Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Jack Humphreys on September 19, 2012, 09:07:27 AM

Title: How to play G minor tunes on a GC box? ( D minor on a DG)
Post by: Jack Humphreys on September 19, 2012, 09:07:27 AM
I'd be glad  to hear from melnetters playing  12+ bass  GC boxes about how you manage G minor tunes.   Do you try to play it mostly pushing, with push-pull to  fit in minor notes from the 3rd row...
or do you play it mostly  on the pull, using the reversed pull Gs  from the 3rd row?

Or, on a DG box,   do you play D minor tunes on the push, with lots of push-pull, or on the pull  when you can do quite a run of pull notes?

Why am I bothered?  It's all about deciding what kind of  box is best for French tunes,  knowing that I'll want to be playing in  G minor and D minor lots of the time, and C minor sometimes.   I can see that D minor is easy on the GC box.. just like A minor on the DG.....but I've always wondered why GC is usual in France etc, when so many tunes are in G minor, and pipes/gurdies very often in G and D.   

I've just had to learn to play a tune with  "D minor" (DG-speak) pull fingering.  And there's only one octave's worth,  so not ideal, but it is possible, .  So I'm reconsidering my prejudice that really it's better to have a CF box for playing the French repertoire, despite 99% of french players taking a different view.   What you do think, mes amis?
Title: Re: How to play G minor tunes on a GC box? ( D minor on a DG)
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 19, 2012, 11:44:24 AM
My G/C has a third row in (mostly) F# and I play Gm entirely on the pull - basically use F fingering if it is a dorian tune or Bb if 'natural' minor.  For harmonic minor you have F pull on the G row for the ii and vii chords.  As it happens my low voicing Gm chord is push (as is Ab for any Blue effects) - which gives me opportunities for 'a breath'  :Ph

Bass end - G is there on pull on the C/G button. Something to take the 3rds out is well worth the extra cost! Major chord against minor scale is instant death  >:E



Title: Re: How to play G minor tunes on a GC box? ( D minor on a DG)
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 19, 2012, 12:59:24 PM

    .. so has sky-diving without a parachute  :|glug
Title: Re: How to play G minor tunes on a GC box? ( D minor on a DG)
Post by: OwenG on September 19, 2012, 01:12:09 PM
Why am I bothered?  It's all about deciding what kind of  box is best for French tunes,  knowing that I'll want to be playing in  G minor and D minor lots of the time, and C minor sometimes.   I can see that D minor is easy on the GC box.. just like A minor on the DG.....but I've always wondered why GC is usual in France etc, when so many tunes are in G minor, and pipes/gurdies very often in G and D.   

I've just had to learn to play a tune with  "D minor" (DG-speak) pull fingering.  And there's only one octave's worth,  so not ideal, but it is possible, .  So I'm reconsidering my prejudice that really it's better to have a CF box for playing the French repertoire, despite 99% of french players taking a different view.   What you do think, mes amis?

I've gone the GCF route with 18 basses (which give me all the basses of a G/C and C/F box, plus some extras). Works for me.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal