I'm really not trying to be clever here (which would be pointless as I'm less than academically gifted!) but if someone asked me to name all of the notes between C and c I would say: C, C#, D, Eb, E, F, F#, G, G#, A, Bb, B, c. That pretty much covers the six major and minor keys (plus modes of course :o) likely to be encountered by most of the players here I would think. Not many instruments offer you the choice of two semitone keys between one note and another of course - and therein lies the crux of the subject here!
I think the crux of this is whether your brain thinks of the notes topographically, or as part of a scale or other 'set'. I'm very much of the latter school, and would incidentally have named the notes exactly as you do - by default. But if I moved to A harmonic minor I'd say A, B, C, D, E, F, G#, A because the function of note 7 is as a 'G' in the A scale.
My present simulator project is designed to work that way, following that logic. Over on concertina.net the anglo players seem cool about this - they can lable as they wish, but the "English" school (at least one of them) wants eg Ab on the left and G# on the right*. Seems unique to the instrument - but actually I suspect they will physically use different buttons in the appropriate sharp or flat scales .. for fluidity?
*..gonna cause some coding difficulties!
My present simulator project is designed to work that way, following that logic. Over on concertina.net the anglo players seem cool about this - they can lable as they wish, but the "English" school (at least one of them) wants eg Ab on the left and G# on the right*. Seems unique to the instrument - but actually I suspect they will physically use different buttons in the appropriate sharp or flat scales .. for fluidity?
*..gonna cause some coding difficulties!
Oh for goodness sake tell him to get a life! What's he going to do if he gets an A# in a piece, ignore the button next to the B because it's called Bb?? (and it is you know, because if you open it up you'll find Bb stamped on the reed shoes!).
All English players use the doubled up accidentals interchangeably and there are times when you would choose to play Ab on the right hand rather than G# on the left if it helps the fingering sequence. I don't think much of an English concertina player who doesn't automatically read all flats and sharps as one note with two names, it's to be hoped he never encounters a B#. >:E