Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Harmonicatunes on December 07, 2012, 04:10:51 AM
-
Yet another nice vintage Hohner went on German Ebay - a Club I - details at http://www.ebay.de/itm/HOHNER-CLUB-I-ViNTAGE-GERMANY-NOSTALGiE-HAND-HARMONiKA-BUTTON-ACCORDiON-HOLZ-RAR-/321031322904?pt=Antike_Musikinstrumente&hash=item4abef53d18#ht_17253wt_1165
This appears to be an older design. The bellows are attached to a wooden frame with metal brackets on the corner, this frame then seems to be bolted to the rest of the instrument. This design presumably pre-dates the introduction of bellows pins.
Are there any disadvantages with this older bellows arrangement? One drawback would perhaps be that the wooden frame takes the space of bellows folds, meaning that you would run out of air sooner.
Anything else?
-
Yet another nice vintage Hohner went on German Ebay - a Club I - details at http://www.ebay.de/itm/HOHNER-CLUB-I-ViNTAGE-GERMANY-NOSTALGiE-HAND-HARMONiKA-BUTTON-ACCORDiON-HOLZ-RAR-/321031322904?pt=Antike_Musikinstrumente&hash=item4abef53d18#ht_17253wt_1165
This appears to be an older design. The bellows are attached to a wooden frame with metal brackets on the corner, this frame then seems to be bolted to the rest of the instrument. This design presumably pre-dates the introduction of bellows pins.
That's not quite how it is. The bellows are glued to a wood frame at each end, and the frames are attached to the instrument ends by two bolts at each end. You have to remove the treble end grille and the bass end plate to access the bolts. You can see this arrangement quite clearly in the Ebay photos. The metal brackets on the corners are purely decorative.
Are there any disadvantages with this older bellows arrangement? One drawback would perhaps be that the wooden frame takes the space of bellows folds, meaning that you would run out of air sooner.
The bellows can have as many folds as you like. Just because the bellows are glued to relatively wide wooden bellows frames, it doesn't mean that you loose any folds. In instruments which have bellows pins, the bellows themselves are still glued to end frames, but just not as wide as in this instrument.
This particular instrument has 16 free folds plus two half folds at each end which are attached to the frame. Seems perfectly normal to me. I have an instrument just like this and don't have any air problems. The Ebay instrument appears to be in beautiful condition. Someone got a bargain there! (:)
-
The disadvantage is that the whole end is held on with two screws which have to take all the pulling and pushing which is quite a force in a larger, higher quality box like that (it was common in cheap Saxony 1 rows) though I`ve not seen how big the screws are, they could be 1/2" thick coach bolts for all I know.. any warping can be taken up with modern thick bellows gasket.. I`d not let this put you off a lovely classic Hohner.
the best method is six screws (3 top and 3 bottom) like Scandalli used on their few 2 rows, better than four Bellows pins and way better than two screws under the grille but less convenient to service.
-
the best method is six screws (3 top and 3 bottom) like Scandalli used on their few 2 rows, better than four Bellows pins and way better than two screws under the grille but less convenient to service.
Not sure how you get to this conclusion, if screws were truly "better" then surely all the premier manufatures would use them as there is little cost differential. But as it is 99% of boxes use bellows pins.
As too the original question, there is no disadvantage to the screw arrangement, indeed I have a Club 1 which uses this arrangement and it is fine, mind you takes longer to remove the ends for tuning etc.
-
The broad bellows frames with internal bolts to attach do have advantages over pins. The frame is more rigid and as the screws tighten more pressure is applied to the gasket which forms a more positive seal. This method is still the standard construction on most makes of one row four stop, with the notable exception of Hohner.
Bellows pins are quicker to remove, but in the long term can suffer from wear to the surrounding wood which leads to loose pins and leaks. I can't think of a single advantage of using screws instead of pins. They take longer to insert and remove, and they add to the problem of the holes wearing with frequent use.
-
You don`t see two rows using the end screw method thesedays though - I`d have thought that the more fixing points the better when force is likely to be used as in the case of bellows powered instruments - just my thoughts of course..
Also WE may take these things apart all the time Lester but in general people don`t tend to open a box from purchase to update or sale and with modern waxes and reedvalves even less need to now..... so the speed of maintenence via screws in the big scheme of things is pretty irrelevant and lets face it, The cases on everything else instrument wise that I can think of not glued or welded is held together with screws - you don`t see metal Pins holding Organs, synths or pianos together, a Synth is more likely to need its memory backup battery replacing before a box will need wax or valves and there`s a lot more than four screws to remove. Bellows pins usage is merely a tradition which stayed (TWO end screws in bigger than 1 rows didn`t and there must be a reason for this) .
-
Eric Martin two rows (as played by Squeezy John Spiers) use the two screw method as do my Wesson Clippers. I have found no drawbacks to this method of construction.
-
Hokay Rees, can`t say fairer than that - just seemed like an awful lot of pressure on just two screws in the same direction as the screw threads to me in a two row. pins or screws at 90 degrees to the force especially as there are more of them seems stronger to me that`s all . looks like yet another of those times where my logic is totally my own :-[
-
I like the Shand Morino's system.
-
The Atlantic used lever clamps, no tools required and sealed well so long as the belows gasket was in good order - I think this is what the earlier shands used also isn`t it Owen ? , the later ones used pins .
-
not 100% sure but I thin clamps were used on all morinos at the same time as used on Shand morinos
george
-
The Atlantics stuck with them to the end (not sure when the Model ended, 1980s I think**) but as they were totally made of aluminium they may have thought it`d be an issue to move to pins - steel going through alloy and all that . I liked the clamp system. I didn`t know Morino PAs used them. there were some Carenas or whatever which had them too
** the New "Atlantic re-issue" is made of wood and more related to the Amica than the proper Atlantic.
-
Yeah, later Shands (and later Morinos) used pins. The early models, including the early Morino Clubs, used the clamp system.
-
i've just acquired a Morino Club. It has the lever system, what a great piece of work it is.
I use the 2 screw method on the Clipper because it's standard practice on Cajun style boxes. It's the way that Emmanuel Pariselle taught me to do it.
My Windjammer model is based on the Hohner 114 and therefore has bellows pins.
-
My club has pins but its an early 70s one I think, I didn`t realise the Clubs used levers on the first ones too but now on re-looking at the pics of the early ones, I can see the same clamp brackets the Atlantic has
The Morino club is a totally unique box, amazingly different to the Ouverture 5 in design even if it looks similar . Sound is unique too , I really like the weighty little thing
-
And this one has the lever system as well: http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/330837402204?ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1423.l2649
-
An unbelievable buy at £400 is that box - even my later model in as close to mint condition as you could expect inside and out shipped from germany cost me quite a bit less than a new Chinese Pokerwork from music room would .. Someone pointed out that these things would cost over 5 grand if they made them to that standard now.