Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: stillicidia on December 09, 2008, 08:39:45 PM

Title: reed mounting/tuning
Post by: stillicidia on December 09, 2008, 08:39:45 PM
ok so I've taken the plunge and got hold of a 1937 hohner accordion to try my hand at restoring things - now its in pieces a couple of questions - the smallest reeds have no valves which I know is standard practice but I also note that they are mounted in an inverted position to the other reeds - i,e,the rivet is at the opposit end to all the others on the block.
its the same on all the blocks so I wondered why?

Also I note that the reed blocks are tapered which conveniently matches the length of the reed plates  but is this also an important factor in the tuning?
I ask because I know that the chanter of bagpipes is critical as to the distance from the reed to the hole of the note being played a fraction of a mm is enought to change the pitch significantly - so if I sand the reed block flat I will change the working length of the note chamber slightly - will that mean I'll have to retune every reed because of this change?
Title: Re: reed mounting/tuning
Post by: Theo on December 09, 2008, 11:09:07 PM
- so if I sand the reed block flat I will change the working length of the note chamber slightly - will that mean I'll have to retune every reed because of this change?


No and yes!   Sanding the reedblock flat will not noticeably alter the pitch, but cleaning the reed tongues, and fitting new valves will make small changes, so its normal practice to check and adjust the tuning of each reed after a reed overhaul.  If the accordion is old they will not be perfectly in tune anyway, so they are likely to need tuning anyway.
Title: Re: reed mounting/tuning
Post by: an bosca ceoil on December 09, 2008, 11:59:54 PM
Was hoping for some words of wisdom regards the reverse mounting of high reeds. I always discounted any idea that it was to stop the inner tongue fouling and assumed it was to stop the reed choking. (Would pressure really be greater at the tapered end??)
While accepting that someone smarter than I decided to do it that way (like nailing reeds ???) and putting things back as they were I cannot understand why you can find identical models, some with the reeds reversed and others not. 
Title: Re: reed mounting/tuning
Post by: stillicidia on December 10, 2008, 09:28:29 AM
thanks Theo - I thought that might be the case as obviously the block could only be a tone chamber for half the reeds but I wasn't sure - any idea why the block is tapered - unless it is just to reduce the weight slightly it adds a lot to the manufacture process and wastes a lot of timber but there must be a good reason for making them that way?
Richard
Title: Re: reed mounting/tuning
Post by: rees on December 10, 2008, 02:50:24 PM
The high piccolo reeds can often not be made to sound at all when placed the right way round.
By reversing them the problem is usually solved.

I asked Emmanuel Pariselle why this was so.
His answer:
"I do not know why it is so, but it is, so we do it"  ???
Title: Re: reed mounting/tuning
Post by: IanD on December 10, 2008, 10:06:41 PM
thanks Theo - I thought that might be the case as obviously the block could only be a tone chamber for half the reeds but I wasn't sure - any idea why the block is tapered - unless it is just to reduce the weight slightly it adds a lot to the manufacture process and wastes a lot of timber but there must be a good reason for making them that way?
Richard

The blocks are tapered because higher-pitched reeds work better with smaller cavities behind them, and lower-pitched reeds need larger ones -- this doesn't just affect the sound quality, but also how well the reeds speak.

A too-large cavity for a high reed may mean it doesn't sound or is slow to start.

A too-small cavity for a low reed may mean it doesn't sound or chokes (stops sounding) when played hard.

The blocks on my Oakwood are not just tapered along their length (taller at the bass end, shorter at the treble end) but the side faces are curved to give more cavity volume at the bass end and less at the treble end -- so if you look at the top of the reed block it tapers in width as well.

Ian

P.S. High reed reversal makes a difference because it changes the direction of the air flow past the reed in the frame, in one case it's base-to-tip (the good one?) and in the other case it's tip-to-base (the bad one?) -- this affects how the reed starts as the gap between the reed and the frame opens and closes.
Title: Re: reed mounting/tuning
Post by: Dazbo on December 11, 2008, 11:19:57 AM
...I know that the chanter of bagpipes is critical as to the distance from the reed to the hole of the note being played a fraction of a mm is enought to change the pitch significantly...

This is what makes free reed instruments like ours different from other reeded instruments like bagpipes.  The note is not dependent on the length of a sound pipe but only to the rate the reed vibrates.  The sound comes from the number of air pulses per second rather than the size of the wavelength created by a pipe.  There is, I believe, a slight effect on the pitch of the note by the way the box is constructed but this is very miniscule compared to pipe lengths
Title: Re: reed mounting/tuning
Post by: stillicidia on December 23, 2008, 08:05:46 PM
these box internals are a steep learning curve - if the reedblock etc will not change the tuning significantly is it safe for me to assume - which it probably isn't - that changing the leathers on these honer reeds I'm playing with to the new hohner vinyl type will not advesly affect the tuning?
accepting that they will require tuning anyway - will I be making things even worse and make the tuning more difficult or labour intensive?
thanks
Richard

PS I'm doing this as a learning exercise - so I hope you don't mind all the questions!

Title: Re: reed mounting/tuning
Post by: IanD on December 25, 2008, 11:40:03 AM
The high piccolo reeds can often not be made to sound at all when placed the right way round.
By reversing them the problem is usually solved.

I asked Emmanuel Pariselle why this was so.
His answer:
"I do not know why it is so, but it is, so we do it"  ???

Tom Tonon has the answer to this question:

http://www.concertina.org/pica/pica_2005_2/html/reed_cavity_design_resonance.htm

(the section titled "Quarter-Wave Tube Resonator")

Also answers questions about cavity sizes and their effect (if any) on the sound, why you sometimes see small air holes drilled into the chambers of high-pitched reeds, and so on...

Cheers

Ian

P.S. Some other useful papers on reed acoustics (pitch, vibration amplitude etc) are here:

http://www.public.coe.edu/~jcotting/acoustics.html
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal