Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: midweb on November 30, 2012, 11:17:32 AM
-
If you go up the scale in either D or G, what are the correct umm pahs, is there a correct base or chord note for a given note played, or is it tune dependent.
sorry if its a stupid question only I have searched but cant find the answer, I am trying to play the bases for Star of County Down which I think is um pa pa, um pa pa, but if I watch the following video, his bases are all over the place, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l_i02lpfD1U
Mick
-
If you go up the scale in either D or G, what are the correct umm pahs, is there a correct base or chord note for a given note played, or is it tune dependent.
sorry if its a stupid question only I have searched but cant find the answer, I am trying to play the bases for Star of County Down which I think is um pa pa, um pa pa, but if I watch the following video, his bases are all over the place, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l_i02lpfD1U
Mick
It is not a stupid question and for a beginner there are some simple "rules" for playing in G or D*. The problem with the Star of the County Down is that it is in E Minor and needs most, if not all, the chords on your box.
Beginners Basses (yes I know there are better?, cross row, sexier, multi finger options)
Playing in G up and down the G row using the lower four basses;
On the push play the G Bass/Chord
On the pull against A and F# play the D Bass/Chord
On the pull against C and E play the C Bass/Chord
Playing in D up and down the D row using the lower four basses;
On the push play the D Bass/Chord
On the pull against E and C# the A Bass/Chord
On the pull against G and B play the E Min Bass/Chord
-
Thanks Lester will give it a go, I can play a couple of tunes with the um pas but not the right ones.
Mick
-
Actually, the basses on the link are a synchopated um-pa-pa, but he is walking around a chord progression which includes an unusual A major. That one is only a transient thing and when I ran through it I found myself playing a C bass at that point and thinking of the song, I was playing it in four time (um-pah). That just shows how influenced I was by music lessons at school all those years ago, wher I wrote the harmonisation exercises almost entirely as a three chord trick (I, IV, V) - everything sounded like hymn tunes!
Rob.
-
his bases are all over the place, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l_i02lpfD1U
Mick
I'm sure you don't mean it like it sounds (I think), but the guy in the video is playing lovely bass (:)
Having only recently started watching peoples' left hands on Youtube I knew exactly what Midweb meant! ;D
-
his bases are all over the place, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l_i02lpfD1U
Mick
I'm sure you don't mean it like it sounds (I think), but the guy in the video is playing lovely bass (:)
No should have phrased it better, where as I play the g chord and bases for the g row, on the video he is playing what looks like all 8 lower bases, something I would love to be able to do, at the moment Im struggling with two.
-
Try playing Bonny Kate.
In the B part you can play:
two beats of G,
one beat A
one beat B
two beats C
one beat D on pull
then continue with the obvious basses till the end.
You can do all this while playing the melody on the G row.
-
You'll be well confused watching that video. He's playing it on a G/C box, and in in the higher register which is typical for G/C playing. It's a minor key tune so the usual rules for playing in major keys don't apply and he's using both treble rows.
On a D/G box you'd be playing it in E minor an octave lower, and some of the notes are E on the D row accompanied by E minor chord, also B on the D row with E minor, and low B on the G row with a B minor chord - another pitfall because your box might have a B major instead of a B minor, so you fake it with a B bass note a a D chord.
So a general beginner's guide to what chords to play wouldn't really cover a tune like that.
-
Thank Theo, Anahata, if anyone else is following this thread I am going to have ago at what Theo sugested, below
Mick
-
It was was Theo who in an earlier thread pointed out something I hadn't noticed before, that you can also go one note further up the scale with an E bass under the G at the top of that sequence. You have to play the G on the D row, which is counterintuitive for a beginner, but it's possible.
Also, 3 notes later where the tune goes e | d e/f/ g ... you can have the basses go C | B A G down the scale they've just gone up. :||: :|glug