Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: rees on November 30, 2012, 10:16:33 PM
-
Following on from the recent kerfuffle regarding standard and non-standard keyboard layouts, I have received the following message from Castagnari:
".............. regarding your order for model Hascy with D/G layout (here attached).
About this layout, we have found it very smart and viable as it makes the D/G a bit lower than the usual, and in facts we have decided to make
it become the new standard D/G layout."
Smart and viable layout pictured below (4th button start with low notes and accidentals) - a victory for Signor Ryall methinks.
Lester old bean, could you update the 2 row keyboard layouts to include this 21 button jobbie, please (:)
-
Smart. ;D
-
Following on from the recent kerfuffle regarding standard and non-standard keyboard layouts, I have received the following message from Castagnari:
".............. regarding your order for model Hascy with D/G layout (here attached).
About this layout, we have found it very smart and viable as it makes the D/G a bit lower than the usual, and in facts we have decided to make
it become the new standard D/G layout."
Excellent! Great news!
Smart and viable layout pictured below (4th button start with low notes and accidentals) - a victory for Signor Ryall methinks.
Whispers: Actually it was me... :|bl ;)
Chris was an enthusiast of the so-called 'Anahata' layout. Myself and Ukebert of this parish preferred this current Castagnari layout. The various merits of the two layouts were debated at length on this forum a couple of years ago.
-
For anyone coming into this late, the original threads (summer 2011) were
21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7019.0.html) 28 May
The standard British D/G should be '4th note start' extra low scale+accidentals (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7358.0.html) 3 July
What should those extra buttons be on a "Standard" British 4th start D/G? (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7727.0.html) 31 August
I'd like to thank Steve (who's not even from UK!) for that original post, that sparked our discussion.
Winning The most popular layout round here was Anahata's, this very much 'optimised for G' (and it's modes). Castagnari have chosen Ukebert's suggested layout, which was championed in the debate as being more flexible, and lasting a beginner longer. It was quite fairly pointed out that quite a few suppliers were already offering this.
I'd emailed our ballot result to the big music shops, and to Hohner in Germany. I'm not aware of any response from them, but if Casta have been won over, I suspect this may be all credit to Rees. Nice to see a big maker willing to change, and sensitive to a national market. Time to toast to melnet's success! :|glug
-
A bit more history on the current layout under discussion and its connection with Castaganari:
My Sander (see my avatar pic) has exactly this 21 button layout with the 4th-button start, low notes and accidentals. This came from Castagnari in this configuration, i.e. it wasn't subsequently modified/converted to a 4th-button start. From the outset, the reed block chamber lengths appear to have been correctly made to fit the longer reed tongue lengths which are needed for the extra low notes.
I took delivery of this instrument in October 2009, so Castagnari were aware of this layout back then, but clearly didn't pick up on its advantages for 21 button 2-row D/G instruments at that time.
I have to say that I love this layout, especially the low push B and F# on the 2nd buttons, and the standard reversal pull D and pull A. For me, the resulting duplication of the pull D and A is a real advantage, as it enables me to play richer RH harmonies and drone effects.
Finally, this layout is not a new idea of course. Saltarelle have been using it for years and years on very many of their 2-row 23-button instruments. For details see the layout link on the forum Home page here (http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/DG23acc.gif).
-
Thanks for the links to the debates, Chris!
... Winning layout round here was Anahata's, this very much 'optimised for G' (and it's modes). Castagnari have chosen Ukebert's suggested layout, which was championed in the debate as being more flexible, and lasting a beginner longer. It was quite fairly pointed out that quite a few suppliers were already offering this....
The thing that upset me a bit at the time was the occasional ferocity of the debate and the idea of having to choose the merits of one particular layout over another. I was (and still am) saddened by the concept of having to have a 'winning layout'. Both Anahata's and the Saltarelle (aka Ukebert) 4th button start layout have great advantages, but they tend to be a bit mutually exclusive. The things you can do with one, you can't always do with the other and vice versa (1).
Which layout you prefer is very much your personal choice depending on the style of your playing and the type of music you like to play. I would very much hope that the choice could always be open and that we are not railroaded by over-enthusiastic lobbying of manufacturers into taking either one route or the other. There is room for both.
1. There is a similar dilemma for anglo concertina players who have to choose between the Jeffries and Wheatstone layouts of notes on the RH third row. Players of single melody line Irish music tend to prefer the Jeffries layout, English-style chordal/harmonic playing tends to be easier and more logical with the Wheatstone system. Both systems have evolved in parallel and both systems are (comparatively) readily available.
-
Spoken like the true gentleman you are Steve. Personally I rather like the omission of the reversal on a one row but I guess that's never going to happen after this length of time. All the Best mory
-
Hi Steve, Rees and all
This is great news!
... I just wanted to add a little point from the tuners perspective ... Steve quite rightly comments
"Both Anahata's and the Saltarelle (aka Ukebert) 4th button start layout have great advantages, but they tend to be a bit mutually exclusive. The things you can do with one, you can't always do with the other and vice versa (1). "
The two 4th button start layouts are indeed different in what you can play and I am a great fan of the Anahata layout. But for anyone who has this Castagnari (or Ukebert) version of 4th button start, the work to have it changed to the Anahata version,should they wish to do so, is absolutely minimal. Change the F# press to G and change the D draw to C.
Compare this with the current situation ... for people wanting the Anahata layout and having a 3rd button start instrument, it is a much bigger job - removing all the treble reeds, cleaning reedblocks, chamber-work, additional reeds in the space created, rewaxing the treble end... then having to check/tweak the tuning throughout.
My point is that whichever variant 4th button start you prefer, this is great news.
Mike R
-
100% agree with Mike.
The great benefit for us tuners of a 4th button start of either variety is it removes the two highest reeds. These reeds are a royal PITA to tune and never (well almost never) ever get played so are a waste of time and cost to the customer.
-
100% agree with Mike.
The great benefit for us tuners of a 4th button start of either variety is it removes the two highest reeds. These reeds are a royal PITA to tune a
It's not really difficult after enough practice, and with the right tools.
-
.. and I can confide that Theo is at this very moment (figuratively) converting the family's "Dolly's box" Casta Lilly into Anahata's layout, with a glighton. Basically it's for chording so that seemed to make most sense to us.
As for this thread and the excellent news: I think "it's about" getting 4th button start seen as the sensible option for D/G, and possibly adjacent tunings? Accidentals then make sense to me.
I think what those extra 2 buttons might carry, and the "accs or not" question will always be a personal choice - I'm entirely content with what Castagnari have picked 8)
-
that is the low note and accidental 4th button do set up I have on my DG Lilly
george
-
Sounds good to me too , I`d have gone for that for my Lilly if I`d have had the choice but for ease sake, I`ll probably just replace the accidentals with low notes on mine , I`ve only used the F# and only then on one tune I can live without playing on it - the Lack of low notes is restricting me quite a bit .
-
100% agree with Mike.
The great benefit for us tuners of a 4th button start of either variety is it removes the two highest reeds. These reeds are a royal PITA to tune a
It's not really difficult after enough practice, and with the right tools.
I agree it is not really difficult but it is harder than the bigger reeds and no one plays them so it's a waste of time.
-
Following on from the recent kerfuffle regarding standard and non-standard keyboard layouts, I have received the following message from Castagnari:
".............. regarding your order for model Hascy with D/G layout (here attached).
About this layout, we have found it very smart and viable as it makes the D/G a bit lower than the usual, and in facts we have decided to make
it become the new standard D/G layout."
Smart and viable layout pictured below (4th button start with low notes and accidentals) - a victory for Signor Ryall methinks.
Lester old bean, could you update the 2 row keyboard layouts to include this 21 button jobbie, please (:)
Still has the F/Eb accidental the "wrong" way round ;-)
(only my opinion obviously -- you need the Eb on push for all those nice Em waltzes where the second phrase ends on a B major with a third on the RH)
Ian
-
Still has the F/Eb accidental the "wrong" way round ;-)
(only my opinion obviously -- you need the Eb on push for all those nice Em waltzes where the second phrase ends on a B major with a third on the RH)
Yes - totally agree. Flipping the reed plates to give me Eb/D# on the push is one of the first things I do on any of my instruments.
-
]".............. regarding your order for model Hascy with D/G layout (here attached). About this layout, we have found it very smart and viable as it makes the D/G a bit lower than the usual, and in facts we have decided to make it become the new standard D/G layout."
.. way up of accidentals will always be a choice, but I'm sure Rees is up to adjusting this for customers.
And just to be accurate on this - we decided, not the Italians! :|glug
-
]".............. regarding your order for model Hascy with D/G layout (here attached). About this layout, we have found it very smart and viable as it makes the D/G a bit lower than the usual, and in facts we have decided to make it become the new standard D/G layout."
.. way up of accidentals will always be a choice, but I'm sure Rees is up to adjusting this for customers.
And just to be accurate on this - we decided, not the Italians! :|glug
I kind of guess you are purposely misreading what Castagnari said? They were discussing their decision to change their D/G layout. The current 3rd button start will remain the de-facto standard until everyone else as well as a niche Italian maker changes.
-
Smart and viable layout pictured below (4th button start with low notes and accidentals) - a victory for Signor Ryall methinks.
Whispers: Actually it was me... :|bl ;)
[/quote]
Oops, sorry Steve, my mishtake :|glug
-
I like the low notes from a fouth button start - ALL of them, so I'd really need a half row for the accidentals, like on my Clubs. With my small hands I can't stretch the extra distance! The low notes allow things like The African Queen and the proximity of the accidentals on a half row allows me to tackle The Pterodactyl Twostep - couldn't manage either of these with the "new standard".
Rob.
-
I took delivery of this instrument in October 2009, so Castagnari were aware of this layout back then, but clearly didn't pick up on its advantages for 21 button 2-row D/G instruments at that time.
As has been recorded before, that particular Sander was originally ordered by me in April or May 2008 and I surely can't have been the first to ask for it. What took them so long to realise the potential of a 4th button start for D/G?. ???
..although if I'd known about the Anahata layout then, I would have asked for that...
-
I'm really pleased that such a major maker has listened to it's customers and adapted to them.
As mentioned, it's the 4th button start idea that's the true victory and then relatively easy to make a change as to which version you want.
In years to come we'll eventually make it the norm.......
Well done all those who have written, spoken and emailed makers to get this result.
Q
-
Just to say #2 .. the Dutch maker Frans van der Aa is making me a 'compact' C#/D/G. Box is made and he's putting the other bits together starting this week ;D I've asked for 4th button start ;) of course. And that C# row affords 24(!) accidentals. Respected maker, yes. But I suspect most of his stuff is bespoke so it won't change the course of melodeon history much :|glug
-
I took delivery of this instrument in October 2009, so Castagnari were aware of this layout back then, but clearly didn't pick up on its advantages for 21 button 2-row D/G instruments at that time.
As has been recorded before, that particular Sander was originally ordered by me in April or May 2008 and I surely can't have been the first to ask for it. What took them so long to realise the potential of a 4th button start for D/G?. ???
.[/size]
I have a 1988 D/G/Acc Rik, which was supplied new from the factory with a fourth button start in 1988, so they've certainly known about it for long enough to cOme to a very well considered decision by now.
Excellent News.
-
So a nearly 25 year headstart at least?, maybe they're now getting more orders for 4th button start than 3rd?.
-
So a nearly 25 year headstart at least?, maybe they're now getting more orders for 4th button start than 3rd?.
Exactly so.
By the way, the Benny has always been 4th button start since its introduction.
-
Incidentally, I think that a good compromise layout, especially for a beginner, is to have the layout mentioned above by Castagnari, but replace the high accidentals with a low G/C. Advantages are that it gives the low notes useful for fiddle tunes where you would expect in relation to the rest of the box and retains the D reversal and low F#. The high accidentals (F/Eb) can be useful, and I talk as one who has bothered to learn how to use them, but they aren't the best solution. Firstly it is a stretch, meaning that it is always a fumble, secondly they sound crap, which I think is due to them being in the wrong place on the block. I think that if the high accidentals are important to you then you should get a half row box. I have a variant of this system on my Preciosa and it works very well.
-
Incidentally, I think that a good compromise layout, especially for a beginner, is to have the layout mentioned above by Castagnari, but replace the high accidentals with a low G/C. Advantages are that it gives the low notes useful for fiddle tunes where you would expect in relation to the rest of the box and retains the D reversal and low F#.
The 4th-button start with low notes and accidentals is indeed a good compromise layout and not only for beginners. However, I suppose it depends on the type of music you like to play (as it so often comes down to this) but personally I value the accidentals far more than those low G and C notes. I only rarely need a low C, and I can usually fudge it on the LH.
The high accidentals (F/Eb) can be useful, and I talk as one who has bothered to learn how to use them, but they aren't the best solution. Firstly it is a stretch, meaning that it is always a fumble...
Again we're talking about a compromise here. It is more of a stretch to get to the chin-end accidentals on a 4th-button start instrument, especially for someone with small hands as Rob2hook commented earlier. But with practise, it doesn't have to be a fumble and you can always use your RH thumb - a digit much under-estimated by melodeon players.
secondly they sound crap, which I think is due to them being in the wrong place on the block.
That's a bit harsh. They do tend to sound different mainly because the sound suddenly seems to come from nearer your ears. But this is only really apparent to the player and not to listeners even a short distance away. Yes - ideally, perhaps the accidental reed plates should be in the middle of the block adjacent to the other nearby notes, but you would need a more complex system of levers in the action, so almost certainly the cost would go up.
I think that if the high accidentals are important to you then you should get a half row box....
Agreed, but then we are leaving behind the concept of the 4th-button start, two-row box which I think is what this thread is mostly about.
-
I have small hands, and firstly settled on a Tommy for that reason. After the initial layout that was ( cough ) enough for a first instrument, I then had to add another lump to it for the cost of a change to a 4th button start simply because it made sense to me even as a very new user. I do use the low G, and by getting this as standard it saves the extra money and inconveinence of having to have it modded to a 4th button start.
I've now quite accidentally acquired a lovely Hascy ( from someone not too far away ;) ) . That is a full sized box, compaired to the Tommy which has a compact keyboard, so the buttons are a touch larger, the extra spacing means it is more of a stretch than the Tommy, and more again because it's a 4th button start. Double whammy!
Even me with small hands can get to the chin end accidentals, and I'm twittering around a French tune at present that uses G# and Bb.. It is a stretch but not unachievable.
....or you can, as Steve says, use your thumb.
The 4th button is for me absolutely worth the occasional stretch!
cheers
Q
-
I think that if the high accidentals are important to you then you should get a half row box.
Or if you want to keep it in mostly the same realm as a 2 row then something with the accidentals linked to two extra buttons adjacent to the main rows like the Castagnari Stephania or Alain.
Taking that idea slightly further, both my new boxes are being made with 23 buttons arranged 11/10/2 with accidentals for the lower octave at the end of the rows and ones for the higher octave on the "quarter row". I think the 21+2 Loffet GeB models might be made that way as well. I like that because it gives a lot of extra options with the overall feeling of the box still being pretty much like a 2 row, which is the kind of instrument I prefer feel and handling-wise.
For a 2 row, I seem to remember someone here saying that they had a 4th button start with accidentals and low notes with the low notes at the end of the rows and the accidentals on the 2nd buttons to keep the reach to them the same as a 3rd button start. Sounds good on paper but I can imagine there being a little reprogramming required to avoid sounding like Les Dawson all the time...
-
11/10/2 is a good solution (:)
-
Excellent news, let's hope this decision by such a respected maker will cause others to follow suit.
I think the change to the 4th button start (in any of the flavours) is great news for the "living tradition" of D/G Melodeon playing! It unlocks the potential of the instrument and removes frustrating and unecessary limitations without losing any of its essential character.
Well done to everyone that has discussed and implemented this. (:)
-
11/10/2 is a good solution (:)
Yes, you would think so.
I have recently acquired a gorgeous C/F Club Modell 1 in this configuration (thanks Rees!). It is 3rd-button start but the chin end buttons are low notes not accidentals. The latter are of course on the two-button mini-row. The same layout on a D/G box would be great.
But you have to be careful. At first sight, something like the Castagnari Alain 8 (http://www.castagnari.com/index.php?strparam=&language=uk&sz=301&id=13) or Alain 12 (http://www.castagnari.com/index.php?strparam=&language=uk&sz=301&id=14) would be ideal, both having the 11/10/2 layout.
However, Rees tells me that the chin end buttons on the main rows are still accidentals not low notes, and that the 2-button mini-row buttons are merely repeater buttons for the accidentals in a more convenient place. So in these instruments at least the advantage of the 11/10/2 layout is lost. :(
-
I think all the off-the-shelf 21+2 boxes on the market are like that. There's a page on La Maison De L'Accordeon's site showing a 2 row being converted to 21+2...
http://lamaisondelaccordeon.fr/pages/claviers
Castagnari and Maugein definitely are, dunno about Saltarelle or Beltuna but the keyboard diagram on Bernard Loffet's site suggests that the GeB models are true 23 button boxes.
-
I also hope other makers will change to 4th button' do 'as the norm on DG boxes. My personal wish list would be for 23 buttons with a 5th button start allowing plenty of low and even lower notes or low notes & retaining the accidentals at chin end. But lets not get greedy as yet!
george
-
... My personal wish list would be for 23 buttons with a 5th button start allowing plenty of low and even lower notes or low notes & retaining the accidentals at chin end....
Have you got large hands, George??
-
no, I always use thumb for chin end accidentals
george
-
I remember George suggesting the thumb as an alternative to a large stretch when I first wondered what was best or what was done when finding out about accidentals.
I find the keyboard waggles around a bit, so prefer a stretch, or maybe move my had along to get to the accidental leaving my pinkie for the note in the main keyboard
i.e. first finger on Bb, pinkie on B to play a B, Bb, B triplet.
.....but we're all different!
Q
-
There is another alternative... and how I had a D/G box re-jigged a couple of years back - 4th start, but with the accidentals in default 3rd start position, and the low notes below that. Saves having to interlink anything, and keeps high accidentals reachable...
And it means 3rd start people can borrow the box without getting lost... :|glug
Ed J
-
Rational - but my brain hurts thinking how to play it ::)
-
Well, rather my brain hurt than have to stretch so much - it's OK once you know where things are...
Ed J