Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: mac on November 15, 2012, 09:23:10 PM

Title: Playing basses on one row.?
Post by: mac on November 15, 2012, 09:23:10 PM
Is it  a case of just do what sounds right for playing bass notes.?

I'd ideally like to get stronger at left hand rhythm, but I feel I might be overanalysing it and trying to be spot on for every note.

Any tips?

:)

Edit: I spent some time playing classical guitar and this could be what is throwing me off? every note matters and classical guitar sticks to the sheet music so much, but melodeon seems a whole lot looser in its playing..?
Title: Re: Playing basses on one row.?
Post by: Rob2Hook on November 15, 2012, 10:29:06 PM
Yes, you're right.  Some phrases allow you to bash away with the "wrong" bass and still sound OK, but some clash so badly that you have to find another way around it.  If you have to drop the base against a particular phrase then maybe you can find a harmony on the right hand to stop it thinning out too much and time the stop and start of the bass to give a more interesting rythmic effect than simply missinga beat...?

It's a simple folk instrument and compromises have to be made.

Rob.
Title: Re: Playing basses on one row.?
Post by: rees on November 15, 2012, 11:10:19 PM
Try missing out the bass note and just vamp on the chord button for a few phrases, then maybe drop the chord and hold the bass note, then back to oom-pah.
You only have 1 and 5 chords in the left hand so it can clash when playing a 4 or 6 note. I usually drop the left hand if dwelling on a 4 or 6 note and maybe play 4 and 6 together or octave thereof.
It depends on the tune. Oscar Woods used to plod away on the left hand whatever was happening in the right - it sounds just fine.
Title: Re: Playing basses on one row.?
Post by: george garside on November 16, 2012, 09:53:07 AM
   leaving the bass off where they don't sound so good will throw the emphasis onto the treble  which can provide a totally free of charge bit of ornementation - less can be more!

george
Title: Re: Playing basses on one row.?
Post by: terry on November 16, 2012, 10:31:10 AM
I have the same problem with bass notes and my left hand, what ever I do, first of all does not sound right, then I find my self messing up the tune with my other hand.

Hopefully there will be someone at the Fleece next weekend who will enlighten me a little more in the mysteries of the bass notes on my one row.

Terry (:)

Title: Re: Playing basses on one row.?
Post by: Lester on November 16, 2012, 11:10:34 AM
I have the same problem with bass notes and my left hand, what ever I do, first of all does not sound right, then I find my self messing up the tune with my other hand.

Hopefully there will be someone at the Fleece next weekend who will enlighten me a little more in the mysteries of the bass notes on my one row.

Terry (:)

I'll bring a 1 row or two, but it is mostly just a matter of turning down your musical expectations  ;)

For at least 50% of the pull notes the bass will sound odd (wrong) but it is how it is, look up on it as percussion. Plus don't try minor key tunes or the basses will sound really wrong  :o
Title: Re: Playing basses on one row.?
Post by: rees on November 16, 2012, 01:17:15 PM
Good point about the minor keys, Lester.
I play in E, A and D minor on the C one row and never touch the basses.
In fact the only note that I have never used as the tonic (root?) is B - any takers?
Title: Re: Playing basses on one row.?
Post by: Simon W on November 16, 2012, 02:49:00 PM
   leaving the bass off where they don't sound so good will throw the emphasis onto the treble  which can provide a totally free of charge bit of ornementation - less can be more!

george

If you watch this clip of Andy Cutting on the one row he only plays bass on the B part of the tune. Still sounds bloody good though.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HQpDe6Q_sss
Funnily enough I was thinking that a one row bass technique workshop would be good at Witney. The best players are capable of doing really subtle things with just the two buttons.

Simon
Title: Re: Playing basses on one row.?
Post by: terry on November 16, 2012, 06:37:11 PM
I'll bring a 1 row or two, but it is mostly just a matter of turning down your musical expectations  ;)

For at least 50% of the pull notes the bass will sound odd (wrong) but it is how it is, look up on it as percussion. Plus don't try minor key tunes or the basses will sound really wrong  :o

Thanks Lester, really looking forward to it.

Terry (:)
Title: Re: Playing basses on one row.?
Post by: rees on November 16, 2012, 06:41:05 PM


If you watch this clip of Andy Cutting on the one row he only plays bass on the B part of the tune. Still sounds bloody good though.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HQpDe6Q_sss
Funnily enough I was thinking that a one row bass technique workshop would be good at Witney. The best players are capable of doing really subtle things with just the two buttons.

Simon

Super doops - first part in minor, no basses - second part in first position with basses.
Title: Re: Playing basses on one row.?
Post by: mac on November 17, 2012, 09:52:00 PM
I have the same problem with bass notes and my left hand, what ever I do, first of all does not sound right, then I find my self messing up the tune with my other hand.

Hopefully there will be someone at the Fleece next weekend who will enlighten me a little more in the mysteries of the bass notes on my one row.

Terry (:)

Hi folks thanks for the replies  (:)
terry I did a search here earlier and came up with this

http://sites.google.com/site/lesterbailey/TuftySwift.pdf

Page 8 of that document has really helped me out..
Title: Re: Playing basses on one row.?
Post by: Lester on November 17, 2012, 10:24:10 PM
Hi folks thanks for the replies  (:)
terry I did a search here earlier and came up with this

http://sites.google.com/site/lesterbailey/TuftySwift.pdf

Page 8 of that document has really helped me out..

Forgotten all about that or that I had it up on my Google Site  :P
Title: Re: Playing basses on one row.?
Post by: mac on November 18, 2012, 07:47:14 AM
Hi folks thanks for the replies  (:)
trry I did a search here earlier and came up with this

http://sites.google.com/site/lesterbailey/TuftySwift.pdf

Page 8 of that document has really helped me out..

Forgotten all about that or that I had it up on my Google Site  :P

Its a great resource.
I wonder if the piece of card between the spoons idea he wrote of would really work?
Has anyone here tried it? I imagine it would need a very large piece to begin with?
Title: Re: Playing basses on one row.?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on November 18, 2012, 08:31:24 AM
I wonder if the piece of card between the spoons idea he wrote of would really work?
Has anyone here tried it? I imagine it would need a very large piece to begin with?
A better idea for a buffer is to glue two thin strips of cork (cut from a wine cork) under the points where the spoon handle tips impact the wooden body of the melodeon. They don't have to be very large pieces - you can make them quite small and discrete. You could also use a piece of dense felt or leather.
Title: Re: Playing basses on one row.?
Post by: Sage Herb on November 18, 2012, 08:34:39 AM

I wonder if the piece of card between the spoons idea he wrote of would really work?
Has anyone here tried it? I imagine it would need a very large piece to begin with?
[/quote]

I once saw a picture of one of Oscar Woods' boxes and it had the cardboard from a Woodbine packet used in this way. So it's traditional!
Title: Re: Playing basses on one row.?
Post by: Lester on November 18, 2012, 08:57:49 AM
I wonder if the piece of card between the spoons idea he wrote of would really work?
Has anyone here tried it? I imagine it would need a very large piece to begin with?

I use little stick on rubber feet from Maplin. Really good at quieting the bass clack.
Title: Re: Playing basses on one row.?
Post by: Anahata on November 18, 2012, 09:00:23 AM
On a one-row, I often make a RH chord when the basses don't fit. Even just an octave helps, e.g. on a C box when you are playing a G and really want a G chord.
Title: Re: Playing basses on one row.?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on November 18, 2012, 09:02:49 AM
I use little stick on rubber feet from Maplin. Really good at quieting the bass clack.
That's a good idea! These things (http://www.maplin.co.uk/stick-on-feet-1840) I guess?
Title: Re: Playing basses on one row.?
Post by: Lester on November 18, 2012, 08:38:00 PM
I use little stick on rubber feet from Maplin. Really good at quieting the bass clack.
That's a good idea! These things (http://www.maplin.co.uk/stick-on-feet-1840) I guess?

The very things
Title: Re: Playing basses on one row.?
Post by: mac on November 21, 2012, 09:38:42 PM
My instrument has gouges from where the spoons have hit the body, from playing by its previous owner.

Would fitting the rubber feet (or the other suggestions) raise the action and make the basses easier to play? since they have less travel.

I can see this might work, but really?
Title: Re: Playing basses on one row.?
Post by: rees on November 22, 2012, 12:28:23 AM
Less travel = less aperture = less grunt. For me this would be a bad thing but mileage may differ.
Title: Re: Playing basses on one row.?
Post by: Anahata on November 22, 2012, 08:19:36 AM
My instrument has gouges from where the spoons have hit the body, from playing by its previous owner.

Would fitting the rubber feet (or the other suggestions) raise the action and make the basses easier to play? since they have less travel.

I can see this might work, but really?

Yes. I've done my G box with a couple of bits cut off an unused mousemat. Maplin rubber feet would have done a neater job, I must say.
It does reduce the travel, and it has been suggested elsewhere that this will prolong spring life too, though it's hard to prove that. It certainly reduced the noise. I don't know if it makes the basses easier to play, but it's surprising how different it feels, and how the sound is somehow smoother without those clacks.


Title: Re: Playing basses on one row.?
Post by: mac on December 03, 2012, 10:05:12 PM
I got a little piece of felt and placed in under the spoons, it certainly reduces the clunky playing noises.

But I am at a loss at how to fix it? glue like PVA seems a bit extreme to use,blu tak gets fluffy in about 5 minutes of playing.. So any ideas?

Title: Re: Playing basses on one row.?
Post by: Lester on December 03, 2012, 10:07:08 PM
I got a little piece of felt and placed in under the spoons, it certainly reduces the clunky playing noises.

But I am at a loss at how to fix it? glue like PVA seems a bit extreme to use,blu tak gets fluffy in about 5 minutes of playing.. So any ideas?

I would use PVA myself but you could try double sided sticky tape as a less permanant solution
Title: Re: Playing basses on one row.?
Post by: rees on December 03, 2012, 10:18:20 PM
Bostik Solvent Free Adhesive is a bit less harsh than PVA.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal