Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Lester on October 31, 2008, 09:13:04 PM

Title: I am converted
Post by: Lester on October 31, 2008, 09:13:04 PM
After 30+ years of 1 strap is best - 2 straps are for wimps I have converted to two. After a workplace accident (*) where I hurt both wrists I am now suffering from tendonitis in my right wrist and found single strap playing really hard. As I was forced to stick with 2 straps rather than my usual 5 minute try and give up I am now a firm convert.

So brothers and sisters join the born again 2 strap cult.

*Should have sued the company but I am of an age where, as the accident was mostly my fault, I have taken responsibility
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: george garside on October 31, 2008, 09:52:57 PM
[  .

So brothers and sisters join the born again 2 strap cult.

* ]

welcome a'bord Lester!

george ( always a two strapper!)
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Tattyjacket on October 31, 2008, 11:24:29 PM
I bought a second strap about two years ago and have never looked back.

Phil
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Quebecois on November 01, 2008, 01:59:02 PM
It's like many other things in this world that work better in a pair :)

 
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Skipy on November 01, 2008, 05:07:53 PM
Pourquoi?

I can understand that if I play standing up, two straps would make sense but I'm curious to know what's the advantage when sitting? rigidity? more control?

Skipy

 

Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Quebecois on November 01, 2008, 05:44:11 PM
Stability. Two straps ensure that the melodeon's position remains the same without using the right hand for anything else but pushing the buttons.   
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: george garside on November 01, 2008, 08:07:36 PM
Pourquoi?

I can understand that if I play standing up, two straps would make sense but I'm curious to know what's the advantage when sitting? rigidity? more control?

Skipy

 



perhaps the question should be the other way round - i.e. what is the advantage of using one strap (instead of two) whilst seated ?

george
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Lester on November 01, 2008, 08:57:38 PM
Pourquoi?

I can understand that if I play standing up, two straps would make sense but I'm curious to know what's the advantage when sitting? rigidity? more control?

Skipy

More control - Tick
Less stress on you right wrist - Tick
Easier access to the extremities of the keyboard - Tick

As they say on 'tinternet Your Mileage May Vary

My 250th post, now a "Respected Greybeard"
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: xgx on November 01, 2008, 09:11:21 PM
I have two straps on all of my boxes, two when standing and two doubled over one shoulder when sitting.

In the sitting position the box rests on one knee... usually the right but I tried emulating Damien Mullane's method of resting it against the left knee... it felt awkward.

I suspect that body position is a prime consideration e.g. when I sit to play I lean forward a little and using two straps feels distinctly uncomfortable.

One or two whatever works for you  ;)
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: george garside on November 01, 2008, 10:08:29 PM
I
 
I suspect that body position is a prime consideration e.g. when I sit to play I lean forward a little and using two straps feels distinctly uncomfortable.

 

You are presumably using two fairly long straps if the box will rest on your knee with both straps over one shoulder.  It is fairly normal with 2 straps to have them adjusted so that the top of the box is about a stretched handswidth below the chin ( when looking strait ahead) and the right strap a bit longer than the left so that the keyboard is more or less under the chin. This allows the right arm to stay down your side rather than waving about in the air and the left arm can also remain down your left side exept for the rare occasions when the bellow need full extension to prepare for a forthcoming long series of push notes. left hand bellows movement is done mostly with wrist assisted by very slight articulation of elbow but no movement of shoulder. Right hand movement up & down keyboard is carried out entirely by wrist movement.  With this strap set up the box stays in exactly the same place in relation to yourself whether seated standing or doing cartwheels! ;)

george
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: xgx on November 01, 2008, 11:27:23 PM
I'm not sure about 'long' straps George... the straps allow playing when standing with a little leeway to accommodate a rag coat when the occasion demands ;)

At 6'3" and 15st I guess short straps wouldn't work for me :D

I had to extend the straps that came with the Compadre by about 8" (200mm) to get a 'comfortable' position.

Having watched Fergie MacDonald the hand movement seems to 'floating' rather than wrist action... I guess the hand position depends on style and which key (B/C; D/G etc)

The important thing is to get the box comfortable for ones self... the 'how' is down to personal preference.
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: george garside on November 02, 2008, 09:55:33 AM
 
Having watched Fergie MacDonald the hand movement seems to 'floating' rather than wrist action... I guess the hand position depends on style and which key (B/C; D/G etc)

The important thing is to get the box comfortable for ones self... the 'how' is down to personal preference.
[/quote]

agreed!  and it often takes a lot of experimenting with the adjustment to get it just right.  There probably is some difference between hand position &fingering BC & DG aalthough when playing I don't notice any real difference whether its DG, BC or BCC# - its possible that being used to a BC(C#)  I find the same works fine on a DG whereas somebody used only to a Dg may find aadaptations needed for a BC ( if that makkes any sense???)- perhaps Fergies hand is floating about on his wrist

george ;)
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Skipy on November 02, 2008, 11:03:47 AM
Quote

perhaps the question should be the other way round - i.e. what is the advantage of using one strap (instead of two) whilst seated ?

george

Well, it's more a case of, the straps provided never seem long enough, so I adapt two straps to make one longer one.

So, the reasoning behind my question is, should I invest in two longer ones?

Skipy
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: xgx on November 02, 2008, 11:12:22 AM

So, the reasoning behind my question is, should I invest in two longer ones?

If you have two straps I'd try them with a little temp modification... I used two old shoelaces to extend my straps, when I'm satisfied that I have the correct length for me, I'll make a more durable extension piece.
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Skipy on November 02, 2008, 04:13:31 PM
Quote

It is fairly normal with 2 straps to have them adjusted so that the top of the box is about a stretched handswidth below the chin (when looking strait ahead) and the right strap a bit longer than the left so that the keyboard is more or less under the chin. With this strap set up the box stays in exactly the same place in relation to yourself whether seated standing or doing cartwheels!

george

He's right you know?

I've just borrowed a strap off my other box and adjusted each as above and sure enough, it works!

Thanks George  ;D

Skipy
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: EeeJay on November 02, 2008, 07:15:37 PM
As an article of faith, I just don't subscribe that two straps are universally superior. For me, it depends on the size/weight of the box, and the style you prefer... like the thumbstrap brigade (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,937.0.html)...

To me, smaller boxes feel (and look) awkward with two straps - there doesn't seem to be enough mass or weight to keep the L/H strap on... keeps flopping down. I tend to hold the box raked over approx. 30 degrees, which rigidises it sufficiently to minimise strain on the R/H thumb/wrist/arm when pushing. Sitting down, inside RH leg does the job some of the time...

As far as D/G goes, I can "git on down an' boogie" 8) on a small box a whole lot easier with one strap - two straps just cramps my style. Likewise, that matter, for small semitone boxes, they just feel better on one strap - two straps is overkill...

However... bigger boxes behave differently, especially if the bass end is heavier. In this case, I'd advocate two straps for standing, and reduce the thumb bracing... enabling the instrument to shift right a bit - guards against the L/H strap flopping down. Despite this, the L/H strap still can slip off now and again (and no, I won't use a sodding backstrap... >:( I'm not into bondage... :D).

Regards posture... any melodeon player should heed the case of Luke Daniels - who developed bad RSI, basically from playing long periods hunched over in contorted, awkward posture... including a lot of that bracing on the far side of the left knee malarkey (like Damien Mullane does)... where the box is overbalanced... forced too far to the left... where the thumb is under constant pressure... and the unsymmetrical weight/strain is twisting the body... some young turks think it looks incredibly cool, but it's a recipe for a bad back before too long...

The key to better posture is not to play for too long in one position - change your bracing position often, and always keep the weight of the instrument balanced, whether on one strap or two. Same with the thumb... vary it... learn when to use it on the edge of the keyboard for intricate work, and in the cruck of the thumb for hammering out simpler stuff...

And yet, there are other ways... for example, stalwart musician of Trigg Morris (and cover boy for 'Cornwall Today' ;D (http://www.triggmorris.co.uk/photogal/chris%20ridley.jpg)) Chris Ridley... he plays his Corona (and Pokerwork for that matter (http://www.veteran.co.uk/images/Legg%20Vic%20(Ridley)%202.jpg)) with two straps - one anchored on each end... which, having seen Chris in action on the Corona, seem to work nicely enough, and enable oodles of bounce... on what one might regard as rather a heavy machine...

Everyone is different, and as Lester says, Your Mileage May Vary...

Ed J
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Chris Brimley on November 02, 2008, 09:43:52 PM
I agree too, having just tried the 'hand-width' rule out on my preferred playing position.   However, I've modded this slightly, because in my experience one or other of the straps keeps slipping off your shoulder, unless they are somehow prevented from doing so.  I've seen piano accordion players who get round this by having a sort of bra strap, but to my mind this is difficult to undo or do up in a hurry (in fact very much like the real thing!). So what I've done is to get a strip of double-sided velcro, and wind it round the two straps just under my chin to hold them close together.  This not only works, but it's also easily adjustable.  I thought at first this would mean that the top of the box might start to wobble, but no, it doesn't seem to.

Talking about wobbly boxes, many years ago, I devised a different way of preventing box wobble when standing up - I made a metal bar shaped like a figure 5, which clamped onto the bottom of the keyboard, and the round bit went round the left side of your waist, replacing the pressure exerted by the right thigh.  I just used one strap then, round the right shoulder. This strange arrangement really worked to make the whole set up very steady, and relieved the right hand of the need to grip or prop the keyboard - in fact you could even use start to your right thumb to play the buttons, with a little practice.  This was great for playing while standing up.

However I dropped it in favour of sitting down, or standing on the left leg with the right foot on a highish stool for various reasons:  

1. I didn't need to stand up any more when I stopped playing for Morris,
2. It started to put strain on my back,
3. The metal 5 was a bit crudely wedged onto the Pokerwork, and I wanted to take more care of my new Satarelle.

But I must admit that apart from these difficulties, it really helped my playing, and I do still hanker after the idea.  Has anyone else tried anything like this?

Chris Brimley
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: george garside on November 02, 2008, 10:38:21 PM
I agree too, having just tried the 'hand-width' rule out on my preferred playing position.   However, I've modded this slightly, because in my experience one or other of the straps keeps slipping off your shoulder,




The velcro idea sounds worth experimenting with as an alternative to a back strap to prevent straps slipping off the shoulder . I have never been comfortable with a back strap even on 120 bass boxes although many consider them essential on larger boxes.  I find that the problem is completely cured by using nice wide padded straps with cloth (? velvet) on the inner side.  I use two & a half inch wide straps on serellini & hohner pokerwork 2 row and 4 inch straps on 48 & 80 bass 3 row  boxes. As a bonus wide straps whilst obviously not reducing the actual weight of a box make it feel a  very much lighter!

george
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Skipy on November 02, 2008, 10:57:36 PM
Quote

I find that the problem is completely cured by using nice wide padded straps with cloth (? velvet) on the inner side.
 
george

Again, here I have to agree with you George. As previously stated, I tried the two strap recommendation earlier today and it certainly works for me BUT the left strap was a bulk standard leather padded, unlined strap which kept slipping off my shoulder, which became just too off putting.

I have ordered (off our hero... Theo) a pair of wide straps with velvet padding which I am sure will cure the problem, however as a temporay cure I have stuck a couple of strips of self adhesive felt padding (like you see on the underside of some ornaments) on the underside of the strap in the area that goes over my shoulder....... Hey Presto, Problem solved!!!

And, whether it's psychological or what but I'm sure my playing has improved over the last hour?  :o

Skipy
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Falseknight on November 02, 2008, 11:09:20 PM
I must admit, I'm amazed that none of the guitar strap makers have divesified to make box straps.

My basses, my electrics and my acoustics all hang on three or four inch wide multi-layered soft, leather straps.  Believe me, my basses weigh more than any box, and the weight sits in one place, unlike a box where you can shift it about.  I have no problems with comfort during long gigs.

If someone wants to start a new fashion...
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: george garside on November 03, 2008, 09:52:16 AM
to stick with 2 straps rather than my usual 5 minute try and give up I am now a firm convert.

So brothers and sisters join the born again 2 strap cult.

*

is there about to become a 'born again 2 wide strap cult'

george ;)
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: xgx on November 03, 2008, 10:10:23 AM
I watched Fergie MacD on BBC Alba last night...

two straps, sitting comfortably, amazingly relaxed style
... didn't check whether the buttons were under his chin ;)
... the straps looked to be padded and around 2" (50mm)
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: george garside on November 03, 2008, 12:38:25 PM
I watched Fergie MacD on BBC Alba last night...

 

what is BBC Alba and can it be recieved in England /wales  - if so how?- is Fergie on it regularly and/or similar bands

george
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: xgx on November 03, 2008, 12:46:54 PM
It's on Sky 168 in gaelic (subtitles) it's a bit tedious to scroll though the other 'interesting' stuff to find cool ceol such as Celtic Connection... there are others but  I can neither pronounce nor spell the gaelic ::)

Last night's prog featured artists and their pupils appearing at the Glenfinnan Hotel ... Fergie and Robert Nairn... + some cracking fiddling and great voices.
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Rob2Hook on November 03, 2008, 01:00:28 PM
Well, the other day we were a couple short of a set for one dance - so two of the band had to oblige.  Now I play two straps for everything bar Border Morris which is one strap on a Pokerwork.  I was surprised how much of the tune survived the jumping around and no fear of losing the box.  Have tried to do a rant step with two straps on and it just doesn't work!

How weird is that?

Rob.
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Bill Young on November 03, 2008, 01:32:49 PM

what is BBC Alba and can it be recieved in England /wales  - if so how?- is Fergie on it regularly and/or similar bands

george
Hi George,

BBC Alba, the new BBC Gaelic channel, is on Sky 168 and Freesat 110. The programme with Fergie was one of a series of "master and pupil" half-hour programmes, of which the last was a ceilidh featuring all of the people in the series (which included fiddle, clarsach, singing, as well as button accordion). The last programme is available on BBC iPlayer at http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b00f8521 (http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b00f8521) for the next 3 days. The Fergie + Robert Nairn programme is no longer available, but I've sent you a PM about that.

The BBC Alba programme schedules for the next week or so are available at http://www.bbc.co.uk/bbcalba/programmes/schedules (http://www.bbc.co.uk/bbcalba/programmes/schedules). There appears to be another series of music programmes starting this week (Thursday 20.30, repeated Sunday 23.30).
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: xgx on November 03, 2008, 01:39:08 PM
Thanks for the link Bill, that's saved me a lot of scrolling ;)
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Lester on November 03, 2008, 07:25:26 PM
Just got back home after my conversion and have fitted two straps to my Salterelle l'Elfique and find I can close the treble end stop with my chin (a'la Brian Peters). So another definite advantage. Mind you because the stop works the other way up (out to add the bass reed) on my Castagnari Tommy it is less useful  ???

ps On my way home from a short hol today dropped into Hobgoblin as I was passing and saw the price of a new Tommy is now £2650 which is incredible, I bought mine for £800 many years ago and it must be worth more than that still?????????????
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Stiamh on November 03, 2008, 09:07:03 PM
On my way home from a short hol today dropped into Hobgoblin as I was passing and saw the price of a new Tommy is now £2650 which is incredible

Incredible it certainly is - nearly Cdn $5000 (swoons).

The currently advertised price for a Tommy at the Button Box in the US$3315 for a Tommy (about £2100) so you'd save a few hundred quid ordering from there, even allowing £100 for shipping and insurance. But - strewth|!
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: EeeJay on November 03, 2008, 10:44:12 PM
...dropped into Hobgoblin as I was passing and saw the price of a new Tommy is now £2650 which is incredible...

How much??? :o :o :o

Bejaysus, they'll be flying off the shelves for sure! ;)

Last time I enquired at my local Serenellini dealer a few months back, his words were - 'new prices have gone a bit silly', and he wasn't kidding. And second hand prices will be all over the place... especially if the demand for uber-expensive new instruments wanes... as it probably will, at least in the short term...

Oh well, soon enough we'll be heading towards deflation - where luxury goods are way too overpriced to sell... then retailers are forced to cut...

Then there's private import... which is equally a bit of a crap shoot at the moment...

Cut-throat old world at the moment, ain't it just?

Ed J
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: EeeJay on November 03, 2008, 10:55:16 PM
Just got back home after my conversion and have fitted two straps to my Salterelle l'Elfique and find I can close the treble end stop with my chin (a'la Brian Peters). So another definite advantage. Mind you because the stop works the other way up (out to add the bass reed) on my Castagnari Tommy it is less useful  ???

Then again, on one strap, you can swing the box up and pull the stop out with your teeth... ;)

Ed J
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: xgx on November 03, 2008, 11:46:06 PM

Then again, on one strap, you can swing the box up and pull the stop out with your teeth... ;)

Ed J

or your teeth out with the stop :o :D :D :D :D :D

Plea to the forum head sarang...can we have some decent emoticons?  Please!
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Pete Dunk on November 04, 2008, 11:31:22 PM
Plea to the forum head sarang...can we have some decent emoticons?  Please!

Answer this question correctly (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1019.0.html) and you may just get lucky!  ;D
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: xgx on November 05, 2008, 12:01:53 AM
That's a tall order ;D

Take a look on MHfun for some real e'cons
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: tedrick on July 01, 2010, 06:21:13 PM
I've been experimenting with different strap systems too and have found for me that 2 straps hold the box stable the best -

the darn left side strap keeps slooping off my shoulder though, so I need a back strap to keep everything connected.

Does anyone have a recommended source for good double straps with back strap here in the states?

Thanks,
Reed
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Bill Young on July 01, 2010, 07:47:14 PM

the darn left side strap keeps slooping off my shoulder though, so I need a back strap to keep everything connected.

Does anyone have a recommended source for good double straps with back strap here in the states?

The Original Accordion Harness (http://www.neotechstraps.com/product/detail/?PRODUCT_ID=6&PRODUCT_SUB_ID=) from the Neotech range includes a backstrap. These straps are extremely comfortable. I use a set on my Paolo Soprani 3-row, though I don't actually use the backstrap - don't have the flexibility to reach round and do it up.
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Owen Woods on July 01, 2010, 09:58:15 PM
You can get backstraps that you can attach to your normal straps I believe. I'm sure that I've seen them somewhere or other.
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Anahata on July 01, 2010, 11:42:32 PM
You can get backstraps that you can attach to your normal straps I believe. I'm sure that I've seen them somewhere or other.
That's what I have for my Oakwood.
On the Saltarelle I have a pair of straps with backstrap parts permanently attached.
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: george garside on July 02, 2010, 09:14:37 AM
hobgoblin do a back strap for £9.95, the music room probably does something similer & all the major accordion dealers should stock them

george
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Guy on July 02, 2010, 09:37:11 AM
You can get backstraps that you can attach to your normal straps I believe. I'm sure that I've seen them somewhere or other.
That's what I have for my Oakwood.
On the Saltarelle I have a pair of straps with backstrap parts permanently attached.


I'd always been a bit sceptical about backstraps, but when I bought my Loffet it came with them (Bernard fits them as standard). I tried them and was a convert, as I've tried both the one-strap and two strap method for playing standing up with anything from a one-row to a three-row and never been happy without something to put one foot up on. I looked at various manufacturers/suppliers on the front page of the MelNet site, and just ordered straps for the other boxes-I can't offhand remember from which supplier, but there were several to choose from and I just picked the ones I liked the look of! They've been great, and I'll be using them at the Wekend of Dance in Chepstow this Saturday if anyone's in the area and would like to try them...I'll be the one in the red and white ice cream seller's jacket....

Cheers,
Guy
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: ladydetemps on July 02, 2010, 09:49:03 AM
Its funny I started off with as many straps as possible (could never get them comfortable) and now I prefer just the one strap, but then I usually sit down to play.
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on July 03, 2010, 12:19:16 PM
If I'm trying to play quietly (eg after SWMBO'd has gone to bed early)  :||: :|glug, I tend to use thumbstrap and "clutch", but for all else I need two.  8)
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Frank Lee on July 03, 2010, 08:58:41 PM
My preference is for two straps, adjusted so that the buttons are below my chin and the centre of the fingerboard is approximately level with my right elbow.  Never thought of the 'extended hand-width' thing, but it probably amounts to the same.  This allows me occasional use of my thumb for the lowest pitch buttons, and, more importantly for me, prevents attacks of cramp in my right thumb ball.  I use my thumb behind the fingerboard relatively rarely.

On the other hand, if looking cool outweighs any musical considerations, as when I need to impress hoards of screaming teenage fans, I dispense with the left strap, and adjust the right one so that the right-hand buttons are somewhere below my left armpit.  I also re-position my shades so they're in front of my eyes, rather than acting as a hair brace,  insert a stick of chewing-gum in mouth, and don a black trilby. 

Unfortunately I started playing far too late in life to be able to play those amazing chromatic runs whilst also using my right hand as a G-cramp. ;)

 
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Steve C. on July 03, 2010, 10:02:38 PM
I try to avoid the melodeon crunch and instead lean back in a chair.  Also, prefer to play standing.  2 straps, no question.
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: george garside on July 03, 2010, 11:34:59 PM
I try to avoid the melodeon crunch and instead lean back in a chair.  Also, prefer to play standing.  2 straps, no question.
   

indeed!
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: ladydetemps on July 04, 2010, 07:50:21 AM
melodeon crch sound like a breakfast cereal
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Steve C. on July 04, 2010, 02:20:38 PM
It does sound like breakfast cereal. Oops.

But when you watch YouTubes of some of our players, that position with legs crossed and treble end jammed in, it seems awfully uncomfortable, but necessary, if only using the one strap.

I did try it, because using one strap seems, well "cooler", but did not find it a good fit for me.

On the other hand, DTN has some YouTubes and definitely does not have Melodeon Crunch!
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: george garside on July 04, 2010, 05:39:47 PM
can anyone explain why using only one strap is 'cooler' than using 2 straps and also why some think it 'cooler' to wave the bellows around  with little control  at arms length - is it to show off who's got the biggest ( bellows  that is of course!)

george ;D
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Rob2Hook on July 04, 2010, 05:43:04 PM
We had a boat in our club called "Crunchy Nut Cornflake" - I kid you not!

Rob.
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Steve C. on July 04, 2010, 06:44:40 PM
George, the coolness thing I cannot quite put my finger on.  The only image I have that works is the image of the fully strapped in Lawrence Welk.  Two straps also reminds me of suspenders, which are also not considered cool.

But as a member of the converted, I cannot really get any advantage with one strap.
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Anahata on July 04, 2010, 06:50:46 PM
George, the coolness thing I cannot quite put my finger on.  The only image I have that works is the image of the fully strapped in Lawrence Welk.

I think association with Piano Accordions has something to do with it.
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Andy Simpson on July 04, 2010, 07:21:28 PM
can anyone explain why using only one strap is 'cooler' than using 2 straps and also why some think it 'cooler' to wave the bellows around  with little control  at arms length

You wear white socks with black shoes, don't you?.  ;D
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: GbH on July 04, 2010, 09:54:05 PM
Prompted by this discussion, I yesterday took delivery of a backstrap of my own.  For some unknown reason, Jeffrey seemed intent on pushing the strap off of my right shoulder, so that backstrap seems to have sorted that out.  Maybe I'm just not used to it yet, but doing the thing up initially seems to be a bit of a tedious exercise in unseen trial and error.  I've clearly not developed the required co-ordination for it yet.

As for one strap looking cool - well, maybe it works for some people.  However, it's going to take a lot more than a one-strap melodeon to stand a chance of ever making me look cool! 
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on July 04, 2010, 10:13:32 PM
I know that using only one strap would make me look exceedingly cool - right until the moment when I started to play! :|bl
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Sandy on July 04, 2010, 10:41:16 PM
I often start the tune with two straps but finish with one.  :|bl

I joke about the one strap style looking cooler 8) but think it's more about the feel. I have had to play a more one strap style due to a frozen shoulder and it now seems to work well but not with the heavier box. :|||:

Will have a try at the backstrap system though.

cheers
Sandy
 (:)
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Rob2Hook on July 04, 2010, 11:01:22 PM
How strange, I had a frozen shoulder - well actually both at different times.  It put paid to my dancing as I couldn't reach above knee level for a star.  By the time it eased, I was too unfit to dance and anyway I'd become involved in the band.

Funny it didn't stop me playing, but it did make me concentrate on bellows control - a lot!  Is there any connection between melodeon playing and frozen shoulder?  My mate had to give up squash when his froze.

Just a passing nod to the topic - I play my Pokerwork on one strap, mostly for border so it's all slow hornpipes.  Faster playing is easier with two straps, especially with a larger, heavier box.

Rob.
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: theSmoiler on July 04, 2010, 11:06:27 PM
Maybe I'm just not used to it yet, but doing the thing up initially seems to be a bit of a tedious exercise in unseen trial and error.  I've clearly not developed the required co-ordination for it yet.


Maybe a skill that comes easier to the females of the species, GbH?  ;)

 :|||:
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Rob2Hook on July 04, 2010, 11:08:59 PM
Maybe I'm just not used to it yet, but doing the thing up initially seems to be a bit of a tedious exercise in unseen trial and error.  I've clearly not developed the required co-ordination for it yet.


Maybe a skill that comes easier to the females of the species, GbH?  ;)

 :|||:
Have you tried putting it on back-to-front and then spin it round to the front and slip the straps over your shoulders?  :-[

Rob.
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Anahata on July 04, 2010, 11:37:57 PM
Maybe a skill that comes easier to the females of the species, GbH?  ;)
I wouldn't know, but you've certainly had more practice at it  ;D
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: GbH on July 05, 2010, 08:44:42 AM
Have you tried putting it on back-to-front and then spin it round to the front and slip the straps over your shoulders?  :-[

Well, I tried putting it on as if it were a backpack, which made connecting the backstrap very easy indeed.  However, subsequent attempts at turning it all around did not prove to be at all satisfactory.  Nor, indeed, did it look cool.  In fact, the only way I could figure out how to do make any progress was to first undo the backstrap, which, of course, proved to be somewhat self-defeating.

Perhaps the backstrap needs magnets installed at the extremities, so that the two ends will find each other, even when you can't see them?
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: ladydetemps on July 05, 2010, 08:56:44 AM
I used an peice of ribbon to tie the two straps together....there's an art in tieing a bow behind your back.
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Sandy on July 05, 2010, 09:15:12 AM
Perhaps we need an all in one elasticated strap and wear it like a crop top  :D
 (:)
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: Sandy on July 05, 2010, 09:19:10 AM
I used an peice of ribbon to tie the two straps together....there's an art in tieing a bow behind your back.

I can see a new trend of box players at folk clubs !.."would you mind tying up my ribbon?"  8)
 (:)
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: george garside on July 05, 2010, 10:43:20 AM
Andy Banksfrom Birmingham used to have an interesting strap arrangement on his shand morino.

the back strap was permenently attached to both shoulder straps,  the left hand shoulder strap was attached to the top & bottom of the box in the normal way but the right hand strap was attached top & bottom by a 'dog lead' clasp.  In effect you put the left strap on left shoulder then reached over right shoulder for top of right strap, clipped that to box & then reached round behind your back for bottom of right strap & clipped it to bottom of box.  I have never seen this arrangement anywhere else but it did work well.

george
Title: Re: I am converted
Post by: tedrick on July 09, 2010, 02:13:37 AM
I just bought a set of the neotech accordion straps from Woodwind Brasswind here in the states --

they are really nice.

I finally feel like my box is under control - no more bouncing around - my accuracy at fast tempos is much improved.

I'm using both straps and the back strap - both are adjustable, I have the left side nice and tight and it doesn't slide off like all the other 2 strap setups I've tried.

SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal