Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Mike Higgins on November 28, 2008, 11:58:11 AM

Title: Replacement reeds
Post by: Mike Higgins on November 28, 2008, 11:58:11 AM
Anybody got an opinion as to a good source of reeds for me old hohner pokerwork? I actually need something for the bass end and I understand that knowledge of the dark arts of tuning won't be necessary.

Mike
Title: Re: Replacement reeds
Post by: Theo on November 28, 2008, 01:14:33 PM
Mike

What reeds do you actually need?  I have some Hohner reeds is stock.
I understand that knowledge of the dark arts of tuning won't be necessary.

Do you mean you are happy to play with the bass end out of tune?
Title: Re: Replacement reeds
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on November 29, 2008, 02:16:51 AM

Near enough for folk music! (Cringe!!!)

MC

Title: Re: Replacement reeds
Post by: Mike Higgins on November 29, 2008, 12:59:30 PM
The tongue which is missing sounds an F# as part of the draw D chord. The other tongue sounds a G as part of the push G chord.
I, foolishly it now seems, believed that these things were manufactured to sound an F# and a G. I have seen references in these august pages which refer to cents etc but thought it was all a bit esoteric. I came to squeezy music via brass instruments and played in bands and an orchestra where we sort of agreed what an F# sharp should sound like before we started, this agreement helped us enormously to avoid fights brought on by using different F#s. I suppose I should be glad to have thrown off the fetters of concert pitch and to have the freedom to choose my own. Or, as usual, have I missed the point somewhere?

Regards

Mike
Title: Re: Replacement reeds
Post by: Falseknight on November 29, 2008, 02:15:24 PM
Contrary to what some musicians may believe, and indeed proclaim, free reed instruments are actually tuned, nd tuned to concert pitch as well.

Regrettably, the process is much more complicated than pulling out a tuning slide or turning a tuning peg.  The instrument needs partially dismantling and meal removing from the right place on the reed to bring it in tune.  This means it is beyond the scope of even many experienced musicians.

That said, once tuned, they stay in tune better than more or less anything I can think of, so it is worth getting it done properly.
Title: Re: Replacement reeds
Post by: an bosca ceoil on November 29, 2008, 03:43:06 PM
Getting back to your initial question.
What sort of Pokerwork is it (one or two row) and what key/s is it?
Are the broken tongues on the same button?
Regards,
Bruce
Title: Re: Replacement reeds
Post by: Mike Higgins on November 29, 2008, 04:33:57 PM
It is a two row D/G pokerwork and the button in question produces the D chord on the pull. The actual tongue which is missing produces the F# on the pull, the G tongue ie the push is sounding fine.
Title: Re: Replacement reeds
Post by: BruceHenderson on November 29, 2008, 06:28:14 PM
The tongue which is missing sounds an F# as part of the draw D chord. The other tongue sounds a G as part of the push G chord.
I, foolishly it now seems, believed that these things were manufactured to sound an F# and a G. I have seen references in these august pages which refer to cents etc but thought it was all a bit esoteric. I came to squeezy music via brass instruments and played in bands and an orchestra where we sort of agreed what an F# sharp should sound like before we started, this agreement helped us enormously to avoid fights brought on by using different F#s. I suppose I should be glad to have thrown off the fetters of concert pitch and to have the freedom to choose my own. Or, as usual, have I missed the point somewhere?

Regards  Mike 

    Mike, one thing that hasn't been said is that you can take a new reed that's straight out of the wax paper from the manufacturer and put it on a "tuning table" and it may (or may not) make a perfect F#.  Then, if you install that reed onto a reed block, it will almost certainly make a different tone than the bare reed (assembly with frame) itself.  And to make it all even worse, if you install the reed block into the instrument, the tone will be (almost certainly) changed again!

    Add to this the fact that the "valve" (or "leather" as it is sometimes called) will alter the pitch of the reed, and you can see how complicated the whole thing becomes. 

    What all this means is that every reed must be installed into the instrument, tested, and then tuned to final pitch.  There's just no other way to do it (unless you're a Chinese manufacturer, that is ... sorry, just couldn't resist the tempation  ;) )

BH NC USA
Title: Re: Replacement reeds
Post by: Theo on November 29, 2008, 06:34:58 PM
The tongue which is missing sounds an F# as part of the draw D chord. The other tongue sounds a G as part of the push G chord.
I, foolishly it now seems, believed that these things were manufactured to sound an F# and a G. I have seen references in these august pages which refer to cents etc but thought it was all a bit esoteric. I came to squeezy music via brass instruments and played in bands and an orchestra where we sort of agreed what an F# sharp should sound like before we started, this agreement helped us enormously to avoid fights brought on by using different F#s. I suppose I should be glad to have thrown off the fetters of concert pitch and to have the freedom to choose my own. Or, as usual, have I missed the point somewhere?

Regards

Mike

In that case your best course of action is to take out the reedblock (the wooden block rather like a very large harmonica) and send it to your favourite melodeon repairer who will replace the reedplate that carries the broke reed, and tune it for you.

Title: Re: Replacement reeds
Post by: Mike Higgins on November 30, 2008, 10:21:16 AM
Thanks very much to everyone who has replied to this post. I now have a much greater understanding of the difficulties and intricacies of tuning a replacement reed.

From these responses it seems likely that loads of people are playing out of tune melodeons as they are frequently played in damp places, or where sudden ingresses of beer can happen, so that the reeds can become corroded, thus affecting the speed at which the tongues vibrate. I would hazard a guess that it is likely that this deterioration goes unnoticed by the players as it is gradual

This forum is populated by very knowledgeable and experienced players so, chaps(esses), how often should we do a tune up and how long does it take? From the descriptions of the tuning process a long time I would think?
Title: Re: Replacement reeds
Post by: BruceHenderson on November 30, 2008, 06:09:07 PM
(snip) This forum is populated by very knowledgeable and experienced players so, chaps(esses), how often should we do a tune up and how long does it take? From the descriptions of the tuning process a long time I would think?

    I am not a repairer but I did get my 15-year-old Hascy retuned about a year ago.  A complicating factor is that I asked for a complete retune to "Dedic" tuning (which meant a slight tone change on all the "M" reeds) but the tuner said that he was quite surprized to see that there was no rust (despite the fact that the box had been to the seaside a few times), little dirt, and few reeds had gone out of their original factory tune.  I don't remember what I paid and the time it took was greatly obscured by the fact that I shipped the box from the US to the UK for this work (thus considerable shipping times), but a simple check on reads and "leathers/valves" and touchup tuning would be quicker and cheaper than what I had.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal