Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Michael on February 09, 2013, 03:04:56 PM
-
I've bought a Castagnari Lilly as a nice portable D/G box to learn on but the 'textured' key on the outer row is in position 6 whereas the nobbly button on my G/C box is in position 7.
I'm finding this a little off putting as I swap between instruments and would rather the two were the same.
So...
- Is there a standard (position 6 or 7)?
- To swap the buttons around do they just unscrew?
Many thanks,
Michael
-
I've never had a nobbly button - what's it for? :D
-
To swap the buttons around do they just unscrew?
Yes
-
Cheers Theo...
I do love me nobbly bits...helps us novices find our way around :o
M
-
On a Club system box, the cross-hatched button denotes the Gleichton. On a Lilly the button with the Castagnari crest is just for show!
Rob.
-
I knew that really - just being facetious! Though my Club II doesn't have any (k)nobbly bits.......
Graham
-
I know that! I was reallly just meaning that you can move the button with the crest anywhere you like.
The only thing is, one of my friends lost a button and screwed a new one in. It kept unscrewing - presumably as the wood of the lever was now quite dry and wouldn't flex and grip - so he had to put a drop of superglue into the hole to get it to grip securely.
Rob.
-
I used black pearloid buttons from Charlie marshall to replace the accidental ones , they match the Castagnari white ones perfectly so probably come from the same factory - so if you don`t want one at all with the crest on, his white ones should be a good match . mine screwed in fine without being loose , in fact had to go slowly even unscrewing the old ones as they were tight and didn`t want to crack the wood
-
Blimey, why don't we just have alternative black and white buttons.
Sure way to a wricked or ricked neck and it would be great fun watching all those players leaning over to see whether they were on a black or white button!
-
Blimey, why don't we just have alternative black and white buttons.
It would look too Tex-Mex then . 3 rows would be fun to copy the CBA layout, a great laugh if an accordionist tries to play it and ends up with different notes sounding on the pull ;-)
-
would be fun to copy the CBA layout, a great laugh if an accordionist tries to play it and ends up with different notes sounding on the pull ;-)
Like it!! ;D >:E
-
Hurrah...button moved on the Lilly to position 7.
Now both my G/C and D/G box have the knobbly key in the same position and I've learned to spell. Just got to work on the grammar next :P
M
-
Similar theme but I have a very old Honher Double Ray and I need to remove the treble buttons to enable me to remove the mechanism from the keyboard case. They appear to be push fit onto a flat metal prong, but won't come off with moderate force. Any suggestions?
-
You don't need to remove the buttons to remove the treble mechanism or keyboard on a Double Ray.
-
I made a knobbly one on my pokerwork with judicious application of a Stanley knife, cutting a union jack into the middle G button. It helps me find the right button when playing in the dark! >:E
-
I made a knobbly one on my pokerwork with judicious application of a Stanley knife, cutting a union jack into the middle G button. It helps me find the right button when playing in the dark! >:E
I've got smiley face stickers on two of my pokerwork bass buttons, originally they were put there to help me find the buttons when moving between sets of basses. Now I've just got to like them (:)
-
I'm with Pikey, and not just in the dark.
The textured button helps find your "home" position as you move around the keyboard.
i'm of the feeling that one should "never" look at the keyboard, that you should know where you are by feel.
-
I agree that a look at the keyboard is a bad habit. I don't need to do it in "home" keys, but if I'm on say a blues scale I confess that I look. IMHO that means I don't practice enough :|bl
Don't like textured keys at all, and will tend to replace them. Basically I think one should work towards a relationship with the instrument analogous to the touch typist. Except that the ear replaces seeing the letter appear on sheet/screen.
Mind you, I can't touch type either :D
[edit] playing in the dark is an excellent hand/ear/brain exercise. If you do it under the duvet it annoys less people ;)
-
I don't have any bumpy keys on my melodeons but I agree. I tend not to look at the keyboard. I don't know where I would put a bumpy one if I wanted one because I'm not sure what the home position is on a B/C accordion.
-
do people honestly rely on knobbly buttons for orientation? To be fair Ive never had a knobbly one, apart from on my b/c but never made any difference to me...
-
dont mean that nastily by the way, it could be read condinscendindingly. genuinely wondering because I never learnt with one (:)
-
do people honestly rely on knobbly buttons for orientation? To be fair Ive never had a knobbly one, apart from on my b/c but never made any difference to me...
I don't have a knobbly button on my Lilly because it's too old ('98 AFAIR) so this has never bothered me... well except that our squire has one on his Lilly and it looks cool so I sort of want one now.
The original poster bought his Lilly to learn D/G on so I can understand how it might be annoying to switch between two boxes with a textured button if the textured buttons are in different places.
-
As a new starter I was keen not to develop any bad habits including looking down at the keyboard. As the weeks go by I'm finding my familiarity of the keyboard improving so I can jump from, say, button 2 to 7 pretty consistently without the need for the tactile feel of a knobbly button. However, I still find swapping between a full size box and my Lilly throws off my ability to predict the distance between buttons so the comforting feel of me' knobbler is helping to build confidence :D
M
-
I lied - I did my DIY knobbly button to make a design statement, plus I'd be able to recognise my own pokerwork from others after I'd had a few beers....... >:E
-
Keep on knobbling Michael. Knobble away :D
-
Slight thread drift: Michael, another "bad habit" to not learn is to be sure to use all 4 left fingers on your basses.
It will be hard especially the smaller, lower 2, but it will make a difference later on.
Note: only about 1/3 of the members of the group will probably agree with this.
-
This thread seems to have reached the end if it's useful life.
PM me with an unlock request if you have something relevant to add.