Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Sandy Flett on January 06, 2013, 06:21:19 PM
-
Apologies if you feel we have been here before, but I have searched through past postings on MM and MMM tuning, and did not find quite the same question.
I currently achieve two different MM sounds from the following boxes:
(a) An LMM box which is tuned to M0/M+4 cents (at A=440) which gives a lovely, sweet MM sound
(b) An M0/M+12 box which has a rich and powerful sound but which stops short of becoming strident, and is a great contrast to the M0/M+4.
The question is, if I were to try to achieve my two different MM sounds in one MMM box what sort of plus and minus tunings would give me a satisfyingly rich (but not strident) MMM sound - eg -4/0/+12, or -5/0/+10, or ... ?
Also, would I be right in thinking that given that most MM boxes are M/M+ (rather than M/M-) our ears are used to and accept that, whereas we notice the "flatness" of an equivalent M/M- tuning more. If so, would it be advisable to make the M+ the wider tuning, so that when the M/M- are played the narrower offset is not so "flattening"?
In case it has any bearing, I would note that the combining box would actually be LMMM.
-
-4/0/+8 ?
-
A better solution perhaps would be to have the three reeds tuned normally, say -4/0/+4 but work out the switches so that you play 0 and +4 together, (sounding slightly sharp, as most boxes would), and -4 and +4 together for a wetter sound that has the bonus of actually being in tune rather than slightly flat.
-
I guess the other question to ask is whether there are intervals I should avoid.
I like your idea of the M-/M+ for the wetter sound, Andrew.
-
I think that the amount of tremolo that works best can depend very much on the instrument, as well as on your personal preferences. It also depends on how well the tuning is done, I believe that the most difficult tuning to get sounding really as good as it can is the narrow interval of 4 cents or so. Tiny differences in pitch of one reed can make a big difference to the sound of the MM pair, and there is also the effect you can sometimes get of two very close pitches locking together as you play harder which can sound really dreadful.
-
A better solution perhaps would be to have the three reeds tuned normally, say -4/0/+4 but work out the switches so that you play 0 and +4 together, (sounding slightly sharp, as most boxes would), and -4 and +4 together for a wetter sound that has the bonus of actually being in tune rather than slightly flat.
Further to Theo's most recent reply, I believe there is also a strong case when tuning M- M M+ for making the offsets asymmetrical to avoid the possibility of phase locking giving an uncomfortably strong tremolo.
So - instead of, for example, tuning the offsets -4/0/+4, instead tune to -3/-1/+5. This should give a perceived M- to M difference of -2, and perceived M to M+ difference of +2, with an overall resultant perceived offset of 0, which is what you want for a three voice MMM tuning. I believe Ian Dedic (of this parish) has previously commented on tuning MMM voicing but the thread is probably deeply buried...
-
I found this La Baf tunings comparison webpage (http://www.la-baf.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=83&Itemid=99) very helpful in terms of determining what "room for manoeuvre" I have wrt tuning ranges. I assume the numbers are cents offset at A=440.
My conclusions are that I could accept up to 6 cents for the mellower of my two sounds and up to 12 cents for the richer MM. As Theo says: "the amount of tremolo that works best can depend very much on the instrument, as well as on your personal preferences"; so it would be a matter of working within those tolerances and the tuner hearing what works best, including for the overall MMM sound.
So if we went with Andrew's idea to use M-/M+ as the wetter MM sound, then maybe a starting point would be -4 0 +8, which would give me 3 MM offsets of 4, 8 and 12 as well as an MMM, unless the relationship of 4 and 8 would potentially cause the undesirable effects mentioned by Theo and Steve, and by Ian Dedic in his post of 8 Aug 2010 (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4665.msg59209.html#msg59209):
You can also see why Theo's suggestion of having different spacings sounds better if you look at the overall sound envelope with three reeds; with equal spacing (or very close to it) you get a slow throbbing sound superimposed on the normal tremolo as the three reeds move slowly in and out of phase.
To break this up you want the spacings to not have a common factor; -20 0 +20 is bad, -10 0 +20 has 2:1 factor, -8 0 +20 is better, but the last two have a tuning offset from concert pitch with all reeds sounding. Of course if you consider what happens when you have stops (and which reed or reeds are removed) it all get even messier.
-
To add to the complexity there is is also the question of how the tuning is arranged across the range of the instrument.
The two extremes are:
a) constant cents difference across the range and therefore a doubling of beat rates every octave
b) halving the cents difference every octave and therefore constant beat rate across the range.
-
To add to the complexity there is is also the question of how the tuning is arranged across the range of the instrument.
The two extremes are:
a) constant cents difference across the range and therefore a doubling of beat rates every octave
b) halving the cents difference every octave and therefore constant beat rate across the range.
For me it would be the same as you did for the AD Erica I bought from you recently which is a great sounding instrument across its full range. I assume that was the tapered tuning of your example (b).
-
To add to the complexity there is is also the question of how the tuning is arranged across the range of the instrument.
The two extremes are:
a) constant cents difference across the range and therefore a doubling of beat rates every octave
b) halving the cents difference every octave and therefore constant beat rate across the range.
For me it would be the same as you did for the AD Erica I bought from you recently which is a great sounding instrument across its full range. I assume that was the tapered tuning of your example (b).
Vibrato used when singing -- which you could say is what deliberately detunded reeds are trying to mimic -- has a beat rate pretty independent of pitch, usually between about 3Hz (untrained voices) and 7Hz (coloratura opera singers); the choice depends on the tradeoff between sounding "natural" and maximum percieved volume.
For the same reason it doesn't make sense to me to have a slower beat rate on low pitched reeds and faster on higher ones (constant offset in cents), having a constant offset in Hz avoids the low reeds sounding drier and the high reeds sounding wetter. This does mean that quoting an offset in cents is meaningless unless you also specify the pitch; for example +/-2Hz offset (my favourite with 2 reeds) is +/-8 cents at A440 but +/-15 cents at A220.
I'm not sure there really *is* a good choice with 3 reeds (MMM or LLM), especially with stops...