Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: gm0lze on December 24, 2012, 12:27:04 PM
-
Maybe it has been explained elsewhere but can some knowledgeable person explain the difference between stoppers or couplers.If i have a 3 voice melodeon with 3 stoppers or three couplers should i get the same combination of sounds.
Thank you for any information.
-
In my mind stops are slides that block/open reeds by pulling on a knob such as 4 stop melodeons. Couplers are switches, either in front of or behind the keyboard that allow you to select combinations of reeds.
So stops allow you to select any combination of the reeds in your box but may need multiple changes to select a desired combination whereas couplers(switches) only allow the manufacturers predetermined reed selection but they can be swapped with single actions.
Hope that makes sense.
-
Suggest this be added to 'melodeon terms' Chris
-
Edited to remove incorrect information! :|bl
-
If i have a 3 voice melodeon with 3 stoppers or three couplers should i get the same combination of sounds.
Thank you for any information.
I think the short answer to your question is no. Pull/Push knobs on top of the box and levers behind the fingerboard have very similar functions, but switches on the front are entirely different. To obtain the same number of permutations as three treble stops or levers would require quite a bank of coupler switches.
I know that is Goodwill to all Men time but I think you are almost entirely wrong (:) All the boxes I have ever met with switches behind the keyboard (Casta Mory/Beltunas various) have the same effect as the ones with coupler switches ie the switches select a pre-determined selection of reeds rather than just switching in individual banks of reeds
-
I know that is Goodwill to all Men time but I think you are almost entirely wrong (:) All the boxes I have ever met with switches behind the keyboard (Casta Mory/Beltunas various) have the same effect as the ones with coupler switches ie the switches select a pre-determined selection of reeds rather than just switching in individual banks of reeds
Thanks for pointing this out Lester. I've never had a box with levers at the back, my information came (a long time ago now) from another player who, erm, obviously should have known better!
-
[snip] All the boxes I have ever met with switches behind the keyboard (Casta Mory/Beltunas various) have the same effect as the ones with coupler switches ie the switches select a pre-determined selection of reeds rather than just switching in individual banks of reeds
IIRC someone was looking for the standardised little icons that show what each switch selects, not so long ago. Possibly a link it it can be found again?
-
I know that is Goodwill to all Men time but I think you are almost entirely wrong (:) All the boxes I have ever met with switches behind the keyboard (Casta Mory/Beltunas various) have the same effect as the ones with coupler switches ie the switches select a pre-determined selection of reeds rather than just switching in individual banks of reeds
On Hohner's older club series (the IIIBS etc) the levers each disabled or enabled a bank of reeds in the same way stops do. the bass end of the Club Morino works the same way - each slide controls a bank of reeds like a stop.
-
I reckon Lester has it right - a stop controls a single bank of reeds and acts in isolation, while a coupler (clue in the name) couples together 2 or more stops so that they operate in sync to open or close multiple banks of reeds in a single action.
Graham
-
Thanks for all the replies.Much appreciated.I have another question.
If i have a three voice melodian (eg Saltarelle Nuage)with three stoppers how many "couplers" (eg Cairdin 3 voice with two couplers) would i need to get an equivalent combination of variations.What i mean is would i get the same amount of combinations with both systems.Hope in not confusing anybody?
-
A simple question, I thought, though the answer may not appear to be quite so simple! Using stops, one usually has a stop for each bank of reeds (=voice) so the number of possible combinations is simple to determine. Depending on the tuning of the voices - which octave and whether with tremolo or not - there are some combinations will never be used. As an example, my box is LMM, dry tuned. But imagiune that it was tuned with tremolo, so one of the M voices was tuned sharp. The combination of the L voice with the M+ voice would sound terrible, so only the following combinations would be offered on switches - L, LM, LMM, MM, M. Of course, the same applies with my dry tuning as the two versions of LM and M will sound the same. As it happens my Trilly has seven couplers, but three are set to LMM. The same box is offered as a four voice which explains why the extra buttons.
Rob.
-
Thanks for all the replies.Much appreciated.I have another question.
If i have a three voice melodian (eg Saltarelle Nuage)with three stoppers how many "couplers" (eg Cairdin 3 voice with two couplers) would i need to get an equivalent combination of variations.What i mean is would i get the same amount of combinations with both systems.Hope in not confusing anybody?
The Nuage has, as you say, three stops for its L M M+ reeds there are 7 possible combinations
L
M
M+
L & M
L & M+
M & M+
L & M & M+
As I remember a Mory has three switches which can select from 5 combinations
Top selects between MM+ and M
The bottom between LM and L
The middle is a master switch for LMM.
-
The combination of the L voice with the M+ voice would sound terrible,
I used that very combination a lot on my Connemara YMMV
-
I know that is Goodwill to all Men time but I think you are almost entirely wrong (:)
In the light of subsequent posts to the contrary you might want to amend that to 'incorrect on some makes/models'
Levers it would seem may be either stops or couplers. :|glug
Happy Christmas Lester. ;) >:E
-
The combination of the L voice with the M+ voice would sound terrible,
I used that very combination a lot on my Connemara YMMV
Blimey - LM,LMM, MM I've heard of - but a Connemara YMMV?
-
WOT?
-
Blimey - LM,LMM, MM I've heard of - but a Connemara YMMV?
It's a reference to Saltarelle's unpredictable quality control issues - Your Melodeon May Vary ;)
Happy Christmas everyone!