Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: alaskairishbox on February 10, 2013, 08:36:26 PM
-
I am thinking of starting to mess with my keyboard again. I find my old Hohner much more playable than the new one because the new one has very high buttons and requires a lot of travel.
I have already blocked the keyboard in such a way that the buttons don't disappear below the keyboard anymore. Despite not disappearing below the keyboard, the buttons are still so high that a substantial amount of travel is still required to play.
Is there an approved way of accomplishing this. I have included a picture of the old and the new keyboard. Ideally I would like the new keyboard to look and behave like the older version. As far as I can tell the old keyboard came that way and was never modified.
-
Assuming from the pictures that this is an Erica or Pokerwork?
Button height can be reduced either by fitting thicker pallet facings or by "adjusting" the levers.
Such "adjustment" can be achieved by holding each pallet shut while depressing the button to the height you want.
This often twists the arms somewhat, resulting in the buttons not being central in the holes, but is easily corrected by pushing the button below the keyboard and levering it in the appropriate direction.
(Ideally both "adjustments" would be made before the fitting of any restriction to the button travel.)
-
The danger is always that by lowering the button height too much the pallets don't lift enough to give a good clear note - especially if you have blocked the buttons from going down the holes. You can't change the gearing so it lifts the pallet by the same amount without a complete keyboard re-build.
-
As per previous advice, hold the pallet with one hand and put pressure on the button to bend it down with the other. Worked fine on my pokerwork.
Mind you, I didn't put anything under the buttons to stop them travelling too far - I didnt need to, as I never had that problem - I must hit the buttons more from the side than on top with my fingers.
As per Squeezys advice, if you end up with too little available travel, you mught need to take out whatever you put under the buttons, and try a different hand position to stop your fingers disappearing!
:||:
PS I've just watched Squeezy get his bands Folk award on BBC I-Player - nice one!
(:)
-
I did lower the buttons as per the advice above. I got rid of the block that reduces button travel and ended up with something more playable.
I am trying to turn this into a faster keyboard that lets me slide into keys which seems especially common in B/C playing.
Is there a standard height recommendation for Hohner double ray/pokerwork keyboards? Seems like with the sharp edge of the button 3mm above the keyboard is about right, but this impression may simply be a function of my inexperience.
-
I dont think there's a standard. I've just measured mine, which I altered a lot of years ago, and it's about 2mm.
Cheers
Pikey
-
I have an open, stepped keyboard on my melodeon so I think this doesn't apply to me but when you say button height that means the distance that the button sticks out of the hole?
-
There was a mention of 3-4 mm as a correct height in this thread:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,735.msg5875.html#msg5875 (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,735.msg5875.html#msg5875)
-
For B/C Irish playing, I personally would go for 3mm or so - I played with 5mm for a good while and I've switched down to 2.5mm and it's heaven.