Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: kenakordeon on January 29, 2013, 04:01:06 PM
-
What type of melodeon (keyboard layout, tuning) should I be considering for dedicated Breton tunes? I'm guessing D/G, right? What about number of basses? Besides a single-row in D I also play a piano-=keyboard accordion but am interested in getting away from the weight and heft of that instrument.
I'm near The Button Box in MA, USA so will make the trip to try their instruments but I'd like a little knowledge before the visit.
Thanks for any advice.
Ken
-
For a 'dedicated Breton tunes' instrument I would definitely recommend a two-row G/C instrument, not D/G. Many Breton tunes are in the keys of G, C or A minor, which work much better on a G/C box. The harmonies are not normally complex, so a standard 8 bass/chord instrument would do perfectly fine.
There's a good selection of Breton tunes in both standard notation and melodeon tablature (for a G/C) on Bernard Loffet's website here:
http://diato.org/tablat.htm#tab3
-
G/C, definitely. At the BB, right now you have the choice between a Weltmeister (good value), a Hohner Morgane (not bad) or a Saltarelle Bouebe, a great instrument if you can afford it. It has the option of a stop to remove thirds on the bass side.
If you try a new one, bear in mind that the bellows need a few months to lose their stiffness !
Good luck,
A.
-
G/C is pretty much universal, and as Steve says a two row will cover a lot. It does seem though that a three row G/C/Acc - usually a Handry but also Rik's, Gaillard and a smattering of others - have become the preferred choice of many of the current generation of players. I only got to one festival this year but I don't recall seeing a single 2 row being played on stage or in a Fest Noz band at all, out of quite a few performers. Friends of mine who live, and play, in Brittany have commented that three rows seem to have pretty much usurped two at a lot of events they go to.
-
Bernard Loffet often plays a F/Bb (of his own make of course) which is a tone lower than GC and has a wonderful sonorous sound. I think he uses that tuning mainly when playing with the clarinet of Yves LeBlanc. But I agree GC is mainstream for Breton.
-
The B/C two-row is wonderful for C, F, G and their relative minors (a minor, d minor, and e minor), which get "on the row" (old-school press-draw) fingering and articulation on the B/C. b-flat and its relative minor (g-minor) are also very comfortable and easy on the B/C. Great box for Breton....Breton additionally has a lot of A-major stuff, which is also quite easy on the B/C, in a different way from the "on the row" keys": namely, you can play it all on the draw using your air button....
-
Breton airs are simple, repetitive and commonly expanded by lmprovised lines. Commonly they may include or be based on song 'j'ai vu le loup' etc. key depends on who you play with but baggpipes and bombardes have strange tonality. A 1-row
could suffice as the minors are simple and tonic shift very rare. My copain Pierre runs BbEb,, annd Bb Martins. His bagad plays in Cm quite a lot!
Its not about chords and I'd say a well chosen half toner was ideal for read TRAD. Bruno le Tron,, and for that matter mission bretonne in Montparnasse all seem to used CGs. So anything is legal!
EDIT I''d say the GCaccs is to assist improvisation. eg thy might play it in F, or B blues to get that jazz frisson. It's 'about' fluidity
-
Breton airs are simple, repetitive and commonly expanded by lmprovised lines. Commonly they may include or be based on song 'j'ai vu le loup' etc. key depends on who you play with but baggpipes and bombardes have strange tonality. A 1-row could suffice as the minors are simple and tonic shift very rare. My copain Pierre runs BbEb,, annd Bb Martins. His bagad plays in Cm quite a lot!
Its not about chords and I'd say a well chosen half toner was ideal for read TRAD. Bruno le Tron,, and for that matter mission bretonne in Montparnasse all seem to used CGs. So anything is legal!
EDIT I''d say the GCaccs is to assist improvisation. eg thy might play it in F, or B blues to get that jazz frisson. It's 'about' fluidity
Yeah, i think the Bombardes and Binious are usually tuned in Bb. So a Bb/Eb is often used when combined with one of those instruments. Ronan Robert has made a beautiful cd with his duo of Melodeon-Bombarde. I cant remember the name at this moment, and his partner died, but you can probably google it. ( I guess is F/Bb is probably better for this, if you want to stick with 8Bass)
Other than that i think everybody does GC, and not halftone. Probably because they want to acccompany themselves ::)
W
-
I don't play many Breton tunes, but when I do they always sound best on a Bb/Eb melodeon.
-
A lot to be said for a monotone bass as the tune are very droney. If this box truly is "dedicated" maybe a BC as discussed with basses of the Bb scale? ThAt'd be a special build for sure I'd sort of emphasise the most real Breton melodeonistas use standard GCaccs and ham the strange keys. Guess that's why 3-row is popular
YouTube a bit, and look at my chateau d'Ars report last July. Also look out the Breton tunes CD on the TRAD magazine website which has about 100 tunes
-
Thanks to all for your replies. Yes, bombardes in a bagad (with bagpipes) are Bb and can play easily in Cm. As soon as I sell a banjo I'll be able to afford another box. I'll start playing GC boxes and see if I can get the feel of a two-row. Playing a single-row in D now.
ken
-
A/D boxes are also used in Brittany... a lot of their Bagpipes are in 'A'
-
Few people are more knowledgeable or passionate about Breton music than Bernard Loffet. He is a very helpful chap and speaks reasonably good English. Why not e-mail him for advice? His e-mail address can be found on his website.
-
The conclusion is that you need at least 5 boxes ... (:)
Well ... if I have to ... ;D
-
And remember to have a box in B/E, most Breton tunes played by Florence Glorion are in B (a semitone below C). The conclusion is that you need at least 5 boxes F/Bb, G/C, A/D, Bb/Eb and B/E to play along in any environemt. Ab/Db might be interesting, too. (:)
Not really. Last time I was there we were invited to a pendaision de crémaillère ("rack-hanging" = house-warming). Much cider was drunk, numerous obscure rondeau were danced, strange keys happened. There were many melody instruments in play so I just vamped on the old 3-row. My host stuck to a triangle, which he frankly played better than most so called drummers
-
A/D boxes are also used in Brittany... a lot of their Bagpipes are in 'A'
And remember to have a box in B/E, most Breton tunes played by Florence Glorion are in B (a semitone below C).
The conclusion is that you need at least 5 boxes F/Bb, G/C, A/D, Bb/Eb and B/E to play along in any environemt. Ab/Db might be interesting, too. (:)
tunes in B? That sounds like a good excuse to practice my "along the row" playing without needing a new box (as my B/C has a B row)
-
my "along the row" playing without needing a new box (as my B/C has a B row)
What about the bass? :o
The what?
... Oh you mean those 8 buttons on the left side of melodeon? I don't use them anyway... ;)
-
Few people are more knowledgeable or passionate about Breton music than Bernard Loffet. He is a very helpful chap and speaks reasonably good English. Why not e-mail him for advice? His e-mail address can be found on his website.
I have but haven't received any replies. Maybe the emails are not going through from his website?
-
That's possible - I PM'd you his email