Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Lester on November 28, 2008, 07:31:10 PM
-
Just received a Music Room catalogue which is offering a own brand melodeon with the following spiel:
Designed by Martin Banks of Oakwood
Quality Italian Reeds
Cherry wood case work
Bass Stop for thirds
Made in China
Price £599 c/w bag and straps
Not much their website other than a PICCY (http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/images/melodeon1.jpg)
Looks good value if it plays well, so has anyone tried one?
-
Not played one, but it seems expensive for a Chinese box.
Compare with a (Chinese) Hohner Compadre or a (German) Hohner Morganne, or for that matter a Delicia Popular III or one of the 2 or 3 reed Weltmeisters. it MIGHT leave them all for dead and justify the price - then again, it might not.
-
Just received a Music Room catalogue which is offering a own brand melodeon with the following spiel:
Designed by Martin Banks of Oakwood
Quality Italian Reeds
Cherry wood case work
Bass Stop for thirds
Made in China
Price £599 c/w bag and straps
Not much their website other than a PICCY (http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/images/melodeon1.jpg)
Looks good value if it plays well, so has anyone tried one?
Yes- I've played a couple. Jon Loomes had them at Broadstairs Folkweek and at Fylde Folk Festival.
I think for a Chinese built box they are well built, although they ain't no Italian box. They do have Italian reeds in, and they respond very well. The action seemed quite light, although being chinese I don't know how long the springs last. The wood is plain cherry, and the bellows are reasonable quality too. They've been developed with Martyn at Oakwood and the grille looks much like the old Oakwood design (although these boxes are nowhere near that good!)
Normally sold as a "Sandpiper" (Music rooms own brand) for £899, which I think is well over priced! The ones in the Christmas specials catalogue are the prototypes that Martyn developed. This means they have no badge, and things like the grille design, and bass stop osition will vary a little bit. But at £599 I think they are actually good value. I'm going to put my neck on the line here and say they're better than a Hohner Morgane in my opinion... :o
But I think the price for them ALL (not just the prototypes) should be £600 or less, not £900!
-
Seen one, heard it, tried it briefly, put it down. Scratched my head... couldn't say I either liked or disliked it, but felt somehow nonplussed by the concept. I can see where they are coming from... obviously an attempt at a 'posh box' for the post credit crunch world, but honestly, if you can score a nice old Hohner for less, I personally can't see the point.
It seems to be neither fish nor fowl - tries hard to look like an Oakwood, which we know it isn't. And this mass cross-kitting of Italian/Chinese bits... I can't particularly see eye to eye with the sense of it...
Some TexMex vendors have been doing this - one was having Italian designed carcasses assembled in China and fitted with their bits, and marketed as something else. Subsequently there were some issues with it devaluing the brand, and related Italian production - which was seen as suspect by association.
At least a Morgane doesn't pretend to be something else - BTW I think Morganes are fabricated (but maybe not assembled) by Delicia/Elpro in the Czech Republic.
£900? ??? :o
As far as I see it, in this more cautious era, put that sort of cash towards something better, or a used box... plenty about...
Ed J
-
(snip) Looks good value if it plays well, so has anyone tried one?
No, haven't tried one or even seen one, but it's kind of like kissing Candice Bergen ... you see, I'm spoiled for anything else in my life. I've played one of Rees's one-rows and I'm sure that nothing else is ever going to live up to THAT!
-
(he blushes) :-*
Good to meet you at Witney, Bruce.
-
I've tried the Sandpiper and also a couple of months ago a prototype vs a Morgane - I prefered the Morgane to be honest but I suppose it depends which prototype you try. I thought the Sandpiper was okay value for the money, I'd still prefer a dino though even if it is a couple of hundred more.
-
The web site says that these are the prototypes of the Sandpiper that are sold at that price, as noted above, so who knows what you might get!
http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/cPath/244_249_485/products_id/4258
-
these are the prototypes of the Sandpiper
They look nice. Too bad they have one too many rows. ;)
-
Sandpiper? Parrot? Same origin? :)
-
Sandpiper? Parrot? Same origin? :)
Just as long as its not a turkey ;D
-
Just as long as its not a turkey ;D
I'd just slurped a mouthful of coffee when I read this and damned near choked to death. There should be a health warning on some of Theo's posts. :o ;D
-
;D
-
I own one of the prototypes.
They were originally on the site for £500 and I bought it in their sale with a 20% discount.
For £400 I'm happy with what i've got... but i'm only a learner and haven't played many boxes so my opinion isn't worth much i'm afraid.
When I spoke to the Music Room they asked me if I had a dry or wet tuned box - when I said dry they told me I had been lucky, the dry tuned prototypes had better quality reeds. They had rejected the reeds in the earlier batch and specified an upgrade in the later prototypes.
So if you decide to buy, give them a call first!
:)
-
It's admirable that they are trying to push the level of quality higher for affordable boxes. The problem is, Chinese factories can be as leaky as the Titanic, so it is only a matter of time before the Oakwood/Music Room design will be copied, exactly, by another factory, which will flood the market.
-
It's admirable that they are trying to push the level of quality higher for affordable boxes. The problem is, Chinese factories can be as leaky as the Titanic, so it is only a matter of time before the Oakwood/Music Room design will be copied, exactly, by another factory, which will flood the market.
I don't know about accordeons but in other industries, they suffer from "batchitis". You'll get one that's really great and all the others in the batch will have similar quality -- then the next batch, disaster! It wouldn't surprize me at all if it worked that way with instruments, too.