Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Martyn on January 02, 2013, 11:57:13 AM
-
I have had two requests in the last couple of weeks to convert a B/C/C# Hohner Trichord to A/D/G. One of the boxes is a two voice the other a three voice.
As I have never carried out this conversion before I was wondering if any melnetters had either done this, or had it done. I am a little unsure of which route to take....do I use the existing reeds by moving them around and tuning some or do I purchase some Corona reeds on blocks for the right hand and just buy the necessary reeds for the left hand using the existing blocks? This way at least the B/C/C# treble blocks would be left intact should the conversion ever needed to be reversed in the future.
Both customers said they are quite happy to leave the decision to me. :-\
What does the team think?
Martyn
-
A lot of hard work given the lack of interest (and therefore low price) of Coronas in this country, even in ADG - Theo`s been sitting on an ADG Corona for ages for less cash than a complicated trichord conversion would likely cost Unless you`re doing a super cheap "January sale" on tuning "3 voices for the price of one" or something (whereas I`ll have you tune my Trike to sound like a Shand Morino ;D )
IMO Trichords are best left as BCC#, they should either learn to play it so sell it to a Scot, they`re just way too uneconomical to convert to ADG (especially the 3 voicers) unless its your box, it`s cost you nothing and you happen have a lot of time on your hands .
Just my Opinion as a Trike owner who actually LIKES Coronas
-
Yes, seems to me to not be a cost effective way of getting an ADG, whichever way you do the conversion the cost is likely to be much higher than buying a used Corona, even if the Trichord cost nothing. If you really do go ahed you can probably by a secondhand Compadre for lest than the cost of a new set of reeds.
Into view on doing key conversions is that it is only worth doing in special situations where the tuning in question is not available, for example where a DG version is required for an instrument is simply not available in that tuning such as a 1930s Hohner club.
-
The compadre is a good point - a new ADG can be had for just over £450 in the UK from a shop off the shelf - they`re even cheaper abroad and probably cheaper if you ask the Music room nicely (and if they have stock they want to shift), it`s every bit as good as a new Chinese made Corona-II bar maybe the bellows tape .....
it`s only a shame they don`t make the 3 voice Vallenato version in ADG (or BCC# come to that) , my F/Bb/Eb one is a killer box.
-
Trichords are both an ideal way to test the british chromatic water and are in fact an exellent BCC# box for long term ownership offering 12 major keys for the price of 5 and bass for CGDA & a ;bit of something for F & E. Bass conversion to 24, 32, 30 or 48 is not that difficult for those who want it. However the supply of half decent Trichords is already limited as they havn't been made for many years.
Therefore in my opinion and irrespective of the economic pros and cons already alluded to and taking into account the ready availability of used coronas etc etc buggering about with perfectly good trichords is to put it politely a dastardly deed that should not be encouraged
On a slightly different tack Hohner have in their corporate 'parts bin' most of the stuff to produce a new good quality Trichord using the posh end Coronas ( not the compadre) with an Amica 11 bass end.
george
-
Therefore in my opinion and irrespective of the economic pros and cons already alluded to and taking into account the ready availability of used coronas etc etc buggering about with perfectly good trichords is to put it politely a dastardly deed that should not be encouraged
I totally agree with you George. I think I might have to try to convince my customers to go for a Corona or Compadre and either keep the Trichord for what it is, or pass it on to someone who is going to play it as a B/C/C#.
-
Martyn, if one of your customers is interested in the ADG I have then I'm open to some kind if deal. Contact me off line if I can help.
-
Thanks Theo, I will pass on the info to them.
M.
-
A lot of hard work given the lack of interest (and therefore low price) of Coronas in this country, even in ADG - Theo`s been sitting on an ADG Corona for ages for less cash than a complicated trichord conversion would likely cost Unless you`re doing a super cheap "January sale" on tuning "3 voices for the price of one" or something (whereas I`ll have you tune my Trike to sound like a Shand Morino ;D )
IMO Trichords are best left as BCC#, they should either learn to play it so sell it to a Scot, they`re just way too uneconomical to convert to ADG (especially the 3 voicers) unless its your box, it`s cost you nothing and you happen have a lot of time on your hands .
Just my Opinion as a Trike owner who actually LIKES Coronas
Agreed- and I love my black corona 2! :||:
-
A lot of hard work given the lack of interest (and therefore low price) of Coronas in this country, even in ADG - Theo`s been sitting on an ADG Corona for ages for less cash than a complicated trichord conversion would likely cost Unless you`re doing a super cheap "January sale" on tuning "3 voices for the price of one" or something (whereas I`ll have you tune my Trike to sound like a Shand Morino ;D )
IMO Trichords are best left as BCC#, they should either learn to play it so sell it to a Scot, they`re just way too uneconomical to convert to ADG (especially the 3 voicers) unless its your box, it`s cost you nothing and you happen have a lot of time on your hands .
Just my Opinion as a Trike owner who actually LIKES Coronas
Agreed- and I love my black corona 2! :||:
Love my 50's model too. Set them up and dry them out a little and they are fantastic boxes.
-
Love mine 50's model too. Set them up and dry them out a little and they are fantastic boxes.
I guess Hohner Coronas are far the most popular and appreciated diatonic accordions on Earth.
Yup, mainly in South America where it really rules the roost. the UK is one of the least Corona Friendly places (a definate 2 row zone)