Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Adam-T on December 03, 2012, 05:25:44 PM
-
Red Celluloid is notorious for fading has anyone come across a method of re-reddening it such as those silicone polishes which are colour coded, they don`t paint but restore the colour somewhat -anyone tried them ? . what about artificially fading the deep red parts to the same shade of pinky red the faded bits are, is that even possible ? ..
-
Just enjoy the genuine aged look. After all you put a big effort into creating that look in another box.
If you do decide to refresh the celluloid use a cutting polish like T-cut, this removes the surface where most of the fading is. And exposes fresh bright pearloid. Don't rub too hard over Hohner name or other graphics or you may remove them.
-
I think faded red Ericas look better.
-
I use Brasso to polish up celluloid (think it was one of your suggestions Theo) I won`t be removing it and making a "wood" version that`s for sure though it would be unique - I guess there`s no way to fade the fingerboard celluloid to match .
-
In a local restaurant, there is an old Erica which has been converted to a lamp which sits in the window. The red celluloid on the corner where it gets the most sun is faded to completely grey. No bringing that back! :||:
FWIW some old Hohner Clubs have a removable celluloid faceplate on the keyboard, which is easily enough flipped over if it's dirty stained, or faded.
-
I really have a problem understanding this debate about trying to bring your melodeon back to showroom looks. I assume that people who want to do this also spend the whole weekend polishing their car.
Surely the most important thing is the sound that the box provides, unless of course you don't play too well and you want to stun your audience with how well your box looks.
I can refer to a wonderful film called " The Worlds Fastest Indian" Anthony Hopkins at his best and it wasn't the looks of the bike it was the performance.
My old Paulo Sop. Was held together with Duct tape. The sound ? Well, that's in the ear of the beholder I suppose. To me, never bettered.
I've thrown this in for fun of course but I think I may have a point.
-
" The Worlds Fastest Indian" Anthony Hopkins at his best and it wasn't the looks of the bike it was the performance.
One of my favourite films. That and Hobsons Choice. Both films show that if you persevere at something it will work out.
-
I really have a problem understanding this debate about trying to bring your melodeon back to showroom looks. I assume that people who want to do this also spend the whole weekend polishing their car.
I`m not trying to get it back to "Showroom" condition , just wondered if there was a way of making it all the same colour . as for polishing the car , I can`t remember the last time I WASHED a car let alone polished it . it`ll get the carwash once a month in the winter if desperate
Surely the most important thing is the sound that the box provides
That`s a given thing with said Trichord
unless of course you don't play too well and you want to stun your audience with how well your box looks.
Well you got me there Nick, you`re looking at the worst B/C/C# player in History -
Squeezeboxes are one of if not THE biggest targets in common musical instruments for visual decorations, look at the Entire TexMex market, Alpine Steirisches, decades upon decades of gem encrusted PAs, fine fretwork in Concertinas and recent Italian melodeons, Pearloid celluloid in itself is a very showy thing . it`s part of the whole squeezebox thing - are you saying that 90 or so years of design and bling was a waste of time , so you`re saying that those who spend ages rebuilding the fretwork on the ends of old Jeffries Tinas are all wasting their time because it`ll sound the same whether they bother or not? ..
Don`t ever bother restoring any more old Books Nick, they`re just as readable with the pages held in with sellotape and are better off scanned and put on CDROM / Kindle anyway
-
I really have a problem understanding this debate about trying to bring your melodeon back to showroom looks. I assume that people who want to do this also spend the whole weekend polishing their car.
I`m not trying to get it back to "Showroom" condition , just wondered if there was a way of making it all the same colour . as for polishing the car , I can`t remember the last time I WASHED a car let alone polished it . it`ll get the carwash once a month in the winter if desperate
Surely the most important thing is the sound that the box provides
That`s a given thing with said Trichord
unless of course you don't play too well and you want to stun your audience with how well your box looks.
Well you got me there Nick, you`re looking at the worst B/C/C# player in History -
Squeezeboxes are one of if not THE biggest targets in common musical instruments for visual decorations, look at the Entire TexMex market, Alpine Steirisches, decades upon decades of gem encrusted PAs, fine fretwork in Concertinas and recent Italian melodeons, Pearloid celluloid in itself is a very showy thing . it`s part of the whole squeezebox thing - are you saying that 90 or so years of design and bling was a waste of time , so you`re saying that those who spend ages rebuilding the fretwork on the ends of old Jeffries Tinas are all wasting their time because it`ll sound the same whether they bother or not? ..
Don`t ever bother restoring any more old Books Nick, they`re just as readable with the pages held in with sellotape and are better off scanned and put on CDROM / Kindle anyway
You're absolutely right Adam, I stand down and didn't mean any offence. Like a Curate's egg I think we are both right in parts.
-
You're absolutely right Adam, I stand down and didn't mean any offence. Like a Curate's egg I think we are both right in parts.
Agreed ;D - No probs Nick and I totally agree with "sound comes first" - I`d never want a box which sounded Naff whatever it looked like unless it was for an ornament - hence why I never got one of those Chinese wooden Costalottilookalikes - but there`s no harm in tidying up the old Trikey3 a bit or taking pride in the appearance of your box, unless you`re going for the "Pikey's Pokerwork" look which is designed to look as tatty as possible (it`s still held together with carpet tape though he changed the matchsticks for bellows pins eventually) ..
BTW Theo, as the Fingerboard was off for re-glueing, I`ve done the "retro aged" look on that, I was going to repaint with car paint but a new looking fingerboard wouldn`t fit in with the fading and the pitted grille (which looks superb with a new cloth & polished up with the pitting still there) ..
Also I actually Enjoy doing this, I don`t enjoy getting covered in old reedwax crumbs though ::) Done the bass waxing, all sounding superb now and I have my very first feeble attempt at A Scottish tune on Soundcloud (15 mins after trying) treble only of course, I did it before the bass wax.
-
In a local restaurant, there is an old Erica which has been converted to a lamp which sits in the window. The red celluloid on the corner where it gets the most sun is faded to completely grey. No bringing that back! :||:
you may have just solved the question of where all these old grey paolo's are coming from. ;) AtB mory
-
In a local restaurant, there is an old Erica which has been converted to a lamp which sits in the window. The red celluloid on the corner where it gets the most sun is faded to completely grey. No bringing that back! :||:
you may have just solved the question of where all these old grey paolo's are coming from. ;) AtB mory
After seeing this poor accordion with the funny lampshade as a hat (and I did snap a pic, see if I can find it...) I would be lying if I told you the thought of a UV bulb and a new, grey Erica didn't cross my mind. And unfortunately, its innards are not for sale (I asked). ;D
-
I would lik to know how to fade or de-color celluloid on wood; and remove it from aluminum parts. Any suggestions? (And, I'm not trying to make new "old" gray Paolos, but that does interest me, come to think of it. At $15K a pop ....)
*Seriously, along that line, just because a Paolo is gray doesn't make it an instantly great accordion. I know its a fashion statement, but if the _ONLY_ difference is celluloid color and a roughly 1950s vintage its kind of silly. The pre-1960 Paolos are in demand mainly because of the wooden soundboard and general good workmanship, good reeds, etc, etc. But the 1940s Paolos with the "target-center" bare aluminum grills and the 1940s lighter grays with the gray celluloid grills with the more refined designs, are the ones REALLY worthy of the collector prices, because they truly are more scarce, not to mention 75 years old! And they had red celluloid ones with the target-center grill in the 40s, they are just as good as the grays. It was the actions and reeds in those 1940s Paolos that really made them more desirable. the Red One on the top is the exact same as the Gray in the middle: 1955-57. Same reeds, same metal counter-balanced action, same wooden soundboards (I used to own this very Gray one). The Gray on the two bottom photos is from the 1940s with wood-stick button armatures, "ballpoint-pen" springs and single wire to pallet action.
-
But the 1940s Paolos with the "target-center" bare aluminum grills and the 1940s lighter grays with the gray celluloid grills with the more refined designs, are the ones REALLY worthy of the collector prices, because they truly are more scarce, not to mention 75 years old! And they had red celluloid ones with the target-center grill in the 40s, they are just as good as the grays.
This is what I call the "target grill" for wont of a better name. Paolo Soprani 1940s. 4-v and 3-v. Bottom, Jackie Daly's 3-v 1940s Gray with a simple refined grill design.
-
Elizabeth, just a couple of points; The red and grey you say are identical are in fact quite different, and belong to different 'generations' of Paolo Soprani boxes. Note how the front of the grille is mounted: On the red, it sits in a slot (like most models from ca. 1955 onwards) whereas the grey is flush-mount with rounded corners (like most models of dark grey (at least 3 different models were made), silver grey, pepperpot and transitional celluloid-grille models up to ca. 1955).
You can group them by looks, by constructional features, and generally speaking also by sound - there are features in the timbre of the tone that they share among similar models. A lot has to do with condition of wax, valves and reeds, if the reeds are original at all, and of course the tuning - but there's something to be found in a 1953 model that a 1957 just doesn't have. Just like a silver grey and a dark grey will generally (!) speaking have their differences. The boost and openness that a good dark grey will deliver is not there in a very similar box made years later.
It's not the reeds and the mechanism that makes the dark grey Paolo Sopranis the most desired of the lot - it's the sound. Sound, sound, sound. Obviously there is something about cultural desirability, a tone associated with certain key figures etc. that draw many, including me, to desire one when I first started playing, but after handling and working on lots of different Paolos, I can vouch for what many famous players and tuners have told me - it's the sound.
I personally prefer the reeds as well as the mechanism of the late 50's and early 60's, and my own dark grey box has reeds from the 60's in it. Still sounds like a dark grey, and when the original reeds went into another box, it still sounded like what it went into.
Now, celluloid.
The first generation red celluloid is actually a thin layer of red on top of a thin layer of silver grey - don't ask me why! That's why you'll see many early ones with lots of wear have silver spots on the corners and where straps rub against the body. I've heard of a few boxes being sanded/scraped carefully to remove the red layer and then buffed and polished - not something I'd like to try myself.
The thin red layer also fades in sunlight, making it almost look orange - just look at some of the many marching band boxes.
You can remove celluloid from metal by pulling it off, loosening with a knife and a syringe of acetone to help, but don't expect it to survive to be re-installed. The metal will need sanding, buffing and polishing afterwards, and the buttons will likely need re-setting if you want the same button height as before.
Also, the grey box you posted a picture of with wooden levers is a pretty rare one - Busilacchio made, and I've only seen maybe 2 or 3 in the 20 odd years I've been mad about Paolos. I would hesitate to compare such a rare one to the more commonly seen ones. It's probably amazing, but apples and oranges etc.
This whole colour versus model is often popping up in discussions, as well as ads where a seller is asking a premium for an otherwise 'mediocre' Paolo (still a good box, don't get me wrong) because it's made in grey celluloid - a 55-57 model or a 5-coupler horseshoe grille. If you prefer the looks, then it sure is worth more, but it's not going to sound like a late 40's Paolo.
Sorry for the long rambling on. Not all who read may agree, and that's totally cool too. There's a box or two for everyone:-)
-
This whole colour versus model is often popping up in discussions, as well as ads where a seller is asking a premium for an otherwise 'mediocre' Paolo (still a good box, don't get me wrong) because it's made in grey celluloid - a 55-57 model or a 5-coupler horseshoe grille. If you prefer the looks, then it sure is worth more, but it's not going to sound like a late 40's Paolo.
Sorry for the long rambling on. Not all who read may agree, and that's totally cool too. There's a box or two for everyone:-)
Great, super! Thank you, Lars. Yes, really my point: the color is a color, and it is much more the vintage. But the idea that a gray 55-59 model is worth 9 or 10 or 14K (quid, euros, buckeroos) better be because it comes with a complimentary gold ingot. More later ... Much thanks!
-
But in the grand scheme of musical instrument prices these are quite modest prices for the best in class.
-
But in the grand scheme of musical instrument prices these are quite modest prices for the best in class.
On the level of a 1957 Fender Stratocaster or a '51 Telecaster, a Gibson F5 mandolin, a 1937 Martin D-28? Perhaps, if the "bones" are good and it's virtually _all_ original and it's been kept in good shape.
Accordions are more fragile than guitars or mandolins, lots more parts. Maybe a Briggs will get that value ($30k range) in 75 years, if its very well kept.
If you are talking about "player" accordions, with swapped out reeds, overhauled mechanisms, new bellows, and less, or much less cosmetic charm, then some of them may be a bit overpriced, today.
Will an accordion ever live long enough to get the priced of a Vuillaume or a Strad? We shall see ...
-
In my shop window I had a old red student accordion that faded over the years in the sun. I used red "candy apple" transparent lacquer. This worked really well, but you will have to spend a lot of time masking off everything you don't want paint on.
Most red celluloid is solid red but some of the older stuff is silver/grey MOP with a clear red layer on top, I think this is the stuff that fades to grey. https://www.amainhobbies.com/spaz-stix-candy-apple-red-spray-paint-3.5oz-szx15059/p167710?msclkid=61b33b92231d109ce1185efd46de52aa&utm_source=bing&utm_medium=cpc&utm_campaign=AH%20-%20Search%20-%20Dynamic%20Content%20-%20RC%20Brands%20-%20US&utm_term=amainhobbies&utm_content=Dynamic%20Search%20Ads%20-%20AMainHobbies