Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: waltzman on November 26, 2008, 02:35:05 PM
-
Are the D rows on a C#/D the same as on an A/D melodeon? My understanding is the the D row on a D/G covers a lower octave than on the A/D but I'm not sure of this and I don't know where the C#/D fits in.
Michael
-
It seems to me that the outside row is always* an octave lower than the inner row in the same key (for quint boxes anyway). So the G row on a GC is an octave lower than the G row on a DG, C row on CF lower than the C row on a GC etc. If Irish boxes follow this then I'd guess that the inner D row would probably be the same octave as the D on a GD. Would a the D row on a DD# box then be an octave lower than the D row on a C#D? Can't imagine it would be but I could believe Italian makers would make that assumption.
*your experience may vary
-
The answer is yes - the D row on a C#/D covers the same range as that on an A/D, but you'll probably have a couple of extra low notes (no need for accidentals on a semitone box).
The D row on a D/G is _not_ an octave lower than that on an A/D, BTW. But you'll have extra notes on a D/G D row because you have more buttons.
-
The way it works with quint* boxes is that (apart from 'specials') D/G is the highest, then C/F, then Bb/Eb, then A/D, then C/G which is the lowest. G is the only key that occurs on the inside row of one and the outside row of another and therefore has a low and a high version.
*All very well calling it that but just try playing Britten's 'The Turn of the Tcrew' on one.
-
Retires somewhere to try and remove foot from mouth ???
-
The way it works with quint* boxes is that (apart from 'specials') D/G is the highest, then C/F, then Bb/Eb, then A/D, then C/G which is the lowest. G is the only key that occurs on the inside row of one and the outside row of another and therefore has a low and a high version.
D also is found on inside row of A/D and outside row of D/G, but in this case they are in the same octave
-
I'm glad to see someone was paying attention!
-
C also is found on inside row of G/C and outside row of C/F, but in this case they are in the same octave
-
I like 1-row, they are so predictable...
-
C also is found on inside row of G/C and outside row of C/F, but in this case they are in the same octave
I've not been well, y'know. What I should have said is: "G is the only key that occurs on the inside row of one and the outside row of another a lower pitched one and therefore has a low and a high version."
-
There, there, poor wee dab.
Have a lie down, cuddle up to your favourite melodeon and all will be well. ::)
-
What I should have said is: "G is the only key that occurs on the inside row of one and the outside row of another a lower pitched one and therefore has a low and a high version."
Well I've not got any excuses but that's what I thought you'd said ;D
-
Anybody else read this thread three times and still come away mystified??????
-
Oh, I get it now.
If you think of an A/D/G triple row as a conjoined A/D and D/G, you will see the D row is common pitch to both, being the OUTSIDE row of a D/G and the INSIDE row of an A/D
-
Let me see if I understand this correctly. All the D rows on melodeons cover the same two octaves give or take a note or two depending on 'extra low notes' vs accidentals.
-
CORRECTION:
F/Bb is the lowest, with F on the outside being one full octave BELOW the inside f-row of a C/F.
-
CORRECTION:
F/Bb is the lowest, with F on the outside being one full octave BELOW the inside f-row of a C/F.
I have never seen or heard of a commercially available F/Bb from a major builder.
I have rebuilt a couple of 2 row Hohners to that pitch at customers' request, and I'm currently repitching an Erica to E/A.
I've probably done a dozen or so low octave D/Gs over the years too, standard D/G fingering, but an octave down. Great sound imho, though the bottom end of the D row is a little slower to respond than I'd like...certainly not great for fast Irish sessions.
How much lower can we get??? ;D (The Elysium, I suppose.)
MC