Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: David80 on January 03, 2013, 10:58:31 AM

Title: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: David80 on January 03, 2013, 10:58:31 AM
Most recently I got my first box, Erica G/C. I'm fresh in boxplaying and still finding my way around the box:) The thing that pussles me is that the keys go so deep when pressed, and I find it a bit uneasy to move my fingers to other keys as the fingertips dig so deep in the keyboard. Is there any damper or key stopper that can be mounted inside? (I'm norwegian, so therefor the possible odd wrighting ;))
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: Lester on January 03, 2013, 11:03:25 AM
The standard modification on Ericas and Pokerwork is to restrict the button travel on the treble end. Theo posted some pictures but they are only available if you have a Facebook account I think, he may well be along soon to help.
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: David80 on January 03, 2013, 11:15:33 AM
Thanks! Yes, I meant the treble end.  8)
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: Rob2Hook on January 03, 2013, 12:15:44 PM
Modifying the treble action so that the buttons do not go below the keyboard is a great improvement for most players.  Theo's method entails putting a strip of wood below the action within the body of the box.  Others have put materiakl within the keyboard below the levers - something resilient but not so hard that it adds another percussion sound!  Originally the keyboard had a layer of felt behond it to stop noise, but hard rubber or cork have also been used adding thickness to restrict the movement of the levers.  Although Theo adds a piece of wood to the standard instrument, there is also a replacement keyboard offered which has a removeable back and is supplied with materials to restrict the action.

Some players manage without modifying the action.  They play with the fingers flatter to the keyboard rather than using the fingertip, so the finger cannot go below the keyboard.

Rob.
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: David80 on January 03, 2013, 01:06:39 PM
Ok. Fingersetting vs modifying.. The first one less expensive:) But maybe the most difficult!
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: Quebecois on January 03, 2013, 02:31:35 PM
Some players manage without modifying the action.  They play with the fingers flatter to the keyboard rather than using the fingertip, so the finger cannot go below the keyboard.
Rob.
By far the best approach, IMHO. It's a lifetime good habit, works for any instrument, and does not require any work on the box!
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on January 03, 2013, 04:02:29 PM
Anyone remember, especially after a week long festival of having a swollen left wrist ( Hohner Pokerwork) and bleeding fingers on the right? Thank God people like Lester, Theo etc have come up with a cure. Why we never thought about a modification in those days is beyond me.
   And it's nothing to do with my sex life I can assure you.
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: Lester on January 03, 2013, 04:32:45 PM
It is my opinion that you can play the box far better with a finger tips than with the flats of your finger, for both speed and accuracy. Therefore the keyboard mod is far better than flat fingering. The modification is fairly simple if you are confident enough to open the box up.
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: David80 on January 03, 2013, 04:41:33 PM
Given the fact that I'm a beginner, it's sensable to learn a clever technic. But I seem (so far) to manage the "klawgrip" on the right end just about ok. But I play with the box dangelig freely on my left knee. So, it's more like i kling on to the box rather than try to make music...😄
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: malcolmbebb on January 03, 2013, 06:23:00 PM
Just to further confound you...

1) A very well known player of Hohners takes the view that your fingers shouldn't be on the buttons long enough to have a problem with going down the holes. He plays almost exclusively English dance music, so I guess YMMV for other styles.

2) It sounds like you have other problems with your posture/straps/grip to sort out before you get too much further. What straps do you use?
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on January 03, 2013, 07:10:38 PM
Some players manage without modifying the action.  They play with the fingers flatter to the keyboard rather than using the fingertip, so the finger cannot go below the keyboard.
Rob.
By far the best approach, IMHO. It's a lifetime good habit, works for any instrument, and does not require any work on the box!

This has come up lots of times. Personally I agree with you but we seem to be in a minority with every beginner being advised to simply change the set-up of the box rather than use the opportunity to learn or at least think about better technique. Many more expensive box players don't get this feedback and never stop using too much force on the buttons.

To the OP ...

By all means make the change, it's your instrument and your experience of it after all, but I think you should also be considering why your fingers are disappearing into the keyboard in the first place.


edited for clarity.
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: David80 on January 03, 2013, 08:11:47 PM
This is interresting. So you all have different views on the matter! I can't really imagine why they made the box like that If it wasn't meant to be like it! ;) So, by altering my fingersetting I would do the right thing. And if I had modified the keys, still i'd end up playing with flatter fingers.
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on January 03, 2013, 08:18:31 PM
This is interresting. So you all have different views on the matter! I can't really imagine why they made the box like that If it wasn't meant to be like it! ;) So, by altering my fingersetting I would do the right thing. And if I had modified the keys, still i'd end up playing with flatter fingers.

You'll get used to it, this is normal  :D
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: The Blues Viking on January 04, 2013, 02:11:06 AM
Some players manage without modifying the action.  They play with the fingers flatter to the keyboard rather than using the fingertip, so the finger cannot go below the keyboard.

When I first got my Erica I found this disconcerting, but I quickly learned to play with a "flatter" fingering (less of the tip) and I still play that way. But I have recently acquired an old Hohner 1-row, with a stepped keyboard ("fingerboard" or "buttonboard" if you prefer). That is, a keyboard with a step in it but only one row of buttons, just below the step. I find this a bit difficult to deal with, with the step in the way of my fingers when playing with a "flatter" touch, and from the damage to the keyboard I'd say that the previous owner had much the same problem (lots of wear on the step itself).

Is/was this common? I haven't encountered another in my limited experience. When I get around to fixing this up (or having it done) I'm going to have to do something about this useless step. The box in question needs a bit of work which I don't have the time or money to do/have done right now, so it isn't urgent. But I like the box's sound, and I'd like to play it one day, but if anyone can satisfy my curiosity on this I'd appreciate it. Sorry I can't do pics right now, but if anyone needs or wants to see it let me know and I'll work something out.

TBV

EDIT: I apologize; I appear to have drifted off topic. Please feel free to repost to a more appropriate place, should you think it necessary.
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: David80 on January 04, 2013, 04:24:43 AM
T'is funny ; my key problem was my one concern. Was! :) I intend to mount a single strap. That will help me to keep the box steady with my thumb pushing it leftwards. Probably familiar position. That must be giving me a firmer lock on my left knee, witch allows my right hand (what's left of it anyway) to play a bit more freely, i hope :||:
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: Graham Spencer on January 04, 2013, 06:09:24 AM
My very first box was an Erica with a plastic keyboard, and in those far-off days the problem of the "disappearing buttons" didn't seem to be as widely or inventively addressed as it is now.  I cut a piece of foam to fit inside the keyboard under the key levers (at this distance I can't remember the thickness, but it was reasonably low-density and the thickness as close to the distance from lever to keyboard back as I could find. Crude, but effective - the action was suitably restricted and the foam had little or no impact on the response of the instrument (or at least, I was in those days insufficiently accomplished or experienced to notice!).  I'm not necessarily advocating this as a way to go, just confirming that the problem has been around for many years and many of us have had to find our own ways of dealing with it. Incidentally, I wish I still had the red Erica - it was stolen, and the black one I got to replace it never felt the same or played as well.

Graham
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: Mike Hirst on January 06, 2013, 09:12:21 PM
Surely, this belongs in the teaching and learning (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/board,5.0.html) section. This is a question of technique. It is not necessary for the buttons to be pushed all the way down for the instrument to sound. If you don't want the buttons to disappear down the hole, don't press so hard. Articulate playing is achieved through practice, not buy sticking a piece of foam under the fingerboard.
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: Lester on January 06, 2013, 09:18:35 PM
Articulate playing is achieved through practice, not buy sticking a piece of foam under the fingerboard.

I'm suprised that Castagnari dont allow the buttons on their melodeons disappear into the keyboard then to allow "Articulate playing" then.  >:E
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: Mike Hirst on January 06, 2013, 09:28:58 PM
Articulate playing is achieved through practice, not buy sticking a piece of foam under the fingerboard.

I'm suprised that Castagnari dont allow the buttons on their melodeons disappear into the keyboard then to allow "Articulate playing" then.  >:E

It is not necessary for the buttons to be pushed all the way down for the instrument to sound.

This is true of all instruments, regardless of make or construction, even those with foam under the fingerboard. Are you seriously suggesting that the Castaganari keyboard will enable me to become an articulate musician without the need for practice or technique?
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: jebe on January 07, 2013, 01:05:46 AM
This is true of all instruments, regardless of make or construction, even those with foam under the fingerboard. Are you seriously suggesting that the Castaganari keyboard will enable me to become an articulate musician without the need for practice or technique?
But this isn't the point.  The OP was interested in limiting the button travel because he doesn't like the feel.  It's a very common modification, he should be free to implement it without being crucified by the pedants on this forum.
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: Steve C. on January 07, 2013, 01:37:08 AM
A strip of piano tuners felt is the easiest, cheapest and did I say cheapest, place to start.  It is pretty hard to mess it up if you go slowly, in removing the fingerboard.

You may need 2 slightly different thicknesses of felt (one for the G and one for the C) but one single piece or 2 of the same thicknesses placed side by side if not wide enough will make a HUGE difference.

And did I say cheap?
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on January 07, 2013, 02:19:29 AM
This is true of all instruments, regardless of make or construction, even those with foam under the fingerboard. Are you seriously suggesting that the Castaganari keyboard will enable me to become an articulate musician without the need for practice or technique?
But this isn't the point.  The OP was interested in limiting the button travel because he doesn't like the feel.  It's a very common modification, he should be free to implement it without being crucified by the pedants on this forum.

I think you ought to stick around a little longer before being so rude. Then we may have a chance to get to know you first and be inclined to let you get away with things ... maybe.

No-one is being "crucified" and no-one should be interested in point scoring here, it's pointless   ::)

There are thoughts being expressed, some discussion as will always happens gets a bit silly, but, really, crucifixions and pedantry?
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: jebe on January 07, 2013, 02:51:21 AM
I think you ought to stick around a little longer before being so rude. Then we may have a chance to get to know you first and be inclined to let you get away with things ... maybe.
Actually, I have had 2 other accounts here over the years and have left both times in disgust at the good old boy attitude of the old-timers and pretend old-timers here.  Not to mention the pedantry and the bullying, especially of new members.  The third time's the charm, you won't have to worry about me coming back.  I have no need of your collective "wisdom" or snotty attitudes.  And I certainly won't beg for your permission to speak my mind.  Moron.

Marc G. Lamb,
Chesapeake, Virginia, USA, formerly White River Junction, Vermont
Former Foggy Bottom Morris Men, Albemarle Morris Men
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: David80 on January 07, 2013, 05:35:22 AM
I see. I totaly get the idea of what this is. And due to all of these answers, I would probably think twice before asking souch a question. And still, given the fact that f.ex hohners do not have any inlay on the treble side tells me that i can do without. - Just use a better technic. And if I don't want to practice any extra to get there, i can still modefy my hohner, and THAT would be just as normal.
So when i play, i often like to play on the inner G row. The only way to hit those keys correctly is by using more tip. If i change the angle of the attack, i seem to touch the outer key as well. Suppose my technic are not yet too good. Add this to the main dissapearing issue, and you get the feeling that this is much harder to learn than it really needs to be:) And especialy when you soon find out that the tone is fully rich as soon as the button opens the reed.
So, to save me for any trouble and to keep up the spirit I will modify my box:)
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: David80 on January 07, 2013, 06:43:00 AM
And, as for any opinion, consevative or not, theese debates are important! It is how we discover how others solve their problems:) So lets be gentlemen and keep shearing our opinions in a good manner:)

David
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: Mike Hirst on January 07, 2013, 10:21:17 AM
It would appear that I have rattled some cages. Certainly not my intention.

My first instrument was a Hohner one row four stop which was bought new in 1977. I have continued to play Hohner instruments to this day. Whilst I have at times been aware of the fact that some Hohner instruments allow the buttons to be pushed lower than the top level of the fingerboard, I can honestly say that it has never been an issue.

I have no doubt that foam/felt inserts can be used to limit button travel. Even with this modification we, as musicians, have a choice of how far the button is pressed. This decision is a crucial factor in the way that we articulate our musicality, regardless of whether that depression takes the button below the fingerboard, or not.

It is significant that the majority of posts in this thread which advocate mechanical limitation are from forum members who are already well versed in the dark arts of melodeon modification. We are not all such able craftsmen. Keyboard modification is an intrusive and, in inexperienced hands, potentially damaging process. I know from personal experience that cludging and melodeons do not mix.

For my own part I have preferred to limit button travel through adopting a less forceful finger action. In my experience this has resulted in a more considered and articulate approach to playing.
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on January 07, 2013, 10:31:38 AM
I must admit that I quite liked the fingers disappearing  down the holes on my Erica. I sort of knew where I was on the keyboard. Crazy I know, but true. With the Dino I now have I find that my fingers are inclined to slip off. Not good for Bob Cann stuff!!!
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on January 07, 2013, 06:27:06 PM
It would appear that I have rattled some cages. Certainly not my intention.

My first instrument was a Hohner one row four stop which was bought new in 1977. I have continued to play Hohner instruments to this day. Whilst I have at times been aware of the fact that some Hohner instruments allow the buttons to be pushed lower than the top level of the fingerboard, I can honestly say that it has never been an issue.

I have no doubt that foam/felt inserts can be used to limit button travel. Even with this modification we, as musicians, have a choice of how far the button is pressed. This decision is a crucial factor in the way that we articulate our musicality, regardless of whether that depression takes the button below the fingerboard, or not.

It is significant that the majority of posts in this thread which advocate mechanical limitation are from forum members who are already well versed in the dark arts of melodeon modification. We are not all such able craftsmen. Keyboard modification is an intrusive and, in inexperienced hands, potentially damaging process. I know from personal experience that cludging and melodeons do not mix.

For my own part I have preferred to limit button travel through adopting a less forceful finger action. In my experience this has resulted in a more considered and articulate approach to playing.

My personal experience, broadly, has been the same as yours, with the addition that for some reason I just don't like the feel of Hohners with a limited button travel. In my mind it also would seem to limit the possibilities round pushing buttons in further to make a different/louder sound. That might just be in my head though.

I would never damn anyone for making the change. There are too many variables around hand/finger size, playing style and personal preference to make any definitive statement either way.

However, I do feel free to comment about my experience and the issue of pushing too hard on the buttons and general tension that makes playing more difficult, most often seen in beginners. Limiting button travel is not really a solution for that.
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: 911377brian on January 07, 2013, 09:10:08 PM
I'm a very late starter on the melodeon, and have probably asked more 'daft' questions than most, I've always been treated with courtesy and my queries taken seriously. I'm not sure where you would have to go to find the sense of friendly humourus debate that we have here on Melnet; I found the accusation of 'pedantry and bullying' completely unfounded and offensive.However, back to fingers vanishing into the keyboard. This happens on one of my 1040's, and thats fine, the other two do'nt behave like that. I get the feeling that my fingering is lighter when the buttons go in further and I play a little quicker. Counter intuitive?.. :o  ::)
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: george garside on January 07, 2013, 10:00:54 PM
  For my own part I have preferred to limit button travel through adopting a less forceful finger action. In my experience this has resulted in a more considered and articulate approach to playing.

I think Mike has a very fair point.  I have never limited the travel of button on my hohners as I don't shove the thing down the hole so it would be a fairly pointless exercise.  Perhaps its because i only had  a hohner for many years that I developed a light touch on the buttons  so as not to get the fingers stuck in the holes!   Switching from  a hohner to a box with limited button travel doesn't present any problem as  I presumably depress them by a similer amount

george
Title: Re: Key solution, anyone?
Post by: David80 on January 08, 2013, 05:38:43 PM
Again, thank you all for sheared answers. I've made up my mind. :)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal