looking for. Thanks a lot!!
-
Seriously confused as to how to read these tabs. For the Reyes tabs, they will say G7 F3 or something, so that I know to press the 7th button in the G row and the 3rd button in the F row. Now, I get the bass buttons (A a a is A note, chord chord) and I get that P and T is push and pull, and I also see numbers, but they don't specify a row. It would make sense for a one row accordion, but if it says 76888 how do I know which row they're talking about? I have a GCF, and I'm assuming this is for GC so it would be the first two rows.
Just trying to figure this out...
-
Hi Tania,
Most of the time it's played on CF rows. For instance, 5' means 5th button, F row or inside row. 5, means 5th button, C row. But, the same fingering would sound OK also on the GC rows. Listening to the sound file will help you to figure out the tune.
No # at the beginning of the score, it's in C. One #, it's in G. In the later case, the fingering will probably be on GC rows.
Hope this helps.
-
Okay, let's see... so I'm playing Mon Amant de St Jean, (http://diato.org/tablat/108.mid) and for the first five notes, it says 7 6' 8 8 8. If I play that in C/F that makes the right sound, but transposed. If I play 6 5' 7 7 7 in G/C, it matches perfectly. There's no # so I assume it's the first one. Don't know why it doesn't match. Well, I'm sure I'll figure it out eventually.
Actually, the notes on the staff match the one I'm doing in the G/C, I just don't understand why it's off by one...unless French accordions have an extra row on top?
-
If you look at the note layouts on this forum for a two row G/C and compare it with the three row G/C/F I think it will clear that up for you. The outside row on the standard three row Hohner layout has the tonic note ( "G" in this case) on the second button instead of the third.
-
Tania, Waltzman is right.
The tonic note of each row key (G for G row, C for C row and F for F row) starts on 2nd or 3rd button. So the C note on the G row won't be the same button than on the C row.
-
Hmm, interesting. I see that in the layout configurations. Sigh...now I need to figure out a good way to do this. So far, it seems that playing it one above, 6 for 7, is working.
-
Hi Tania,
The interesting thing is that once you know the fingering of a tablature, you can play this fingering on any standard accordion, no matter the key, and it will sound right. But, the starting button may not be the same. For instance, I learned Mon amant de St-Jean on my GCF Panther, but I play it on my Weltmeister in A/D. Same fingering, but transposed.
-
That's the good thing. A lot of the Mexican songs I learned are played on FBbEb (Fa) or EAD (Mi) accordions, but I only have a GCF (Sol). There are many pros and cons with the button and piano accordions, I'm finding. With a combination of tabs and playing by ear, I'm sure I'll be playing these songs in no time.
Also, anything that can be played on the GC rows can be played with the same fingering on the CF rows, just maybe a row down or up?
-
"Also, anything that can be played on the GC rows can be played with the same fingering on the CF rows, just maybe a row down or up?"
Right. And on any accordion having an interval of 4th between the rows. So, GC, CF, FB, AD, DG, BE, etc.
-
Interesting. Thanks for shedding some light on this. Hopefully I'll learn that song soon and move on to some others. :)
-
It also helps to think of the three row G/C/F as a C/F two row accordion with a G row added. The two inside rows and the lower (closest to the floor) 8 bass buttons on a three row Hohner G/C/F are arranged the same as as two row C/F. So you can play any tab written for C/F accordion with exactly the same fingering and same basses. Similarly an A/D/G is just like a D/G with an added A row etc.
-
Interesting. Thanks for shedding some light on this. Hopefully I'll learn that song soon and move on to some others. :)
There's a lot of stuff written out for G/C/F here http://www.ggms.nl/GCFbladmuziek.html