Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Dave Honey on December 05, 2008, 02:14:26 AM

Title: B major v B minor on DG box
Post by: Dave Honey on December 05, 2008, 02:14:26 AM

As a new contributor, forgive me if this has been raised many times before. But what is the advantage of a B major chord rather than a B minor chord on a DG box? As a guitarist as well as a box player I frequently use Bm but hardly ever use B major when accompanying melodeon players in keys D, G, Am or Em. Is there any hiccup that I haven't thought of if I get my Castagnari Tommy chord retuned from B to Bm, or at least neutralised?
Title: Re: B major v B minor on DG box
Post by: Stiamh on December 05, 2008, 03:11:26 AM
Hi Dave,

This rang a bell so I searched the old forum and found this thread:

http://melodeon.aimoo.com/Technical/B-Major-1-553916.html (http://melodeon.aimoo.com/Technical/B-Major-1-553916.html)

Cheers
Steve
Title: Re: B major v B minor on DG box
Post by: Malcolm Austen on December 05, 2008, 08:47:20 AM
Thanks for that Steve I had forgotten what a good thread that was, I still don't understand it though.
malcolm
Title: Re: B major v B minor on DG box
Post by: Falseknight on December 05, 2008, 05:37:25 PM
Isn't this the chord of the dominant in the key of E minor?
Title: Re: B major v B minor on DG box
Post by: Doug Anderson on December 06, 2008, 02:20:16 AM
I've had the equivalent chord (E) on both of my G/C boxes changed from major to minor. On the Saltarelle I have a bass stop to neuter the chords, but I can't remember the last time I used it because the Em chord (which would be a Bm chord on a D/G box) didn't work.
Title: Re: B major v B minor on DG box
Post by: waltzman on December 06, 2008, 11:21:27 AM
Isn't this the chord of the dominant in the key of E minor?

I'm sure that is why the designers of the melodeon put it there.  On the other hand B minor is the relative minor of D major.  So if 80% of your tunes are in D then the  B minor chord would probably be more useful.  It just represents another compromise.
Title: Re: B major v B minor on DG box
Post by: IanD on December 06, 2008, 12:26:06 PM

As a new contributor, forgive me if this has been raised many times before. But what is the advantage of a B major chord rather than a B minor chord on a DG box? As a guitarist as well as a box player I frequently use Bm but hardly ever use B major when accompanying melodeon players in keys D, G, Am or Em. Is there any hiccup that I haven't thought of if I get my Castagnari Tommy chord retuned from B to Bm, or at least neutralised?

Instead of just blocking off the third (which can leave the chord rather thin-sounding) you could do what Theo's just done with my Preciosa and replace the third with another fifth -- sounds much more balanced :-)

Ian
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal