Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Dunny on September 04, 2012, 03:51:28 PM
-
A friend of mine (honest!) is having a lot of trouble playing the basses, finding that her left hand tries to mirror the right. I remember having this problem and eventually managed to get there by learning one melody so thoroughly that I could play it without thinking, thus allowing me to concentrate on the left hand.
Has anyone any other suggestions? (I have pointed her towards Daddy Long Les' excellent videos)
-
With odd-timed LH accompaniment I usually just try to start simple. Work it a measure at a time at first playing really slowly until you get it down and then add the next measure. Eventually getting the whole tune down then increasing the speed. Don't know if this is the best way or even a good way but it seems to work for me.
-
Slowing it down so much its like your in slow mo - and you literally think when I press this button on RH I press this one on the LH- and really concentrate.
I found it was like trying to shut a very full suitcase....you just have to push as hard as possible till it finally goes click.
-
Thsi is one of these really personal things, so you'll probably get 10 replies with at least 15 suggestions, many of which are mutually exclusive.
But for what it's worth:
I wonder whether trying some "dummy" finger exercises would help? She could try tapping out the rhythm of a tune with her right hand, either with the appropriate fingers or just any old how, and then try tapping two "bass" fingers in a steady "oompah" pattern, just to get some practice in operating her hands independently. She could do this any time, like when watching tv or listening to music.
Another option would be to learn a tune the other way round: start with the basses and get that going steadily, then add the melody. She might need to get someone else to play the melody with her, or perhaps she could sing it to herself while she gets the basses sorted.
Or .... would it help for her just to find the bass buttons (fundamental + chord) and press them down for each whole bar at a time, just while she's learning the melody right hand? This would mean that at least her fingers would be in the right places, and they could move on to more rhythmic playing later.
I'd advise against learning the tune and then adding the basses, as I think they're best learned together, no matter how slowly, but others will no doubt disagree.
-
I wonder whether trying some "dummy" finger exercises would help? She could try tapping out the rhythm of a tune with her right hand, either with the appropriate fingers or just any old how, and then try tapping two "bass" fingers in a steady "oompah" pattern, just to get some practice in operating her hands independently. She could do this any time, like when watching tv or listening to music.
[/quote]
I used to do that on the steering wheel when driving! With hindsight not the safest technique.......
Thank you all for your suggestions, which I will pass on (:)
-
I agree with all of the previous advice.
Practice just playing the bass accompaniment to a tune - oom pah, oom pah etc etc. Do it for a few weeks until it's second nature. Then bring in the tune on the right hand.
It worked for me many, many years ago! ;D
-
I agree with all of the previous advice.
Practice just playing the bass accompaniment to a tune - oom pah, oom pah etc etc. Do it for a few weeks until it's second nature. Then bring in the tune on the right hand.
It worked for me many, many years ago! ;D
..and I still do it in Sessions(quietly though) where I am not up to speed with the tune or it is Irish and too fast for me. Good practice for the C when playing in D (you don't need to worry about crossing the rows) or Em/B when in G. Sometimes I do it just for the fun of it!
-
I "come in" in sesions with right hand chords - same logic applies but at least you have a start into the tune 2nd time through, and can do it with a lighter touch.
I learn all tunes bass first and would highly recomend that. Fitting bass to a pre-worked-out right end fingering may actually be impossible!
Don't personally think this applies much to Irish, it isn't usually based on chord runs in the same way. :|glug
-
Don't personally think this applies much to Irish, it isn't usually based on chord runs in the same way. :|glug
Not sure what you mean here Chris - Irish tunes have chord runs just like any other tunes? :-\
-
I agree with all of the previous advice.
Practice just playing the bass accompaniment to a tune - oom pah, oom pah etc etc. Do it for a few weeks until it's second nature. Then bring in the tune on the right hand.
It worked for me many, many years ago! ;D
..and I still do it in Sessions(quietly though) where I am not up to speed with the tune or it is Irish and too fast for me. Good practice for the C when playing in D (you don't need to worry about crossing the rows) or Em/B when in G. Sometimes I do it just for the fun of it!
So do I! But I skip the 'quietly'...... :o
-
So do I! But I skip the 'quietly'...... :o
mmm, so do I sometimes! >:E
-
I don't know if it helps and I know that poor old speed the plough is much maligned but it was the first tune that I learnt, and as a former woodwind player so with some musical background but completely not used to having left hand and right hand doing complementary but different things - the melody and bass did seem intuitively to fit together (eventually - after ploughing on through it! (sorry) :D. There is no alternative to just playing the thing over and over again until it makes sense and everyone in earshot is thoroughly fed up with it - it is about making it a physical memory rather than a conscious effort. The really nice thing a year on in to this melodeon lark is that I still play speed the plough and continue to develop it in terms of the base line and the melody ornamentation and I can feel the progress am not bored with it (although everyone in earshot is still probably thoroughly fed up with it!).
-
good suggestion!
-
Agree about Speed the Plough! Perfect for fitting chords between notes (ie one-row rather than cross-row style of play). Its bass/chord taps (do make them light little taps on the buttons, light left end is good) nearly all fit on alternate melody notes, the 1:2 sort of "locks in" and seems easier to master.
It was the first tune where I managed to get "both ends together" in any way I was happy with. I also taught it to little Mathilda (then age 6) who could play STP passably well within a week. Sadly she quickly abandoned melodeon and took up cello - but that's what happens if you call your infant Mathilda :|glug
-
I play both - but not at the same time......
-
Great advice from everybody, and very useful for me as well.
BUT I've now got that infernal tune running through my head. Gah!!
-
I've just learned a really cool alternative version of Speed the Plough. The A music is fun, as it's one of those versions where the emphasis shifts to different beats of the tune, if you know what I mean; you think it's not going to add up to the right number of bars but it does. The B music is also different from the standard version, and perhaps a bit fussier than it need be, but the whole thing makes a nice change from the usual tune.
I'm told it comes from the playing of William Andrews (a Devon fiddler) but it's not in the William Andrews Tunebook I've got. I only have it in JPEG version at the moment but I may have a go at converting it to something more convenient to share here - unless anyone here already has it (and can recognise it from my description)?
-
Thank you very much everyone (esp Dunny who is obviously fed up of having to sit within earshot of my bass attempts lol!!!)
Oddly enough STP is the tune I am most confident with and the one I am trying to work the bass into. I will try your various suggestions and see which sits with me most comfortably, but do now recall many (far too many!) years ago when I learnt piano I did indeed work out both hands together, a bar at a time and repeated until known, then added the next bit!
-
:-) Isn't is strange that we ignore techniques used to learn other instruments when learning how to play melodeon?
i.e. learning one hand at a time, repeated scales (5 notes, full octave, octave and a note), arpeggios, intervals (3rds, 4th, 5ths, 6ths, 7ths) , starting with simple tunes first that fit the instrument (eg playing open strings on a fiddle), and learning tunes one bar at a time?
Keep at it, it will soon become second nature! (:)
-
Agree with Pikey (for once!) and that's the reason I said "one row technique" above
I don't play at all like that unless I'm hamming in a new melody is a session. Cross-row technique allows you to hold, "dum ching", or more subtle left hand chording in due course. You then fit in the melody against it, walking fingers between rows. You have all but D of the G scale on pull. Push misses 2 notes. Em uses same notes - just start a different button.
So do practice those scales (especially on the pull) - because the other way to work with chords is to lay out a 'pavement' of chords and play against it. You'll rock the bellows mainly passing through D and E notes, or when the notes you are playing conveniently happen to be on the same button. It all becomes automatic with practice.
Pikey's (implicitly) suggesting you learn the right end chords too (cf many other threads) - they are very useful as you can bang them in as "variation" whenever you feel like it in a tune.
Suspect StP and friends is where you are at - but there is a lot to this instrument .... enjoy your journey
-
What Pikey & Chris are saying is spot on. Learn to play the bloody instrument rather than an ever increasing catalogue of , often poorly played, tunes.
The two most important ingredients are
1. knowing where every note is on the box ( both ends) and which combinations thereof make a sound you like ( I am thinking of the majority of by earists) Or if you are into chord theory where the required notes of the chord are.
2. Just as important is developing the manual dexterity that is required to play whatevr notes or combination of notes is required for a particular bitof a particular tune without slowing down or making a john halls of it!.
Achieving both requires as Pikey said practicing scales arpegios and all sorts of useful little exercises regularly - just like playerof most other instruments consider to be compulsory!
MOst people , having mastered the manual dexterity and instrument knowledge have more than enough inherent 'musical ability' whetever that is!
george
-
Spot on George!! ;)
PS Sadly I didnt get to see you in Whitby . Next year I'll make sure I do!
-
I've just learned a really cool alternative version of Speed the Plough.
I only have it in JPEG version at the moment but I may have a go at converting it to something more convenient to share here
Let's have the jpeg!
Another alternative version of Speed The Plough from William Clarke of Feltwell in Norfolk:
On YouTube (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cn4wwxkKexY)
on our New album (http://maryanahata.bandcamp.com/track/speed-the-plough-stybarrow-crag) (you can hear the low-rate MP3 for free) and
ABC and PDF on Mary's Web site (http://www.maryhumphreys.co.uk/William_Clarke.php)
-
This is defo not learner/advancer stuff - but I think its clever triple imaging and relatively slow speed might give a feel for how a skilled player partitions left v right. NP is using French (cross row) right end and mixing chords on the left to get sus effects etc (that's what the video is about). Note the "pavement of chords" method on the first piece in particular. Ignore his 18 bass - he only uses the ones we all have. It is a basically G/C machine with a row of accs.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-y-E0el3wYw
-
This is defo not learner/advancer stuff - but I think its clever triple imaging and relatively slow speed might give a feel for how a skilled player partitions left v right. NP is using French (cross row) right end and mixing chords on the left to get sus effects etc (that's what the video is about). Note the "pavement of chords" method on the first piece in particular. Ignore his 18 bass - he only uses the ones we all have. It is a basically G/C machine with a row of accs.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-y-E0el3wYw
I think I'll stick to Rumpty Tumpty and Um Pahs thanks all the same. Cant understand why, if you want that sort of sound, the player does not get a CBA or PA?
-
I've just learned a really cool alternative version of Speed the Plough.
I only have it in JPEG version at the moment but I may have a go at converting it to something more convenient to share here
Let's have the jpeg!
Another alternative version of Speed The Plough from William Clarke of Feltwell in Norfolk:
On YouTube (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cn4wwxkKexY)
on our New album (http://maryanahata.bandcamp.com/track/speed-the-plough-stybarrow-crag) (you can hear the low-rate MP3 for free) and
ABC and PDF on Mary's Web site (http://www.maryhumphreys.co.uk/William_Clarke.php)
Nice version, Anahata! But quite different from the one I have.
I'm afraid am going to need a bit of spoonfeeding to get any further with sharing it. I can't find how to display or upload anything to appear here. I now have the tune as a midi file, or a Noteworthy file, or a scanned image of the dots tune (.img). Can you (or anyone) tell me what to do next, please?
-
Cant understand why, if you want that sort of sound, the player does not get a CBA or PA?
You can't do any of that bass stuff on a conventional stradella bass - its all open fifths, something you cant do on a PA or CBA bass.