Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Ed Rennie on September 30, 2012, 01:24:31 PM
-
Hi all
I was just wondering if folk would find it a useful thing if I were to produce The Melodeon Tutor in GC and/or CF versions?
Tell me all and tell me true.
Ed
spinningpathmusic.co.uk
-
G/C yes.
-
I would say there is more difference to be explored between GC and DG, than between CF and DG.
-
You have my vote. I think you knew that already ;)
-
It would be great if you could do both - then I'll get my GCF sorted! The DG version has been brilliant.
robin
-
Another GC vote from me, Ed--thanks for following up on this...!
Jack
-
...and another vote from me.
-
G/C would interest me. I assume shipping it to the USA would be no problem. However, what I would really like is an electronic publication so that it could travel on my laptop rather than my having to leave it behind.
Doc
-
Another vote for GC plus with option of electronic file. Shipping hard copy across the Pond costs as much as the book itself.
Though the Diatonic Liaisons was a very nice hard copy, probably worth the shipping.
-
Count me in for the G/C electronic file version. I'm also in the US would prefer a file for laptop.
-
Also interested in getting into the G/C world. Also in the US here.
-
I would say there is more difference to be explored between GC and DG, than between CF and DG.
Totally correct: CF and DG are the same instrument.
GC (French style) is a totally different world, IMHO.
I would agree with this assessment too. I have a C/F Hohner, and I bought a G/C Sandpiper last year to try to learn some French tunes in their usual keys. I've found that you need a 'different brain' to your D/G one, when most tunes are played in the top half of the keyboard, so a manual in English by an Englishman would be very helpful.
-
G/C.
-
The Melodeon Tutor in GC and/or CF versions?
We have so many excellent GC tutor books, I have three...
Yes, but are they written in English?
As I understand it, the general feeling on this thread so far is that:
(a) the G/C melodeon is played with a different technique to D/G or C/F instruments - I completely concur with this.
(b) there is a need for a tutor book for G/C melodeon, written in English, aimed at English-speaking players who want to learn the techniques, styles, idioms, etc., for playing French music (and similar).
-
The Pignol/Milleret books also have parallel texts in English and French, and provide a thorough grounding. A tad on the dear side, but very good. (:)
-
(b) there is a need for a tutor book for G/C melodeon, written in English, aimed at English-speaking players who want to learn the techniques, styles, idioms, etc., for playing French music (and similar).
No, you don't.
Not necessarily my requirements - I was just trying to summarise the feelings so far expressed in this thread! (:)
A friend wanted to learn Slovak heligonka music, and she learned enough Slovak in 6 months to be able to learn from a tutor book written in Slovak. Frankly, if you want to learn French music, you should learn some French, too.
I understand and mostly agree with you here, but you need to remember that peculiar British phenomenon which is a reluctance to learn/engage with a foreign language. In my own case, my German is reasonably passable having initially learned it at school and I can linguistically survive in most German-speaking environments. However, this meant that (to my regret) I never formally learned much French, and to this day my knowledge of that language is very rudimentary indeed. :-[
-
The Pignol/Milleret books also have parallel texts in English and French, and provide a thorough grounding. A tad on the dear side, but very good. (:)
As are the Yann Dour books.
-
Quite so - I think my first book was Yann Dour's beginners book. It has more of a folk orientation than P/M, but is clear and well thought out. No surprise there! You can hear him playing at Lorient here:
http://m.youtube.com/#/watch?v=b67vGdbtjvE&desktop_uri=%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Db67vGdbtjvE
Really, G/C is well provided for!
-
As I understand it, the general feeling on this thread so far is that:
(a) the G/C melodeon is played with a different technique to D/G or C/F instruments - I completely concur with this.
I don't really understand this notion. I think it is misleading to say that a G/C is a 'completely different instrument'. The only difference is that the G/C 'technique' involves playing in the upper octave more frequently. This can be done on a D/G or a C/F in exactly the same way. D/G is a bit shrill in that octave but if you have an L reed it works fine.
-
As I understand it, the general feeling on this thread so far is that:
(a) the G/C melodeon is played with a different technique to D/G or C/F instruments - I completely concur with this.
I think it is misleading to say that a G/C is a 'completely different instrument'.
??? Hmmm... I didn't actually say that...
-
I'm a G/C 'er mainly and have been using the M&P tutors. As others have said, they have French and English text and are incredibly well thought out, easy to use and effective (with lots of practice!).
To be honest, unless you were to approach the book from a completely different angle from the well established and respected competition, I wouldn't think there's enough room in the market to make it worthwhile putting in all the effort required. That said, id love the G/C to become more popular here so if you go ahead, good luck!
Just my opinion, Bob
-
As I understand it, the general feeling on this thread so far is that:
(a) the G/C melodeon is played with a different technique to D/G or C/F instruments - I completely concur with this.
I think it is misleading to say that a G/C is a 'completely different instrument'.
??? Hmmm... I didn't actually say that...
No, someone else did in a different post.
-
I don't really understand this notion. I think it is misleading to say that a G/C is a 'completely different instrument'.
I would have agreed with you, until I -- a longtime G/C player -- picked up a D/G box. It really was a different world.
-
Ed--
Did this project go anywhere?
Hopefully yes?
--Steve, others
-
I would say that the G/C is very well covered with excellent tutors in both French and English. I have the M&P set of books and they are very, very comprehensive and easy to follow in English.
If you are looking for ideas, I would suggest there is a very great need for a tutor book aimed at intermediate D/G players - i.e. a follow on from your beginners book.
-
Arty, I too am working through the M&P, but alas, still in volume 1, plugging away, good stuff, but I guess it's the "comprehensiveness" that I am perhaps NOT wanting…. (at the moment)
When I got serious about DG, I found I enjoyed, and learned a lot, fast, from the Mally Complete Beginners… In a couple months, I had a bunch of tunes and decent knowledge of the layout…
With the GC, not so much…
Maybe I should put it down and just learn more tunes from Loffet's beginner's list?
-
Arty, I chatted to Ed before Christmas and got his chord book as a pressie. I think it's a step up from a basic tutor as its more explanatory about chord structure and keys available. The stuff you don't really need when initially struggling with the instrument right at the beginning of learning to play.
I agree, an intermediate book would be good but I suspect very hard to assemble.
It seems to me that once you have a reasonable command of the basics, we all go off in our individual directions. It feels to me that no two players are the same.
Some get entranced with French/ Euro styles and head off in the Cutting and Naragonia mould, some start to look at more than 2row/8basses heading for 2.5/12bass or more and some start to really get under the skin of the 2row/8bass.
It's difficult to take a straight line through those very broad generalisations.
Perhaps with French manuals for their music, such as Steve above has, a 'greater than 2row/8bass' D/G manual might be an option, though with the huge variation in 2.5 or 3 row designs it would add another difficulty to overcome.
Q
-
Maybe I should put it down and just learn more tunes from Loffet's beginner's list?
Steve, I can't tell you what is best for you. All I can say is what feels right for me. I am 65 years old and I don't want to spend the next few years studying every detail in the M&P books, I want to have some fun too. That means, I want to play tunes but I also want to work through the tutor books in order to get better, understand more and learn more about music as well as the instrument. So, for me, the answer is to work at the tutor book when I am in the mood and learn and play some tunes when I want to have some fun. Just because you are doing the M&P books, doesn't mean that you have to stop enjoying yourself. You need a balance.
I agree, an intermediate book would be good but I suspect very hard to assemble.
It seems to me that once you have a reasonable command of the basics, we all go off in our individual directions. It feels to me that no two players are the same.
I can't see why it would be difficult to assemble, M&P have done it very well for a G/C instrument. The whole purpose of a good tutor book, is to give one the skills to be able to go in any direction one chooses. I haven't really looked at it yet but I believe it is not until you get to Book 3 in the M&P series, that they address those instruments with more than 2 rows.
I have only been playing melodeon for a short time, (2 1/2 years), so I don't know much. All I can say is, that I loved learning from Mally's book, which I would recommend to any beginner. But after I had completed it, I felt abandoned, because there was no where else to go. Prior to starting on the melodeon, I played the oboe for nearly 30 years. The tutor book that I had for that, was as thick as a telephone directory and I never got to the end of it. But it was always a source of reference and never far from my music stand. It took you from a complete beginner all the way to a virtuoso, if that is what you wanted.
It's not about teaching different styles of music, it's about teaching you the skills to play anything you want and in any style. And it's not just about learning techniques for one's instrument, it's also about learning more about music.
At the end of the day, I don't want to be a melodeon player - I want to be a musician who plays the melodeon. I do realise, at my age, that I have got a hope in hells chance!!! But I love the learning process.
-
arty, I too greatly enjoyed Mally's book and it got me going quite well.
I didn't quite feel as abandoned as you, but do see the benefit of an intermediate tutor book.
When I first touched a melodeon in '78, there were no books, people giving tuition etc. I ended up putting it down and being involved in other instruments and picking up the melodeon properly just over 4 years ago. I too greatly love learning and so have tried to tread my own path after getting going initially. I suspect strongly if there was an intermediate book, I'd get it.
I wonder if the French have a longer history of tutor books?
In my understanding, modern tutor books in the UK are a very recent developement. I know there were some very old tutors in the UK turn of last century stuff, but not applicable to us here and now. It might be that if the French have a long history of tuition then they have improved their books to the current level.
Dunno, merely thinking out loud, but it wasn't that long ago when here we had nothing to help you unless a mate was around that was further up the playing path than you and could offer some advice. Sort of sink or swim stuff!
Q
-
I wonder if the French have a longer history of tutor books?
Right answer, wrong question. In essence accordéon diatonique is seen as a 'real' instrument in France, whereas (I'd argue) not in Britain. Petit Jacques/Marie might well take diato up, either from home or at school, and would be assigned a tutor (or go to the local académie de musique.
That teacher would then usually have a diploma. There are also numerous 'serious' courses in summer and (as per me last week) school holidays. That means they put dots up, expect you you know where Bb is on your instrument! I have never seen ABC in use in France. Also very few players are 'self taught': indeed Pignol is mildly apologetic (http://norbertpignol.mustradem.com/biopresse.html) about being 'autodidacte'.
In this context, the odd manual is not entirely unexpected?
-
" Right answer, wrong question...."
;D
That's fascinating. I had no idea of the way the French regard their instrument. With a formal learning structure like that, it is, as you say, no coincidence the learning process is supported by equally formal and detailed tutors to back up the process.
It also answers the questions about the French workshops attended by you and the musical depths and complexity which you talk about afterwards. Their musical knowledge and depth applied by them to their tunes and instrument comes though.
That answers a lot of questions.
It also poses the question of 'which direction would we go?' for an English D/G tutor of similar depth and completeness.
With no formal learning structure or direction to aim for or support, anyone trying to put together a tutor would have a difficult task in my opinion.
Q
-
Right answer, wrong question. In essence accordéon diatonique is seen as a 'real' instrument in France, whereas (I'd argue) not in Britain. Petit Jacques/Marie might well take diato up, either from home or at school, and would be assigned a tutor (or go to the local académie de musique.
That teacher would then usually have a diploma. There are also numerous 'serious' courses in summer and (as per me last week) school holidays. That means they put dots up, expect you you know where Bb is on your instrument! I have never seen ABC in use in France. Also very few players are 'self taught': indeed Pignol is mildly apologetic (http://norbertpignol.mustradem.com/biopresse.html) about being 'autodidacte'.
In this context, the odd manual is not entirely unexpected?
I am sure everything you say is absolutely correct Chris.
Hopefully, in the next year or two, I will also be taking part in 'serious' courses in France. I am in the throws of changing my melodeons from the D/Gs that I have to G/Cs. It has taken me 2 years to decide on this and now I have bitten the bullet and I am waiting for my new instruments to arrive later this month. It makes a lot of sense for me because, not only do I love French music but also, I live in Jersey. Here, there are no melodeon teachers unfortunately but I am just 1 hour away from France on the ferry. I tend to go to France often, in fact I used to live there and I will definitely be looking out for helpful tuition in the future. There is a lot of choice. Meanwhile, the M&P books will do me nicely.
-
Don't get me wrong. Pignol is quite capable of disappearing up his own nether regions* when he gets deep enough into harmonics. But behind that he's got some deep understanding of what works ,and importantly why. Lately he's mapped all dominant chords - that's yer '7's in all 12 keys, diminisheds, augmenteds, Jamie Abersold A7b9,#9s even minor 7 turnarounds on folk ballads to just the three diminished scales "there are only three dominants" and y'know it works! (http://it works!) (solo is in latter half of the bourrée, peaks at 3'20)
But GC isn't so much about that … as simply having your useful notes in mid instrument. Rather than all heaped at the head end. And actually a 4th start achieves that (helper buttons the wierd stuff). The main reason GC works in France is that so much of the repertoire is in Am :|glug
[ed] *as am I ;)
-
A few words by someone who plays both the D/G (well, I moved to the A/D/G) and the G/C boxes.
The D/G and the G/C box are definitely the same instrument. What is different is the approach the first is played with in England, and the second in France, Spain or Italy. Let me stress that “in Englandâ€, since in Germany the C/F is played rather in a continental way! If you're rooted in one of the approaches, you might find hard to hug the other, although I think anybody could benefit to find his own synthesis between them.
Yes, it's true that on the D/G in England you play mainly in the lower octaves, where the full scales spans four buttons, while the G/C is played mainly in the upper ones, where the scales spans five. And that makes a bit of a difference, since we just have four fingers (and a thumb). Yet, this is telling just half of the story. That happens because in England most of the G/C boxes are models with just a couple of reeds.
On a D/G box with a third bank of (lower) reeds, you can actually play a majority of the continental tunes using the G/C fingering. Not all of them, since those that insist on the highest range of the G/C will sound squeaky on the D/G, but surely most of them. The opposite is not true, since using the fingering adopted in England for the D/G on the G/C will use the lower, muddy range on the latter, which is virtually never played at a fast pace. But then, a G/C player would usually transpose...
What makes a difference is not the tuning of the box, but rather that of the player!
About the publications that were quoted, the ones by Yann Dour are excellent. Probably on the same level is Fancesc Marimon's “Mètode d'Acordioo Diatonicâ€, issued in Spain in 1987. Not sure it's still available, and probably wouldn't anyway be the best choice for an English player because of the language barrier. But then, using both them, you are likely to learn little more than a 50% of what is worth learning about playing the melodeon.
By the way, I bought the first volume of the method by Pignol and Milleret when it got in print: their statement that the 3/4 is a “simple triple time rhythmâ€, while the 3/8 is a “compound single rhythm†(reading the French text, rather than the English translation, you end up with the idea that a 3/8 bar is in fact a single beat bar!) almost made me die out laughing. Then, since I saw no reason to waste time after someone who was reinventing the music theory, I decided, rather than buying the following volumes, to save my money for some Wodehouse's novels. But I don't know, maybe thein the following volumes they have improved...
On the French front, if I'm not wrong, Jean-Michel Corgeron, Francois heim and Patrick Quichaud had started publishing another method – the first volume wasn't bad at all.
Also, in Italy, a few year ago Andrea Capezzuoli put in print the first method in Italian. I just had a quick look at it, so I can't express a well thought opinion, but I know Andrea since he moved his first steps on the box, and I am sure it's worth the price.
The Dave Mallinson's D/G books for beginners, in my opinion, remain in a different league thought. None of the methods quoted above enters in a detailed discussion about the different solutions you can end up with when learning a tune. And yes, maybe there could be sense to ask for something similar for the intermediate player, but as they offer the beginner the chance to build some sound foundations, I guess after them one could as well progress on his own.
I haven't seen the Ed Rennie's D/G method yet – it was released after I stopped playing, and since I picked up again the boxes on my wish list there are really a number of books and CDs, more than the money in my pockets allow me to buy at the moment -, but the Bismarks's recordings are among my favourite English dance music albums, and his videos on YouTube are showing an English box player at his best. Given this, I think he could be the right man to fill the gap of a G/C method in English.
In the meanwhile, those who own a D/G box in thirds could profit from the stuff freely available for the G/C box on the web. There are literally thousands of tunes from France, Brittany and Italy in the two main tablature formats (that devised by Corgeron, and that adopted by the CADB), and to learn them there is no need to learn another language, and not even to read music. The tablatures, both systems, are released using two programs that offer a free viewer – Tabledit and Harmony Assistant-, so you just have to figure out what buttons you must use to play which note!
Peace!
Gianni
-
Gianni's post also led me to this site: http://diatonique-amateurs.pagesperso-orange.fr
Since my French is high school level, I am running it through the translate.google.com and it's not bad….
-
Plus, I learned a great new word "picotage" !
-
Well, probably the Accademia del Mantice will not be that popular here, after the comment of Barbara Rocchi's video of In Continental Mood, but their LinkTab page is quite useful - not a search engine, but an index to the actual web pages, listing now 2874 tablatures (but the numeber is increasing). Here's the link to the search page:
://www.organetto.info/archivio/index.php