As one of my great melodeon playing heroes, Harpo Marx*, once said: "You know what bored people become? Boring."
A class act is someone who can play a tune, as per Martin's comment, unsophisticated, hackneyed etc and really make you take notice.
There is a close parallel in morris, to dance a simple dance exceedingly well, and then you realise it's worth.
Where as session takes a tune, and lets it develop according the chemistry of the musicians in the room, the result can be glorious, and there has been a general "Amen" here several times when it is pointed out that the simpler tunes allow most scope for development in the melange.Sure In a session (usually) most anythings goes and you can play "it's the final count down" like a waltz or the Drowsy Maggie Psychobilly style, as long as you are having fun and are not making the pub owner throw you out. But that way of treating a piece of music isn't always possible, and when it comes to simpler tunes by all means throw them my way and lets have fun >:E
So "boring tunes" .. Not really. Boring approach ..
I've now taken the approach that if I don't like it I won't learn it. I've discovered there are tons more tunes in the world. Can't ever see myself in a band, cos I'd just say 'no don't like that one'!That's an approach I would very much like go by, (and do whenever I can), but as I very much prefer to play in groups and don't really play in sessions that often any longer, you do have to compromise to a certain degree, and sometimes play music that's not always your first choice, and as you write Mr Q it's much easier to learn a favourite than someting you find less interesting. And right now I got several tunes I find less interesting to learn, but as Lester wrote
Well, maybe not ;)
hey ho we all have our quirks. Just that I seem to have been first in line in the quirks queue........ :D
Q
So all tunes can be boring, even great ones, unless you make something of them. This can be a struggle with some tunes but is probably not impossible all you need to do is find the hidden interest.And I know some say there aren't any, but OF COURSE there are BORING tunes, and sure some tunes will grow on you and maybe become a favourite of yours, while others will wander straight to the back of you head to be stored and maybe forgotten, but if your lucky they will come back out front smelling like tasty old cheese in need of a good bottel of wine and a melodeon of course!
but OF COURSE there are BORING tunes
I find myself heartily agreeing with Lester.
Some of my favourite tunes are those which might be considered by some as unchallenging, unsophisticated, standards and, dare I say, hackneyed. If you approach a tune with the idea that it's boring then you are anticipating the outcome. A self-fulfilling prophecy.
As one of my great melodeon playing heroes, Harpo Marx*, once said: "You know what bored people become? Boring."
Martin
*I lied about him playing melodeon, he is a hero though.
For me burying or hardly playing a tune so as to give priority to bass and treble harmony sounds very boring and at the opposite end of the spectrum nice Irish jigs and reels played at '' shit off a shovel'' speed are also boring.
BUT -- that doesn't mean that there is anything wrong with them -its just that they don't apeal to me!
Around 70% of the songs are based around a single chord, i.e. if I'm wearing my Bb box the chord is F, for the A/D box the chord is E and for the C box the chord is G.
ain't what you do, it's the way that you do it.
| My old Uni friend Peter was a NYO standard transverse flute player and I showed him the stuff Gheorghe Zamfir played (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Wv3Ya9nskA) on the Romanian Nai. He loved it, but "can't be done"! More saliently to this group the neighbour to his flat on Edinburgh's Morning-side was Cathal Mc Connell; Irish stuff used to drift through the wall occasionally. "That can't be done either"! I should add that he's absolutely brilliant in his own genre. | (http://i1.ytimg.com/vi/dJByeRX004M/default.jpg) (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Wv3Ya9nskA) |
Totally agree George. That's what I'm discovering - giving it lots of welly and playing with conviction really lifts these tunes. And I did see Jimmy Shand in Oxford in 1969 (when I was just a lad you understand), not to mention the White Heather Club with Andy Stewart and all that, so I do have the subconscious grounding in all this!
When playing for North Wst Morris there is a lot to be said for playing simple tunes that the public can identify with and plahying them with great rhythm so that the public want to stay and watch for longer as they are tapping their feet and enjoying themselves--- and the longer they stay the more brass goes inthe tin!
I used to regulary play cock of the north, 100 pipers, lilly the pink, puttin on the style, blaydon races, loch lomond, scotland teh brave,
nelly the elephant etc etc and when dancing out around Christmas time tunes like good king wencelas, jingle bells, etc etc could be substituted.
The absolute master of playing simple tunes brilliantly was the late Sir Jimmy Shand .
<snip>I'm quite surprised and find it a little amusing that it seems to be such a (no! no!) among some of you folks to admit that you find some tunes to be uninteresting or darn plain boring compared to others. Sorry can't help it ;D: But have some of you folks no personal taste/preference when it comes to tunes? Do you just always love what ever tune you stumble on equally much? and do you really never find yourself in the position of being compelled to play a tune that makes you think "why?"?</snip>
Well, I guess that many of you have been in the situation where you've obligated yourself to play some piece of music that you felt uninspiring och just plain boring! I've done that before, the worst time I was saying yes to a theater project where the music was turning out to be real zzzZzzzzZZzmusic. But normally performing this "boring" music is no problem getting inspiration from the audience, dancers, fellow musicians and makes it fun and worthwhile in the end, but the way there... :P Some how it seems like it have become more and more difficult for me to motivate myself for learning "boring tunes" over the years.
So simply! Do any of you have any brilliant tip, (not involving alcohol) ::), to make the process of learning the music more inspiring and maybe even getting the music to stick faster!?
People seem to have been answering a question that wasn't asked, or rather, addressing a side issue to your question that they find more interesting. Maybe it was more interesting because your post was actually more of a grumble than an easily answerable question ;)
Other Latin American rythms, such as Bossa Nova and Rumba, are great fun and really make your toes tap :D
Easy fix for boring tunes - try and play them in a different musical style.
Reggae is good, and lots of fun and makes you smile. 8) Tango makes you think, but can get a bit depressing . :( Other Latin American rythms, such as Bossa Nova and Rumba, are great fun and really make your toes tap :D nPlus the added benefit that the purists hate anything like this. Try it and make your tunes less boring!! >:E
ain't what you do, it's the way that you do it.
Wot he said.
Easy fix for boring tunes - try and play them in a different musical style.
Reggae is good, and lots of fun and makes you smile. 8) Tango makes you think, but can get a bit depressing . :( Other Latin American rythms, such as Bossa Nova and Rumba, are great fun and really make your toes tap :D nPlus the added benefit that the purists hate anything like this. Try it and make your tunes less boring!! >:E
Certainly peps up the old bones of the tune, to say nothing of those of the dancers! I take it that this is how you play for for your Morris side, up there in cosmopolitan York? >:E
Of course ! We also use mixed modes duch as mix a me toasties