Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: rabblebox on February 02, 2013, 10:24:45 PM
-
I had the chance to play my friend's new Castagnari Lilly the other day and was very impressed with how lightweight they are and with the action of the bellows very quick and hardly any effort needed to get a good sound.
having watched this video very interested to see how the different woods affect the overall sound produced by the reeds
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FW9-eu39iSc
-
Ah, have a search, this subject has been well discussed, at length.
Put simply, they have no discernible effect. Certainly not one that has been proven.
What does affect the sound/tone are things like the finish of the wood inside the instrument, size of the instrument and it's chambers, set up of the reeds and reed blocks (eg. the reeds laid flat or on blocks), air pathways, the grill and keyboard design etc etc.
See, there's lots of variables, but what melodeons don't have are "tone woods" or "sound boards".
-
'cept the ones that do....
-
Let's not go there again ???
-
Oh, go on - let's!!!!!
... Its just SO entertaining!
.... beware Rabblebox ... for you have disturbed the 'anti-fondo agents'!
Mike R
-
having watched this video very interested to see how the different woods affect the overall sound produced by the reeds
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FW9-eu39iSc
What, none at all? :-\
-
Oh, go on - let's!!!!!
... Its just SO entertaining!
.... beware Rabblebox ... for you have disturbed the 'anti-fondo agents'!
Mike R
Oh, what's wrong with Fondo (http://www.fondo.it/)?
I'm sure it's a very nice place full of Italians who know in their hearts that there is no sound board in an organetto :P
-
now now no fighting ;D ::)
-
I had the chance to play my friend's new Castagnari Lilly the other day and was very impressed with how lightweight they are and with the action of the bellows very quick and hardly any effort needed to get a good sound.
having watched this video very interested to see how the different woods affect the overall sound produced by the reeds
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FW9-eu39iSc
I've played supposedly identical boxes in the same wood (or celluloid) back-to-back and heard similar or even greater differences. I've also played boxes in different woods which sounded identical. All the video really shows is that several boxes of the same model sound different, which may or may not be anything to do with the wood they're made from -- but simple box-to-box variation between largely handmade instruments (especially reeds) is a much more likely cause than the wood.
The first step to try and show this was really the wood of the case making the difference would be to swap the reed blocks over -- but of course you can't do that with a Lilly since there aren't any...
Oh no, I've replied again, and after I promised myself I wouldn't >:E
-
haha :|||:
-
I was under the impression that wood aside, much the same as a IanD, that due to the fact they're handmade all are unique and will sound ever-so-slightly different :D
-
I sometimes (unfairly) blame Jon Loomes for this, as in one of his Music Room You-tubes he described a particular wood as giving a box a "warm" tone (I think it was cherry)
-
Aye tis right, I mean he does state it's his opinion, not sure if I agree with it necessarily...
-
it's walnut that gives a bit of a darker tone; cherry kind of in the middle; while maple gives a bright tone.
everybody knows that. :||:
-
it's walnut that gives a bit of a darker tone; cherry kind of in the middle; while maple gives a bright tone.
everybody knows that. :||:
Always though walnut would give a nutty tone, cherry a fruity tone and maple would give a syrupy tone (:)
-
What sort of tone from Acer saccharum (Rock Maple)?
-
I`m wondering if Jon had grabbed three Walnut ones if he`d heard a difference too , I`d suspect that there`d be more difference between different ages of Lily than different outer case wood going on posts from Owen and others
-
What sort of tone from Acer saccharum (Rock Maple)?
Rock music?
-
Oh, go on - let's!!!!!
... Its just SO entertaining!
.... beware Rabblebox ... for you have disturbed the 'anti-fondo agents'!
Mike R
The Fondomentalists? ;D
(Actually that's not a bad name for a melodeon ensemble!)
Graham
-
The Fondomentalists? ;D
The Mentalfondoists >:E
-
it's walnut that gives a bit of a darker tone; cherry kind of in the middle; while maple gives a bright tone.
everybody knows that. :||:
Always though walnut would give a nutty tone, cherry a fruity tone and maple would give a syrupy tone (:)
So would my chestnut Dony have a chesty tone or a nutty one?
-
So would my chestnut Dony have a chesty tone or a nutty one?
Hoarse Chestnut.
-
it's walnut that gives a bit of a darker tone; cherry kind of in the middle; while maple gives a bright tone.
everybody knows that. :||:
Always though walnut would give a nutty tone, cherry a fruity tone and maple would give a syrupy tone (:)
So would my chestnut Dony have a chesty tone or a nutty one?
I Dony know ;)
-
To quote Marc Savoy's website...
"Wood choice should be a cosmetic and weight consideration since the exterior wood itself imparts no measurable difference in either tone, volume, response, or sustain. Unlike string instruments which feature a vibrating sound board set into motion by the action of vibrating string transmitted via the bridge, accordions have vibrating steel reeds driven by air. Specially designed reed chambers, precision in the switching mechanism, and experience in bringing all this together are the criteria which determine tone, volume, response, and sustain- not the wood choice."
-
I think it's possible that a different wood might create the impression of a different tone quality in the listener, even though there's no objective basis for that impression.
Recent wine-tasting tests monitored the brain activity of the participants & found a measurable increased response to expensive wines when the participants knew the wine was more expensive, compared to when they were unaware of the price of the wines. ie. expectations colour perception in "irrational" ways.
-
LOL :|||: >:E
-
I think it's possible that a different wood might create the impression of a different tone quality in the listener, even though there's no objective basis for that impression.
Recent wine-tasting tests monitored the brain activity of the participants & found a measurable increased response to expensive wines when the participants knew the wine was more expensive, compared to when they were unaware of the price of the wines. ie. expectations colour perception in "irrational" ways.
Well known in psychology as "bias of expectation". Still, it sells a lot of vastly overpriced cables to hi-fi equipment fanatics who don't know any better ;-)
(before anyone says "oh yes they do", please point me to any blind test where they've been shown to make a difference, then I'll point you to the ones where it has been shown they don't)
-
Just wondering, does the differing density of melodionistas make the decaying echo of their statements carry on for ever? ;) AtB mory
-
Just wondering, does the differing density of melodionistas make the decaying echo of their statements carry on for ever? ;) AtB mory
Now now, play nicely...
-
Before we get onto the ripples in the 4o cosmic background radiation, but are still on wave physics, I'd love someone to tell me why a metal clarinet sounds different from a wooden one? Answers on the back of an envelope please. :|glug
-
Before we get onto the ripples in the 4o cosmic background radiation, but are still on wave physics, I'd love someone to tell me why a metal clarinet sounds different from a wooden one? Answers on the back of an envelope please. :|glug
The walls of the tube on a metal one are thinner. A wooden one the same thickness would probably be structurally unsound and even if it was possible to make one and for it to hold together then it would develop cracks in no time if it was actually played. In other words, constructional differences that different materials enable/require rather than acoustic properties of the materials themselves.
The whole "tonewood" debate with melodeons is a bit like homeopathy. The mechanism by which it is claimed to work is known not to be true yet there are still people who want to buy into it for some reason...
-
Before we get onto the ripples in the 4o cosmic background radiation, but are still on wave physics, I'd love someone to tell me why a metal clarinet sounds different from a wooden one? Answers on the back of an envelope please. :|glug
I have two Xaphoons....the same size and key (my Christmas presents). The bamboo one sounds more like a clarinet, the resin one more resembles a saxophone. An explanation of this would be welcome too....
-
So to be clear, Andy.
The thickness of the wall affects the tone, but this is not due to any manner of acoustic interaction of the developing sound .. with that wall?
-
It affects the tone to the extent that it affects what reaches your ear to a small degree and is totally passive. The properties of the material do not have any effect on the wave inside the tube, unlike the bridge and soundboard on a stringed instrument that has a direct effect on how the vibration of the string is amplified. A metal clarinet with walls the same thickness as a wooden one would probably sound similar but weigh a ton.
If someone's talking to you on one side of a door you'd hear their voice differently if that door was a screen door, a 2" thick wooden door or a 12" thick steel blast door. You wouldn't hear much if any difference between identically constructed 2" thick pine, larch or fir doors...
-
Hmmm.... Andy's explanation using doors as an example does seem to make sense, as does the homeopathy analagy.
Thanks for those comments
Q
-
The senses, being a combination of receivers and processors (hearing, sight, smell, touch to brain), larded with emotions, memories, experiences and so forth, must be unique to each of us. I have yet to meet anyone who I know for a fact hears, or sees, exactly what I hear, or see.
Being a naive Suffolk chap, and one who believes that playing the melodeon is a pleasant art, and not necessarily scientific, I tend not to worry too much about the subjective things, like whether cherry with knots sounds different to birdseye maple; and concentrate on what the owner of the fingers, ears, brain etc. is getting (or not) out of the box.
But tuning and such is quite another matter.
-
So to be clear, Andy.
The thickness of the wall affects the tone, but this is not due to any manner of acoustic interaction of the developing sound .. with that wall?
Wind instruments like clarinets (and saxophones, and recorders, and organs,and...) have a high-Q resonant column of air inside them which is what makes the sound; the resonances of this are affected strongly by things like the tone hole diameters and wall thickness and more weakly by the material of the (not infinitely rigid) walls, especially if said walls are relatively thin. For example, otherwise identical (Yanagisawa) brass, bronze and silver saxophones *do* sound different (even if they're being played behind you and you don't know which is which) -- but then a sax body is quite "live" compared to a clarinet, as anyone who has played both can tell you...
Any conclusions drawn from this are even less relevant to free-reed instruments than those drawn from stringed instruments ;-)
-
My Gaillardia vibrates when I play it. The others are more "solid" :|glug