Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Andrel on December 31, 2012, 03:10:00 AM
-
I am trying to find out which Castagnari Rita F. is playing here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JQxOAClUius
1) Is it a Trilly without the bass registers ? Sounds lovely, whatever it is. I'm sure she can get the most out of it !
2) Tuning ? (Bb/Eb or... ?)
Thank you much !
A.
-
And just look at all the "bad" habits she has - thumb behind the treble keyboard, "um-pa-pa" basses, only using two fingers of her left hand.... ;) >:E
Graham
-
And in this video,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nxFesCh3NRQ (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nxFesCh3NRQ)
actually watching the dancers she is accompanying...and no "melodeon face".
Hope these "bad habits" will never catch on... >:E >:E >:E
Oh, and returning to the op question #2, appears to be a F/Bb from her bass fingering. The piece is in Gm.
However, the treble could be something especially modified.....but probably F/Bb, so 2 semitones flat of G/C; a most unusual tuning.... and played beautifully.
-
Reminds me of many many young people who have been taught to play at an early age.
BUT, with no emotion, no feeling,and probably not wanting to be there at all.
If you were still here Bob Cann, you could teach em a lesson or two.
Happy new year one and all
-
It's in F/Bb, unless my ears are going mad. Nice sounding box.
-
Well I think ukebert has got perfect pitch so let's assume my idea of F#/B is based on a poor understanding of You Tube Italian.
No, your understanding is spot on - she definitely does say it's in F#/B. Of course, SHE could be wrong......... ;D
-
Nick, I cannot agree that these clips showed "no emotion, no feeling", and equating this performer with the late Bob Cann (for whom I always have had great admiration) seems in many ways to be comparing apples with oranges, not to mention consideration of a generational difference in attitude and approach. Additionally, we do not know under what circumstances these recordings were made.
Just to make things clear, my earlier comments about bad habits (and presumably Graham's comments also?) were more than somewhat tongue in cheek. I should perhaps apologise for my attempt at humour, but only to those who's playing is devoid of bad habits and can play as well as this lady does. Musically, the end justifies the means imho (which, incidentally, is why I often play diminished chords on a 6 row piano accordion bass with my thumb!!! It works for me.... :P)
I had not previously heard of Ms Fancello, and I appreciate the op bringing her to my attention. Some very enjoyable playing.
Still don't recognise the Castagnari model though.... :(
-
The accordion in the solo video is a Castagnari Montmartre, four voice, seven couplers.
Nick Cooke has one in G/C.
Picture here: http://www.castagnari.com/index.php?strparam=&language=uk&sz=301&id=17 (http://www.castagnari.com/index.php?strparam=&language=uk&sz=301&id=17)
If it had bass couplers it would be a Wielly.
Fabulous playing in that second video with the dancers. It has more life than any Morris music I've heard.
-
Just to make things clear, my earlier comments about bad habits (and presumably Graham's comments also?) were more than somewhat tongue in cheek.
Absolutely.
-
If it had bass couplers it would be a Wielly.
Would it Wielly? Sorry - must be the G&T. Happy New Year all!
Graham
-
Thanks for the input, folks. Rita Fancello first came to my attention when I was looking for guidance to play L'Inconnu de Limoise, ans she's been an inspiration ever since. Great player.
-
Regarding Ms Fancello's playing, I think Malcolm and Rees are absolutely spot-on.