Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Quebecois on December 26, 2008, 10:28:37 PM
-
Can someone tell me if these reeds (http://cgi.ebay.ca/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=170282404377) are worth the money?
I would use them to restore a little 1-row and give it a new life.
Thanks.
-
I used to play a Harmona/Weltmeister one row in D (made in the late 90's) before I got my Baldoni.
I found the reeds to be very good - they had a lot of toot, and though I played it very very rough I never found any problems with them. They kept in tune throughout the level of volume.
The only thing that I found was that they had a somewhat "harder" sound than similar italian reeds. Great sound for Quebecois, but nothing like the sound of a Hohner 114 or a Messervier.
At that price I have myself been temptet, but alas, the fincial issues...
-
Hi Québécois
Can't comment on those reeds but I have bought from Charlie Marshall on this site under Repairers etc. and his pricing was rather more competitive. Depends on P&P for you I suppose. Calls himself CGM, got a web site and supplies Castagnoni reeds. I have always found it best to telephone him and get his recommendations, he's very helpful and knowledgable.. He often has items on Ebay.
Hope this helps.
-
Hi
I do not know if I am right, but to my knowledge Harmona use Harmonikas reeds from Czech.
http://www.harmonikas.cz/en/home.html
Correct me if I am wrong.
I've tried in Harmonikas reeds and they have been quite OK.
Aaro
-
Hi Québécois
Can't comment on those reeds but I have bought from Charlie Marshall on this site under Repairers etc. and his pricing was rather more competitive. Depends on P&P for you I suppose. Calls himself CGM, got a web site and supplies Castagnoni reeds. I have always found it best to telephone him and get his recommendations, he's very helpful and knowledgable.. He often has items on Ebay.
Hope this helps.
I contacted them and they have indeed very good deals on Cagnoni reeds, with very reasonable postage fees.
Thanks for the tip :)
-
Hi
I do not know if I am right, but to my knowledge Harmona use Harmonikas reeds from Czech.
http://www.harmonikas.cz/en/home.html
Correct me if I am wrong.
I've tried in Harmonikas reeds and they have been quite OK.
Aaro
Hi Aaro
Have you tried any of their top-end "a mano" reeds which use spark erosion to cut the holes and have very fine clearance between reed and frame ?
Do you know how much these cost compared to "tipo a mano" reeds (and the Italian suppliers) ?
Cheers
Ian
-
Hi Aaro
Have you tried any of their top-end "a mano" reeds which use spark erosion to cut the holes and have very fine clearance between reed and frame ?
Do you know how much these cost compared to "tipo a mano" reeds (and the Italian suppliers) ?
Cheers
Ian
Hi Ian
I do not have the experience of Harmonikas A Mano reeds.
I am test only mechanica and export dural qualities reeds.
I do not know their cost tipo a mano or a mano reeds, but I think that they are close to the same as the Italian suplier.
Aaro