Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => News and Events => Topic started by: Ollie on November 27, 2012, 12:36:09 AM

Title: Squeeze This! A Cultural History of the Accordion in America
Post by: Ollie on November 27, 2012, 12:36:09 AM
Just discovered this new book whilst doing some research.

http://www.press.uillinois.edu/books/catalog/47bqd8bm9780252036750.html

The link also includes a 50 minute interview with the author.

 (:)
Title: Re: Squeeze This! A Cultural History of the Accordion in America
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 27, 2012, 07:13:07 AM
Hmmm .. the GREATEST influences on the accordion were the 'apartment building', (17'15") and the 'German occupation of Mexico' (17'55").  I'm gonna have to rethink quite a lot! Cue Godwin's law? :|glug

Title: Re: Squeeze This! A Cultural History of the Accordion in America
Post by: jb on November 27, 2012, 11:36:33 AM
Hmmm .. the GREATEST influences on the accordion were the 'apartment building', (17'15") and the 'German occupation of Mexico' (17'55").  I'm gonna have to rethink quite a lot! Cue Godwin's law?
Had me startled too, initially.
'Occupation' in the migratory sense rather than the military, though. German settlers in Mexico (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_Mexican) and Texas (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_Texan) had a formative (and obvious to the ear) influence on TexMex music  (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tejano_music) and its instrumentation (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conjunto).
Title: Re: Squeeze This! A Cultural History of the Accordion in America
Post by: David J on November 30, 2012, 01:37:33 PM
Received this yesterday as a birthday present. Some fine pictures in the middle of it and it's nicely printed. Could be a tad too much of 'socio-ethnologist' type guff judging by the introduction, but I'll report back.
Title: Re: Squeeze This! A Cultural History of the Accordion in America
Post by: David J on December 10, 2012, 02:08:11 PM
Well I've finished reading it, or skim-reading it to be precise. Frankly I fail to see how any cultural history of the accordion in America can ignore the diatonic box, and the author has problems in keeping it out of the narrative, with Flaco Jimenez and other players being cited. Another example of this is trying to discuss cajun and zydeco and just referencing Buckwheat Zydeco and Clifton Chenier, when most of the top players use a button box.

The book reads like an expanded version of somebody's thesis, which is probably what it is, with an awful lot of repetition, and concentrates largely on vaudeville performers, the 'industrial accordion complex' (the quite small number of actual US accordion manufacturers), the 'studio system' where performers opened chains of shops-cum-tuition centres all over the north of the states, the particular association of the PA with polka and other European immigrant communities, and accordion groups and associations involved in its revival. IMO whole chunks of the picture are missing - e.g. its use in jazz, or country music (Western Swing artists of the '30's and other acts like the Carter Sisters in the '40s).

And then there's the obsession with Lawrence Welk. Having looked up some YT videos of the man's TV shows, I can see why the PA's association with this kind of hokum did for its image, along with the advent of rock and roll of course. Again, there's a rather insular assessment of this, with the implication that what happened in the States was somehow different to the rest of the world. Welk's sidekick Myron Floren was clearly a very talented guy. Check out this for an example of great skill combined with terrible taste:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0ziYB_73u2E

So if you have a particular interest in PA or its American performers the book could be of interest. There isn't enough musical context to make it generally worthwhile. For a more meaningful idea of the accordion in American history, I recommend Annie Proulx's 'Accordion Crimes', which does include both PA's and melodeons. The 'hero' of this book is, of course, a little 2-row diatonic  ;)
Title: Re: Squeeze This! A Cultural History of the Accordion in America
Post by: Theo on December 10, 2012, 02:17:07 PM
great skill combined with terrible taste:

Probably sums up why the piano accordion fell out of favour. ;)
Title: Re: Squeeze This! A Cultural History of the Accordion in America
Post by: Mystery Jig on December 10, 2012, 02:46:14 PM
Cajun and Zydeco are two different kinds of music. I've never heard cajun on anything but a one row and never heard zydeco on anything but a piano accordion.
Title: Re: Squeeze This! A Cultural History of the Accordion in America
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on December 10, 2012, 02:57:25 PM
Cajun and Zydeco are two different kinds of music. I've never heard cajun on anything but a one row and never heard zydeco on anything but a piano accordion.

Even in my limited experience that just ain't true. Look up Boozoo Chavis and Rosie Ledet just to start with for Zydeco.

Considering their close links (Zycdeco and Cajun), it would be rather astonishing not to have Zydeco one-row players.

Edited to add: though of course it might have been to your experience, but that that can always be updated  :-)
Title: Re: Squeeze This! A Cultural History of the Accordion in America
Post by: Mystery Jig on December 10, 2012, 03:28:29 PM
Sure, they're related, like Miles Davis and Tommy Dorsey both play jazz. But I still say Zydeco and Cajun are different. Speaking broadly, cajun is more like country/folk music with simple two chord waltzes and fiddle. Zydeco is more like rock/jazz with electric bass, rub board and drums.

You're absolutely right to say there are a few zydeco box players with button accordions in their hands. There's exceptions to every rule. But I've still never seen a cajun player use a piano accordion.
Title: Re: Squeeze This! A Cultural History of the Accordion in America
Post by: Matthew B on December 10, 2012, 03:29:45 PM
Squeeze This sounds a bit one-dimensional, from your description.  There are studies that cover the wide range of accordion-friendly musical traditions in the US, North America, and South America.  However, they tend to be quite specialized.  See, for example Guadalupe San Miguel's Tejano Proud: Tex-Mex Music in the Twentieth Century.  These kinds of books tend towards ethnomusicology, and are definitely the stuff of academic discussion.  For example a friend of mine has been working for a couple of decades on the definitive work analyzing the squeeze-box music of Franco-Americans in Maine.  In my opinion the best broad overview of the influence of the instrument(s) on this side of the Atlantic is still Annie Proulx's Accordion Crimes.  The novel is remarkable in part because it acknowledges so many of the different musical (and a few of the non-musical) uses to which the instrument has been put in the past couple of hundred years.  The author has a remarkable grasp of the variety and scope of squeezed free-reed music.  If I recall correctly she worked quite closely with the late Rich Morse of The Button Box in Amherst, MA when she was writing the book. 

Meanwhile, if you want a better history of free reeds in the Americas, I think you'll have to write it yourself!

Oh, and Mystery Jig, come by the house: I've a few CDs to lend you!   
Title: Re: Squeeze This! A Cultural History of the Accordion in America
Post by: Mystery Jig on December 10, 2012, 04:09:23 PM
Hey, Matthew B, I'll do that. Thank you. I'm going to the library today to get a copy of that Annie Proulx novel for sure.
Title: Re: Squeeze This! A Cultural History of the Accordion in America
Post by: AirTime on December 10, 2012, 07:53:51 PM
Unfortunately, I'm not sure you can over-estimate the influence of Lawrence Welk in making the accordion the unhippest instrument in north America - it's "ethnic" music at its schmaltziest.  :(
Title: Re: Squeeze This! A Cultural History of the Accordion in America
Post by: Johnf on December 11, 2012, 10:49:12 PM
Cajun and Zydeco are two different kinds of music. I've never heard cajun on anything but a one row and never heard zydeco on anything but a piano accordion.

Even in my limited experience that just ain't true. Look up Boozoo Chavis and Rosie Ledet just to start with for Zydeco.

Considering their close links (Zycdeco and Cajun), it would be rather astonishing not to have Zydeco one-row players.

Edited to add: though of course it might have been to your experience, but that that can always be updated  :-)

Absolutely there are Zydeco one-row players, especially in more recent years. There is quite a lot of overlap between the cajun/creole/zydeco worlds and many modern Zydeco players are actually moving away from PA and back to the one-row box. Clifton Chenier was in their grandfather's day. If you would like to learn about the evolution of Zydeco and the relationships between these three forms check out the book "The Kingdom of Zydeco" by Michael Tisserand.  Very interesting read.
Title: Re: Squeeze This! A Cultural History of the Accordion in America
Post by: AlexCJones on November 28, 2013, 04:33:56 PM
I recently checked out "Squeeze This!" from the library, and I was put off by her description of the 3 row chromatic button accordion.  She confused a 3-row with a 5-row.

Also, it is centered around the Piano accordion, so I skimmed it for what I could find about Diatonic Button Accordions, but it is not enough.  Many other valid criticisms of it have already been posted here, as well as in other places around the web.  I suppose I could read through it and find more things to criticize about it too, but I have found enough to convince me not to waste my time.  I am glad that I borrowed it from the public library and did not buy it.

I found another book that I like better that I recently started reading.  Each chapter is by a different author, but I am calling attention to this other book in a separate thread: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,13675.0.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,13675.0.html)

If I like this other book enough, I might buy my own copy.
Title: Re: Squeeze This! A Cultural History of the Accordion in America
Post by: Kimric Smythe on December 03, 2013, 05:11:59 PM
You may want to check out a video a friend of mine did http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4qyzcSfvOwc&list=FLN1uchlHIA6DYaedaHmnWVg it took about 7 yrs to make and a lot of the older players he interviewed have passed on. It is somewhat US centric but he get a lot of ethnic stuff in too.
Title: Re: Squeeze This! A Cultural History of the Accordion in America
Post by: MandoC on December 04, 2013, 02:06:03 AM
Folks:  Just today I saw this book in our library and checked it out.  I had to choose between the accordion book and David Byrne's book about music.  Sounds like I should have picked David's book. But I'll have a look at it anyway.  Charlie
Title: Re: Squeeze This! A Cultural History of the Accordion in America
Post by: Chris Brimley on December 04, 2013, 09:50:15 AM
It does sound interesting, I might buy one.  (Annie Proulx's novel is probably more about multi-cultural integration than the accordion, but it's a cracking book for all that.)

I don't know who wrote this blurb:
Quote
the accordion as a uniquely American musical and cultural phenomenon.
, but if I was the author, I would have immediately put that in the bin!
Title: Re: Squeeze This! A Cultural History of the Accordion in America
Post by: AlexCJones on December 17, 2013, 03:17:22 AM
It does sound interesting, I might buy one.  (Annie Proulx's novel is probably more about multi-cultural integration than the accordion, but it's a cracking book for all that.)

I don't know who wrote this blurb:
Quote
the accordion as a uniquely American musical and cultural phenomenon.
, but if I was the author, I would have immediately put that in the bin!
Ha ha ha ha! (A simply LOL did not suffice) Where did you see that one?  Was that actually something Marion Jacobson said or wrote?
Title: Re: Squeeze This! A Cultural History of the Accordion in America
Post by: Kimric Smythe on December 30, 2013, 04:33:58 PM
The book has a lot of info, but it is a bit uneven.
Title: Re: Squeeze This! A Cultural History of the Accordion in America
Post by: Novascotian on January 01, 2014, 11:44:52 PM
I looked at a copy of this book recently too, and I strongly agree with the general drift of other people's comments.  The whole take struck me as too much in the thrall of Tin Pan Alley and American pop mythology.  Although I do believe the diatonic squeezebox tradition was much more prominent in British (especially Eastern) Canada and Newfoundland, the absence of any serious treatment in her book is unscholarly.  As far as the Zydeco-Cajun distinction is concerned, I would say the same point applies.  Early 20th-century Cajun music still retained something of the musical culture of old Nova Scotian Acadia, and much less of the bar room aesthetic of American popular music.  As a middle-aged Maritimer, I have witnessed the sharp decline of authentic Acadian playing in Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, and Prince Edward Island, and it's replacement by the Zydeco-influenced festival music that has arisen as the Americanization of the Canadian Acadians through false history pedalled by social historians and sociologists like the author of this book.  In Cape Breton and PEI, Acadian music closely relates to and resembles the Scottish and West Country English country dance music played by other Maritimers often at the same dances and until quite recent times.  My grandparents used to dance set dances to melodeon and harmonica in covered bridges and barns as late as the 1940s.  I know this music was also played in Maine and New England, and probably elsewhere in the US as well.  By the way, anyone interested in historical recordings should have a poke through the Virtual Gramophone site from the Canadian Archives (http://www.collectionscanada.gc.ca/gramophone/028011-9000-e.html).  Although not on a button box, I can especially recommend Cock of the North and Caller Herrin by David Ferguson, the Canadian Jimmy Hendrix of the pipes (http://www.collectionscanada.gc.ca/obj/028011/f3/2763.ram).  There are dozens and dozens of wonderful things there.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal