Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Malcolm Austen on November 18, 2008, 12:42:34 PM

Title: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Malcolm Austen on November 18, 2008, 12:42:34 PM
I found the link to this article from a thread on the concertina.net.
A gift or hard graft? (http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2008/nov/15/malcolm-gladwell-outliers-extract)
I had read before that the average student starting a music degree would have done about 3000 hours practice and this seems to support the the idea that the main talent that you need is the ability / desire to practice.
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: TomB-R on November 18, 2008, 01:02:09 PM
Very interesting. Thank you for posting the link.

Yes, as it happens I did a rough calc the other day that a typical music student is likely to be on about 3,000 hours when they start college, and by the end of their course they should be on the 6,000 or so that's "traditionally" said to be necessary for a professional level.

Makes me feel better about my (fiddle) playing to estimate that I'm probably somewhere in the region 2,000-3,000 hours after ten years!  (That's leaving aside the issue of "playing" versus focussed "practice" of course! )

Tom
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Stiamh on November 18, 2008, 01:26:23 PM
In my view there's a fair amount of horsesh!t being spouted on this subject by certain people on concertina.net. Of course we need to practice, but I think people are just trying to make themselves feel better when they claim, as they appear to be doing over there, that talent doesn't exist or natural aptitude doesn't enter into it, and all you need to do is work your bum off.

Quote from: the article
Their research suggested that once you have enough ability to get into a top music school, the thing that distinguishes one performer from another is how hard he or she works.

In other words, they have talent to start with.

Another complicating factor is that the article is looking at people who began learning music as children. Many in the folk world start in their 30s, 40s, and beyond, at which point life will deal them a very different set of cards. I've taught many adult students, mainly fiddle and whistle, and some on accordion, and I can assure you that sheer dedication and hours of practice is not all that is required. A hard truth - heartbreaking, for some.

 
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: TomB-R on November 18, 2008, 03:07:56 PM
Very fair point about time of life Steve.

The impression I got from the article was that they found that it was hard to distinguish natural aptitude/talent from the willingness/capability to put the work in! That could be misread as saying there's no such thing as aptitude/talent! (As I think you're saying.)

I haven't read comments on concertina.net.

I think it's important to distinguish different levels.  The "rules" just aren't the same for time-limited older amateurs as they are for youngsters in education who are aiming at a professional level.
I think we all know those (often lovely people) who slog away for years with great enthusiasm, but never actually seem to make much progress.  (Perhaps that's most of us in some ways!)

Tom

Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Pushpull on November 18, 2008, 03:10:29 PM
In my view there's a fair amount of horsesh!t being spouted on this subject by certain people on concertina.net. Of course we need to practice, but I think people are just trying to make themselves feel better when they claim, as they appear to be doing over there, that talent doesn't exist or natural aptitude doesn't enter into it, and all you need to do is work your bum off.

Quote from: the article
Their research suggested that once you have enough ability to get into a top music school, the thing that distinguishes one performer from another is how hard he or she works.

In other words, they have talent to start with.
No it means they have put the work in - as the article states.

Note in particular this paragraph carrying on from where the above quote ends:
"the thing that distinguishes one performer from another is how hard he or she works. That's it. What's more, the people at the very top don't just work much harder than everyone else. They work much, much harder".

The 10000 hours thing gets bandied about a great deal, but I'm sure if you add up how many hours a top class musician has put in it's probably more than that. I think the issue is "what makes someone want to work that hard?" It's probably simply a love of music and the instrument and the feeling that time spent not playing is time wasted.
Quote
Another complicating factor is that the article is looking at people who began learning music as children. Many in the folk world start in their 30s, 40s, and beyond, at which point life will deal them a very different set of cards. I've taught many adult students, mainly fiddle and whistle, and some on accordion, and I can assure you that sheer dedication and hours of practice is not all that is required. A hard truth - heartbreaking, for some.
There are masses of adult beginners in all genres of music on all kinds of instruments doing very nicely. Frankly, I think if a person isn't getting anywhere, they either aren't putting in the amount of hours they think or say they are, or they aren't doing "effective" practice.
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: TomB-R on November 18, 2008, 03:15:01 PM
There are knots to tie oneself in here, but the points at issue seem to include:-

It's hard to distinguish between talent and capacity to put the work in.

Its hard to distinguish between talent and the capacity to practice (progress) effectively.

Tom
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Quebecois on November 18, 2008, 03:38:12 PM
The "better students" in music schools (i.e. those considered gifted) are encouraged and often compelled to spend more time practicing than the "average". Works with some students, doesn't seem to work with others.

In my family, out of 2 adults and 4 children, 3 had the "musical gift" and no matter how hard or how often the 3 others practiced they just could not get their music to sound fine! But the 3 that were good at playing got better with the practicing.

I think it also has to do with how motivated the would-be musicians are, like anything else. No motivation, poor results. Good motivation and teaching, combined with some talent can make great musicians.



Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Pushpull on November 18, 2008, 04:02:23 PM
There are knots to tie oneself in here, but the points at issue seem to include:-

It's hard to distinguish between talent and capacity to put the work in.

Its hard to distinguish between talent and the capacity to practice (progress) effectively.

Tom
Agreed. But if you have a genuine passion (not just a passing interest) in music, rockclimbing, football, stamp collecting, you WILL work hard at it and you WILL get better and probably get very good at it.
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Pushpull on November 18, 2008, 04:03:50 PM
The "better students" in music schools (i.e. those considered gifted) are encouraged and often compelled to spend more time practicing than the "average". Works with some students, doesn't seem to work with others.

In my family, out of 2 adults and 4 children, 3 had the "musical gift" and no matter how hard or how often the 3 others practiced they just could not get their music to sound fine! But the 3 that were good at playing got better with the practicing.
Were the 3 who were not "as good" as interested in music as the 3 who had the gift?
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Dazbo on November 18, 2008, 04:25:40 PM
So why can't top women athletes run as fast or throw things as far as their male equivalents?  I'm sure many women athletes put in as much, or more, effort than men but are obviously not as good.   Like all physical activity someone has to have both the mental and physical attributes to succeed and only a gifted few have enough of both to reach the very top. 

No matter how much time and effort someone puts in someone else who puts in the same amount of work will be better - I've seen this in education, sport and life in general.  To argue otherwise is to blame the unemployed person for being unemployed in a recession or a person dying of cancer is at fault for inheriting a cancer gene.

Of course to reach the top, or even half way you must hone what you've been given by practice, practice, practice but practice isn't the be all and end all of success or failure, however it is measured.
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Pushpull on November 18, 2008, 04:57:09 PM
So why can't top women athletes run as fast or throw things as far as their male equivalents?  I'm sure many women athletes put in as much, or more, effort than men but are obviously not as good.
Not as good? You mean not as fast or not as strong surely?
Quote
Like all physical activity someone has to have both the mental and physical attributes to succeed and only a gifted few have enough of both to reach the very top.
If we go back to the origin of this thread, it's to do with playing music. Now it can be argued that certain physical attributes can help or hinder. For example, I know a very talented young musician who started piano at 5 and transferred to oboe at 12 when it became obvious that her small hands and slender fingers meant she was better suited to that instrument. Within a year, she was studying at a conservatoire. Is she gifted? Well, I don't know but my rough estimate is that by now she's put in about 20000 hours of playing.

What does "musically gifted" mean anyway? If it's supposed to mean some inherent musically ability (God given or otherwise), I don't buy it. As I said before, those who succeed at something work hard at it and they work hard at it because they don't want to do anything else.
Quote
No matter how much time and effort someone puts in someone else who puts in the same amount of work will be better
If you read the article you will see that is not supported by the evidence.
"The curious thing about Ericsson's study is that he and his colleagues couldn't find any "naturals" - musicians who could float effortlessly to the top while practising a fraction of the time that their peers did. Nor could they find "grinds", people who worked harder than everyone else and yet just didn't have what it takes to break into the top ranks".

I'm not suggesting that everyone who puts in exactly the same amount of practice will be equally good. The quality of practice is vitally important. It is a fact that most people practice what they can already do. That doesn't bring any great results.
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Quebecois on November 18, 2008, 05:28:27 PM
Were the 3 who were not "as good" as interested in music as the 3 who had the gift?
Not really, that was part of the problem, also my mother is tone deaf!
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Pushpull on November 18, 2008, 05:36:13 PM
Were the 3 who were not "as good" as interested in music as the 3 who had the gift?
Not really, that was part of the problem, also my mother is tone deaf!
That's my point. It's nothing to do with being "gifted", it's to do with being interested.
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Quebecois on November 18, 2008, 06:49:04 PM
Some people say that "practice makes permanent"...  It's not only gift, interest and practice time, it's also about the quality of the work one puts in practicing. This is where a good teacher can help.

Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Pushpull on November 18, 2008, 06:55:30 PM
Some people say that "practice makes permanent"...  It's not only gift, interest and practice time, it's also about the quality of the work one puts in practicing. This is where a good teacher can help.
Indeed. As I said:
"I'm not suggesting that everyone who puts in exactly the same amount of practice will be equally good. The quality of practice is vitally important. It is a fact that most people practice what they can already do. That doesn't bring any great results".

Of course most of us learn to play squeezeboxes on our own or from books or from a mate. Not the best method is it?
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Simon W on November 18, 2008, 09:06:02 PM
For anyone who wants a better discussion of this study there's a book called "This is your brain on music" by Daniel Levitikin a neuroscientist. There is a chapter entitled "What makes a musician?" which discusses this study in much greater detail. As he says "Of course this doesn't explain why some people don't seem to get anywhere when they practice and why some people get more out of their practice sessions than others"
Its an interesting book and reasonably straightforward to read.

Simon

Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: george garside on November 18, 2008, 10:19:56 PM
Some people say that "practice makes permanent"...  It's not only gift, interest and practice time, it's also about the quality of the work one puts in practicing. This is where a good teacher can help.
Indeed. As I said:
"I'm not suggesting that everyone who puts in exactly the same amount of practice will be equally good. The quality of practice is vitally important. It is a fact that most people practice what they can already do. That doesn't bring any great results".

Of course most of us learn to play squeezeboxes on our own or from books or from a mate. Not the best method is it?

for most of us it its 10% inspiration & 90 % perspiration, the latter being necessary to develop the  degree of manual dexterity that is required to enable us to transfer  what is hopefully going on in the mind ( or on a sheet of dots, abc or whatever) to the atmosphere via the brain - arm - fingers  & box. Many players (of all & any instruments) are let down , not because of lack of 'musical ability'  but by not being able to opperate the machine  with aplomb!

george
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Ellie on November 18, 2008, 10:57:07 PM
I found the discussion on concertina.net to be profoundly depressing. There's musical ability which is unrelated to any particular instrument, then as George says, the dexterity on any particular instrument, and then there's practice. A combination of all these is obviously a good start.

More practicing it is, since there isn't much you can do about the others :D
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Dazbo on November 19, 2008, 12:49:12 PM
I'm not suggesting that everyone who puts in exactly the same amount of practice will be equally good

That's the point I was trying to make.  I am in no way trying to say that those with musical talent will rise to the top without any effort.  I'm not surprised that I can't play like John Spiers as I've not had the time since starting to put in the amount of hours he has since he started but I'm certain even if I had he would still be a better box player than I would be.

Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Dazbo on November 19, 2008, 01:03:56 PM
I've just figured out what has been nagging at my mind about the article referenced in the first post.

They say there were no natural musicians in the group, the only difference was that the best ones had worked hardest.   Surely the group studied were all very competent musicians BEFORE they went on to study the violin in tertiary education.  In other words they have self selected themselves and are not representative of the population as a whole.  So, it seems to me, they were trying to identify musical talent out of a self selecting group of musicians who must have had talent for music, the violin, hard graft or, more likely in my opinion, all three.

It made me laugh though that the lowest group were planning on being music teachers ;D those that can do, those that can't teach
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Alison Scott on November 19, 2008, 01:21:26 PM
I've just figured out what has been nagging at my mind about the article referenced in the first post.

They say there were no natural musicians in the group, the only difference was that the best ones had worked hardest.   Surely the group studied were all very competent musicians BEFORE they went on to study the violin in tertiary education.  In other words they have self selected themselves and are not representative of the population as a whole.  So, it seems to me, they were trying to identify musical talent out of a self selecting group of musicians who must have had talent for music, the violin, hard graft or, more likely in my opinion, all three.

It made me laugh though that the lowest group were planning on being music teachers ;D those that can do, those that can't teach

I don't think that the material in Gladwell's new book is terribly new, particularly as references music and sport (it's more controversial in other areas). Every article I've read about it misses a key point about outliers though, which is obvious to anyone who spends any time around them (particularly children). The articles keep talking about all the 'hard work' they do; but a key characteristic of these people is that the activity doesn't feel like work; it's just the thing you have to do, and want to do more than anything else. I think the talent  part is, as much as anything, the desire that's so strong it forces out other activity. I suspect that 10,000 hours is a little on the light side; it sounds like a lot, but by comparison I've put in way more than 10,000 hours into my professional career, even counting all the time I spend browsing melodeon.net.

(One of the reasons I know this is that I was an outlier as a child; I put in surely 10,000 hours in my speciality, perhaps a little more, and reaped the rewards. I went off to University and promptly discovered a ton of other interesting things to do, and very rapidly turned into someone who wasn't an outlier any more! Though some of my old teachers are still wistful about my 'lost potential').
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Pushpull on November 19, 2008, 02:08:43 PM
I think the talent  part is, as much as anything, the desire that's so strong it forces out other activity.
Exactly the point I was making Alison. It's not a "gift", it's a need to to it.
Quote
I suspect that 10,000 hours is a little on the light side; it sounds like a lot, but by comparison I've put in way more than 10,000 hours into my professional career, even counting all the time I spend browsing melodeon.net.
Yes I did that calculation myself  a while ago and I reckon it's close to the number of hours required to take a degree and then become professionally qualified.
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Pushpull on November 19, 2008, 02:10:33 PM
So, it seems to me, they were trying to identify musical talent out of a self selecting group of musicians who must have had talent for music, the violin, hard graft or, more likely in my opinion, all three.
I'm sorry Darren, i just don't buy this "talent for music" or "musically gifted". It's simply being interested enough to want to pursue it.
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Quebecois on November 19, 2008, 02:27:43 PM
I'm sorry Darren, i just don't buy this "talent for music" or "musically gifted". It's simply being interested enough to want to pursue it.
Yes, in theory anyone can learn anything given the proper motivation and interest.

However, some people learn faster than others, some require more help in their learning process. What we can call "gifted" people are those who seem to require less learning effort to get measurable results. I know a pianist who is 12 years old and plays better after 3 years of tutoring than other students (of the same teacher and equally motivated) who spent many more years studying and started at about the same age.

What gives?!? Pre-disposition? Better muscle memory? Faster brains?
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Malcolm Austen on November 19, 2008, 02:42:21 PM
I started this having just found the article an interesting read but after thinking about it a bit was going to make the same point as Darren. They were a selfselecting group as they had already attained a high level of proficiency and so any element of low or no talent was excluded.
There must be a range of conditions that will prevent people from attaining a high level of musical ability just one of which will be the lack of determination to practice.
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Stiamh on November 19, 2008, 02:56:02 PM
I'm sorry Darren, i just don't buy this "talent for music" or "musically gifted". It's simply being interested enough to want to pursue it.

So, Roy, if I understand you right, all you need to do is practise assiduously to get good at music. And to convince people that your point of view is correct, just keep repeating it assiduously?  ;D
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Pushpull on November 19, 2008, 03:22:05 PM
I'm sorry Darren, i just don't buy this "talent for music" or "musically gifted". It's simply being interested enough to want to pursue it.

So, Roy, if I understand you right, all you need to do is practise assiduously to get good at music.
Yes, though the practice has to be "good" practice.
Quote
And to convince people that your point of view is correct, just keep repeating it assiduously?  ;D
No. That would be the realm of evangelists. I don't have the required white suit.
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Stiamh on November 19, 2008, 07:07:26 PM
Ah, evangelists. Like Richard Dawkins, you mean? Maybe you should write "The Talent Delusion"...

Only kidding. I quite agree that interest, motivation and productive practice, and lots of it, are determining factors. And that when many people don't get on as fast as one might expect, it's because of a deficiency in one of these areas.

George's point about mechanics is well taken, btw, and it applies particularly to older learners.

Another factor is confidence in one's own ability to get on - resourcefulness, perseverence, and a will to battle through difficult moments and not get discouraged.

All that aside, my lifelong experience of my own abilities and lack of abilities in many areas, not just music, leads me to believe that one is predisposed to do well in some spheres and less so in others. (How much of this might be, for example, genetic, and how much the result of early exposure or encouragement, is irrelevant.)

Then there's my experience of teaching music over the past 20 years. Your observation that plenty of adult learners of music are doing well doesn't disprove the point I was making, which is that some fail to do well despite enormous dedication and persistence on their part, and patient help from a number of teachers. I've known a few. No doubt you'll say they weren't practising correctly. Perhaps you'd be able to show them how to, but I wasn't able to, with all the creativity I could muster, and neither could better musicians than I.

To use your expression, I just don't buy the idea that with equal motivation and equal amounts of work everyone will progress equally in music - or in any other avenue.

Cheers
Steve
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Pushpull on November 19, 2008, 07:29:54 PM
Ah, evangelists. Like Richard Dawkins, you mean?
Er, no. The other lot. The ones that don't have evidence to back up their claims.
Quote
All that aside, my lifelong experience of my own abilities and lack of abilities in many areas, not just music, leads me to believe that one is predisposed to do well in some spheres and less so in others. (How much of this might be, for example, genetic, and how much the result of early exposure or encouragement, is irrelevant.)
No Steve, it's not irrelevant, it's the essence of this particular discussion. Are we born with certain predispositions (e.g. a musical gift) or do we develop the means to progress in a particular sphere?
Quote
Then there's my experience of teaching music over the past 20 years. Your observation that plenty of adult learners of music are doing well doesn't disprove the point I was making, which is that some fail to do well despite enormous dedication and persistence on their part, and patient help from a number of teachers. I've known a few. No doubt you'll say they weren't practising correctly. Perhaps you'd be able to show them how to, but I wasn't able to, with all the creativity I could muster, and neither could better musicians than I.
No I doubt I could.
Quote

To use your expression, I just don't buy the idea that with equal motivation and equal amounts of work everyone will progress equally in music - or in any other avenue.
Well, given "standard deviation" of course we won't all end up the same but I think at the beginning we all have pretty much the same raw material to work with.
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Quebecois on November 19, 2008, 07:34:38 PM
Of course most of us learn to play squeezeboxes on our own or from books or from a mate. Not the best method is it?
Depends... If you have a plan and work towards getting better every time you practice, and not practice the same over and over, there will be progress. Of course, a good teacher is always welcome!
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Rob2Hook on November 20, 2008, 09:54:31 AM
No certainly not a quicker brain, that would maybe be useful, but it isn't a prerequisite!  Manual dexterity?  I think Django Reinhardt was a little challenged there!

There is definitely something (perhaps undefinable) in one's character that makes one take up chosen hobbies, pastimes and careers in the first place and something else again that drives some to greatness.  Thinking back to visiting the Music Room to try out some boxes, Squeezy was always more interested in what I was playing and why and could he join in, please?  Not a natural salesman in the conventional sense, but just what us box players could empathise with.

Getting enough time to practice may reveal a sadder aspect of one's character!  Let's not go there in too much detail, suffice to say I was living alone when I took up playing!  I am now engaged and doing practically no practicing = much happier!  Must get back to playing during lunch at work... (we have a sound proof room!)

Rob.
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Pushpull on November 20, 2008, 02:38:32 PM
No certainly not a quicker brain, that would maybe be useful, but it isn't a prerequisite!  Manual dexterity?  I think Django Reinhardt was a little challenged there!
Or indeed Paul Wittgenstein who lost his right arm in World War One, spent several years in a Russian PoW camp learning how to play with one hand on a cardboard box (no piano) and later went on to have many works written for him. And you tell the kids of today that............
Quote
There is definitely something (perhaps undefinable) in one's character that makes one take up chosen hobbies, pastimes and careers in the first place and something else again that drives some to greatness. 
Obsession?
Quote
Must get back to playing during lunch at work... (we have a sound proof room!)
I thought we had one of those until I was told otherwise.
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: george garside on November 20, 2008, 06:43:34 PM
Quote from: Rob2Hook link=topi !  Manual dexterity?  I think Django Reinhardt was a little challenged there!
[/

surely he needed to develop more not less manual dexterity as his two fully functioning fingers had to do the work of four

george
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Hello on November 21, 2008, 02:20:06 PM
Although most people can make good progress with the melodeon or any instrument, I do feel that everyone has a ceiling which at some point will be reached. The more you practice the quicker you'll reach this ceiling.
Where your ceiling is depends partly on an unfairly distributed musical aptitude (It seems to me that the extraordinary capabilities of some prodigies and savants serves to prove that aptitude is not a fiction) and partly on physical characteristics. For example there are two types of muscle fibers; slow twitch and fast twitch. If you happen to have more of the latter then you'll have faster fingers.

Even if you are a prodigy, you'll probably need to practice, but there's practice and there's practice.
Too many people consider practising as hacking through tunes hoping that if they play it long enough or fast enough, it'll all magically congeal. 
What practice really means to me is aiming to get something consistently right. This often requires a self-critical approach and a degree of restraint to play at a speed where you can get it accurate. As you get better, the threshold where it all falls apart will become further and further away so that eventually you'll make something quite complicated look effortless.

It's not a linear path, however. There's usually some sort of 2 steps forward one step back pattern.



Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Rob2Hook on November 21, 2008, 03:18:17 PM
I've tended to find that it's more of a plateau effect from time to time and then a sort of slow breakthrough.  Irritatingly (tantalising?) I sometimes sit down and play all the tunes I couldn't the day before and then realise I shan't be able to the next day either!
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: joe on December 15, 2008, 11:46:50 AM
I agree it seems to be plaeau / breakthrough. I just hate those timees when you feel like your playing is rubbish, that the rhythm has gone and you just cant seem get it back.
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: george garside on December 15, 2008, 01:29:47 PM
I agree it seems to be plaeau / breakthrough. I just hate those timees when you feel like your playing is rubbish, that the rhythm has gone and you just cant seem get it back.

when that happens its best left till tomorrow!

george
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Accordion Dave on January 25, 2009, 09:40:45 PM
I dislike the word "practice", although I do play my accordions for 2 or 3 hours each day. Practice sounds too much like work. For me the accordion is a great way to unwind after work. Sometimes that unwinding can take 4 hours. For several years I did not play much at all, but recently I have become very enthusiastic about the instrument. Part of this is due to the internet, exposing me to many different types of music that have the squeezebox at the forefront. I also enjoy attending various polka events. Instead of dancing, I enjoy watching and listening to the accordionists. I have learned many techniques that I never thought I could accomplish. I often get new ideas during a concert and try them out the next day. I have progressed more on the piano accordion in the past couple of years than in the 40 previous years. The diatonic accordion was always baffling to me. Websites such as this one have taken away some of the mystery. I have recently obtained a half dozen one and two row boxes that have steel reeds and bellows that don't leak. I am learning the ins and outs of the melodeon and having great fun doing it. I don't consider it to be work, although on some of the older leaky wheezeboxes it is indeed work. I keep my various boxes at various locations around the house, so I can squeeze out a tune when the urge presents itself. Time flies when you're having fun, but work can drag on forever.
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: FREED on February 09, 2009, 04:54:38 PM
Been a bit of a break in this thread but I thought I would add my (limited) experience which is that I can practice and practice and then quite unpredictably jump up a step. That's one of the things I really enjoy about these boxes, makes all the ordinary practice sessions worthwhile !! I struggle on because I know that eventually it will fall into place.
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Martin J on February 10, 2009, 01:25:41 PM
There is definitely talent/aptitude for playing any instrument and also a talent/aptitude for music.  The two are quite separate.  I've read comments on this net that noted one player as having more 'soul' than another despite the fantastic manual dexterity of the first player.  That again raises the point of how do we judge musical ability.  Speed alone is not it but superbly executed pieces done at speed can take the breath away.
Personally I have no talent and have to practice a lot but I know what I want to hear as music in the finished piece and by diligence I can get there eventually.  I know others who are more dexterous, pick tunes up more quickly but do not have the feel for the soul of the piece.  Such people are technicians and undoubtedly are both quicker at playing and learning a piece than I ever will be but as to who is the better musician then I think it should be left to the listener.
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Wurdal on February 10, 2009, 08:21:51 PM
I think that how far you progress on the melodeon will be a combination of teaching, practice and talent. For the average player (myself) the main factor is practice. The more I practice the better I get but I will never be virtuoso (just as I will never be an England striker). It depends how far you want to go. I think that a lot of dissatisfaction comes from comparing with professional recorded performers. Melodeons are associated mainly with folk music and the people who originally played these instruments would have been self taught and would probably have had a limited repertoire. What they did have was a function which was to play for dancing or for self entertainment. A lot of fun comes from playing with others complete with errors. If you know hundreds of tunes its not always possible to keep them in tip top condition. I played in a ad hoc ceilidh band with musicians who could sight read (I can read music slowly). I was amazed at their ability to play tunes at sight. However they could never remember the tunes and they had to play the dots as written. They on the other hand were amazed that I could keep so many tunes in my head and play them as needed (even if I had hacked them around a bit).I was the leader and organiser of the band and our fiddle player, who was a music teacher, thanked me for teaching her so much about music. It's a funny old world.
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Pete Dunk on February 10, 2009, 10:55:30 PM
There is definitely talent/aptitude for playing any instrument and also a talent/aptitude for music.  The two are quite separate.  I've read comments on this net that noted one player as having more 'soul' than another despite the fantastic manual dexterity of the first player.  That again raises the point of how do we judge musical ability.  Speed alone is not it but superbly executed pieces done at speed can take the breath away.
Personally I have no talent and have to practice a lot but I know what I want to hear as music in the finished piece and by diligence I can get there eventually.  I know others who are more dexterous, pick tunes up more quickly but do not have the feel for the soul of the piece.  Such people are technicians and undoubtedly are both quicker at playing and learning a piece than I ever will be but as to who is the better musician then I think it should be left to the listener.

Your thoughts here mirror mine perfectly. Just like you I don't think I have a particular talent or aptitude for music (although I do fervently believe that these exist) and anything I can play passably well is the result of dogged determination and hard work. Just once in a while though I do 'click' with a piece and gain a hard earned nod of approval (mixed with genuine surprise) from a good musician. Sometimes playing with genuine emotion and getting down to the nitty-gritty of the tune rather than the technical expertise required to play at a blistering speed really hits the spot.

Pete.
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: george garside on February 11, 2009, 08:57:31 PM
 the reality for most people is that learning to play melodeon or any other instrument  requires about 10% inspiration , which most people have, and 90% perspiration  wich most  of us find it difficult to aspire to!

george
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on February 13, 2009, 09:17:43 PM
I agree George, :-[  but I'm getting better!
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: HallelujahAl on February 23, 2009, 08:46:20 PM
Quote
the reality for most people is that learning to play melodeon or any other instrument  requires about 10% inspiration , which most people have, and 90% perspiration  wich most  of us find it difficult to aspire to!

george

I agree - but - there are ways of shifting the balance of the equation.  One of the best books that I have ever read (period) is by Joe Morelli the great accordion teacher (Target Focus, Imperial Printing Inc, North Vancouver, BC. 1997).  In his introduction he compares the two following directives:

1. "You must try harder. You must work harder and practice more."

with

2. "Find a lay-back; don't push it. Don't try to play, let the playing happen.  It must happen by itself with no interference from you".

The first directive, he says is made up of three fixed points. Trying is a fixed point, because trying of itself is, is not a force that always moves in just one direction - it vacillates.  One tries, and in the process of trying, inevitably fails or falls back to some degree only to try again.  This he describes as the 'teeter-totter effect of trying'. It operates like the familiar pendulum. I guess we all know that feeling.

Alternatively, he suggests that the pupil drop any thought about perfection.  Quality practice he says is really the art of exploring.

Now we can either focus on the 'work & practice routine' - which is a false surrender in my opinion, a giving in to the false idea that only by the sweat of our brow will we improve (a kick-back from the Protestant work ethic). 

Or we can save our energy and focus on exploring our own possibilities and discovering our instruments whilst developing & honing the good habits needed to explore some more.  Its not hard work then - its just fun - which I guess is also the reason why most of us here are involved in this forum?!

AL
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Quebecois on February 23, 2009, 10:21:13 PM
...
Or we can save our energy and focus on exploring our own possibilities and discovering our instruments whilst developing & honing the good habits needed to explore some more.  Its not hard work then - its just fun - which I guess is also the reason why most of us here are involved in this forum?!
AL
Right on! I call it "fun work".

Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Accordion Dave on February 25, 2009, 04:22:52 AM
Hallelujah!

This Joe Morelli sounds like a good teacher. Exploration and letting the music happen is what seems to work for me.

The diatonic accordion was baffling to me a several years ago. Now the music seems to flow.

The same thing has happened with the piano accordion, as I listen to and observe the great accordionists.

I will figure out something new, try it out, and a few days later it will sort of just "click".


 

Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: HallelujahAl on February 25, 2009, 08:49:38 AM
Quote
This Joe Morelli sounds like a good teacher. Exploration and letting the music happen is what seems to work for me.


Yes Joe Morelli's teaching has radically altered the way I play (don't you think it's funny how playing and hard work have seem to become interchangeable terms in some folks minds?). To me it's all play now.

AL
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Bryson on February 25, 2009, 11:13:49 PM
I play melodeon therefore I am.

Choose a tune you really like e.g. after hearing it, say, ten times.

Investigate the ways the melodeon could play the tune. Not simple, but worthwhile.

Experiment with the different ways.

Decide you've got it. This is a decisive critical step, sometimes having to leave behind possibilities.

Play and practice like mad until you have it as you envisaged when you first took a step into the tune. (see above - choose a tune that turns you on :)

If you like a tune i.e. you are not learning it to take part in a session. An excellent apprenticeship though it is. Swim in it ... with the arcane possibilities of the Melodeon as a fascinating and rewarding way to spend one's time. Seems better then losing 100 billion dollars
greetings from Berlin
Bryson
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Quebecois on February 26, 2009, 03:34:26 PM
Play and practice like mad until you have it as you envisaged when you first took a step into the tune.
This seems to me like the critical point. I practice s-l-o-w-l-y each segment of the tune until all notes sound right, then assemble the segments progressively increasing the tempo until it reaches the expected speed. What I find amazing is that every time I get back to the tune, the fingering and bellows movements seem to occur without giving them much thinking. And that's a great reward!
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: OwenG on February 26, 2009, 05:05:23 PM
What I try and do is find key milestones in the tune. In other words, I try and have an idea in my head of where the tune is going and what the key points are, and then use the s-l-o-w-l-y technique to fill in the gaps and link the sections together.

The thing that I struggle with is moving from being able to play the tune through competently with a decent accompaniment, to turning it into a 'thing' with a definite structure, or a beginning, middle and end. I really like Bryson's advice of experimenting with all of the different ways of playing and accompanying the tune, so perhaps this will provide the ideas I need to develop tunes.
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: HallelujahAl on February 27, 2009, 10:42:37 AM
Thing is that this kind of exploration is not simply an esoteric finger in the hole exercise that only happens at home, on one's own. It is a very corporate activity too. Was out last night at our Morris side's rehearsal and found myself listening not just to myself but to all the other musicians too.  I noticed that whilst we were all - technically speaking - playing the same tune, the variants within were quite startling. And as we played more we were inadvertantly 'learning' to gel or mould our differences into something really quite acceptable - shame about the dancing ;D

AL
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Bryson on February 27, 2009, 11:26:48 PM
Yes! We should practice to sing and dance at the same time as playing (sic) the melodeon. :)
greeting!
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on February 28, 2009, 10:40:54 PM
Both our side's main box players do this as a matter of course, often joining in a set while playing or adding an extra pair. I find it more difficult to dance and play as a fiddler (which is probably the real reason for my starting to learn melodeon!), but I usually manage something! We also have special musicians' sets for certain dances.
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: HallelujahAl on March 01, 2009, 10:42:36 AM
Quote
We also have special musicians' sets for certain dances.

Ah, (to keep to the thread) but do you play, dance and sing?

AL
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on March 01, 2009, 10:20:16 PM
I didn't read Bryson's post properly did I?  :'( Two out of three isn't bad though  ......
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: HallelujahAl on March 02, 2009, 03:04:37 PM
Quote
Two out of three isn't bad though  ..

Ye gods, two out three by my reckoning is pretty remarkable!
AL
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Bryson on March 03, 2009, 10:04:28 PM
There's another thing I have found useful when having a struggle making any progress with a dream tune (see my post above) e.g. executing (..til dead of course) a particular run (left or right hand) and that is to focus fully on the rhythm of the tune i.e. forget the notes and focus on their rhythm (e.g. is the tune a reel, jig, polka etc). 

I've recently been having a go at a jig called Shores of Lough Gowna. On practicing with a fiddler mate, who had, incidentally, introduced me to the tune, I found myself saying that my aim was to "Hang the notes on the rhythm".

I think when you practice it presents the opportunity not only of improving the mechanics of actually playing the tune but also an opportunity to get under the skin of a tune and the melodeon. A sort of "If you focus on the destination you may miss beautiful landscapes on the way."
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Quebecois on March 04, 2009, 03:29:44 PM
Another tool that helps improve your playing is the metronome. I was amazed at how uneven my rhythm was for most of the tunes I play until I put on the metronome and tried to keep an even tempo... This is useful practice especially when playing for dancers.
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on March 04, 2009, 03:38:33 PM
I shall now turn this *****ing thing of and do some practice! (Honest!)

 :-[
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: HallelujahAl on March 04, 2009, 07:41:04 PM
Quote
I shall now turn this *****ing thing of and do some practice! (Honest!)

 


Naw..I'm so much better when I talk about it!
AL
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Owen Woods on March 14, 2009, 12:32:13 PM
Another tool that helps improve your playing is the metronome. I was amazed at how uneven my rhythm was for most of the tunes I play until I put on the metronome and tried to keep an even tempo... This is useful practice especially when playing for dancers.


I'll second that. My metronome is coming with me next term after my few disastrous attempts at playing for Morris...
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Theo on March 14, 2009, 12:36:34 PM
Another tool that helps improve your playing is the metronome. I was amazed at how uneven my rhythm was for most of the tunes I play until I put on the metronome and tried to keep an even tempo... This is useful practice especially when playing for dancers.


I'll second that. My metronome is coming with me next term after my few disastrous attempts at playing for Morris...

Except that (speaking as a non-Morris musician)  when I watch Morris teams in action, the best ones don't play anything like a fixed tempo, there are constant shifts in tempo to support the dancers.  To my ear its one of the characteristics of Morris.
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Owen Woods on March 14, 2009, 12:55:36 PM
Another tool that helps improve your playing is the metronome. I was amazed at how uneven my rhythm was for most of the tunes I play until I put on the metronome and tried to keep an even tempo... This is useful practice especially when playing for dancers.


I'll second that. My metronome is coming with me next term after my few disastrous attempts at playing for Morris...

Except that (speaking as a non-Morris musician)  when I watch Morris teams in action, the best ones don't play anything like a fixed tempo, there are constant shifts in tempo to support the dancers.  To my ear its one of the characteristics of Morris.

Aye, but it would help if I was playing rhythmically to start with ;) It's one of those things that when you're dancing feels entirely natural and when playing throws you into a sort of panic. I always forget how to play the melodeon when playing for Morris. Most peculiar.
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: george garside on March 14, 2009, 04:47:23 PM
[

Except that (speaking as a non-Morris musician)  when I watch Morris teams in action, the best ones don't play anything like a fixed tempo, there are constant shifts in tempo to support the dancers.  To my ear its one of the characteristics of Morris.

I have always found that for any sort of dancing, eg ceilidh, morris( in its many manifestations) & old time the simplest way is to beet your foot  at exaactly the same rate as the best dance i.e. your foot  must come down at exactly the same time as the dancers so that you can concentrate on shoving them up again on the offbeat ( the beat does not need  strong emphasis as  gravity brings the buggers down with or without your efforts to make them hover! 

When playing for other than dancing I find the foot , or sometimes feet, function as a sort of built in metronome whilst , as Theo suggests, allowing scope for  SLIGHT deviations in tempo to suite whatever is going on.  Foot tapping also helps enormously to keep a band together( or indeed a session) just look along the line at everybodys feet including yours - if they are all goin up & down precicely together & match the landings & take offs of the dancers you are all in synchronised perfection - otherwise you are heading towards the SH-ONE-T!

george
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Martin J on March 14, 2009, 05:37:42 PM
 :( We have a local 'musician' who always taps his feet out of sync, whatever he or anyone else is playing.  Most disquieting.
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: george garside on March 14, 2009, 08:22:09 PM
:( We have a local 'musician' who always taps his feet out of sync, whatever he or anyone else is playing.  Most disquieting.

Indeed!  thats why I try to get everybody watching everybody elses feet ( and have suggested to certain individuals that if there feet arn't doing the same as the rest of the band they should stop playing.  Or is your person keeping time ok but footuping when he should be footdowning, which would perhaps work  but as you say be somewhat disconcerting.

george
Title: Re: Practice Practice Practice
Post by: Martin J on March 14, 2009, 11:05:54 PM
Just a skat out as we say.  Very close but not quite with the music.  The foot tapping unfortunately is anywhere and seems totally disconnected from anything else thats going on, his or anyone else's playing !  :(
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal