Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: boscaceol on February 01, 2013, 05:40:42 PM
-
I'm looking some advice on tuning; I've bought an old Hohner presswood melodeon in C and have fettled it, re-padded the pallets etc. On one row the reeds vary between minus 9 to plus 4 cents and the other row plus 4 to plus 25 cents. I read on other posts about Dedic tuning and think that's what I want to do. If I want a lean towards a wet tuning starting at A440 what would I tune to +/- ?
-
You need to re-valve and re-wax all the reeds before its worthwhile starting on tuning.
Typical Hohner tremolo usually based on around 5Hz difference, so either 440/445hz for standard Hohner or 437.5/442.5Hz for Vienese tuning as rediscovered by Ian Dedic.
You will also have to learn how to file and scrape reeds to change their pitch up and down, and to work on the both suck and blow reeds in situ on the reed blocks.
-
Somewhat surprised that nobody has yet mentioned this http://accordionrevival.com/ACCORDION_REPAIR_3.php (http://accordionrevival.com/ACCORDION_REPAIR_3.php) treatise. (Posted by Bill Young on Accordion Forum.)
Considering the number of people who talk of tuning to tenths of a cent against a meter, it is quite interesting that the author asserts this to be nigh on impossible, even with the use of a manometer to achieve constant pressure. ;D
-
Somewhat surprised that nobody has yet mentioned this http://accordionrevival.com/ACCORDION_REPAIR_3.php (http://accordionrevival.com/ACCORDION_REPAIR_3.php) treatise. (Posted by Bill Young on Accordion Forum.)
Excellent resource, if somewhat wordy in parts. It is aimed at piano accordions, rather than diatonic push-pull instruments but there is much common ground here.
Considering the number of people who talk of tuning to tenths of a cent against a meter, it is quite interesting that the author asserts this to be nigh on impossible, even with the use of a manometer to achieve constant pressure. ;D
To be fair, the author doesn't say that tuning to ± 0.1 cent is impossible, but he discusses the reasons why the pitch of a reed may drift after it has been tuned to such accuracy (e.g. changes in ambient temperature/humidity, bellows pressure, bellows volume, etc), and whether such drift is important in the overall 'in-tuneness' of the instrument.
I've been discovering these factors for myself and it is useful to read another person's viewpoints and experiences. When trying to achieve a target tremolo and pitch on the very highest pitched reeds, tiny changes of less than 1 cent will have an audible effect on the result, so it is important to tune accurately and listen carefully to the results of what you are doing.
The other major difference between tuning melodeons/diatonic instruments compared with accordions is the push-pull action of the former. There are far more bellows direction changes and associated rapid positive-negative pressure gradient fluctuations. Deciding how to tune to accommodate the transient pitch of a reed when it starts up (flat at first before achieving its steady-state pitch) becomes more important on the lowest pitched reeds of diatonic instruments.
-
Thanks guys for the help and info. I have removed and ultrasonic cleaned the reeds and replaced the old leather valves with vinyl ones and waxed them back in. I was able to do this thanks to the generosity and experience of the members of this forum.
So I'm more or less ready to go on the tuning, however I don't want to mess this up as this is a nice little box to be resurrected and enjoyed again. One thing that I'm not sure about is if I tune the reeds at A440 to + and - 5Hz do I half this at A880 and double at A220? Any advice on filing and scraping would be very welcome.
-
One thing that I'm not sure about is if I tune the reeds at A440 to + and - 5Hz do I half this at A880 and double at A220?
It depends on your personal preference for tremolo. You previously indicated 'leaning towards wet' and Dedic (Viennese) tuning.
If it's any help I've attached the tuning curve which I've used for Viennese tuning of a Hohner C/F box. You can extract the information you need for your 1-row C box. The purple dots show the tremolo which I wanted to achieve (previously determined by listening to notes on instruments which I like the sound of) and the blue/red markers show the offsets from Equal Temperament required on the M- and M+ reeds to achieve that tremolo.
This curve generates a 2.25 Hz tremolo at A3=220, 4 Hz tremolo at A4=440, 5 Hz tremolo at A5=880 and 5.75 Hz tremolo at A6=1760. This equates to a warm swing tremolo, not quite as wet as current factory-tuned Pokerworks say, but certainly not dry.
-
Any advice on filing and scraping would be very welcome.
Not an exhaustive list of course and I'm sure others with more experience than me will chime in:
- Go slowly and carefully.
- Ensure you are filing/scraping the correct reed. Check and double check each time.
- Keep your tools sharp; have an oilstone to hand to frequently touch up the sharp edge/tip on your reed scratcher.
- Support the reed-tongue with a shim/reed lifter whilst you work on it. The exception to this is scraping the belly of the underneath reeds to flatten them This can be done directly through the reed plate slot - but your scratcher must be sharp and take care not to apply too much pressure to the scratcher which could alter the reed set/gap.
- Filing - I've started using a fine diamond needle file (400 grade size) which removes steel gently but efficiently without the need for excess pressure. You can also make fine files by gluing strips of 200 and 400 grade carborundum paper to wooden lolly sticks or coffee stirrers. Short lengths of carborundum nail boards as used by professional manicurists are also good.
- Be especially careful with the smallest, highest pitch reeds. They are very delicate, especially at the tip. Ensure they are always supported when working on them. Only a tiny amount of filing/scratching can cause a significant effect on the pitch.
Good luck! Be careful and cautious but have confidence too.
-
Buy a scrappy accordion off eBay and practice on those reeds before launching on to a half decent box.
-
Buy a scrappy accordion off eBay and practice on those reeds before launching on to a half decent box.
Absolutely - the best £12 I ever spent ( and I ended up with a boxful of useful little screws and so on, not to mention the bellows for a tuning table).
Graham
-
Any advice on filing and scraping would be very welcome.
Not an exhaustive list of course and I'm sure others with more experience than me will chime in:
- Go slowly and carefully.
- Ensure you are filing/scraping the correct reed. Check and double check each time.
- Keep your tools sharp; have an oilstone to hand to frequently touch up the sharp edge/tip on your reed scratcher.
- Support the reed-tongue with a shim/reed lifter whilst you work on it. The exception to this is scraping the belly of the underneath reeds to flatten them This can be done directly through the reed plate slot - but your scratcher must be sharp and take care not to apply too much pressure to the scratcher which could alter the reed set/gap.
- Filing - I've started using a fine diamond needle file (400 grade size) which removes steel gently but efficiently without the need for excess pressure. You can also make fine files by gluing strips of 200 and 400 grade carborundum paper to wooden lolly sticks or coffee stirrers. Short lengths of carborundum nail boards as used by professional manicurists are also good.
- Be especially careful with the smallest, highest pitch reeds. They are very delicate, especially at the tip. Ensure they are always supported when working on them. Only a tiny amount of filing/scratching can cause a significant effect on the pitch.
Good luck! Be careful and cautious but have confidence too.
Really good advice here. (:)
-
Many thanks to everyone, excellent advice.
(:)
-
I bought the book!
-
What book?
-
What book?
This one (http://accordionrevival.com/OWNER_S_MANUAL.php), I assume...
-
What book?
This one (http://accordionrevival.com/OWNER_S_MANUAL.php), I assume...
This one is much more useful (http://www.musicforaccordion.com/Boutique/inform/benetoux/index.htm).