Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: JoeTierno on November 19, 2007, 09:52:00 PM
-
Hello,
On November 1st I started playing my brand new Hohner Panther g/c/f (12 bass). I have no musical experience or access to a live teacher but I am taking an online course I found in Italy. I am a complete rookie who wants to learn Italian folk songs.
I am overwhelmed even though I've done as much research as one could expect from a novice before I made my purchase. At age 66, I'm not inclined to learn how to read music but am willing to give it a try, if necessary.
Tablature makes it easy and I was pleased with my progress on the treble side. Then I got to the bass side and the Hohner book left me in the cold when they went to using musical notation after only one page.
Here is my question: How best should a beginner approach the bass side of a 2 row x 6 button accordion? Are there some simple exercises I can follow? Is there any simple Christmas music for a beginner in g/c/f ?
I know all of this sounds terribly naive` but that would be a good description of how I feel. I want to get off to a good start and would appreciate any helpful advice.
Thanks,
Joe
Rochester, NY
-
How best should a beginner approach the bass side of a 2 row x 6 button accordion?
You could start by thinking of the 12 bass buttons divided into four square groups of four. The four nearest the floor go with the inside row, the four at the top with the outside row, and the four in the middle with the middle row. That's is a pretty severe approximation, but it should get you started.
-
There was a book by Dave MAllinson on the A D G three row
you could get that and "pretend" that you were playing in ADg or your box is in ADG or whatever works
Also lots of tabs and instruction on the reyesaccordions website discussion group but this is TEX MEX
same layout different music but good stuff
-
Joe,
There are a couple of online resources that might be worth looking at. Reyes Accordion is dedicated to encouraging conjunto and Tex-Mex music in the US South West. They're a really nice bunch of people, not too dissimilar from us, I suspect. Their "Universidad", written entirely in brilliant Texican Spanglish, can be found at http://www.reyesforum.com/ (http://www.reyesforum.com/). There's a lot of G/C/F stuff there, as well as help with various other tunings, and some guidelines for the Bajo Sexto, if you want to expand your skill set still further. It also includes such gems as periodic updates from a guy who's amassing three-row accordions for all of his nine grandchildren: a case of MAD gone sane? From a theoretical perspective Jacques "Jax" Delaguerre has a guide to the instrument http://www.delaguerre.com/delaguerre/pedagogy/3rowbacc/index.html (http://www.delaguerre.com/delaguerre/pedagogy/3rowbacc/index.html) here. His style's a bit dry, but there are useful nuggets buried in there.
Enjoy.
M
-
My apologies for not thanking all for your valid tips. I lost this link for quite awhile but promise to stay in touch. I need to find an automatic email notice within this forum to keep me up-to-date. Again, thank you for your advice.
Joe
-
Hello Joe--
Most of the non-Anglo EU sites are written primarily for GC, GC# or GCF.
There are a ton of songs that have the midi, the "dots" and often the tablature.
To me, this is an easier way than approaching Tex-Mex, unless this is only what you are interested in. Most of those guys don't even play the bass (sometimes, the reeds are removed, though the buttons stay!)
Try these, though there are many others:
http://folkadanse.free.fr/repertoi.php?tri=Date&sens=DESC
the one's labeled "facile"
http://pagesperso-orange.fr/diato-amateurs/danses_folk.htm
the tunes with one star
http://diato.org/tablat.htm#2
"the debutants corner" i.e. beginners
http://diouflo.com/francais/debutants_diato.html
in the "espace debutante"
Good luck. I also have a Panther for 3 row playing.
--Steve
-
Good on you Joe! I have started playing this year (am also quite 'old' as learners go!) and am having a ball learning my G/C Hohner. This forum is a fantastic place to get good ideas and friendly advice/criticism. I don't have a teacher or know anyone else who plays a box but mel.net enables one to be part of a learning, sharing community so no need to feel on your own. Enjoy!
-
Bernard Loffet's website has a long list of tabs, mostly arranged for the G/C box. Many of the tunes are quite nice. You can either play try to play them with the G and C rows of your accordion, or you can play them on the C and F rows, and the effect is that the key will be transposed but the intervals will be the same. If you're just playing from tab them you may be ignoring the notes on the staff anyway so this should get you going.
http://diato.org/tablat.htm#tabs
Another player (who was also a member of this forum) has a helpful website with tabs for all sorts of diatonics -- just click on the 'G/C/F harmonika' icon at the top of the page. below that link is his youtube page. You may also try contacting him, he's friendly and has lots of music.
http://www.ggms.nl/
http://www.youtube.com/user/Gerard374
Then there's durspel.com -- it's in Swedish but the music is terrific and mostly for G/C box but you can manege it on the CF rows (it will transposed as above) but still have all the necessary basses. On the contrary, you can play tunes using only the root and the 5th and you'll get a more rustic feel that works very well with some folk melodies.
Either click "Hitta låtar" in the lefthand frame or just have Google translate the page.
http://www.durspel.com/
-
Thanks for the help and links, cpsmart. However, I still am somewhat confused. There must be something fundamental that I am missing here. On the first song on the ggms.nl site (http://www.ggms.nl/gcf/pdf/05planxty%20Irwin%20gcf.pdf) the song is Planxty Irwin. It shows in the first measure a "B" note played on the the 7th button on what I assume is the outside (G) row. Likewise in the fourth measure there is a "D" note on the 5th button. On my accordion these seem to be the 6th and 4th button. Is this tab for a different setup, for example a G/C/F accordion with 11 buttons in the G row?
Thanks again for you help.
-
some setups are for fourth button 'Do' - and yours, I think Ben, is a 3rd button 'do'? Perhaps that's why?
AL
-
Thanks, Al,
Yes, I think I see what's happening. It seems like the tabs might be set up for the accordions that have G as the main row (like mine is C), having for example a row of 11 buttons on the outside in G and a row of 10 buttons on the inside with C. So, the row of mine on the outside in G is not quite the same configuration as the other. The 11 button G row has an extra button (the second on with D and F#). So, yeah, Al, that puts do (C) on the 4th button.
Seems like in TablEdit you have the option to define the configuration of the buttons on your accordion and it will make the tab accordingly. But really what this shows is it's best just to get right to reading "regular" music instead of tab.
So, how's the fiddle going anyway?
Talk to you later, Ben
-
So, how's the fiddle going anyway?
Ah..it's been nearly four days since I last fiddled! Feels like forever ;)
-
Well, don't be too hard on yourself, take your time, you've got the rest of your life!
-
However, I still am somewhat confused. There must be something fundamental that I am missing here. On the first song on the ggms.nl site (http://www.ggms.nl/gcf/pdf/05planxty%20Irwin%20gcf.pdf) the song is Planxty Irwin. It shows in the first measure a "B" note played on the the 7th button on what I assume is the outside (G) row. Likewise in the fourth measure there is a "D" note on the 5th button. On my accordion these seem to be the 6th and 4th button. Is this tab for a different setup, for example a G/C/F accordion with 11 buttons in the G row?
The tabs by this tune and other tunes on this page http://www.ggms.nl/g_c_f_harmonica.htm (http://www.ggms.nl/g_c_f_harmonica.htm) are made for 11 buttons, that is a correct conclusion. But you can use it offcourse for 10 buttons on the G row to.
There is a keyboard lay out on the same page, which give you the answer, but you have to understand a little bit dutch to find it: It is called "toetsenschema" .
And thanks cpsmart for youre wise words ;)
-
Hello Joe--
You are going to drive yourself crazy with tabs.
For "most" 2 rows and "most" continental style 3 rows you might get tabs to work for you.
But with the Corona layout, the tab numbers (more often than not) will not line up.
I got a great headstart on the DG with Mally's book (where the tabs work fine) and then made a chart so I could "read" musical dots. I can send it to you if you want to try it.
-
Thanks again for your advice, guys. Yeah, it's all coming clearer and I think the thing to do is just forget about the tabs and go right to learning the notes.
-
Ben - I would go further and say 'forget even the notes man' - its the easiest instrument I've ever come across for playing by ear with. Think of a tune and out it will come. I never bother to read notation for melodeon, it's too slow and cumbersome. ;D
AL
'Make Music, not Paper'
-
Ben - I would go further and say 'forget even the notes man' - its the easiest instrument I've ever come across for playing by ear with. Think of a tune and out it will come. I never bother to read notation for melodeon, it's too slow and cumbersome.
This is right on a chromatic instrument, you can start on any note/key; but. on a diatonic box it is very important to know which button to start push or pull, otherwise the tune will not fit. When I gave lessons to my son, for him it's enought to tell him which button to start (push/pull) and he was able to figure out the rest by ear.
-
Hello Joe--it's not pretty but here's what I used when I started out, from the moldy archives.
-
Ben - I would go further and say 'forget even the notes man' - its the easiest instrument I've ever come across for playing by ear with. Think of a tune and out it will come. I never bother to read notation for melodeon, it's too slow and cumbersome.
I completly agree with All!!
Although I have a website with 'paper' on it the site is called: Playing with the melodeon. That is what I like the most. Just play and see if there is a melody line in it. And if I got the wrong button to start, I'll try again.
Its like building a castle in the sand when I was young, just forget time, play and have wild fantasies.
-
Just play and see if there is a melody line in it. And if I got the wrong button to start, I'll try again.
Its like building a castle in the sand when I was young, just forget time, play and have wild fantasies.
Sandcastles! That's the best way to describe playing the melodeon! :||: :||: :||: :|glug
It's a very intuitive instrument, and it rewards tinkering by ear very quickly. I play largely by ear but I found that when I was first starting out, tabs (like those from Gerard's site and others) were helpful in learning the fundamentals of cross-row play as opposed to along-the-row play. They gave me an idea of how to use both rows and keep the bellows more flowing, rather than playing the box as if there were two single row instruments on the same keyboard. Also cross-row play allows use of more basses, which is a heck of a lot of fun once you know how to use it.
Cheers.
Chris
-
Try these, though there are many others:
http://folkadanse.free.fr/repertoi.php?tri=Date&sens=DESC
the one's labeled "facile"
http://pagesperso-orange.fr/diato-amateurs/danses_folk.htm
the tunes with one star
http://diato.org/tablat.htm#2
"the debutants corner" i.e. beginners
http://diouflo.com/francais/debutants_diato.html
in the "espace debutante"
Good luck. I also have a Panther for 3 row playing.
--Steve
I'm curious, I had never seen the other 2, although I have seen the diato site. You know other sites that are of the quality you mentioned for French melodeon music?
Thanks,
Steve
-
The folkadance site was new for me, thanks for that Steve.
It has a lot of music for two melodeons playing together just what I was looking for.
-
You're right Al, it's just that for some reason it's always been easier for me to go to the notes when I can't figure out the tune. I know I "should" just try to learn only by ear but you know, I don't know if realistically I'll get there.
Really, the only "should" here is to do what works for you to get to the music. I use sheet music and ear to help me learn new tunes. I get it in my head, then find the dots. Having bother the aural and visual cues really helps me. I also find Tab very helpful if it's an accurate rendition of what the player is doing. It was very helpful for me to have Frederic Paris Carnet de Bal and Rue de l'Oiseau book, with the tab. It was like having a map that tracked his fingers!
-
There's rather more to Frédéric Paris's play than rendition of fingers ???
.. and he plays music by ear .. pipes, hurdy-gurdy, flute, been seen on electric guitar
-
There's rather more to Frédéric Paris's play than rendition of fingers ???
.. and he plays music by ear .. pipes, hurdy-gurdy, flute, been seen on electric guitar
Okay, I get the growly/question-mark face ... no one stands more in awe of Frédéric Paris than I do, seriously. All I'm saying is that I found the tabs of his two accordion recordings (put out by AMTA and possibly directly approved by the man himself?) to be mind-blowingly helpful. It was a window into the playing of this guy I admire very much.
Really I was just saying that some of us find sheet music helpful and there's no shame in that. (:) Unless there is. :-X
Also, you forgot clarinet. Frédéric Paris' CD with Gilles Chabenat (hurdy gurdy) and himself (clarinet only) is a masterpiece.
-
Ah, but wait, it gets better yet!!!!! Just when you think you've got it made you find that "The C/F the G/C and the A/D melodeon has a turned fifth button on the second row. " Huh?? Well maybe the Dutch melodeons are different than the French or English?
That is correct, Ben. It is not my invention, but some years ago someone in Holland turned that fifth button on the second row. On a CF you have now a D in the push and a C in the pull. Two notes that you have normally only in direction. It is a very handy change which makes playing especially in the key of C easier. That is off course the only reason.
I see the methodology here. It's done totally to confuse the Americans so they will never be able to learn melodeon by tab and that's why they are forever doomed to listen to Lady Gaga and Justin Beiber. Tell me i'ts not so!
It is not. I can imagine that you start to laugh now, but all tabs are just made for one reason, to make it easier to play when you have none idea of the notation.
By the way I got some tabs from America about a year ago, from a steier player. I was very surprised. He has copied the layout of his buttons many times very small and on every lay out he has made some buttons black so he knew which buttons he had to use. And an arrow to push or pull.
It seems that was not his invention, later I saw this notation on a slovenian website to. http://frajtonerca.net/tab.php?d=Franc+Miheli%E8 (http://frajtonerca.net/tab.php?d=Franc+Miheli%E8)
-
I can see the humor of it, no problem.
I'll put two tunes in pdf attached. These are simple tunes to play on a GCF melodeon.
They are part of a book I made with simple waltzes for the GCF melodeon.
-
, you forgot clarinet. Frédéric Paris' CD with Gilles Chabenat (hurdy gurdy) and himself (clarinet only) is a masterpiece.
Whoops in a big way. Nor did I explicitly mention accordeon :|bl As far as I can see the Man plays "music" and it doesn't matter what's in his hands, his timing is just exquisite.
-
I'll put two tunes in pdf attached. These are simple tunes to play on a GCF melodeon.
Gerard, Your work is exceptional http://www.ggms.nl/g_c_f_harmonica.htm
Here is my method of learning tunes on a three-row diatonic accordion (ADG and GCF). Since I can more-or-less read sheet-music, I do not need button numbers. On the other hand, fingering is very important. I like Dave Mallinson's tutor book the best.
When I start learning a tune on a three-row, I first get the sequence of chords for the tune (mostly from Dave Mallinson's books). Then I work out a bass pattern: which measure/bar is push, which one is pull. In a couple of cases a bass chord is available on both push and pull: A, D, C on an ADG and G, C, Bb on a GCF, which makes possible some more efficient air control.
Then I work out the simplest fingring for the tune matching the push-pull sequence.
This is hell lot of work, and eventually I'm never sure, if the fingering is really the optimal.
Working out (inventing) a fingering for a chromatic button accordion (CBA) is much simpler, since the left and right hand are completely independent. Working out a single-row fingering (for a 10-button box, for example) is much simpler, too. Learning a three-row diatonic accordion is far the most challenging of all accordions I've ever tried.
-
I'll put two tunes in pdf attached. These are simple tunes to play on a GCF melodeon.
Gerard, Your work is exceptional http://www.ggms.nl/g_c_f_harmonica.htm
Here is my method of learning tunes on a three-row diatonic accordion (ADG and GCF). Since I can more-or-less read sheet-music, I do not need button numbers. On the other hand, fingering is very important. I like Dave Mallinson's tutor book the best.
When I start learning a tune on a three-row, I first get the sequence of chords for the tune (mostly from Dave Mallinson's books). Then I work out a bass pattern: which measure/bar is push, which one is pull. In a couple of cases a bass chord is available on both push and pull: A, D, C on an ADG and G, C, Bb on a GCF, which makes possible some more efficient air control.
Then I work out the simplest fingring for the tune matching the push-pull sequence.
This is hell lot of work, and eventually I'm never sure, if the fingering is really the optimal.
Working out (inventing) a fingering for a chromatic button accordion (CBA) is much simpler, since the left and right hand are completely independent. Working out a single-row fingering (for a 10-button box, for example) is much simpler, too. Learning a three-row diatonic accordion is far the most challenging of all accordions I've ever tried.
But....but, It doesn't have to be difficult. You can play it as a one row in three keys, or a two row. That's what I like about it. You can use all your previoulsy learned fingerings on it and then, if you want, try some techniques crossing all three rows. Very versatile.
-
You can play it as a one row in three keys, or a two row. That's what I like about it. You can use all your previoulsy learned fingerings on it and then, if you want, try some techniques crossing all three rows. Very versatile.
You are completely right. I was talking about the "try some techniques crossing all three rows" with the objective of playing perfect bass chords for a tune. This goal is straightforward on a chromatic button accordion or any accordion with stradella bass; but, it is challenging on a three-row.
There is, however, some limitation with "You can use all your previoulsy learned fingerings": this statement is true when you ignore the bass. A GCF is practically a CF extended with a G row from the perspective of bass and not a GC extended with an F row. That is, on a GCF you have no F bass pull, and you cannot play tunes on a GCF exactly like on a two-row GC.