Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: alaskairishbox on December 26, 2012, 07:17:02 PM
-
Hello,
I am brand new to the b/c box, and have a less than well tuned Double Ray.
Since I am quite good at making notoriously tricky Uilleann pipe reeds, tune Pianos and Harpsichords, I rather arrogantly assumed I was going to learn how to tune Melodeons in just a few hours. Wrong!
I have not had much luck using the search function, although I am sure this is all well covered ground on this forum. Here is what I have done thus far.
I am using a cheap spare box to experiment with, but eventually will want to get rid of the "circus clown tuning" on the Double Ray.
Questions:
1. I have reeds that will "speak" just fine in the instrument, but not outside. Visually the "set" of the reed looks fine. I assume that these reeds need to be tweaked until they "speak". Or how do you tune them if half the reeds won't speak on the tuning table in or out of the reed block? They also won't speak if mouth blown (yes i know, terrible thing to do).
2. The pitch of a reed on my tuning table is 20-30 cents low on the table when it is out of the block.
3. The pitch of a reed in the block while on the tuning table is a random5-10ish cents below its instrument installed sound.
So the only way for me to tune is to alter the reed a slight amount assemble the whole box test, over and over again. I don't see any way to tune inner reeds while the block is in the instrument.
4. Is my tuning table the problem? I'd attach a picture, but haven't figured out how. I have a modified push/pull rubber raft bellows attached by a hose to the hole in the table, so the air space behind the reed is not the same as in an accordion. I have observed that the size of the space behind the reed has a profound impact on pitch.
Even if I had a thin sound board and an accordion bellows as I have seen in pictures, the push pull would still be the wrong way when the reeds are in the blocks. But would a traditional tuning table closely match instrument pitch?
5. Reeds played together "frequency capture each other". To end up with A440 would one tune #1 reed at 238 and #2 reed 242? It seems most accordions are effectively sharp, because the tune something like #1 reed 440 and #2 reed 445. So you end up randomly somewhere in the middle depending on which reed "frequency captures" more effectively.
So as you can see I am struggling with some very basic problems. Any advice?
-
I'll try and find some links later but the whole issue of tuning has been discussed at length time and again on this forum as you may well imagine. The first thing you need need to get your head around is that it is possible (nay routine and vital!) to 'flip' an inside reed tongue out through the slot for tuning without removing the plate from the block! This particular trick can be achieved in a couple of ways, either way requires a proper tool to be bought/made.
Use the advanced search features on a google search and do lots of reading on the forum here! (Tip: large reeds often need a nudge to get them started when they are out of the box . . .)
Pete. (:)
-
You do have to tune reeds in position on the reedblock, and ideally inside the instrument, but you can get close with the reedblock on a tuning table. I put these photos together a while back to show the tools and how they are used.
https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.110159238166.95032.709188166&type=1&l=5be6150682 (https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.110159238166.95032.709188166&type=1&l=5be6150682)
This is a public link, you do not have to be a Facebook user. The individual photo captions explain what is going on.
-
I put these photos together a while back to show the tools and how they are used.
https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.110159238166.95032.709188166&type=1&l=5be6150682 (https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.110159238166.95032.709188166&type=1&l=5be6150682)
This is a public link, you do not have to be a Facebook user. The individual photo captions explain what is going on.
Theo - this link used to be accessible to non-Facebook users but sadly no longer. FB must have tweaked something so that only users can see it. :(
Any chance of hosting the photos elsewhere please - e.g. Flickr perhaps?
-
5. Reeds played together "frequency capture each other". To end up with A440 would one tune #1 reed at 238 and #2 reed 242? It seems most accordions are effectively sharp, because the tune something like #1 reed 440 and #2 reed 445. So you end up randomly somewhere in the middle depending on which reed "frequency captures" more effectively.
There are two points here:
1 - if two reeds are tuned differently from each other the resultant perceived pitch is, as you have correctly indicated, the mean of the two frequencies and with a pulsating amplitude tremolo equal to the difference between the two frequencies. So, all things being equal, to: "end up with A440 would one tune #1 reed at 238 and #2 reed 242?", the answer is yes, the perceived pitch will be 440 Hz and there will be a 4 Hz tremolo. This is the basis of 'Viennese' or 'Dedic' tuning which has been discussed at length on this forum at different times.
2 - the second point is to do with "frequency capture each other". If two reeds are tuned very close in pitch, the acoustic coupling between them will 'pull' the frequencies together to a single pitch with no tremolo at all. This is most annoying when one is trying to achieve a slow tremolo. Depending on the individual characteristics of the instrument/reeds/reedblocks, this generally happens if you try to tune reeds to within 2 - 3 cents of each other. This unwanted effect can be cured to a certain extent by fitting a rigid connecting strap across the top of the reed blocks which (somewhat counter-intuitively) reduces the acoustic coupling.
You might find this thread (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,2306.msg24893.html#msg24893) from three years ago useful. It's worth reading it all, but I tried to summarise things in this (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,2306.msg103665.html#msg103665) post.
Hope this helps.
-
5. Reeds played together "frequency capture each other". To end up with A440 would one tune #1 reed at 238 and #2 reed 242?
Probably not, but we know what you mean.
-
5. Reeds played together "frequency capture each other". To end up with A440 would one tune #1 reed at 238 and #2 reed 242?
Probably not, but we know what you mean.
Ah yes, well spotted. Funny how I misread 238 and 242 as 438 and 442! ;)
-
5. Reeds played together "frequency capture each other". To end up with A440 would one tune #1 reed at 238 and #2 reed 242?
Probably not, but we know what you mean.
Ah yes, well spotted. Funny how I misread 238 and 242 as 438 and 442! ;)
It's yer harmonics in'it!
-
Right you guys were reading my mind rather than what I wrote. Yes 438 and 442 = 440
Also the concept of pulling the reed through from the outside with the block installed did blow my mind. I made a little tool to do this and that seems to work ok. However I just end up taking the block off anyway to re-set the reed, so it still doesn't seem to be a real smooth process.
Theo's pictures were most helpful and I did find way more information by searching the forum using google. But many of my question still remain.
I find the reed table completely useless, because no matter what I do, many of the larger reeds just plain won't speak. I've tried poking them to get them started and other black magic to no avail.
Even the reeds that do behave well on the tuning table, are far enough off the installed pitch that I can't imagine altering any reed based on the pitch or behavior I am getting on the table.
I guess I could do everything while installed, but I see myself opening an closing the box several hundred times to do that. Since you guys all seem to be using tuning tables I have got to be missing something absolutely fundamental.
-
Can you show us an image of your tuning rig?
-
Here is a picture of the tuning rig.
Henry
-
My guess is that the air bed inflator you are using to provide the air is delivering air at too high a pressure and causing the reeds to choke. I believe that you really need a tuning rig run with a set of accordion/melodeon bellows for more success.
(https://lh4.googleusercontent.com/-mzUex7O4dt4/UF1yXVkxSOI/AAAAAAAAJCo/mVfG0CQlbrM/s1280/P1320983.JPG)
-
I think it is a combination of what Lester suggests and that your rig can't deliver sufficient volume of air. Too high pressure may cause the high reeds to choke, and insufficient volume of air will make it difficult to get the bigger reeds to sound at all. The solution is the same, bigger bellows!
-
And the bigger bellows must not be connected by a narrow tube. Ideally the reed block or reed holder should be positioned as near as possible in the same relation to the bellows as they have inside the instrument, ie sitting directly on a plate over the end of the bellows. With the system Lester uses with a separate air chamber linking to the bellows you can get some odd resonance effects which cause particular notes to misbehave. I started with a similar setup to Lesters where it was impossible to tune an Eflat. Avoiding that is down to avoiding certain dimensions that cause resonance, and the best chance of that is to make the intermediate chamber as deep as you can.
-
Thanks guys,
I will build a traditional setup and see what happens.
-
Well I am not conviced that there was an air flow/pressure issue with the old setup, but can't exclude it. I bet the airspace geometry was the culprit as Theo pointed out. Just finished this more traditional setup and guess what. It works great! So much for taking shortcuts on established ways of doing things.
Thanks so much for all the input and for setting me straight.
Henry
-
Is this picture upside down by any chance ??
Or are you located in Australia ? ;)
Glad to hear it works better, anyway !
Martin
-
You do have to tune reeds in position on the reedblock, and ideally inside the instrument, but you can get close with the reedblock on a tuning table. I put these photos together a while back to show the tools and how they are used.
https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.110159238166.95032.709188166&type=1&l=5be6150682 (https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.110159238166.95032.709188166&type=1&l=5be6150682)
This is a public link, you do not have to be a Facebook user. The individual photo captions explain what is going on.
I can't find the photos. Are they still available somewhere?
As mentioned earlier in the thread - the photos on Facebook seem to no longer be available on the previous link (which used to work fine). It's something that only Theo can tweak...
-
I have found some instruments to have more problems tuning accurately on the table. Some will have 3 or 4 some will have half the reed block. It is not a quality issue.
Leaks (glue gaps,cracks) between tremolo reeds can do a lot to damp out the desired effect, as can a warped reed block (check for flatness on bottom) you want to maximise the seperation of those reeds as much as possible.
Someone here also mentioned that the metal bit screwed across the top of (thus joining) the blocks will help a lot in curing reluctant tremolo.
-
Digging out some old pics recently, I was reminded of an old Hohner pokerwork of mine that was fettled by a family member of a friend in Alsace.
By the application of a dab of (silver) paint, (quelle horreur), on the tips of the reeds of one of the voices, a very creditable 'French' sounding box was created.
This lasted for years, until the sold on.
Has anyone come across this technique?