Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: george garside on January 11, 2013, 10:54:44 AM
-
have just bought a wrist support from Liddle £2. It is unobtrusive and velcros round the wrist and is the best thing I have ever tried to stop pokerwords Lillies etc etc digging in painfully. Perhaps not quite the purpose intended by the maker. Something on similar lines probably available more expensively from boots or wherever
george
-
Thanks George !! .
I never understoood that the lily hadn`t a bevelled case at the bottom, especially given the serious attention to detail in other areas (the etched 1914 & scrolling detail, "black" chromework etc) , can understand it on the pokerwork, it`s thrown together from cardboard-thin plywood
-
Thanks George !! .
I never understoood that the lily hadn`t a bevelled case at the bottom, especially given the serious attention to detail in other areas (the etched 1914 & scrolling detail, "black" chromework etc) , can understand it on the pokerwork, it`s thrown together from cardboard-thin plywood
I tink you need to take another look at a pokerwork, cardboard-thin plywood, hah ::)
My Baffetti (costing considerably more than a pokerwork) is make from plywood, and a fine (light and strong) construction material it is too.
George, thanks, I might well have a look in my local Lidl for one of those, though I generally try to avoid it.
The elasticated sports wrist support thingies are indeed good to use with a pokerwork.
-
I tink you need to take another look at a pokerwork, cardboard-thin plywood, hah ::)
it is cardboard thin, 1 layer thinner corrugated cardboard is about the same thickness - when I was adding decent bellows straps to one, I had no problem pushing a jewellers screwdriver through without much twisting, can`t do that with a Baffetti - it wasn`t a complaint Andrew (it may even help produce the Pokerwork sound) , just an observation that wood (ply or otherwise) that thin doesn`t leave any leeway for bevelling
-
I've not actually looked, but I thought Lester said he'd bevelled his to save his wrist.
-
I tink you need to take another look at a pokerwork, cardboard-thin plywood, hah ::)
My Baffetti (costing considerably more than a pokerwork) is make from plywood, and a fine (light and strong) construction material it is too.
So is my Saltarelle. If it was good enough to build De Haviland Mosquito(e)s.......... ;)
-
It has always seemed miraculous that they could hang two12 cylinder merlin engines on plywood wings they must have weighed around 10cwt each
george
-
Seems like magic. That's why they had to use Merlins.
-
I bevelled my Pokerwork just like Lester - it really makes a difference.
-
How Rees, there`s nothing much to Bevel (about 3 to 4mm of the ply thickness) unless you add wood first - the bit added to the later ones made mine more uncomfortable than anything, I could have tried bevelling that ........ anyway George's Wristband is a great idea.
-
I cut out some of the substantially thick plywood and inset a piece of quadrant on the Penguin of Death. Now I have a router table I do it differently. When I am home again I will post some images.
-
Puzzled by all this talk of ply, most of the pokerworks I've seen are built of solid timber, even the recent Chinese ones, and the timber of the casing is usually between 7.5mm and 8mm. The bass cover plate is usually ply. Older 2915s with celluloid finish are ply, but that is usually 8mm including the celluloid. I've just measured several boxes. Plenty of scope for rounding the edge.
-
Puzzled by all this talk of ply,
That's what comes of being 200 miles from my nearest melodeon.
-
Thanks for the heads up, may need to get a wee wrist protector. You can draw blood with the corner of my old Double Ray if you play it enough ??? ??? ??? ??? ???
-
I use 2 of the longer tennis wristbands, one on top of the other. I find that gives me sufficient protection whichever melodeon I'm playing. Not sure how much they cost, but not astronomical I'm sure. Don't get white like I did - they look pretty grubby at the moment; time in the washing machine means time not playing - or playing with pain!
-
Sharron Shannon uses a huge sponge, looks terrible but it must work for her! I use one of those aforementioned sports wristbands if I'm going to play for long periods, it has a scull and crossbones on it....quite 'sporting' for me. anyway, it's the nearest I ever get to sport these days :-[
Ken.
-
I use 2 of the longer tennis wristbands, one on top of the other. I find that gives me sufficient protection whichever melodeon I'm playing. Not sure how much they cost, but not astronomical I'm sure. Don't get white like I did - they look pretty grubby at the moment; time in the washing machine means time not playing - or playing with pain!
the Lidle ones are black so should never need washing!
geroge ;)
-
I cut out some of the substantially thick plywood and inset a piece of quadrant on the Penguin of Death. Now I have a router table I do it differently. When I am home again I will post some images.
Works a treat.
-
Strange - I play my pokerwork longest and hardest of all my boxes, but I never have this problem. Perhaps I'm doing it wrong.
-
Real Nen just play until a callous develops then the problem goes away (:)
-
That should be Real Men. I hate posting from my phone.
-
Puzzled by all this talk of ply, most of the pokerworks I've seen are built of solid timber, even the recent Chinese ones, and the timber of the casing is usually between 7.5mm and 8mm. The bass cover plate is usually ply. Older 2915s with celluloid finish are ply, but that is usually 8mm including the celluloid. I've just measured several boxes. Plenty of scope for rounding the edge.
Yes, that's what I meant. Every Pokerwork I have owned or examined is solid wood.
-
Real Nen just play until a callous develops then the problem goes away (:)
I'm not sure that it does go away Lester. I haven't played a Pokerwork for years, picked one up recently and within seconds the swelling was back. I think that once you have damaged that part of your wrist you are stuck with it. Certainly seems so in my case.
-
Puzzled by all this talk of ply, most of the pokerworks I've seen are built of solid timber
Wow, I stand corrected, the Student-1 and Double-Ray 2915s were certainly solid wood, I was convinced the chinese pokerwork was ply, I`m sure it wasn`t anywhere near 8mm thick though , that thin screwdriver went through awfully easily when making the holes for the swivel bracket bellows straps , it took some twisting to get it through the 30s Double-ray
-
Puzzled by all this talk of ply, most of the pokerworks I've seen are built of solid timber
Wow, I stand corrected, the Student-1 and Double-Ray 2915s were certainly solid wood, I was convinced the chinese pokerwork was ply, I`m sure it wasn`t anywhere near 8mm thick though , that thin screwdriver went through awfully easily when making the holes for the swivel bracket bellows straps , it took some twisting to get it through the 30s Double-ray
Don't knock the qualities of plywood. It is an amazingly strong material. OK, yes there are various qualities, for example 2 ply, 3 ply, cross ply , MARINE PLY. but as a general material for building wooden structures it is unsurpassed . Don't confuse it with Hardboard. Which when damp becomes egg box consistency . Remember, most sailing boats are made out of this stuff, until of course Fibre glass became popular. Now there's a thought!!
-
Don't knock the qualities of plywood. It is an amazingly strong material.
Who`s knocking it ? ::) . I was merely acknowledging Theo`s correction of the materials used and my observation of the ease of making a hole in whatever was used in the chinese Pokerwork. I don`t care if they`re made of doped Cardboard ** if they're rugged last well over time and sound good .
** I bet Strasser and Hyde probably have tried this at some stage ;D
-
Don't knock the qualities of plywood. It is an amazingly strong material.
Who`s knocking it ? ::) . I was merely acknowledging Theo`s correction of the materials used and my observation of the ease of making a hole in whatever was used in the chinese Pokerwork. I don`t care if they`re made of doped Cardboard ** if they're rugged last well over time and sound good .
** I bet Strasser and Hyde probably have tried this at some stage ;D
I stand corrected.
-
Who are Strasser and Hyde?
-
Strasser is an Austrian Steirische Harmonika (Big Muti-row Alpine Melodeon with tuba-like bass) maker and "Stormy" Hyde is an Australian Melodeon maker who posts here occasionally ........
Both are famous for experimenting in alternative materials for casework and reedblocks - Stormy still uses a foam sandwich for his current boxes, Strasser now only use wood and carbon fibre
-
Strasser is an Austrian Steirische Harmonika (Big Muti-row Alpine Melodeon with tuba-like bass) maker and "Stormy" Hyde is an Australian Melodeon maker who posts here occasionally ........
Both are famous for experimenting in alternative materials for casework and reedblocks - Stormy still uses a foam sandwich for his current boxes, Strasser now only use wood and carbon fibre
WOW!
thanks Adam, we learn a bit more every day. I wonder what their thoughts are on our little toy Melodeons, using odd materials?
-
Dunno, Stormy MUST have had a play with the things in his time .. he`s pretty far out in his construction materials, has even used Balsa wood for reedblocks before now (I`d imagine it`d make re-waxing or reed replacement a nightmare) but his boxes are held in high regard and he`s gracious enough to post here occasionally
It`s great when a maker posts on Melnet - we`re lucky to have Rees here all the time too - I personally have never seen a post from Frans Van Der AA , Bertrand Gaillard, Olav Bergflodt, Doug Briggs (despite being British) or Bernard Loffet on here, though we did get one from Castagnari fairly recently which stunned most of us
-
The delightful Bernard Loffet has indeed posted here ;)
-
Sports wristbands do work well (I have a green one to fit the morris colour scheme), but also removing your watch, if you wear one that side, helps quite a bit too. Does rather annoy me that the Pokerwork design couldn't have evolved just a little over the decades to accommodate a simple improvement in this area. Not to mention the 'buttons-down-the-holes' issue. Part of the charm I guess.
-
I guess we`re lucky that the Pokerwork still exists and that the current parts still fit 2915 models even dating as far back to the 1930s . they did kinda have a go with the extra bit of wood added , shame they didn`t try to chamfer that ..
-
Sleeve of an old wooly jumper does it for me..cut it so that there is enough to double over if required... ;)
-
Great tip George. Buy a job lot to sell at festivals? ;)
I use a wide leather wrist strap, a 'hippy' one I bought when I was a lad and they were all the rage.
:D