Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Steve C. on February 17, 2013, 07:09:24 PM
-
I was listening to Clive's "In a continental mood" (I think played on a Streb).
I have a Lee Oskar in A Harmonic minor which I believe is:
push/pull>>A/B, C/E, E/G#, A/B, C/D, E/F, A/G#, C/B, E/D, A/F
I suppose anything is "possible" but are there any boxes set up to play harmonic minor "only"?
If one were to do this, would harmonic Dm be the 2-row complement to Am? (essentially an AD 2-row box with the accidentals built in)
And if someone were to do this, what would be the complementary basses?
I have read some of the posts, Chris' R in particular, and it sounds like it could be done. It would be a limited box, for sure, but.....
Or is this why Strebs/FR18's were invented?
-
I'm not sure of the exact layout but I think Squeezy has one in Dm/Gm.
-
I'm not sure of the exact layout but I think Squeezy has one in Dm/Gm.
Squeezy's layout is HERE (http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/DminGmin21spiers.gif)
-
Pignol-Milleret layout is basically G, Amharmonic, accs. I'd say that even if the tune was in Am harmonic they still wouldn't play it "on the middle row"
I played a folk box in Finland 2010 that similarly had a G# on its inner row, quite appropriate for the local tunes :|glug
-
I was listening to Clive's "In a continental mood" (I think played on a Streb).
Yes indeed, with the keyboard programmed to Squeezy's harmonic minor layout (as in the keyboard map area). Real harmonic minor boxes do exist; they're mostly old pokerwork boxes which have been retuned slightly by enthusiast owners - to make a Dm/Gm, take a D/G and detune a few reeds by a semitone.
I've not actually played/got a real Dm/Gm, but judging from the impression that the Streb does of one, they're limited in what they can do, but what they do well, they do *very* well. Look for DTN's version of 3 Jolly Sheepskins on youtube - it's just stonking. I find that I can't get anywhere close to playing the minorised versions that these things do on a standard box even if I change the key to suit; the harmonic minor is a very different beast to, say, the dorian minor you might get playing a D/G in Em.
I did consider inventing a melodeon that did both D/G and Dm/Gm (use a stop to blank off and unblank the appropriate reeds to change the scale), but it turns out that many italian makers have been making "major/minor" boxes for years like that. Ah well.
Cheers,
Clive
-
Clive: You are right, DTN's version is terrific. But yours in pretty darn nice.
My Schurr's says "stonking" = devastating?
It there a different/better translation for us, "across the pond"?
-
Clive: You are right, DTN's version is terrific. But yours in pretty darn nice.
My Schurr's says "stonking" = devastating?
It there a different/better translation for us, "across the pond"?
It's generally taken to be in a positive meaning. A 'stonking' box means one which is very, very good. As in 'devastatingly good' i.e. one which would clear away (devastate) all opposition or rivals.
-
I'm concerned that the word "limited" is getting through unchallenged for a harmonic keyboard. Yes, if you tend to find notes along a row and play in its diatonically related scales, you'll have to cross to another row or a helper button for that note.
The more you play "across", the less this is a problem. In that context our G sharp is a useful step towards chromaticity, and one less note needed on accidentals. The same principles apply to gleightons and Dutch inversions. Of course, the devil is in the application of these; the Squeezy, Pignol, Le Tron and Heim layouts all start with a main row change and then "develop" in different directions. :|glug
-
I too have recently been considering alternative tunings. In particular I find myself fixated on the extended possibilities offered through adopting the chromatic harmonica tuning known as C/F bebop (http://www.angelfire.com/music/harmonica/beboplayouts.html) (sometimes C7 bebop). The attached png image gives a rough idea of how this might work on a B/C accordion. There are some good options for making maj, min, maj7 and dim7 chord shapes. There some excellent opportunities for playing in thirds and sixth, something which is severely limited with a standard layout.
-
Thanks Steve, the Schurr's does not do a good job with modern slang (often ironic) usage.
It's like a band around here called "We Totally Destroyed It".
-
IMHO French is much worse. It sometimes seems to me that street usage changes every summer. Stonking as a superlative is probably on the fade here, I hear it but rarely here in the north; this ipad has certainly never come across it. Clive lives in a different isogloss, and (as with the mid Atlantic divide) these things evolve slowly.
Mike ::) interesting! I have very little understanding of half tone play, and would never have thought of that. My stamina is coming back up to the point where I can sit stand a couple of hours at the PC and will be using that to move ME on to its next stage. Both the squeezy layout, and your wacky bebop one will be in the experimental section. "Improve the breed" as they say in Newmarket ;)
-
I too have recently been considering alternative tunings. In particular I find myself fixated on the extended possibilities offered through adopting the chromatic harmonica tuning known as C/F bebop (http://www.angelfire.com/music/harmonica/beboplayouts.html) (sometimes C7 bebop). The attached png image gives a rough idea of how this might work on a B/C accordion. There are some good options for making maj, min, maj7 and dim7 chord shapes. There some excellent opportunities for playing in thirds and sixth, something which is severely limited with a standard layout.
That's very clever.
-
I find myself fixated on the extended possibilities offered through adopting the chromatic harmonica tuning known as C/F bebop (http://www.angelfire.com/music/harmonica/beboplayouts.html) (sometimes C7 bebop).
will be in the next version
<rodec>
→ push↓ → © ºD © ºG
→→→→ →→ © ºB © ºC
→ ºG ¹Bâ™â™ ¹C ¹E ¹G ²Bâ™â™ ²C ²E ²G ³Bâ™â™
ºF♯ ¹A ¹B ¹D♯ ¹F♯ ²A ²B ²D♯ ²F♯ ³A ³B
=
→ pull↓ → © ºA © ºD
→→→→ →→ © ºE © ºC
→ ¹A ¹B ¹D ¹F ²A ²B ²D ²F ³A ³B
ºG♯ ¹A♯ ¹C♯ ¹E ¹G♯ ²A♯ ²C♯ ²E ²G♯ ³A♯ ³C♯
</rodec>
.. once I've fixed a little bug to let it show B♠on push, A♯ on pull ;)
(the concertina people wanted that facility anyway)
What left end chords does it like? Not an issue on mouth organ >:E
-
Back to an instrument made to play in Dm/Gm (harmonic).
I love it and have explored it a lot - it's used on several tracks I've recorded including Bellowhead's Hopkinson's Favourite, Rigs of the Time and Copshawholme Fair. It has a very natural theatrical/fairground sound when played in the home keys - but it also has a very nice "push" key of Bb major which can be brought in to play too.
Ultimately though, it is a less versatile system than a D/G as most other standard keys of play tend to veer towards diminished chords and the such like. But the home keys can provide a comfortable way to play in harmonic and melodic minors with an ease you just don't get from a 2 or 2.5 row D/G and it's a fun addition to the arsenal!
Cheers
Squeezy
-
Did the rodec for this last night. For the present anyone wanting to explore should paste it into Melodeon Explorer (http://squeezebox.chrisryall.net/)s edit box. Next proper release will have "double harmonic minor" as an experimental preset, along with Mike's C/F bebop and a few other exotica.
<rodec>
→ push↓ → © ºD © ºG
→→ →→ →→ © ºB♠© ºC
→ ¹B♠¹D ¹G ²B♠²D ²G ³B♠³D ³G *B
ºG ¹A ¹D ¹F ²A ²D ²F ³A ³D ³F *A
=
→ pull↓ → © ºA © ºD
→→ →→ →→ © ºF © ºC
→ ºC ºF♯ ¹A ¹C ¹E♠¹F♯ ²A ²C ²E♠²F♯
¹B♠¹C♯ ¹E ¹G ²B♠²C♯ ²E ²G ³B♠³C♯ ³E
</rodec>
Source is Lester's layout diagram here. The voicing is as ever my best guess, subject to correction please (NB, ME's octaves begin at "A").
Also, is that final B natural on the push actually correct?