Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Sandy on November 07, 2008, 12:28:01 PM

Title: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: Sandy on November 07, 2008, 12:28:01 PM
I was at Bill McKinnons session at the Banbury Canalside Folk fest. in October and there was a guy playing a very nice oakwood. He wrote down some interesting discordant french tunes and players on a scrap piece of paper for me. Unfortunately I can't find it but would love to remember what they were. (think they might have been Cyrille Brotte tunes). Anyway, just a slim chance that you might be a member here and could remind me what they were.

Also, interested in French Cafe style music. Can anyone recommend a good book. I know there's a few around but maybe some are a lot more popular than others.

Cheers.
Sandy
 ???
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: Simon W on November 07, 2008, 01:17:07 PM
He wrote down some interesting discordant french tunes and players on a scrap piece of paper for me. Unfortunately I can't find it but would love to remember what they were. (think they might have been Cyrille Brotte tunes).

Sandy

Try Cyrille's website - it looks like he has a book of tunes published! but you might findthe names of tunes on the discography.
www.brotto-lopez.com/. They've also got a MySpace page.
There's lot of sources of transcriptions of French tunes out there - this is a good site
http://www.diatonia.net/home.html.
Good luck

Simon
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: EeeJay on November 07, 2008, 05:11:17 PM
I was at Bill McKinnons session at the Banbury Canalside Folk fest. in October and there was a guy playing a very nice oakwood. He wrote down some interesting discordant french tunes and players on a scrap piece of paper for me.

Oh, that was Chris Ryall (http://chrisryall.net/index.htm) - I was 'otherwise engaged' at Banbury, but saw him about... give him a shout, he should be able to sort out what tunes they were...

BTW, Chris bought the Oakwood off me a few years back... :)

Ed J
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: EeeJay on November 07, 2008, 05:25:03 PM
Also, interested in French Cafe style music. Can anyone recommend a good book. I know there's a few around but maybe some are a lot more popular than others.

One very useful, multilingual, retailer's website I would reccomend is di-arrezo (http://www.di-arezzo.com/)... they're based in Paris, and have a scad of pukka French Accordion books available (such as umpteen chromatic accordion tutors...). Very easy search system for browsing... They take cards or PayPal... which is useful.

For the Cafe 'standards', there's a range of (I think 6, but unsure if they're all in print) spiral bound 'Succes Musette' books - here is the listing for volume three (http://www.di-arezzo.co.uk/detail_notice.php?no_article=BEUSC00107), which includes the titles...

Hope this is useful...

Ed J
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: Sandy on November 10, 2008, 09:55:48 AM
Thank you very much. All the info is great and yes, I shall give Chris a shout and see if he remembers the tunes he played!
Cheers
Sandy
 :)
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: mikesamwild on November 19, 2008, 07:54:30 PM
Maybe it was Chris we met at Whitby this year in the Station pub. he was eating a pork hock for lunch so maybe his greasy fingers moved faster for those classy tunes!

His Oakwood was D/G/Csharp(inside ro I think he said) and he played some great French tunes in minor keys.
Mike
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: EeeJay on November 19, 2008, 09:43:03 PM
His Oakwood was D/G/Csharp(inside ro I think he said)...

It was a C#/D/G last time I saw it - still is as far as I know...

Ed J
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 13, 2009, 11:59:27 AM
It was a C#/D/G last time I saw it - still is as far as I know...Ed J

Crikey! My own thread ...   Hello to all. Especially Ed  (:), did your van der Aa come through OK?

That Oakwood got buggered about a bit. A  C#/D/G  box has duplicated  F# and C pull notes on its inner/outer rows. So some of these were filed to retune to F and D respectively giving it every note except Ab on the pull.  As of yesterday it's back with Martyn and co for a 'general overhaul'.

The tunes I play  I think sone might term 'discordant'  ??? ...

Impasse by Giles Chabenat which is mostly straight Em and related modes. It modulates briefly into C on the b-part, via a Gmaj -> F#maj -> Fmaj* -> Em bass run (the three other chords are all in the ubiquitous Em/G scale.).  Technically the chord should be Fmaj#13 but we melodionists dont extend to extended chords!

Conveniently Ed's old box has all those chords as simple triads (and unusually for a basically D/G machine is extremely happy in C)!

I also play Dromadaire by Patrick Bouffard (Phrygian major aka 'Arab' aka 'Spanish' scale);  and Dominic Forge's Sonsonnet (Dorian#4). Both these scales are just modes of the bog standard harmonic minor. Which is generally considered ... harmonious?

Never mind. They're all hurdy-gurdy tunes, and gurdy tunes are like that. So I know what you mean.

cheers, Chris Ryall
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: Owen Woods on June 13, 2009, 12:24:36 PM
Woo, Gilles Chabenat. He is the same one that wrote Chassepain, yes? That's one of my favourite tunes.
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: Sandy on June 13, 2009, 01:56:33 PM
It was a C#/D/G last time I saw it - still is as far as I know...Ed J

The tunes I play  I think sone might term 'discordant'  ??? ...


Sorry, when using that term I meant it in a nice way. I do love the gurdy type tunes and modal stuff. Thanks for the details of tunes, I think the one I liked was Impasse by Giles Chabenat.

Cheers

Sandra (:)
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: EeeJay on June 14, 2009, 12:53:41 AM
Crikey! My own thread ...   Hello to all. Especially Ed  (:)

Begorrah :o - 'tis yer man himself... Dr. Ryall, I presume? :D

, did your van der Aa come through OK?

Oh yes indeedy, and then some ;D. Glad I made the jump and got one when I did too...

The tunes I play  I think sone might term 'discordant'  ??? ...

Dunno about discordant tunes, but as for the sneaky subversive type >:E... The Finnish Schottische (http://www.folktunefinder.com/tunes/76850/)... such perfect bait for the D/G player... yet guaranteed to bring most D/G melodeons to a grinding halt. ::)

Ed J

P.S. tune at link is a little screwed up - too many dotted notes, a couple of short bars and odd accidentals.
Rehashed the ABC code for what I usually play... a synthesis of Blowzabella and the usual 'Chinese Whispers' session evolution... ::)

X: 4
T: Finnish Schottische
T: Jack in the Green
M: C
L: 1/8
K: D
|: "D"D2 F2 A>G FE | DF Ad f2 ef | "A7"g2 ec Ac ef | ed cB AG FE |
   "D"D2 F2 A>G FE | DF Ad f2 ef | "A7"g2 ec Ac ec \
  |1 "D"d2 d2 d2 AF :|2 "D"d2 d2 d2 A2 ||
K: Gm
|: "Gm"d2> d2 d2 =c2 | _B>c BA G2 ^FG | "D7"A>B AG ^FG E^F | D2 DE D2 CB, |
   "Cm"C>=B, CD EG ^FE | "Gm"D2 DG Bd cB | AB AG ^FD =EF \
  |1 G2 G2 G2 B2 :|2 G2 G2 G2 "D"^FE ||



Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 14, 2009, 07:37:00 AM
Dunno about discordant tunes, but as for the sneaky subversive type ..The Finnish Schottische... such perfect bait for the D/G player... yet guaranteed to bring most D/G melodeons to a grinding halt. ::) Ed J

Hmmm, recall that one from old Blowsabella records, but had completely missed a connection with Finland! As it happens I'm there a lot at the moment (haven't yet found a folk club, though the Storyville night club in Helsinki does excellent jazz)!  Next month she's taking me "wandering in Lapland" so may I report back on what I find.

A move into minor other than the related one (D->Bm Gm) is always interesting because so few British/American tunes do it. I have another little Finish tune fis scottiche which I got 18 years ago off a Grupa disc. It has 3 parts, G, D and Gm, and feels just the same.  Played it solo as a session party piece since then, but just recently I've noticed people joining in  (:) I think the general standard has risen - hope so - yes it has.

But the main point of this ramble is that most of that time I'd ran a simple 2-row Castagnari, and Gm was quite reachable on that! The D7 chord in your Finnish B part puts it in harmonic minor, so there are in theory only two accidentals Bb and Eb. However on your score it does the usual brief diversions with a natural E (easier) and natural F (harder). But these are style issues, and passing notes.

I'll have a go. Assume Dave Roberts played it? Dave used a 2-row Castagnari G/D (no kidding!), 2 accidentals.

BTW the "man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes" plans to go to Middlewich next weekend - but don't look for the Oakwood as it's presently back at't mill. I'll with my two loves - a C/G Gaillard (probably just vamping chords for now), and a very nice Finnish lady.

Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: EeeJay on June 14, 2009, 09:42:58 AM
I'll have a go. Assume Dave Roberts played it? Dave used a 2-row Castagnari G/D (no kidding!), 2 accidentals.

Yes, indeed - low G row, higher D row. Someone on here owns one of Dave's old Hohners - though now returned to a more 'standard' layout. However, he might not have used this for everything...

According to the Blowzabella sleeve notes, Dave also used an old Cooperativa (I think that was the name) contraption in B/C. Or was it C/B (as some of these old boxes were)...? I vaguely remember seeing a picture of it once, and I recall it was some kind of mini stradella bass L/H... :-\

Ed J
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: ganderbox on June 14, 2009, 12:02:19 PM
I'll have a go. Assume Dave Roberts played it? Dave used a 2-row Castagnari G/D (no kidding!), 2 accidentals.

Yes, indeed - low G row, higher D row. Someone on here owns one of Dave's old Hohners - though now returned to a more 'standard' layout. However, he might not have used this for everything...

According to the Blowzabella sleeve notes, Dave also used an old Cooperativa (I think that was the name) contraption in B/C. Or was it C/B (as some of these old boxes were)...? I vaguely remember seeing a picture of it once, and I recall it was some kind of mini stradella bass L/H... :-\

Ed J

Dave Certainly did play a B/C Cooperativa...he is holding a button accordion, which I presume must be it, in the photo on the cover of their first album.
I don't know whether he played box at all on Finnish Schottische, though. I'd have to fire up the turntable and listen to the track, but I think it was mainly Dave Shepherd on fiddle who played it.
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: pipives on June 14, 2009, 02:29:58 PM
I'll have a go. Assume Dave Roberts played it? Dave used a 2-row Castagnari G/D (no kidding!), 2 accidentals.

Yes, indeed - low G row, higher D row. Someone on here owns one of Dave's old Hohners - though now returned to a more 'standard' layout. However, he might not have used this for everything...

According to the Blowzabella sleeve notes, Dave also used an old Cooperativa (I think that was the name) contraption in B/C. Or was it C/B (as some of these old boxes were)...? I vaguely remember seeing a picture of it once, and I recall it was some kind of mini stradella bass L/H... :-\

Ed J

Yes, it would be me who has Dave's old hohner. The rows have been turned round, but it still sounds exactly like when Dave had it. His B/C accordeon is still in the attic at racheal's... daves wife!
I had a look at it, it's in s bit of a state, but I've seen worse.

PS- it's the G/D that's in my profile pic
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 14, 2009, 05:20:57 PM
Knew Dave from folk camps in the early 70's and we last got drunk together (twice, very) at one in Holland '79.

Then came Blowsabella (probably just a few month earlier?) I had the pleasure of seeing Dave again in AFAIR '94 at the mid Wales festival, and told him that he had done more to change English melodeon playing than anyone I knew...

.. he seemed surprised! A few month late the tragedy of an early death. Big loss as he was also a great bloke.

I'm glad that garbled fabled 'G/D' found a good home - and somehow a shame to put it right! Dave's pipes went into the crem. with him, and I'd somehow assumed his accordion had met the same smokey end.   D3R
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 15, 2009, 12:43:36 AM
Impasse by Giles Chabenat which is mostly straight Em and related modes. It modulates briefly into C on the b-part, via a Gmaj -> F#maj -> Fmaj* -> Em bass run (the three other chords are all in the ubiquitous Em/G scale.)
A number of people have said that Impasse is a great tune, but I don't think I have ever heard it. Does anyone know whether there is a recording of it on the internet?
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: waltzman on June 15, 2009, 01:41:01 PM
Is this it?

http://www.thesession.org/tunes/display/7854 (http://www.thesession.org/tunes/display/7854)
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 16, 2009, 07:51:05 AM
A number of people have said that Impasse is a great tune, but I don't think I have ever heard it. Does anyone know whether there is a recording of it on the internet?
google google ...  it's on Bleu nuit available on the emusic.com (http://www.emusic.com/album/Gilles-Chabenat-Musiques-pour-vielle-%C3%A0-roue-Bleu-nuit-MP3-Download/11393963.html) download site (which you have to join)

According to google there may be a jpeg of the dots at http://pix.nofrag.com/2/8/f/de063834cfad3b82d32f72d2444f0.jpg (http://pix.nofrag.com/2/8/f/de063834cfad3b82d32f72d2444f0.jpg), but I got an HTTP timeout error when I tried to download it.

The page http://teemix.aufeminin.com/w/musique/t3457543-gilles-chabenat-l-impasse-Play.html (http://teemix.aufeminin.com/w/musique/t3457543-gilles-chabenat-l-impasse-Play.html) plays a very brief extract (starting on the B music and quite improvised).

Found it!  http://www.ozap.com/musique/collectif/live-en-flandres/5425000300700 (http://www.ozap.com/musique/collectif/live-en-flandres/5425000300700) track 12 has Frédéric Paris playing Impasse on a C clarinet.

The underlying chords are

   Em  C      Em  C  x2
   G  F#/D  F  Em  x2

so a bit of  fudging to be done on a D/G. It's in a 9/8 metre which gives it its swing. Bear in mind you can play your runs of notes over C, and D-bass in either direction, and get different notes.
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 16, 2009, 08:02:43 AM
Is this it?

That's the one Gilles wrote when he was "about 12"  ??? I've never seen a named for it. Very popular in central France, still.
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 16, 2009, 09:04:39 PM
Is this it?

That's the one Gilles wrote when he was "about 12"  ??? I've never seen a named for it. Very popular in central France, still.

Seems similar, if not the same as L'Impasse. Thanks for posting the links, Chris.
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: ganderbox on June 16, 2009, 10:46:40 PM
Is this it?

That's the one Gilles wrote when he was "about 12"  ??? I've never seen a named for it. Very popular in central France, still.

It's on www.diatonia.net under the name of Mazurka des Escholiers de St Genest.
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: EeeJay on June 16, 2009, 11:01:34 PM
Seems similar, if not the same as L'Impasse.

 ???

I couldn't say I think they're at all similar, to be honest...

Ed J
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: ganderbox on June 17, 2009, 09:03:42 AM
Seems similar, if not the same as L'Impasse.

 ???

I couldn't say I think they're at all similar, to be honest...

Ed J

Over the last couple of days I had a go at playing Escholiers de St Genest from the dots, and also listened to l'Impasse on my tape of Bleu nuit, and I got them mixed up in my head. In fact it was the first tune I ended up remembering. When I tried learning l'Impasse from the tape, I realised it was totally different, although the feel and shape of the tunes are similar. It was quite hard to pick up because it's a short track, played on piano and clarinet, with lots of variations, and there wasn't a lot of the basic tune.

I also learnt Chassepain....it's brilliant! :|||:
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: Owen Woods on June 17, 2009, 06:02:47 PM
I also learnt Chassepain....it's brilliant! :|||:

You can say that again, it's my "sound check tune", not only because I can play it in all circumstances, but because it has just about everything I could throw at the sound engineers. It also happens to be one of my favourite tunes.
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 18, 2009, 10:26:50 PM
I also learnt Chassepain....it's brilliant! :|||:

Does anyone have a link (ABC notation or an MP3'll do)  to Chassepain - don't know it at all but with two mentions already here, it looks one to look into. cheers D3R
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: Tyker on June 18, 2009, 11:07:14 PM
I have this abc

X:1
T:Chassepain
C:Gilles Chabenat
M:2/4
L:1/8
R:bourree
K:G
|: dz/A/ Ad | cB AB | Ez/F/ GB | AE FD |
dz/A/ Ad | cB AB | Ez/F/ GA | B^c d2 ::
BG Ed- | dB Ge- | e^c AB | ^cd c/B/A |
BG Ed- | dB Ge | d^c AF | GA FD :|
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: Tyker on June 18, 2009, 11:10:53 PM
And this link (http://www.noteflight.com/scores/view/e17e0b40cacec18dd4d064594f4eda4db973eb1a)
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: risto on June 18, 2009, 11:12:49 PM

.... (haven't yet found a folk club, though the Storyville night club in Helsinki does excellent jazz)! ...

You could try the O'Malley's on Yrjönkatu, same building as Hotel Torni (opposite side). Not too far from Storyville. They used to have a session on regular basis, don't know the week day(s) though. May be slower now when folks are on summer vacation. Same may apply to the bluegrass session held once a week in another bar in the city area.
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 19, 2009, 08:35:11 AM
Thanks chaps, I have heard chassepain many times, but hadn't reached my "to do" list, and it's the first time I've seen it named. That Flash music player is neat, but very quiet on my kit. Is there any volume setting in it (I couldn't find one)?

.. bit of a shame that they didn't attribute to Chabenat.

I'll mention O'Malley's as a possibility. However it looks like a late evening landing next month and we're driving up North to be with the reindeer on the Friday morning (looong way)! I suspect sessioning might have to wait for a winter trip. Also Maija will experience her first such this weekend - we'll see if she likes it!   D3R
Title: Re: man with 3 row oakwood and french tunes??
Post by: Owen Woods on June 19, 2009, 10:26:55 AM
I also learnt Chassepain....it's brilliant! :|||:

Does anyone have a link (ABC notation or an MP3'll do)  to Chassepain - don't know it at all but with two mentions already here, it looks one to look into. cheers D3R

It's on the session: http://www.thesession.org/tunes/display/3356
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal