Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Frank Lee on August 26, 2012, 11:55:16 AM

Title: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Frank Lee on August 26, 2012, 11:55:16 AM
Reading the posts about Irish music under the Shrewsbury Folk Festival sessions thread elsewhere prompted me to mention an event I ran at Whitby last week.  I  had wanted it billed as a tune-swap, but it appeared as a 'session' in the programme anyway, although 'tune-swap' was mentioned in the small print.  Also in the small print were the words 'be prepared to listen, as well as play', and in the newsletter I suggested folks considered playing tunes they wouldn't otherwise play at a 'session' for fear of the backlash from others about not being able to join-in.  I had not precluded Irish music, although the format of a play-around-the-room event probably dissuaded the 'Diddlies' anyway.  Twenty musicians turned-up, and such Irish music as was played was played by a lad from Cork, and beautifully too, at a pace which allowed the tunes to 'paint pictures and speak'.  The idea was precipitated by having had to abandon a tune half way through last year, as due to the fact that no-one knew it (it was trad English - and northern too!) the inevitable (in England) conversation drowned me out.  The session resumed with 'Three-around-three' as I left.  On my way home I passed four other sessions, and as I passed three of them, the strains of 'Three-around-three' were clearly audible. Coincidence I know, but 'nuff-sed' about what the concept of the 'session' is doing to our music.  I've been attending sessions or their precursors for over 50 years now, and thought I knew most of the tunes I was likely to hear, but at the Whitby tune-swap,  about 40 tunes were played, of which I think I'd heard ten or eleven before.  And folks DID listen, and DIDN't join-in before hearing the tunes once through, and when they did join-in it was with some sensitivity.  And they DIDN'T shout across the room or even start conversations while others were playing - HEAVEN! It IS possible to achieve this! Not only this, but the regular drinkers kept quiet and listened too, and this in the otherwise noisy bar in The Middle Earth.  BTW some of my favourite music is Irish, so far as I know, but I'm 'getting on a bit' and have consigned my Irish repertoire to Room 101, preferring now to spend my remaining time promulgating my own culture.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: pbsalt on August 26, 2012, 12:27:04 PM
Sorry I missed your tune swap Frank - sounded a good opportunity to learn some new tunes. You must have had a civilised group in your session. One or two of the sessions I attended were spoilt by people with no manners especially the person who said I'll give you a Scottish and  sang "Banks and Braes of Loch Lomond" immediately after the session leader had announced that they were going to play "The Queer Fella's Scottische and before they had a change to play it.
Back on thread - I'm with you on the Irish music - thought I didn't like Irish music but some of my current favourites - Pearl O Shaughessy's & The Hunt are Irish in origin. I suspect why you hear a lot of 3 Around 3 & other common session tunes at Whitby is that the sessions are so large that playing "new tunes" excludes lots of people. In such large sessions playing new tunes can sound horrid as people try and learn them on the spot Also playing the well known tunes in large sessionscan sounf fantastic with lots of harmonues and brass accompanment etc.     
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Frank Lee on August 26, 2012, 12:43:39 PM
 I suspect why you hear a lot of 3 Around 3 & other common session tunes at Whitby is that the sessions are so large that playing "new tunes" excludes lots of people. In such large sessions playing new tunes can sound horrid as people try and learn them on the spot Also playing the well known tunes in large sessionscan sounf fantastic with lots of harmonues and brass accompanment etc.     
[/quote]

Yes I agree.  But no tune excludes me, as I'd just as soon listen as play, new tunes are food and drink to me.  Some of my best moments in sessions have been when folks have been  brave enough to attempt a tune on their own - sometimes I suspect because they thought everyone would know it - and the particular mix of the other musicians has been such as to allow the tune to be heard.  It only takes a modicum of ordinary human decency!  What kind of people are we? 
I agree with your last point too, Simon Ritchie led 'Polly put the Kettle On' (I'm sure it has a 'proper' title!) in the Radway in Sidmouth and it was a 'wake-up call'.  We all sat there realising that, actually, it is a great and very danceable hornpipe! 
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 26, 2012, 02:19:50 PM
Interesting thoughts Frank.
Having been absent from sessions at a festival for a long time, I was one of the listeners this year in the Radway, as I'm sure you might have noticed! I was amazed at the sheer exclusivity of each area's common tunes. By that I mean I was amongst some people from the other end of the country to me and they had a totally different repertoire. I found it lovely to listen to and inspiring to know there are just tons of tunes out there. Also as an aside, as I said at the time, listening to a set of Northumbrian Pipes a couple of chairs away from me was an exquisite treat. You don't get many in Devon!!!
With this localism apparent, perhaps it's only tunes like 'Three around Three' that break the localism down, possibly because it's a tune that is used in a dance by many sides so therefore it ensures a large popultion of players know it. A tune therefore that lays down a communal start for people to hopefully progress on from.

As for general chatting etc. whilst others play, well, that's just bad manners and inexcusable, especially if you've got the nerve to put the spotlight on yourself whilst you try and perform a piece, concentrate, control nerves etc. - whilst also trying to remember the tune!
Q
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Frank Lee on August 26, 2012, 03:08:04 PM

 With this localism apparent, perhaps it's only tunes like 'Three around Three' that break the localism down, possibly because it's a tune that is used in a dance by many sides so therefore it ensures a large popultion of players know it. A tune therefore that lays down a communal start for people to hopefully progress on from.

Hi Quintin,  Yes, and I actually think the "3 around 3 thing' is excellent, it shows we're all getting to grips with our own musical heritage instead of playing exclusively foreign stuff (although I dip into this too at times); but last year at Whitby I got the unshakable impression that the number of common session tunes was beginning to shrink, and although '3 around 3' was an extreme example, all the sessions, save the Irish and Euro ones of course, sounded exactly the same as each other.  The 'go as you please' session last week showed just how lovely it can also be when folks don't feel fettered by the 'session police' who they feel might accuse them of indulging their egos in 'party pieces'.  There was an explosion of wonderful 'new' - though often trad. tunes, and this was from just the 20 who turned-up!
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 26, 2012, 04:16:57 PM
It is good when people feel they can let fly with their favourite new tune just learnt, without, as you say, falling foul of the session police. In my local 'first thursday' session, there often seems to be lulls during the evening when people spontaneously play a favourite of theirs and others listen. Usually after a few lulls it then picks up again into a communal set of tunes. In many ways this is to my mind the best of both worlds - communal stuff and interludes when people can present solo tunes. I think the balance comes from the people in my session having known each other for a long time and equally like and respect their playing, whether they are experienced or beginners.
It is a difficult thing to get right though.  If someone at a session continually breaks up communal playing it can loose the enjoyment of a group of people playing together.......
Q
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Owen Woods on August 26, 2012, 04:24:55 PM
Frank - I know how you feel and that tune swap sounds fantastic!

The main problem I have is that around where I am, tunes are generally only played 3 times through. You have to start picking it up immediately to have any chance to play it, which means that the music is lessened. I'm going to try and change that this year.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Gromit on August 26, 2012, 06:01:47 PM
Interesting but what's 3 around 3 ??
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Frank Lee on August 26, 2012, 06:37:32 PM
Ukebert. - I usually play three times through and if no-one joins in, leave it at that, but otherwise a maximum of six times through. 
Gromit.  It's a dance tune,  you're almost certain to know it, if not its title!
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Graham Spencer on August 26, 2012, 07:16:35 PM
Interesting but what's 3 around 3 ??

A traditional English dance tune, also known as "Pleasures Of The Town", from, if I recall correctly, Salcombe, Devon. It must be one of the 5 most widely known and played trad English tunes, and I'd be AMAZED if it hasn't been TOTM at some point......offhand I can't recall meeting an English box-player who didn't know it!

Graham
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 26, 2012, 07:33:23 PM
Graham: didn't realise it was one of ours down here. For some reason thought it was from along the Welsh/English borders
As ever, always you're full of surprises  (:)
Q
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 27, 2012, 02:44:09 AM
This sounds absolutely wonderful. I was in Shrewsbury yesterday and got into a very competent, predominantly "English" session (to be fair, not a "tune swap") in the Wheatsheaf. The Welsh Marches aren't my normal stomp, and what with several there from Essex there were quite a few tunes I'd never heard before.  :D

I'm generally up to listen once. chord second time and have a stab at the melody third. Not here, sadly. The local fashion is to medley (sometimes brutally) after twice through. Shrewsbury's apparently famous for pushing the speed and we generally ended up about 40% faster than we started. As a traveller/collector some of my melodies are admittedly  off centre, I tried a waltz and a couple of players near me started doing nice things with it .. but when I dropped to chords (3rd time through) to give them space ..  a fiddler saw that as opportunity to blast in with a mazurka.  Nice enough tune, but wrong rhythm  :-\

So technically pretty good, musically rather weak, educationally .. well, I had my trusty recorder going.  ;)  Agreeing to swap tunes seems a great idea.  Actually - isn't it just a shorthand for "respect"  :|glug
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 27, 2012, 09:24:17 AM
" Actually - isn't it just a shorthand for "respect"  ......."
I think that's spot on Chris.
Sadly, 'respect' is under used.....
Q
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Marje on August 27, 2012, 09:52:00 AM
Q, you'd be surprised how many Northumbrian (and similar) pipes there are in this part of Devon. At our last session, the three main regular pipers were all away, and the whole sound and repertoire was different. They/we normally play a lot of north-eastern tunes as well as more general session stuff.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 27, 2012, 10:54:21 AM
Marje:
I didn't know........ I'm really surprised. They are beautiful instruments, and I listened to a lot of piping when starting English Concertina, following Ali Anderson around at festivals.
I intended on popping down on 20th but the family decided last minute to visit in-laws in Polzeath, so that was that. As said, normally mondays are practise or dancing out, so I'm normally tied up.  I'm miffed now......  :(
thanks for the heads up
Q
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Lester on August 27, 2012, 12:38:49 PM
Whilst I appreciate the general flow of this thread I don't get how if you don't agree with "The local fashion" it is them being disrespectful? A way of doing things doesn't become "The local fashion" without the tacit agreement of the locals.

As to people speeding up your tune set, if you are big and stroppy like me you just stop everyone playing by shouting and start again  (:)
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 27, 2012, 02:12:26 PM
See the other thread on Shrewsbury. Seems the burgers of that town are fairly notorious for speeding. There were more of them than me and it's best to go with the flow. Actually I lasted 2 hours and then toddled to the singaround, conveniently in same direction as the town's one remaining parking bay - where I'd left my car  ;)

"Irish content" is irrelevant in this incidentally. I'd be delighted to earn some Celtic stuff at sane velocities and indeed have several times taken the trouble to do just that. But where does one get to play it without foreign travel?  :|glug
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: forrest on August 27, 2012, 05:33:06 PM
Very interesting thread...where I live, there are no sessions. The sessions I have attended in other more populous areas are much as mentioned above.....with the advanced players running away speed wise, and an embarassed silence if someone starts an unknown tune. Your concept of the 'tune swap' is quite brilliant, Frank....it pretty much will determine who's going to show up, and they will likely be the ones, either beginner or advanced, who is willing to listen as well as play. Plus it gives everyone a chance to introduce something to the group. Ideally, the presenter should come prepared with a bit of background to their tune, and a source of where to get dots, abc's or audio/vids as well.
    One thing that does happen here occasionally (usually in the Bluegrass genre) is a "slow jam". This is usually conducted by an experienced player who has no huge ego to sustain, whereby very common and popular tunes are played slowly and repeatedly so that beginners may get their 'musical boats floating', as it were. It is strictly a learning venue, but quite useful.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Frank Lee on August 27, 2012, 06:19:15 PM
Yes, the more laid-back, yet somewhat more structured format of the tune-swap did allow folks to introduce their tunes, adding an interesting dimension to the event.  Also, the title 'tune-swap' implies sharing,  a process which is not happening if other musos are demonstrably switched-off, if not engaging in 'shouting sabotage' when anything new is played.  I don't know about others, but I'd prefer to compete with a road drill outside to a barrage of conversation.  Talking is actually a series of rather bass and monotonous musical sounds which conflict with music - with, unlike the road drill, the added irritation that it's thoughtless, unecessary and disrespectful!
As a banjo player myself I also touch on the bluegrass scene at times, and notice the more nurturing atmosphere that prevails in their sessions.  While the music may not have universal appeal, it can hardly be denied that the musicianship is usually of a high order. 
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Graham Spencer on August 27, 2012, 06:45:21 PM
.....with the advanced players running away speed wise, and an embarassed silence if someone starts an unknown tune.

H'mm... if they were as "advanced" as they think they are, they would be aware of the importance of tempo and character in any given tune, and also be able to appreciate and quickly pick up at least the harmonic structure of a "new" tune.  It reminds me of my hill-walking days, when one constantly ran across "peak-baggers" who went on at length about how many 2000ft-plus peaks they'd reached but had absolutely no appreciation of the beauty, the history and the sheer magnificence of the landscape they galloped through in order to bag an extra peak so they could sound off about it in the pub in the evening.

Graham
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: ladydetemps on August 27, 2012, 07:37:55 PM
I think the ability to play notes fast is often mistaken for the ability to play music well. ;p
Its about respect. Everyone should have opportunity to start a tune if they wish at a speed comfortable to them and that speed should be respected. Be it snail or lightspeed. And not be sped up/slowed down.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Stiamh on August 27, 2012, 08:16:52 PM
I like sessions that allow solo playing of unusual tunes, "tune swapping", chatting about the tune just played, comparing one tune with another, dissecting the differences between settings, and a bit of crack and banter, while still including robust ensemble playing of standards.

All this only tends to happen when the session is fairly small. Which is generally why I prefer sessions in private, rather than public, houses. But I like the fact that it happens naturally, without a gathering having to be declared a "tune swap" or anything else specific. 
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: forrest on August 27, 2012, 08:31:24 PM
Talking is actually a series of rather bass and monotonous musical sounds which conflict with music - 
       ;D

I think the ability to play notes fast is often mistaken for the ability to play music well. ;p
Its about respect. Everyone should have opportunity to start a tune if they wish at a speed comfortable to them and that speed should be respected. Be it snail or lightspeed. And not be sped up/slowed down.

Good point.....the tempo should be carried as started. If played at break-neck speed, and others cannot follow, it may well become a solo for the starter...then it's no longer a session, it's a demonstration... ;)  I knew of one bluegrass group that would purposely tune about 10 cents sharp when they played together at gatherings.....that way, 'outsiders' were discouraged from jumping in  >:(
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Frank Lee on August 27, 2012, 08:41:46 PM
Hmmm, I know several folks who wouldn't even notice if they were 10 cents flat! 
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Graham Spencer on August 28, 2012, 06:03:42 PM
I think the ability to play notes fast is often mistaken for the ability to play music well. ;p
Its about respect. Everyone should have opportunity to start a tune if they wish at a speed comfortable to them and that speed should be respected. Be it snail or lightspeed. And not be sped up/slowed down.

Dead right. Now if only I lived in that Never-Never Land....... ;D
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: deltasalmon on August 28, 2012, 06:54:27 PM
I think "playing fast" vs "playing rushed" should also be taken into consideration. I've heard people play at a higher BPM yet play completely in control and relaxed than someone (like myself attempting to play tunes like I hear on albums...) that tries to rush the tempo yet still playing at a lower BPM.

if that makes any sense...
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Theo on August 28, 2012, 07:22:15 PM
Perfect sense.
Any player should be capable of playing faster than they would play in public. 
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: IanD on August 28, 2012, 10:56:52 PM
I think "playing fast" vs "playing rushed" should also be taken into consideration. I've heard people play at a higher BPM yet play completely in control and relaxed than someone (like myself attempting to play tunes like I hear on albums...) that tries to rush the tempo yet still playing at a lower BPM.

if that makes any sense...

For example, the playing of Denis Pepin or Philippe Bruneau -- sounds lovely and relaxed (swing, ornamentation, all that stuff) and not all that fast, until you try to play the same tune at the same speed yourself...
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Rob2Hook on August 28, 2012, 11:57:56 PM
The only exception to accepting the given tempo is when a relative beginner - ideally only if you know them - starts to suffer that nervous lack of tempo.  The starting phrase is at a good tempo, but the easier phrases get rushed and then he/she tries to maintain a new tempo, runaway.  At our morris side's closed session, one of our beginners is still prone to this and if I jump in and restore his original pace, you can guarantee a smile and can then see his shoulders relax and he's damned good then!

Rob.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: sticky fingers on August 30, 2012, 05:58:14 PM
"Arghhhhhh" IRISH ALERT, Mr Steve Jones you accidently mentioned the word "crack", Irish for laughing and having a great time, this is an English music only debate!, appology needed!, sorry all English squeezers, Theo please can you move this entire thread to the Radway Sidmouth section of the forum, many thanks. sf.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Lester on August 30, 2012, 06:05:39 PM
"Arghhhhhh" IRISH ALERT, Mr Steve Jones you accidently mentioned the word "crack", Irish for laughing and having a great time, this is an English music only debate!, appology needed!, sorry all English squeezers, Theo please can you move this entire thread to the Radway Sidmouth section of the forum, many thanks. sf.

ENGLISH ALERT - The term crack for having a good time etc is an Northern English term ultimately derived from the Middle English crak, meaning "loud conversation, bragging talk". It was borrowed in a respelled manner - craic in the mid-20th century.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: xgx on August 30, 2012, 06:06:32 PM
appology
Would that be an ITM alert App, or the study of Apps in general  ;)
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: deltasalmon on August 30, 2012, 06:21:10 PM
Quote
"Arghhhhhh" IRISH ALERT, Mr Steve Jones you accidently mentioned the word "crack", Irish for laughing and having a great time, this is an English music only debate!, appology needed!, sorry all English squeezers, Theo please can you move this entire thread to the Radway Sidmouth section of the forum, many thanks. sf.

ENGLISH ALERT - The term crack for having a good time etc is an Northern English term ultimately derived from the Middle English crak, meaning "loud conversation, bragging talk". It was borrowed in a respelled manner - craic in the mid-20th century.

I learn something new here everyday. And not only about melodeons!
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Theo on August 30, 2012, 06:23:53 PM
Crack is also used In the same sense on Tyneside, has been forever as far as I can tell, so it is an English word too.  And anyway Irish music is just as welcome as any other on this forum.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: rees on August 30, 2012, 07:50:57 PM
"Arghhhhhh" IRISH ALERT, Mr Steve Jones you accidently mentioned the word "crack", Irish for laughing and having a great time, this is an English music only debate!, appology needed!, sorry all English squeezers, Theo please can you move this entire thread to the Radway Sidmouth section of the forum, many thanks. sf.

ENGLISH ALERT - The term crack for having a good time etc is an Northern English term ultimately derived from the Middle English crak, meaning "loud conversation, bragging talk". It was borrowed in a respelled manner - craic in the mid-20th century.

Thank you, Mr Lester Bailey. Where's the "vindicated" icon?  :P  8) (:)  :|glug

No other comments on my contribution - do none of you "English squeezers" participate in house parties/kitchen sessions?

Every day.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Theo on August 30, 2012, 08:05:30 PM
There is even an Arts/listings magazine that circulates in Northeast England entitled "The Crack". (http://www.thecrackmagazine.com/) 
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Frank Lee on August 30, 2012, 09:44:27 PM
And.      Come here me little Jackie
Now av smoked me baccy
Let wer hav a cracky
Till the boat comes in.

Trad.  Tyneside song. 
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Owen Woods on August 30, 2012, 10:10:46 PM
No other comments on my contribution - do none of you "English squeezers" participate in house parties/kitchen sessions?

Not as often as I would like :( Reason being that over the last four years, none of us have had a kitchen or a house :P Hopefully that will change next year.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Frank Lee on August 30, 2012, 10:25:42 PM
I've given-up with sessions as such, and do have the occasional evening of tunes in the kitchen - much more satisfying for me, and probably for the punters at the sessions I no longer attend!
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: rees on August 30, 2012, 10:40:03 PM
"What's the crack, butt?" is a very Welsh expression.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Sandy Flett on August 30, 2012, 10:53:30 PM
Sandy Coghill, an excellent Shand Morino player, produced an LP of Scottish dance music in the late 70s called "Just for the Crack".
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Frank Lee on August 31, 2012, 12:30:08 AM
Was playing in a pub near Skibbereen last month.  They were having a 'Pirate Competition' and wanted some 'Pirate Music' to accompany it.  I played them a few English hornpipes.  Said the landlord, "Now that's the sort of stuff we've been waitin' to hear all weekend - all we get in here's feckin Irish music" (!)
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Stiamh on August 31, 2012, 12:38:09 AM
Ah sure that's just the old Irish diplomacy at work there Frank. About 20 years ago my I was staying in a cottage deep in the wilds of Connemara. Strolling down the lane one Sunday morning I met an elderly farmer coming home from mass. We fell into conversation and when he asked me where I was from, he remarked, without any detectable trace of irony: "England. Ah, the English have done great things for this country."
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: smiley on August 31, 2012, 04:16:49 AM
Ah sure that's just the old Irish diplomacy at work there Frank. About 20 years ago my I was staying in a cottage deep in the wilds of Connemara. Strolling down the lane one Sunday morning I met an elderly farmer coming home from mass. We fell into conversation and when he asked me where I was from, he remarked, without any detectable trace of irony: "England. Ah, the English have done great things for this country."

 (:)


Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: AnnC on August 31, 2012, 07:46:54 AM
.......  I played them a few English hornpipes.  Said the landlord, "Now that's the sort of stuff we've been waitin' to hear all weekend - all we get in here's feckin Irish music" (!)

   :D had to laugh at that .... some musician friends have asked if I'll go on holiday to Ireland with them next year, they go every year and session in a pub  :||: :|glug 

      ...... one reason for the invite is that I play plenty of English, some Scottish, French, Finnish and Swedish but very little Irish other than a handful of O'Carolan's  ....... no diddly diddlies ;D  :|||:
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Frank Lee on August 31, 2012, 10:17:07 AM
Ah sure that's just the old Irish diplomacy at work there Frank. About 20 years ago my I was staying in a cottage deep in the wilds of Connemara. Strolling down the lane one Sunday morning I met an elderly farmer coming home from mass. We fell into conversation and when he asked me where I was from, he remarked, without any detectable trace of irony: "England. Ah, the English have done great things for this country."

We (Carlisle Sword & Morris) had a dance team from Dublin staying with us once.  They couldn't get enough of our music and bought several CDs.  I've also heard Irish teams booed at in Ireland, whilst foreign teams were signing autographs.  I think, like folks everywhere, they needed a change.  To refer to my original post,  I find that generally, in Scotland, Ireland and Wales, people are prepared to listen to each other's music, whatever their country of origin.  Much less so in England. 

 (:)
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Lester on August 31, 2012, 10:30:50 AM
To refer to my original post,  I find that generally, in Scotland, Ireland and Wales, people are prepared to listen to each other's music, whatever their country of origin.  Much less so in England. 
 (:)

That may well be true in your world but I think that it is probably just Irish music that is "unwanted" in English sessions I have been too. We seem to be quite happy with Euro/Scots/Welsh - any thing but Irish etc. I think it is a reaction against the whole English Plastic Paddy sessions which appear to want to exclude visitors. The view you get of Irish music from those sessions and thesession.org etc is of a heavily exclusive and rule bound cliquey bunch of bores. YMMV
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Graham Spencer on August 31, 2012, 11:44:35 AM
I am a little out of touch with the current English session situation, but I don't recall any real animosity towards non-English music; the last session I went to before emigrating had about a dozen English, two Scottish and an Irish player and a reasonable mix of music from all those - and other - origins. I have to admit that French music doesn't really do much for me, but that doesn't mean I can't listen to it and respect its traditions and the musicianship of those who play it; I do play a few Scottish and Irish tunes (mainly a s a result of being exposed to quite a lot of both in the Birmingham folk clubs and "folk dances" (they weren't usually called ceilidhs in those days) in the 60s and 70s, and while I wouldn't necessarily go out of my way to find Celtic music I'm quite happy to listen to it.  Yes, my main interest is in English traditional music, but I'll happily listen to (almost!) anything that's well played.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 31, 2012, 11:52:21 AM
I suspect Frank's connections were a result of a friend moving up and introducing Carlisle to our friends over the sea in Dublin.
When we were in Dublin in 1980, a coach trip took us somewhere beside the sea and we danced at a bar, to enthusiastic crowds who were amazingly generous in spirit and in coin. It was only when back on the bus we realised we'd just danced at one of the best music pubs in the locality, but *they* wanted to see *us* as opposed to doing their own thing. We were disappointed at missing the music but they obviously wanted to see something different.
It was on that tour I made friends with an amazing fiddler, who also disliked the 'diddly diddly' stuff commonly considered as Irish tunes. His repertoire was far more varied, beautiful in fact, and much more laid back. His opinion was the 'diddly' tunes were merely functional for dances, and preferred not to play them. It sounds similar to anlej's experiences.

Maybe in answer to Frank's comment about being less tolerant in English sessions is that perhaps we are still trying to re-establish our traditional music, since the revival of the '70's and so feel more protective of 'our' tunes and less tolerant ( or maybe feeling threatened by? ) other tunes.
At our local monthly sessions, common tunes from France/Sweden/Europe do get tossed into the mix and played with vigour and enjoyment, without adverse comments so perhaps the barriers, if they exist, are breaking down.

....and I sympathise with Lester's comment about exclusions felt by visitors, though having felt excluded many years ago, I haven't been to an Irish session since so cannot make an up to date assessment of what goes on.
Q
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: ladydetemps on August 31, 2012, 12:00:53 PM
I don't have anything against Irish tunes...or tunes in general where ever they come from. Just don't like any tune being played like its a message in high pitched morse code at lightning speed, gives me a headache. :o
For me its not where it comes form its how its played. I like tunes that make me want to tap my foot or bob along.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 31, 2012, 12:18:04 PM
LdT: Well put, totally agree!
Q
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Frank Lee on August 31, 2012, 04:29:47 PM
Quintin,  yes, that was the Dublin connection.  Was the fiddler Jimmy Troy?
Jim would certainly fit your description! The point I was making was that there appears generally to be more of a 'listening' culture in our neighbouring countries.  Certainly I never meet with the rising level of conversation if a tune is unknown, as is the norm here, at least, as Lester says, in my world.  Living near the Scottish border I often venture north, and even in Neil Gow territory (Dunkeld) where my folks live, they listen and ask questions. 
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: IanD on August 31, 2012, 05:02:08 PM
To refer to my original post,  I find that generally, in Scotland, Ireland and Wales, people are prepared to listen to each other's music, whatever their country of origin.  Much less so in England. 
 (:)

That may well be true in your world but I think that it is probably just Irish music that is "unwanted" in English sessions I have been too. We seem to be quite happy with Euro/Scots/Welsh - any thing but Irish etc. I think it is a reaction against the whole English Plastic Paddy sessions which appear to want to exclude visitors. The view you get of Irish music from those sessions and thesession.org etc is of a heavily exclusive and rule bound cliquey bunch of bores. YMMV
To quote from the Committee Band (and now Panjandrum) website:

"We don't care where the tunes come from -- England, Scotland, Italy, Sweden, France, America, Northolt -- so long as they're good enough to become Ohrwurm"

Ireland is not on the list because we have found very few tunes that we like playing, especially for dancing. Many of the Irish tunes you hear just sound like pick-a-random-set-of-played-far-too-fast-arpeggios-out-of-the-box with no memorable shape or form to the tune, where you've forgotten the tune a minute after you heard it because it sounds like all the other ones.

And to be blunt there's always the risk that if you do play an Irish tune at a session in England any Plastic Paddys present will take this as a sign to jump in and diddly-diddly everyone to death by boredom ;-)

-- yes there are good Irish musicians -- or musicians who play Irish music well -- but in England they're greatly outnumbered by those who aren't and don't...
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Lester on August 31, 2012, 05:09:39 PM
Why do Irish tunes have names?

So you can tell them apart  ::)
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Owen Woods on August 31, 2012, 05:19:42 PM
Heh, I've always said that the common response of English musicians to Irish music is that "All the tunes sound the same and it's too fast", whereas the common response of Irish musicians to English music is that "All the tunes sound the same and it's too slow" :P
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: deltasalmon on August 31, 2012, 05:23:15 PM
I agree with the statement of "people that don't know it think it all sounds the same, but the deeper you get the more interesting the small differences get." whether talking about Irish, Jamaican, Pop, Rap, New Wave, American Country music, etc.

It's easy to make a blanket statement "All _____ sounds the same". However, being a fan of Irish music I still have no problem laughing at a joke like Lester's above  ;D


P.S. My 50th post!! I have a new gold star!
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Graham Spencer on August 31, 2012, 05:44:04 PM
Of the relatively small number of Irish tunes I play, the majority are from the south-west, and there are some cracking polkas and slides to be found round that neck of the woods (albeit often needing the brakes to be applied!); it seems to me most of the riddly-diddly tunes are more at home on a fiddle than a box.  The rising conversation over an unfamiliar tune must be either a regional thing or else it's a display of appallingly bad manners that's crept into UK sessions since I left - in which case I'm very glad I live here, where sessions and fellow musos are few, but minds are truly open.  If it's really like that in UK now I might reconsider my decision to make a special effort to get to Whitby next year - I can think of far better ways to splash out a load of cash than spending a week sharing sessions with a load of musical bigots.....

Graham
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: FlatNote on August 31, 2012, 06:09:39 PM
Many of the Irish tunes you hear just sound like pick-a-random-set-of-played-far-too-fast-arpeggios-out-of-the-box with no memorable shape or form to the tune, where you've forgotten the tune a minute after you heard it because it sounds like all the other ones.

There's nothing inherently wrong with one tune sounding like another nor is it necessarily antithetical to memorability.  Without similarities there would be no styles, traditions or genres, and the whole basis of learnability is the recognition of similarity.  If two tunes sound alike that's good if they're good and bad if they're bad.  Of course good tunes have bad players and vice versa, there's nothing to distinguish England and Ireland in that respect.  And everyone of whatever nationality starts off bad and hopes to get better.  For me personally English and Irish music have the striking similarity that the solo performance is often hauntingly good while the group session is often aptly described by Seán Ó Riada's comment that "everyone takes hold of a tune and belts away at it without stopping. The result is a rhythmic but meaningless noise with as much relation to music as the buzzing of a bluebottle in an upturned jam jar."
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Gromit on August 31, 2012, 07:01:11 PM
With all this talk about English tunes and sessions can someone recommend an English session or sessions in or around southwest London

Thanks
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: sticky fingers on August 31, 2012, 07:35:55 PM
With all this talk about English tunes and sessions can someone recommend an English session or sessions in or around southwest London

Thanks

"Er yes", The Radway inn, Sidmouth, Its about 145 miles southwest of London, you will know you have arrived when you read the sign on the door, No Irish Music!, No Gypsies, No Immigrants, vagabonds or dog on a string types allowed,   "Welcome". sf
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 31, 2012, 08:03:31 PM
Frank - yes indeed it was Jimmy, I think the best fiddler I've met. His thoughts on Irish music were wonderful, as was his take on Irish stepping, pre- RiverDance. Haven't seen him in years but we did speak about a year ago. Didn't realise but he came down here to Bampton Fair a few times, and by utter coincidence, I was talking to Ed Rennie's wife Anni, who I work with, and we were both amazed that we both knew him. She said he'd been down a few times. Shame he didn't get in touch. Do you keep up with him?
His attitude to tunes was an inspiration. He did once send me a tune on a cassette, I dutifully learnt on the English concertina, found it in an odd key but perceivered. When we next met we both tried to play it but were perplexed. He'd played it in G but the slow tape recorder had dropped it down a half tone starting on F#. Both of us were utterly confused!
Q
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: IanD on August 31, 2012, 10:51:42 PM
Heh, I've always said that the common response of English musicians to Irish music is that "All the tunes sound the same and it's too fast", whereas the common response of Irish musicians to English music is that "All the tunes sound the same and it's too slow" :P
There are plenty of unmemorable tunes in all traditions including English, Irish, French, Italian, Scandinavian, often played badly by people who just don't get what they ought to be played like. The key is finding great tunes and working out how to play them so that they *do* sound good; personally I find this harder with Irish tunes than any of the others, so maybe it's just me. And quite a lot of my musical acquaintances...
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Stiamh on September 01, 2012, 02:45:05 AM
... often played badly by people who just don't get what they ought to be played like...

This is really the nub of the matter. And it applies to listeners too.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Gromit on September 01, 2012, 09:37:41 AM
Quote
...personally I find this harder with Irish tunes than any of the others, so maybe it's just me. And quite a lot of my musical acquaintances...

Harder in what way?

I'm the exact opposite when comparing Irish tunes to English I find most Irish tunes generally more interesting and the same applies to most of my musical acquaintances.

It's English music played on melodeons with the overpowering alternating bass/chord playing that I'm not keen on. English tunes played on a fiddle are lovely - oom-pah bass is not for me.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Frank Lee on September 01, 2012, 12:16:15 PM
Oom - pah can sound interesting if the full potential of the left hand is exploited (one rows excepted of course!).... and it doesn't have to be oom pah anyway.  Perhaps a thread on 'how to play the melodeon' might develop from this?  Could run for a page or two eh?
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: olly on September 01, 2012, 12:51:05 PM
Plus some useful tips on how not to play a melodeon perhaps. An otherwise good session at Whitby was left temporarily stunned and silenced by someone playing the Canal en Octobre on a Dino Baffetti using all strength and might at the gentlemans disposal. Played with a bit of feeling it could have been so different.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Marje on September 01, 2012, 01:19:31 PM
The use of bass and chords (whether clumsily or skillfully done) is one of the things that separates Irish and non-Irish sessions. Irish music, like Irish song, relies a lot less on chords and harmonies, preferring to use ornamentation, and an Irish session is often content with a single guitarist to accompany the melody. English and Scottish music, and much continental European music, can be played that way but generally needs the chords and basses to bring the full character to the tune.

That's one reason why I don't really enjoy playing Irish music, even if I can manage most of the notes - the left hand bit is rather superfluous, and one of the things I like about the melodeon is that you can do the whole thing including chords and harmonies. Irish melodeon players often have their left hand just flapping about like a kipper while the right hand does all the work, and it seems a bit of a waste of a two-handed instrument to me.

I also like the rhythmic variation in English music. There are hundreds of tunes that can be recognised, or narrowed down to a few contenders, when the rhythm is tapped out. The same is not true of most Irish tunes, which have largely interchangeable diddly-diddly or diddle-diddle rhythms.  The English rhythms suit the melodeon, which can get stuck into them and bring out the best of them, but this isn't an option with Irish tunes, which all have similar pounding pulses with few distinctive rhythms.

I agree with what others have said re the acceptability of other traditions in Irish/English sessions - it's most often the Irish sessions (in England) that get prescriptive and insist on only Irish music. It seems daft to me when a folk music session is taking place to exclude the native music of that country and region. The "mainly English" session that I run has mainly English tunes but also the occasional Scottish, French, American or Scandinavian tune. Now and again we allow an Irish one as a special exception, or because some visitor starts one, but as the other session in the town is for purely Irish music, I like to keep ours for all the rest of the stuff that people want to play.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Theo on September 01, 2012, 01:29:34 PM
with Irish tunes, which all have similar pounding pulses with few distinctive rhythms.

I must have been listening to different Irish music!  To me there is more variety: single jigs, double jigs reels, hornpipes, polkas, mazurkas, waltzs, highlands, slides, slip jigs all have distinct rhythms, and there are probably a few more.   As has been mentioned earlier in this discussion if you just listen to Irish music as played at "Irish" sessions outside Ireland then you don't really get the full variety.  Try listening for example to Martin Hayes.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 01, 2012, 03:10:15 PM
Just to remind everone that this is not about Irish music.

It's about respect for the music of others in a session, be that in listening to it and trying to learn/expand - or in playing it in a way that others are able to join in  )
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Lester on September 01, 2012, 06:10:58 PM
Ok some of you don't like Irish music (although from these comments most of you probably have not heard the real thing) - f

From what I have read this is most peoples point, most of the Irish music heard in England is not the "real thing".
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Marje on September 01, 2012, 06:16:47 PM
with Irish tunes, which all have similar pounding pulses with few distinctive rhythms.

I must have been listening to different Irish music!  To me there is more variety: single jigs, double jigs reels, hornpipes, polkas, mazurkas, waltzs, highlands, slides, slip jigs all have distinct rhythms, and there are probably a few more.   As has been mentioned earlier in this discussion if you just listen to Irish music as played at "Irish" sessions outside Ireland then you don't really get the full variety.  Try listening for example to Martin Hayes.

I agree, I love Martin Hayes's playing. I was referring  - and should have made it clearer - to the music that is played in "Irish" sessions in England. It's often wall-to-wall double jigs and reels, with dispproving looks thrown at anyone who attempts any other type of tune. (truly, I've known this happen).
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: EeeJay on September 01, 2012, 10:48:54 PM
... temporarily stunned and silenced by someone playing the Canal en Octobre on a Dino Baffetti using all strength and might at the gentlemans disposal.

I feel their pain... ::)

Likewise, there's Irish sessions and Irish sessions... I frequent quite a few locally - which are mainly made up of local Irish and 2nd/3rd generation musicians just out for a tune and a bit of friendly banter - but I tend to avoid advertised 'Irish sessions' at English festivals... principally 'cos they're full of people desperate to kind of outdo each other, and it generally descends into an incoheseve thrash, topped off with too many goat bashers... :P

But that's not always... if you follow your nose away from the advertised stuff, that's where the good music lies... :|glug

Ed J
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Stiamh on September 02, 2012, 12:34:04 AM
Leaving aside the question of Irish sessions in England (the displeasures of which I have no trouble imagining, because some truly horrible music gets played in some Irish sessions in Montreal): to my mind, Irish music is a language that needs to be learned properly, and that is something that can only done the way you learn any language - by long immersion, exposure to (and preferably hanging around with) "native speakers", and patient practice. Without that it is hardly surprising that people will have a hard time making it sound good, as some of you have professed.

And without the familiarity with the language that comes with long exposure, it's hardly surprising that tunes sound alike. I mean most of us would have trouble recognising different sentences in Mik'maq or Pitjanjara (sp?).

There's a hoary old saying that to become an Irish piper takes seven years of listening, seven years of learning or practising, and seven years of playing. While it's a cliché there is truth in it... you don't become a good Irish musician overnight.

No doubt the same applies to any tradition, but I do think that Irish music has a particular wealth of subtleties many of which only become clear when you are already some way down the road.

When I was living in Australia in the 1980s there was a wave of popular bands that tackled folk music from all over the world, literally. I used to listen to the cringe-worthy fashion they played Irish tunes and wonder whether they were making a similar hash of/failing to comprehend the basic rhythms of all the other traditions they were dabbling in.
 
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: forrest on September 02, 2012, 04:36:43 AM
... often played badly by people who just don't get what they ought to be played like...

This is really the nub of the matter. And it applies to listeners too.

Uh oh, now I'm scared silly that someone might reveal my most deeply buried secret: that I have been listening improperly the whole time!  :|bl
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: FlatNote on September 02, 2012, 09:58:22 AM
I used to listen to the cringe-worthy fashion they played Irish tunes and wonder whether they were making a similar hash of/failing to comprehend the basic rhythms of all the other traditions they were dabbling in.

No doubt making a hash of other traditions is the norm, but would you ban the sale of blended whiskey because the single malt is better?  There may be many a palate which has been led on to the more subtle but harder to acquire product from an acquaintance with the more available mass market version.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: IanD on September 02, 2012, 11:56:32 AM
with Irish tunes, which all have similar pounding pulses with few distinctive rhythms.

I must have been listening to different Irish music!  To me there is more variety: single jigs, double jigs reels, hornpipes, polkas, mazurkas, waltzs, highlands, slides, slip jigs all have distinct rhythms, and there are probably a few more.   As has been mentioned earlier in this discussion if you just listen to Irish music as played at "Irish" sessions outside Ireland then you don't really get the full variety.  Try listening for example to Martin Hayes.

I agree, I love Martin Hayes's playing. I was referring  - and should have made it clearer - to the music that is played in "Irish" sessions in England. It's often wall-to-wall double jigs and reels, with dispproving looks thrown at anyone who attempts any other type of tune. (truly, I've known this happen).
My worst "Irish session" memory was an advertised -- not as Irish! -- session in the Rose and Crown at Warwick during the festival, which was "lead" by a young band who I won't name in case they've got better since. I went up there with MJ to find the band sitting in a circle in the middle hammering out relentless sets of super-fast Irish jigs and reels that none of the other musicians sitting around were joining in with -- as soon as they finished one set they started another after a few seconds pause.

Sometimes when they mistakenly left a gap a few seconds too long I jumped in and started up a couple of well-known English tunes, which everyone else in the room then joined in with gusto while the "band" set there talking and chatting amongst themselves; as soon as the tunes finished (to much applause) they leapt in with another aren't-we-brilliant-look-at-how-fast-we-can-play set while all the other musicians in the room sat holding their instruments waiting for them to stop and give someone else a chance.

After an hour or so of this we left in disgust. I don't think I've ever -- before or since - seen an example of how badly wrong you can go when running a session. I even wrote a vituperative letter to the festival organiser suggesting that said band shouldn't be given the task of running a session when they were so patently bad at it, but never got a reply.

In contrast we (Panjandrum) were asked to run the beer tent session one afternoon at Towersey last year; we lead a few sets of favourites when needed (but always "common" tunes, not "band specials" which nobody else would know), and otherwise looked round the room to spot people who looked like they had a tune bursting to get out and asked them to start a set -- or in some cases encouraged people who were obviously less experienced (but competent) who were shyly sitting there to start something, and watched them have a big grin afterwards when they realised they *could* start/lead a tune set.

We got an afternoon of what I'd call English-ish music -- with some tunes from Scotland, Italy, France, Scandinavia, even a few from Ireland! -- but aimed at being inclusive rather than exclusive. There were also some subtler tunes played by one or two people which were also well received, but the session was really about band-type playing not solos -- and there was some lovely harmonisation and ornamentation/improvisation also creeping in over the solid ground of people playing the tune.

As a band we played hardly any of our "favourite" sets, just a few which we also knew lots of other people knew and loved and would join in with. Afterwords someone came up to be while I was having dinner and said it was one of the best sessions he'd ever been to, which made me very happy indeed -- not because everyone marvelled at how brilliant *we* were, but how good *everyone* was and what a good time they'd had.

That to me is what a session is all about :-)

Ian
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Stiamh on September 02, 2012, 12:05:10 PM
Good point, flatnote, but I wouldn't ban anything, myself. I would just [drink something | go somewhere] else. 

And JW, I merely meant that if you don't hear the subtleties of what is being played, a) you won't appreciate it fully, and b) you certainly won't be able to reproduce it.

Feel somewhat ambivalent about having chimed in in this thread, because I can see how my attitude can come across as musical snobbery. Ah well, guilty as charged  (:)

Ian posted while I was typing this. I love the idea of a session being "lead" - the atmosphere certainly sounds heavy! ;-) 
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 02, 2012, 12:14:22 PM
With Ian's post, I think it brings this thread full circle.
Frank started off by complaining that some people were unsympathetic in sessions when others were playing, and he felt it was bad form. Ian's post to my mind shows the worst case scenario - which surprisingly many of us seem to have witnessed - followed by what it should be, an all inclusive ego supressed enjoyment of music with everyone looking, listening and including all.
It's been an interesting journey.......
Q
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: IanD on September 02, 2012, 02:51:23 PM
Good point, flatnote, but I wouldn't ban anything, myself. I would just [drink something | go somewhere] else. 

And JW, I merely meant that if you don't hear the subtleties of what is being played, a) you won't appreciate it fully, and b) you certainly won't be able to reproduce it.

Feel somewhat ambivalent about having chimed in in this thread, because I can see how my attitude can come across as musical snobbery. Ah well, guilty as charged  (:)

Ian posted while I was typing this. I love the idea of a session being "lead" - the atmosphere certainly sounds heavy! ;-)
Organised sessions lead by a band are quite common at festivals and can work very well if done properly, which is why the festivals do it -- the Towersey one was a good example of a "band"-type one, the ones at the Volunteer Inn at Sidmouth are good examples of "solo"-type ones.
A brilliant informal session can be as good or better, but can also go horribly wrong if taken over by cliques or people who think they're superstars who everyone's gone to hear do a concert set -- like the Warwick one I mentioned...
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: FlatNote on September 02, 2012, 04:43:27 PM
Ian's post to my mind shows the worst case scenario - which surprisingly many of us seem to have witnessed - followed by what it should be, an all inclusive ego supressed enjoyment of music with everyone looking, listening and including all.

I think the suppression of ego takes a good few years of meditation tucked away somewhere quiet in the Himalayas and is not to be expected from the typical session player!  The whole problem is surely one of advertising.  What groups of consenting musicians choose to do in the privacy of their own session is surely their own affair.  If they want to play at breakneck speed or to forbid tunes from beyond the Watford Gap or outside the Pale that is their privilege.  It's only when a public session is labelled in a way that frustrates the expectations of those attending that there is a problem.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 02, 2012, 04:59:51 PM
Supression also includes realisation that perhaps they aren't god's gift to the folk world  >:E
.... yes a Himalayan venture is required, or the alternative therapy often applied down here which requires many times rinsing of the brain cells until forgetfulness intervenes making them mere mortals  ;D

As you rightly say, if it's a public session then it should be just that, open to all mortals.
Q
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Gromit on September 02, 2012, 05:37:12 PM
Quote
outside the Pale
Probably not the best terminology to use in this context.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: forrest on September 02, 2012, 06:03:45 PM
 Having read thru this thread so far, some points seem to emerge re. Sessions:   

   Everyone wants to play their favorite tunes together with a group.
   Some want to showcase their abilities
   Some are there to learn new tunes, or tips to improve the ones they know
   Some are there to present something new, or novel
   Some are there to park and listen

   When a medium to large group comes together, perhaps unknown to one another, having differing backgrounds, abilities and expectations, then it seems a rather large conflict of interests could ensue.
  I think Frank's notion of the "Tune Swap" is one step toward unravelling the emotional knot that occurs when all the energies run to cross purposes. By setting up an orderly presentation, the domination of the activity could be minimized. Everyone would have an alloted time limit to present, with a small time for discussion, then on to the next. Interested parties could confer privately on detail.

 This could lead to a 'slow jam' type of activity where an interested group could form to learn the tune and it's subleties. Or multiple tunes...

The Session, of course, would remain the free-for-all that it is, with the idea that if it was too intimidating or unfamiliar for some players, there would be the previous set of nurturing activities that they could take advantage of to bring up their abilities. This notion would also imply that there would be more advanced players out there willing to lend a hand with some instruction from time to time.
 
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Howard Jones on September 03, 2012, 10:13:20 AM
The role of a session leader is to get the session started, make sure people have an opportunity to start tunes, and keep things going if there is a lull.   However, when a well-known band, or individual, is programmed to lead a session at a festival many people turn up expecting to hear them play and hoping to be able to join in with them.  In these situations I feel it is appropriate for the band to take the lead a little more often than might normally be the case when leading a session.  However they should not take it over and turn it into a concert, and neither should they exclude others from joining in, either by their attitude, speed or persistently playing obscure tunes.

Ian and Panjandrum, being experienced and sensitive musicians, would obviously understand this.  The other band clearly did not.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: oggiesnr on September 03, 2012, 11:10:35 AM
The best led session I've been to this year was a Danish tunes session at Beverley lead by Habadeduk (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JxR6H2_dzRY (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JxR6H2_dzRY)).  They took three of the tunes that they performed and led us through each tune phrase by phrase explaining how it all went together, rhythms etc.  We then played through the tune before going on to the next one.  To finish the sssion we then played them through as per their show arrangements with the different instruments being highlighted.  Great fun.

I enjoyed it all the more as I was playing bass that day so their bass player took me in hand and we worked through his arrangements.

I got the impression that although it might have seemed a bit more formal than most sessions everyone got something out of it because we were all included and had a chance to learn, not just left to sink or swim.

Steve
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Graham Spencer on September 03, 2012, 02:30:02 PM
Personally I wouldn't go to a session led by a band; it seems to me to fly in the face of what a session should be.  I went to one once at Whitby many years ago and it was just pointless, what with the huge number of people and the lack of anywhere to sit. I stayed about 5 minutes.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Bob Ellis on September 03, 2012, 02:51:37 PM
The best led session I've been to this year was a Danish tunes session at Beverley lead by Habadeduk (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JxR6H2_dzRY (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JxR6H2_dzRY)).  They took three of the tunes that they performed and led us through each tune phrase by phrase explaining how it all went together, rhythms etc.  We then played through the tune before going on to the next one.  To finish the sssion we then played them through as per their show arrangements with the different instruments being highlighted.  Great fun.

I enjoyed it all the more as I was playing bass that day so their bass player took me in hand and we worked through his arrangements.

I got the impression that although it might have seemed a bit more formal than most sessions everyone got something out of it because we were all included and had a chance to learn, not just left to sink or swim.

Steve

I also enjoy this kind of event, but from the description of it (I wasn't there, so it is all I have to go on), it sounds as though it was more of a workshop than a session.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Bob Ellis on September 03, 2012, 03:27:00 PM
There are all kinds of different sessions catering for different tastes both in terms of the type of music played and the way in which it is played, so it is dangerous to generalise......but I have always been a thrill-seeker, so here goes! :Ph

People attend sessions to meet up with like-minded friends, to join in with others playing tunes they know (or half-know), to discover new tunes that, hopefully, they will be able to learn either during the session or (more likely) after they have gone home and found the tune on the internet, and to listen to other people playing tunes that they enjoy hearing but have little desire to play. There are other reasons, but I suspect these are the main ones for most people.

To my mind, a good session is one that addresses all the aforementioned, preferably without too much intervention from the session leaders. Our view in the Loose Knit Band when running our nightly sessions during Sidmouth Folk Week is that we should kick things off with a couple of well-known tunes and then let others take the lead, making sure that nobody dominates to the exclusion of others. We also try to ensure that there is a balance of standards where everyone can join in and less well-known tunes that might be started by one or two musicians, with others either joining in as they begin to hear the pattern of the tune or simply enjoying listening.

We like to encourage players of quiet instruments, like mandolins and hammer dulicmers. In a large session that often has over fifty musicians, there is a danger that players of quiet instruments won't get a look-in, so, having ascertained with a quiet word that they would like to do so, we ask for quiet at a suitable point so that such players have the chance to start a tune. We also try to identify those who lack confidence and/or experience so that one of us can ask them quietly if they would like to start something and then give them the space to do so. If they don't feel comfortable starting a tune, we ask them what tunes they know and start those tunes for them (provided we know them!), so that they can join in.

Variety and sensitivity to the needs and wishes of others is, I think, the key to success. Judging by the numbers who attend our sessions, I think we must be doing something right!
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Graham Spencer on September 03, 2012, 05:03:30 PM
That sounds like a good way to go to me. Fifty people is a big session, but you seem to have it sorted. I guess a regular session for its own sake (which is what I assume yours is) is probably a different animal from a session in a festival programme led by a "guest" band.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Howard Jones on September 03, 2012, 08:25:05 PM
Personally I wouldn't go to a session led by a band; it seems to me to fly in the face of what a session should be.  I went to one once at Whitby many years ago and it was just pointless, what with the huge number of people and the lack of anywhere to sit. I stayed about 5 minutes.

A session with a huge number of people and nowhere to sit is going to be problematic irrespective of who is running it.

It may not attract you, but a number of people seem to like to have the opportunity to sit in with a well-known band and play along with some of the sets they've heard the band play elsewhere at the festival.  It shouldn't become just a performance by the band, and first and foremost they should be facilitating other people to play, but at the same time they should remember that some people have gone to listen to, and play with, the band.  As with everything, it's a question of getting the right balance, but I suggest it is a situation where the band might take the lead slightly more than might otherwise be the case.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Graham Spencer on September 03, 2012, 08:50:05 PM
I quite agree; the fact that it doesn't appeal to me doesn't affect its validity or mean there aren't loads of people to whom it does appeal - and good luck to 'em. It's simply my personal opinion - I happen to like small to medium size sessions (not too small - there's a limit to what you can do with 3 people!) and chance to swap tunes and talk about where they came from, how they developed and so on. One man's meat.....
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Howard Jones on September 04, 2012, 10:28:15 AM
GPS, I agree, but the size of the session is a different matter from who is running it.

It is inevitable that programmed sessions at festivals are likely to be larger than is desirable.  Nevertheless, the best session I have ever participated in was at festival (Beverley), and was one led by a band (as it happens, it was my then band the Electropathics, but that's not the reason it sticks in my memory).  It was a fairly large session too, but made up of very competent and, more importantly, sensitive musicians who were willing listen to what other players were doing and able pick up and develop their ideas.  It was, quite simply, a superb and very laid-back afternoon which carried on long after the programmed finishing time, and was finally brought to an end by a <insert orifice of choice> of a piano accordion player who walked in and decided it needed "livening up".  Fortunately it was coming to its natural end by then, and we all packed up and left him to it.  More than 25 years later it still lingers in my memory.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: malcolmbebb on September 04, 2012, 04:04:19 PM

...We also try to ensure that there is a balance of standards where everyone can join in and less well-known tunes that might be started by one or two musicians, with others either joining in as they begin to hear the pattern of the tune or simply enjoying listening.

... We also try to identify those who lack confidence and/or experience so that one of us can ask them quietly if they would like to start something and then give them the space to do so. If they don't feel comfortable starting a tune, we ask them what tunes they know and start those tunes for them (provided we know them!), so that they can join in.
There were a couple of organised sessions at Dartmoor FF, one led by Gareth Kiddier and Nina Hansen, the other led by All Blacked Up fronted by Baz, of this parish, which I thought came pretty close to the above. I didn't play much but was given the opportunity, and in both the emphasis was on giving everyone a fair crack of the whip rather than airing their own tunes.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Stiamh on September 04, 2012, 04:16:21 PM
Not taking sides here, you all understand, but I don't mind admitting that decades ago a) for quite some time I played Irish music badly enough to annoy those who knew better but who indulged me and straightened me out (with hints gentle and less gentle) and b) later I was in an Irish band who, if asked to lead a session at a festival where people from other traditions were milling around, might well have behaved in a manner akin to the one in Ian's nightmare session.

If we'd been sitting close enough maybe we would have heard them talking among themselves... maybe the hushed asides went like this:

- Hmm, dunno what this is going to be like. Not many people here into the music.
- Yeah they're all into English stuff.
- English? What's that when it's at home?
- Davy Davy bloody Knick Knack and Bobby effin Shaftoe.
- Don't know any of that stuff.
- I do but I really don't want to play any of it today.
- Look lads, they've asked us to lead this session, so obviously Irish tunes is what they want. Let's get stuck in
[They get stuck in]
- Don't look now but a whole bunch of melodeons just sat down behind you.
- God there's that bloke who plays with one of the Morris teams.
- What about him?
- He's OK - well, if you like that sort of stuff - but he's LOUD.
- If we don't watch out they'll bloody well take over.
- Start another set quick!
- Oh Lord he's off. Rumpty-tumpty rumpty-tumpty - aaargh!
- They're all bloody joining in!  Torture!
- They didn't join in with any of our sets.
- Well they don't know the tunes do they?
- Why did they come to our session then?
- Thank god that's over. Quick lads, into the Finbarr Dwyer set... and Jim have another one ready to go into as soon as we stop. Maybe they'll get the hint and take their infernal machines somewhere else.


As I said, I'm not taking sides, not defending anyone, not attacking anyone. Just musing...  (:)
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Bob Ellis on September 04, 2012, 04:36:12 PM
Isn't leading a session all about trying to provide what people who are attending want rather than providing what the leaders want?
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: mory on September 04, 2012, 07:31:22 PM
Lots of internal rule books and rule makers, very intersting, but......   
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Theo on September 04, 2012, 08:04:47 PM
Ideally a session should be a musical conversation among a group of friends, as soon as it is "led" or in other ways organised, or when it gets too big to sustain the feel of a conversation then it becomes something much different, and will appeal to different people.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: LDbosca on September 04, 2012, 08:17:32 PM
Isn't leading a session all about trying to provide what people who are attending want rather than providing what the leaders want?

It all depends, sometimes yes, sometimes no.

For example, I used to do a (session) gig one night a week that was attended by beginners (in standard, not necessarily time playing) where I was the sole melody player paid to be there. The crowd who attended were there for years before I took over the gig so I made sure to start appropriate tunes at an appropriate speed and prop up peoples' attempts at starting tunes; this was the dynamic of the situation.

At my regular session (at which m'self and two friends are the musicians paid) we play any tunes we like and transpose etc. if we feel like it. We start the majority of sets but people we know will start a few and we might ask a visiting musician to start a set if it seems appropriate. The musicians who attend know enough of our tunes to play along a lot of the time and often pick up the new additions to our repertoire, as we do from them sometimes. We aim to maintain a suitable standard of music that keeps the session interesting for good musicians who wish to attend. If we don't do that then (from experience) good musicians attending drop off and we end up stuck working against bad players and being miserable for 3 hours every week. Why should we do that? We're not charity workers and we've worked hard to get where we are musically. We've played music on our own in the place until it has gained popularity and so it's our domain and responsibility.

The flipside of all this is that when I go to a session I only start a set if I'm asked and just play along otherwise. This, to me, is a positive as it makes sure you've a different musical experience to usual and makes you revive old tunes, learn new ones etc. It can make you play in a completely different way to normal re: rhythm, pace etc. too, which is great. It's also nice to be forced to just listen. I think people need to learn that not being able to start ones own sets is a brilliant experience.

Recently, a man who was (obviously) relatively new to the tin whistle came in and started about 7 or 8 items that he could hardly play and that weren't appropriate to the session; while it is important not to discourage a learner, it is important for someone like this to learn that this isn't ok; playing music in sessions is a form of socialization and the only way to ever enjoy it fully is to become socialized in it, i.e. learn that certain things are appropriate in some situations and not others.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Bob Ellis on September 04, 2012, 11:23:07 PM
Ideally a session should be a musical conversation among a group of friends, as soon as it is "led" or in other ways organised, or when it gets too big to sustain the feel of a conversation then it becomes something much different, and will appeal to different people.

I like the idea of "a musical conversation among a group of friends". The phrase sums up a certain kind of session admirably well and I take great pleasure in that kind of session.

However, there are session - especially at festivals - where someone is designated as the 'leader' (for the want of a better word). In such cases, I think that it is incumbent on that person (or those persons) to consider the interests of those attending that session. The sessions that George leads at Whitby are perfect examples of this. Their success, in my opinion, lies primarily in the fact that George encourages the playing of tunes that are within the compass of those attending rather than just playing what appeals to him.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 05, 2012, 08:24:20 AM
One of the best regular sessions I've frequented was at the pub at the back of Manchester Airport. Being well connectded it attracted travellers (including me), piper Adrian Schoefield from Bury way, concertina  player Chris Jordan from Jodrel. No-one felt any need to show off, apart from Adrians'  Northumbrian rants all was  steady and considered. Sadly like all good things .. the landlord changed

What is the point, well my non musical neighbour, a long time friend used to come along. Though he's liked folk music from his teens, he didn't last. "I feel out of it" "there's a conversation between you and I can't be part of it".   :|glug
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Graham Spencer on September 05, 2012, 11:03:54 AM
For example, I used to do a (session) gig one night a week....... where I was the sole melody player paid to be there.

At my regular session (at which m'self and two friends are the musicians paid) we play any tunes we like

Getting paid to run a session?  I must have been hanging round the wrong pubs/towns/countries my entire playing life.........

Graham
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Owen Woods on September 05, 2012, 11:11:07 AM
Quite!
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: LDbosca on September 05, 2012, 12:22:35 PM
For example, I used to do a (session) gig one night a week....... where I was the sole melody player paid to be there.

At my regular session (at which m'self and two friends are the musicians paid) we play any tunes we like

Getting paid to run a session?  I must have been hanging round the wrong pubs/towns/countries my entire playing life.........

Graham

It's pretty much the standard in Ireland. There's very few regular sessions anywhere in the country that don't have paid musicians who anchor it, ensure that it doesn't descend into chaos and who play when no one else shows up. This includes every session in the Cobblestone, most of the well known ones around Dublin, a few in Cork/Galway that I know that spring to mind.

Having music in a city centre pub can be a great boost for a pub, there is an economic interest for them. Perhaps there's less of a market for English music?
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Marje on September 05, 2012, 12:55:32 PM

It's pretty much the standard in Ireland. There's very few regular sessions anywhere in the country that don't have paid musicians who anchor it, ensure that it doesn't descend into chaos and who play when no one else shows up. This includes every session in the Cobblestone, most of the well known ones around Dublin, a few in Cork/Galway that I know that spring to mind.

Having music in a city centre pub can be a great boost for a pub, there is an economic interest for them. Perhaps there's less of a market for English music?

I think there is less of a market for traditional music in England, which is not quite the same thing, as it applies to Irish sessions as much as English ones. If there is anything in the way of freebies (beer or food) it's generally offered to the whole group and nothing special is offered to the leader. In some ways this suits the slightly anarchistic and disorganised nature of many folk sessions - if we're not being paid, we can enjoy our music as we like, without caring too much about the demands of the landlord or the punters. But in fact most players enjoy the attention of others and will try to please anyone who's showing an interest in the music.

I lead a local session and try to do this with a light touch, just keeping an eye on any newcomers who arrive, greeting people and saying goodnight when they leave, starting a tune if there's a need, and inviting the tentative to contribute (well, a selection of them - some are tentative with good reason and like to stay in the background). It's also important to have someone to liaise with the pub about special events, what happens if the session date clashes with Xmas, etc, and communicate this to the others. I like to think that a casual outsider watching the session wouldn't know there was anyone in charge, as it really belongs to all the regulars as much as to me.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Howard Jones on September 05, 2012, 12:58:07 PM
My experience is similar to Marje's.  Sessions in England are usually initiatives by the musicians themselves, rather than being a marketing ploy by the landlord.  You find a suitable pub and try to persuade the landlord to let you play.  If it goes well you might sometimes get a drink or round of sandwiches, but it's fairly unusual in my experience for the pub to promote it and pay musicians to run it (although it does happen, and I know some entrepreneurial musos who go round offering their services).  In Ireland, where music is perhaps seen, especially by tourists, as an essential part of a pub's character it's probably different.

Steve Jones makes a valid point though: if a festival session is programmed to be run by an Irish band then it implies that Irish music will be played, so you can't really complain if that's what you get.  And the same for an English band, obviously.  If you want to play something different, find (or start) another session.  Which doesn't excuse the behaviour of the band originally mentioned way back in the thread, but they might just have been trying to keep the session 'on track', as they saw it.

Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Graham Spencer on September 05, 2012, 12:59:37 PM
For example, I used to do a (session) gig one night a week....... where I was the sole melody player paid to be there.

At my regular session (at which m'self and two friends are the musicians paid) we play any tunes we like

Getting paid to run a session?  I must have been hanging round the wrong pubs/towns/countries my entire playing life.........

Graham

It's pretty much the standard in Ireland. There's very few regular sessions anywhere in the country that don't have paid musicians who anchor it, ensure that it doesn't descend into chaos and who play when no one else shows up. This includes every session in the Cobblestone, most of the well known ones around Dublin, a few in Cork/Galway that I know that spring to mind.

Having music in a city centre pub can be a great boost for a pub, there is an economic interest for them. Perhaps there's less of a market for English music?

Ah, so it was the wrong countries I've been hanging round, then.... ;D
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: baz parkes on September 05, 2012, 02:41:52 PM
One of the best regular sessions I've frequented was at the pub at the back of Manchester Airport.

Which one Chris?  I can only think of the Romper that way on...
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: baz parkes on September 05, 2012, 02:54:31 PM

...We also try to ensure that there is a balance of standards where everyone can join in and less well-known tunes that might be started by one or two musicians, with others either joining in as they begin to hear the pattern of the tune or simply enjoying listening.

... We also try to identify those who lack confidence and/or experience so that one of us can ask them quietly if they would like to start something and then give them the space to do so. If they don't feel comfortable starting a tune, we ask them what tunes they know and start those tunes for them (provided we know them!), so that they can join in.
There were a couple of organised sessions at Dartmoor FF, one led by Gareth Kiddier and Nina Hansen, the other led by All Blacked Up fronted by Baz, of this parish, which I thought came pretty close to the above.

Thank you Malcolm.  I think there's a world of difference between a session which is announced as part of a festival program, nd those which spring up spontaneously, or those organised on a regular basis by lije minded friends.

If I/we are asked to host a session I usually steer away from band repertoire, as so much of our stuff is self penned.  If some one asks for a specific tune we'll try to oblige.  What I like doing is giving the session a theme or a peg on which people can hang musical hats.  It avoids people thrashing away at Chestnuts, and offers some choice of repertoire..you'd be surprised how versatile people are.  I also go round the room and give people the chance to start a tune if they so wish...or a song or a story...People who don't want to usually make it known before the start, so avoiding any red faces.  And if they want to play an Irish, Welsh or Manx tune that's fine.  Not for everyone perhaps, but it seems to work for me.

And I'm still waiting to hear Malcolm's Lilliput...

Baz
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Anahata on September 05, 2012, 02:57:26 PM
I'd agree that getting paid to run a session is rare in England, but the practice of paying core musicians in Irish pubs certainly used to happen in London many years ago (and for all I know still does).

Also I got a phone call the other day from someone who wanted to book our ceilidh band to play in a pub where they were having a beer festival. After a few questions it became apparent they just wanted music (no songs, no caller, no PA, no dancing) - i.e. a paid session, and I rounded up a handful of local sessionaires who were very happy to be paid for doing what we normally do every week for the love of it. Went down well with the punters too, but I have to say we were a well-rehearsed group of hand picked musicians. And it was all English music!

And I did get paid for organising a session once before, but that was about 10 years ago...
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: deltasalmon on September 05, 2012, 03:10:23 PM
FWIW, in Philadelphia and NYC in the US they pay session leaders but as far as I know most of the small local sessions are just making a deal with the proprietor to let people play music there.

This is just for Irish sessions also. I don't even know of any English or other folk get togethers in the area.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 05, 2012, 03:17:29 PM
When I did a locum in Norwich the musicians got free jugs of beer (very welcome) at the Raindeer, and Tony Hall was slipped some cash at the end for running the evening.

Gosh, we're well off topic!
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: mory on September 05, 2012, 04:28:21 PM
Quote from: Marje
 without caring too much about the demands of the landlord or the punters.


I know you went on to quantify a little Marje, but I do think this does rather sums up something lacking in the approach of some. AtB mory
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 05, 2012, 05:41:49 PM
I too have never known anyone paid locally for a session.
In fact, it's hard enough to find a local pub that is happy to host a session, let alone pay you for playing.
Our first monthly session venue's changed after the landlady for 25+ years left and St Austell breweries took over. They were a bit sniffy about the session at first, but went with it. After the inevitable referbishment they just didn't want to know. When we were guests of another local side   :M in the summer and danced outside in the road.....for an hour whilst about 40 people consuming drinks they just said 'no' when asked if we could go inside and play. Apparently they'd served people with a look that said we'd obviously trodden in something before entering.....

A good pub with an enthusiastic welcoming landlord is to be treasured!
Q
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Lester on September 05, 2012, 05:54:51 PM
A good pub with an enthusiastic welcoming landlord is to be treasured!
Q

And are becoming fewer and further between as pubs close or become restaurants  :'(
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Marje on September 05, 2012, 06:32:02 PM
Quote from: Marje
 without caring too much about the demands of the landlord or the punters.


I know you went on to quantify a little Marje, but I do think this does rather sums up something lacking in the approach of some. AtB mory

I see what you're saying, and I didn't mean it to sound as if we were ignoring our audience and the pub environment. I just meant that if the landlord was actually paying someone, he'd expect something more like a proper band, and might not like it if there was too much chat between tunes, or too many experimental new tunes, or too many inexperienced musicians. Because we're not paid, we can run the session pretty much as we like, and I think this actually raises the standard of music overall by allowing us to get away from the safe, lowest-common-denominator tunes and be a bit more adventurous. We also tend to arrange to have sessions on nights when the pub is quiet, which means we're not impinging too much on the regular drinkers and their socialising, and not playing to a large gathering.

Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Stiamh on September 05, 2012, 06:51:19 PM
Mory, I thought that Marje made (and has just expanded on) a very good point. If the landlord is not a trad-music lover but is only paying musicians to host a session because he thinks it's good for business, then more likely than not he'll feel entitled to make suggestions about the kind of material musicians should be playing, or how they present it, and so on. In these circumstances a falling-out with the musicians is only a matter of time. I say this based on my knowledge of the half-dozen or more sessions in "Irish" pubs (of the plastic paddy variety) in Montreal (a scene I have been avoiding for the past decade).

The ideal paid session would no doubt be the kind that Luke does - where the landlord has a genuine appreciation of trad music for its own sake and is happy to pay a couple of anchors to ensure a good standard that everyone, players and punters alike, will appreciate. Even so, a pub session will nearly always be a transient phenomenon. If you find a good one, enjoy it while it lasts!
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Howard Jones on September 05, 2012, 07:56:46 PM
Even so, a pub session will nearly always be a transient phenomenon. If you find a good one, enjoy it while it lasts!

I've been going to my local session ever since I moved here 30-odd years ago, and it was well-established back then.  It has its ups and downs, and numbers can vary (can you have a session on your own?) but it keeps going, and on a good night the room is packed and the music is great.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: mory on September 06, 2012, 08:59:48 AM
Marje, Steve, points taken. I do feel that an element that is often missed is that music, ours included (box music) is a form of entertainment for people, if the musicians are the only ones being entertained then something is very wrong. I love all types of music and have never had any problems just pulling out a box (of any sort) and playing and entertaining people but I have to say I find the often massed bands of boxes banging out om-pah om-pah very difficult, great in the field as it were, but in a confined space like a pub! I've seen ordinary punters queuing up to leave. A real shame as it denigrates the music, whereas really its poor presentation. Oh well each to their own. All the Best mory
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Theo on September 06, 2012, 09:38:00 AM
I know what you mean Mory.  I much prefer to play with a mix of instruments.  At the Cumberland Arms last Tuesday the lineup of instruments was: fiddles (lots), nyckelharpa, guitar, melodeons (two), mandolin, whistle, piano(a real one not electric), recorder, and the variety of tunes and styles was amazing.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Frank Lee on September 06, 2012, 01:03:05 PM
Yes,  more than one melodeon and you have a foundation for a cacophonous evening, unless the box players all agree which left hand buttons they're going to use.  I don't have a problem with 'Oom-pah' as such,  but it gets a bad name, and drags the genre of English music along with it, if the left hand buttons are used merely to give the left hand something to do, and this is so often the case.  I think the Cumberland (and any) session really depends as much on the folks, and their egos, behind the instruments as the mix of those instruments.  I remember the Cumberland when there has been the variety you describe, Theo, but began to suffer from tempo sickness after 30 minutes of relentless fiddle reels played at breakneck speed, and in relay format so that the music could continue uninterrupted while a few rested their arms or got another beer.  Very close to Ian Dedic's nightmare session.  The playing is usually of a very high order in that pub, and the fiddlers obviously have a great time,  but I've become tired of the 'core' reels,  good to listen to now and again, but way too fast for me and I guess it's time for me to bow out and look elsewhere for a quieter life!.   By the way (Theo) the air button on my Dino is still going strong on the 'milk carton spring'!
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: forrest on September 06, 2012, 04:07:12 PM
Here in the US, the places where sessions occur are few and far between, but many taverns, bars and 'brew pubs' offer music of some sort occasionally. There is an interesting dynamic that occurs in venues that serve alcohol. Some patrons are there to drink and converse with friends, some to hear music, and some for both reasons. The musicians, wanting to be heard well, will often play at three levels: loud>, extra loud>, and deafening. If they have mixing boards and speakers, (most clubs have them, and even acoustic instruments are run thru these), then it becomes a tug of war.....'music' vs. 'talk'. This reaches a point where the talkers are obliged to scream into each other's ears to be understood. It makes for a rather unpleasant venue for all parties.  This seems to happen less often in a Cafe or coffeehouse setting....is this the case in Britain as well?
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Marje on September 06, 2012, 04:46:56 PM
Here in the US, the places where sessions occur are few and far between, but many taverns, bars and 'brew pubs' offer music of some sort occasionally. There is an interesting dynamic that occurs in venues that serve alcohol. Some patrons are there to drink and converse with friends, some to hear music, and some for both reasons. The musicians, wanting to be heard well, will often play at three levels: loud>, extra loud>, and deafening. If they have mixing boards and speakers, (most clubs have them, and even acoustic instruments are run thru these), then it becomes a tug of war.....'music' vs. 'talk'. This reaches a point where the talkers are obliged to scream into each other's ears to be understood. It makes for a rather unpleasant venue for all parties.  This seems to happen less often in a Cafe or coffeehouse setting....is this the case in Britain as well?
In Britain, the "coffeehouse" setting for folk events is almost unknown. Almost all folk sessions and concerts take place in a licensed venue where alcohol is sold, usually a pub, ale being the favoured drink with most folkies. This doesn't generally entail drunkenness or drinking to excess, but it's considered a normal and civilised enhancement of the evening. I'm just pointing that out becasue I know that attitudes to alcohol in the US are somewhat different.

If a band is booked to perform, they'll usually use amplification of some sort, but in that case the understanding is that people will have come to hear the band and won't mind it being loud. It tends to mean, as you've observed, that the audience get louder and louder, and can also (to my mind) create a bit of a barrier between them and the performance.

An open music and song session will not normally be amplified. The volume will depend on the number and type of instruments/voices and also on the acoustic of the room - some pubs have quite a "soft" acoustic with carpets, upholstery, etc, while others have bare floors that amplify the sound more. Pubs often have low ceilings that are divided by exposed beams, which can make it tricky for the musicians to hear each other properly if there's a beam across the middle of the room.

The best pub venues for music sessions are those with a room that has some sort of alcove or L-shaped arrangement that allows the session players to gather in a defined area that is open to the bar and the rest of the pub. This allows other pub guests to move closer to or further from the music, depending on thier inclination. But the music not generally loud enough to prevent conversation in most of the room, and people who want to chat can move away from the music to do so. People do often sidle up to listen for a while and then move away to chat. The pub where we have regular sessions also supplies newpapers and board games, so we sometimes play to people who are reading the paper or playing Scrabble.

Folk song clubs, by contrast, are most often held in a separate room, often a back or upstairs room of a pub, and the only people in the room are those who are there to contribute or to listen. This also enables them have paid performers, and to charge an entry fee, which doesn't happen at sessions.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Gromit on September 06, 2012, 05:30:01 PM
Quote
Almost all folk sessions and concerts take place in a licensed venue where alcohol is sold, usually a pub, ale being the favoured drink with most folkies.

Irish sessions in Irish pubs in the U.K. are not known as folk sessions just sessions - the drink is mostly stout or lager rather than ale and you wouldn't call either the muscians or the patrons folkies without risk of a severe talking to  (:)
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Marje on September 06, 2012, 06:02:05 PM
Quote
Almost all folk sessions and concerts take place in a licensed venue where alcohol is sold, usually a pub, ale being the favoured drink with most folkies.

Irish sessions in Irish pubs in the U.K. are not known as folk sessions just sessions - the drink is mostly stout or lager rather than ale and you wouldn't call either the muscians or the patrons folkies without risk of a severe talking to  (:)

I think a lot of English and Scottish musicians would also object to the tag "folkie" but I can't think of another neat word that covers it. And although English sessions are also referred to by the regulars as just "sessions", I was trying to make it clear to someone from the US what I was describing. You are quite right about the drinks, though, the Irish session players tend to be Guinness-drinkers. I don't really know what the favoured drink in sessions in Scotland is, but perhaps someone will tell us. I did go to a session on Skye once, where they brew wonderful ales, but I didn't notice what the local musicians (who were mostly students form the Gaelic College) were drinking.

This thread is now in danger of becoming a beer thread.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: deltasalmon on September 06, 2012, 06:06:52 PM
Quote
The musicians, wanting to be heard well, will often play at three levels: loud>, extra loud>, and deafening. If they have mixing boards and speakers, (most clubs have them, and even acoustic instruments are run thru these),

Most local sessions by me are un-mic'd acoustic sessions whether they be in bar/pub or coffeehouse. I find there are more of the amplified "sessions" in the bigger cities like New York. These also are usually the same 3-5 people and some would consider it to be more of a performance than a session for these reasons.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: malcolmbebb on September 06, 2012, 06:07:16 PM
What do make I larf:

The local Irish session (in Moseley) is at the Prince of Wales. Which is just across the road from an O'neill's pub which doesn't have sessions.

They sell lots of Guiness. But also have several guest ales :|glug
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on September 06, 2012, 06:46:06 PM
To change the subject away from the Demon Drink ( >:E)- has anybody else noticed how many "folkies" look like Harold Shipman clones?  :|bl
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: malcolmbebb on September 06, 2012, 06:52:05 PM
<bad taste alert>
I bet there's a few dead ringers...
</taste>

Actually, thought he, looking at his security pass - the bloke has got a point...
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Graham Spencer on September 06, 2012, 07:04:46 PM
The local Irish session (in Moseley) is at the Prince of Wales.

Ah, I remember it well; good to know it's still there, as so many of the pubs round that neck of the woods seem to have turned into Indian restaurants. I used to teach just down the road in Sparkhill........   Is The Old Moseley Arms still going? (Sorry about the thread drift!)

Graham
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: malcolmbebb on September 06, 2012, 07:17:49 PM
I believe so (a couple of possible candidates?? but both I think still going).

I am staying just on the border between Moseley and Sparkhill - the latter being a place where one would NOT expect to find an Irish session. Or indeed, an English one. But small supermarkets, ready food and clothing shops of a variety of ethnicities abound, as, oddly enough, do pharmacies. Never seen so many so close together.

Digressing further (sorry) the group in which I am working don't do doughnuts, sweets, or sticky buns on birthdays - instead it's a box of fresh cooked local meat or veg samosas. Terrific. I'll never buy a supermarket samosa again.
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Graham Spencer on September 06, 2012, 07:43:56 PM
Absolutely - I spent most of my teaching career in inner-city multi-ethnic schools, the last 6 or 7 years in Sparkhill; a lot of the kids I taught worked weekends in balti houses in and around Ladypool Road, as a result of which we always used to get VIP treatment, and the kids' mothers were always sending "food parcels" in.  Happy days........

Anyway, back to melodeons!  :||:

Graham
Title: Re: Session v Tune-swap (some Irish content)
Post by: Bob Ellis on September 07, 2012, 12:27:12 AM
(Back on topic)  ::)

I've just come in from a near perfect session at the Old Hill Inn - just six musicians, all playing different instruments, some standard tunes with everyone playing, some lovely new ones with most of us listening or trying to pick up the tune, and some relaxed conversation between tunes. No pressure or feeling of embarrassment when I fell off a tune. Now, that's my kind of session!  (:)  :||:  :|glug  (:)  :|||:  :|glug
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal