Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: pgroff on May 18, 2013, 06:15:22 PM
-
Hi all,
Over the years I've seen some lovely Paolo Sopranis in G/C, built in similar body and trim styles to some of the PS models that have become very popular for Irish traditional music. When found in 4-voice LMMM voicing, these G/C boxes often have one switch or two couplers, stepped keyboards, 21 melody keys and 12 basses. The early ones have naked aluminum grilles in various styles and later ones have celluloid covered grilles. Red seems to be the common color (even when these boxes are constructed and styled like the "old grey" Paolos). I've come across examples with extremely original reedwork allowing the original tuning to be determined, which seems in my examples to be A 443, very wet, and very unequal-tempered (both the chords and the melody scales). This tuning system, together with the low notes rather than accidentals on the melody side, suggests these boxes were designed for playing sweet harmonies in traditional diatonic or modal music, and in a few related keys -- rather than chromatic tunes or modulation to many keys.
See pics below for a couple examples, one probably from the 1940s (similar in style to the "old grey" boxes) and one probably from the 1950s (an uncommon style with grille similar to the B/C that Bobby Gardiner once played). We've discussed these and/or similar boxes before on this forum.*
Stepped-board Paolos like these often get converted to flat-keyboard, semitone-tuned boxes for playing Irish music, and the results can sound superb for that application. That's the first idea that comes to my mind when I see one, and the (1940s?) box shown below on the left, originally with a stepped keyboard just like the original one at right, has been converted to a flat keyboard and appropriate buttons, and re-reeded first to a C#/D, more recently to a D/C#.
But before converting the (1950s?) box on the right, which amazes me in its originality and sound (almost unplayed, but playable with the original PS-stamped valves), I'm wondering if anyone here would prefer to play it in its striking and beautiful original tuning and with the original stepped board? And if so what would be its best musical use as an original box -- Portugese or Italian traditional music, or maybe songs with those wonderful just-tuned harmonies? If someone wants it just as it is, I might be open to very interesting trades.
PG
*
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7735
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,3344
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,2387
-
sweet boxes!
-
Lovely Real Paolos (not Baffetti or Serenellini) and QUINT TUNED too !! .. as for Value in the USA, funny really Paul because you`d be the first one I`d ask if I needed to value a classic box over there :-\
-
Hi Adam,
Thanks! I guess I meant: what's the best value in musical terms for boxes like these in original condition; who would value them the most in their original state of playability and sonority, and how best could that original condition be used to musical advantage?
I have a couple of ideas for ways that I would like to modify the 1950s box I pictured, for my own musical use. But before altering it, I'm wondering how it might have musical value to someone else as an original example that plays and sounds much as it was made. It's a high quality musical instrument with very distinctive and careful designed features, especially its tuning, and I suspect there are players who might really value that originality and use those features in some kinds of traditional music.
Those players I'm trying to reach may not be melnet members . . . but on the other hand there are some players here with very interesting and broad tastes in music.
The general question I posed comes up often on www.banjohangout.org, since over the years many vintage Gibson tenor banjos have been converted in various ways (more often these days, reversibly) to five string banjos that are more desirable to bluegrass players. There's a wide range of opinions among the members there about different approaches to such conversions.
I also spent a couple of years trying to raise consciousness about the idea of originality in concertina reedwork. When I first learned about concertinas in the 1980s, and right up to the present, many fine concertinas were being subjected to an automatic repitching and retuning to equal temperament immediately on discovery, and before offered to players. Many players and even restorers did not know (and some still don't) that there are particular, designed reasons that fine original concertinas -- even if found in 100% original tuning -- wouldn't read as "in tune" on a meter set for equal temperament.* Hundreds if not thousands of the best anglo concertinas have had their historical tuning information, which really affects their original sound dramatically, casually discarded. Sure, a Jeffries anglo can sound very well and be very useful for many modern purposes when "done up" and retuned to A 440 ET, but many players are blown away to hear how different an original-tuning Jeffries sounds.
So I thought it might be interesting to raise the issue in the case of these Paolos. I can pull out the factory-original-condition G/C reeds and save them for re-installation, which will preserve the original tuning pretty well. Even the keyboard modifications (replacing keyboard plate, re-surfacing the black button stems and substituting replacement buttons) can be reversed. But right now it's really "original" rather than "restored to original specifications." I'm wondering who if anyone might value that.
PG
* Re: valuing originality in concertina tunings, here's an example of one discussion thread on cnet from my missionary days:
http://www.concertina.net/forums/index.php?showtopic=477
At this point I had been trying to convince well-known members of that forum, including Jim Lucas (an old friend) that the note layout of Wheatstone's english concertina keyboard was designed for meantone temperament. That observation was not original to me, of course, it's in all the old literature, mentioned by Jeremy Montague and later Wayne, Atlas, etc. But this points out that the "restoration" and alteration of concertinas was going on full force in isolation from an understanding of the original tunings and their musical use. And wider understanding of the anglo concertina tunings (which are much more complex and less documented) lags even further behind, all the while as I hear of more and more new "restorers" itching to quickly repitch and flip each new Jeffries they uncover.
-
This is extremely interesting! I don't have a lot to add, though I'd love to try those Paolo's. I can "hear" that sound in a lot of the French music that dates back a number of decades (though you can still hear it in groups led by Michele Esbelin, e.g., Les Costauds de la Lune ... although, in those groups its a CBA).
-
Yup, interesting info regarding concertina tuning Paul, thanks .... Is there any way you can get hold of spare reedblocks so you can keep the G/C ones intact ? . I`m sure there would be plenty of European / Latin American interest in these as G/C is the lower part of G/C/F (popular in Bavaria, Tirol, Austria, Slovenia etc and South America - all who like MMM too) . I`d love one as would many others over here, I couldn`t afford a UK based one let alone one shipped from the USA .
-
As with other posters, my involvement with classic Paolo's is limited to casual lusting. In this instance I am particularly fascinated by the possibilities of the extended basses. A 12 bass four voice vintage Paolo in D/D# has to be pretty damn close to my dream box.
That said, i would be interested to know the precise details of the reeds on these two. By how much is each bank of reeds offset, and what is the relationship between intervals (thirds, fifths, etc.). There is much to be gained from documentation.
-
On a separated, but not entirely unrelated point, I cannot help but be fascinated by the seeming limitless variety of tunings in which these classic boxes were produced. I note this recent ebay posting of a similar A/Bb instrument:
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/181143047293?ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1438.l2649
This would suggest that G/G# is another possibility. What documentation is there of the layouts? Were 16/18 bass instruments made?
-
Hi Mike,
The more basses you add, the heavier they get though! But the chords on these aren't bad.
Ted McGraw has catalogues listing some Paolo Soprani models marketed to Ireland. I think by the mid-1950s the keys included B/C, C/C#, C#/D, D/D#, and G/G#. I don't think A/Bb was listed so possibly the box for sale in the link you posted may have been re-reeded.
Both the 4 voice boxes in my pic above were originally in G/C and I have seen others also. The earlier one is now (reversibly) re-reeded to D/C# with the original reeds preserved and kept at hand, with the original keyboard plate and treble buttons.
You can also find 2 and 3 voice stepped-keyboard PS boxes with similar body styles in G/C and F/Bb among other keys.
Re: the cost, the models described in the thread title sometimes sell unrestored for very modest prices. Even sometimes you can find them in overhauled condition for much less than it would cost to make one today. Maybe because the stepped keyboard scares off some bidders? See the thread linked above where reelkidmusic got one of the 1940s (?) type -- admittedly needing repair -- for a few hundred dollars + shipping. In fact, you might easily pay more than the purchase price fettling an unrestored one, even a nice example, because of all the parts in these -- then it would cost more again to re-reed one and to convert the keyboard if desired. The Button Box listed one of the later examples, with celluloid-covered grille, for sale for months if not years recently at US $1200 or so. That one seemed to be in the original keys (except maybe a chord or two changed) and with original keyboard and buttons, but presumably ready to play. I don't have a link to theirs, but see below three borrowed pics from an ebay auction of a celluloid-grille GC Paolo 12 bass with stepped keyboard. Sorry for the poor cropping (not my pics). In the chronology, the one shown below might possibly be the next in the series after the two examples that I illustrated above.
PG
-
Wow Paul, that`s MINT - the paint is still on the bass plate even !
-
Wow Paul, that`s MINT - the paint is still on the bass plate even !
Hi Adam,
Yes, if you mean the last 3 pics I posted of the celluloid-grille box, it looks in very nice shape. Sometimes these show up in North America in nearly unplayed condition (though only rarely with reeds, wax and leathers in perfect condition as with the 1950s box in my first post above). A good friend of mine won the ebay auction for that celluloid-grille box a couple of years back and IMO it was a good buy. I believe that one may be in the hands of an excellent box tech for conversion to a B/C. But as I mentioned, a very similar one, near stock in G/C, was available for sale for a long time at the Button Box.
PG
-
I`ve never seen one over here in such good shape , well worth spending the money on . I`m a Quint player but can appreciate why someone would want to B/C it . shame that Paolo & Baffetti weren`t up for putting even Mini Stadella in these boxes (even now)
-
. . . shame that Paolo & Baffetti weren`t up for putting even Mini Stadella in these boxes (even now)
Hi Adam,
Well there's always the chance that the bass end of something like the one in this auction would match up -- although-Paolo Soprani-badged accordions came in a lot of sizes over the years. The two in my original post are not the same size!
http://www.ebay.com/itm/VINTAGE-PAOLO-SOPRANI-ITALIAN-ACCORDION-GREAT-CONDITION-/181103926096
PG
-
Out of interest Paul, do you know were there semitone boxes made in red with the curved metal grill in either the 1940s or 50s? I think I've seen just one but its curved grill was celluloid. I wonder if I came across one would I be able to get a sneaky red grey...if you get me.
That said, my black Paolo's the nicest instrument in the world. I'd never cheat on it.
-
Out of interest Paul, do you know were there semitone boxes made in red with the curved metal grill in either the 1940s or 50s? I think I've seen just one but its curved grill was celluloid. I wonder if I came across one would I be able to get a sneaky red grey...if you get me.
That said, my black Paolo's the nicest instrument in the world. I'd never cheat on it.
Hi Luke,
Great question!
If I understand it correctly, I think -- based on fallible memory -- the answer is "yes but rare."
First, am I right that you mean Paolo Sopranis? (So we'll leave out, for example, red Busilacchio etc boxes in C/C# etc with a metal grille, even though those and other labels can show up on boxes that look much like Paolos).
I've seen a few different kinds of red Paolo Sopranis with a "pepperpot" grille including the one Ray recently had for sale, also D/C# boxes, etc. You've seen 'em too, so shall we exclude those?
I think you're looking for Paolos that have these features as factory original:
1) the 1940s or 1950s rounded body styles with naked aluminum curved grille (of some pattern but not pepperpot), not celluloid covered grille
2) red celluloid on the body
3) semitone tuned, e.g. B/C, C/C#, D/D# -- but let's leave out the D/C# Paolos?
4) (presumably with flat keyboard, 23 melody buttons, 8 basses, 3 or 4 voices, wooden soundboard etc)
5) (we're trying to exclude examples such as John Tabb's red Paolo that has had a naked metal grille made to replace the original celluloid-covered one, or examples where the red celluloid has been stripped from the metal grille, or examples converted from quint tuning or from stepped keyboard)
I *think* I remember seeing a couple over the years that fit your criteria. You might be much more likely to see them than I, since I haven't been over to Ireland in decades and most ought to be there, and Great Britain. And the Paolo experts over there (and on this forum) can answer you better than I: Lars, Ray, triskel? Not to mention all the pros who don't seem to join the discussions here. Best to phone them up! Maybe if I stick my neck out, one of these guys will correct me, which is how I often learn something here.
But since you asked me, if my memory is right, the one example I can pinpoint belonged to Kevin McGillian* of Philadelphia and Co. Tyrone when I met him years ago. Kevin, his wife Mary, and son John all play the box and very well too. The parents contributed to a project that Ed Reavy Jr and I put together, to document the styles of 1-row box playing among the older Irish players in Philadelphia. For that video, Kevin played a Clement Breton melodeon loaned to him by my student Joe McEachern. But Kevin's own box was a 2-coupler 4 voice red "grey" Paolo with the classic aluminum grille and red-celluloid-covered keyboard. Now I'm thinking whether that grille might be a replacement, but I don't think so . . . this was decades ago and unfortunately I'm not finding a photo of Kevin with that Paolo on the web today. I do remember Kevin told me that the accordion came over on the same boat (but a different trip) that brought Kevin to America . . . and that in the 1990s it was playing better than when it was new!
Other "almost a grey Paolo" boxes in red that *don't* match all of your criteria include the ones we discussed above in this thread, and some 2 or 3 voice Paolos with stepped keyboards, and some of the Irish-American D/C# Paolos . . .
. . . and unusual Paolos like the two shown below are more examples of red boxes that don't fit your criteria but come close. The pearl-button box was listed for sale, but I haven't seen it and don't know who bought it. Probably A/D, G/C etc. The early Paolo club has a wooden soundboard, a bar air lever, a coupler lever behind the keyboard, and in many other features is almost identical to the Sonny Brogan / Paddy O'Brien (Offaly) "old grey" B/C box -- except in being a Bb/Eb LMM club. I think of this club (and the Brogan box) as early even though the grille of each is celluloid-covered and has square corners in front, which is usually considered a late feature.
As you can see, I like your idea of searching out the "almost a grey PS" boxes -- they can have a great sound, can be re-reeded to a semitone system (or not), and why not play something a little different.
*
http://irishphiladelphia.com/2010/09/philadelphia-ceili-group-festival-ends-on-a-high-note/kevin/
http://midatlanticcce.wordpress.com/hall-of-fame/kevin-mcgillian/
-
Hi Paul,
Thanks for all the information, you're a goldmine. You've pretty much got what I was after described there. My motivation for finding an "almost grey" is that it'd be way cheaper than a grey and hopefully be roughly the same box. That said, I'm not buying anything for a while after the two Paolos I got relatively recently. One is a red repainted black with an aftermarket metal grill (no round corners) and it sounds pretty damn close to a grey (it's very, very special), the other's a nice red but is no where near as special, but still a great box. It makes me wonder about all the variations there might have been in reeds that were used etc., especially since these boxes were made on such a large scale. Did one of mine coincidentally get reeds that were like those in the prized greys? Or was it just a good day at the factory? It'd be great if an online Paolo Soprani library was put together...cough
I can't find the photo of a round-cornered semitone red I saw, but I wonder whether it's construction would be roughly grey or red. If you get me.
Going back to your box, it'd be great if someone would be interested in it for it's original setup, it looks really nice. Also, I love the idea of a more just-tempered instrument; equal temperament can be a bit grating. I'm not sure how I feel about changing the reeds in old Paolos as well. I hope someone'll express an interest in it.
Luke
-
Going back to your box, it'd be great if someone would be interested in it for it's original setup, it looks really nice. Also, I love the idea of a more just-tempered instrument; equal temperament can be a bit grating. I'm not sure how I feel about changing the reeds in old Paolos as well. I hope someone'll express an interest in it.
Luke
Thanks Luke! That was my thought in posting this topic -- a discussion of how these boxes can be used without modding them, and fair opportunity for the 1950s box to find appreciation as an original instrument. If I keep it, I will likely modify it to give more notes and maybe the keyboard too, just because it sounds so nice and I know I would use it more if re-reeded at least (with Paolo reeds, maybe to B/C, C/B, G/F#, or ?). But in the meantime, I'm actually loving playing the 1950s box just as it is. Just tuning (not a temperament really) is a great sound, that I use (with related tunings) on concertinas. On the 1950s box, any 1-row-melodeon setting works on either C or G row taken singly (but with some awesome chord backup choices). With a little crossing rows the inflected Irish tunes in G that were traditional on 2-row concertinas (with F natural and F sharp) are available too, though concertina has the G row higher rather than lower in pitch. Airs and waltzes are great if they don't need more sharps.
Back on topic, here's *one* kind of traditional music for which I suspect these big quint-tuned Paolos were intended. The Portugese call these instruments "concertinas;" am I right that this one is MMM in F/Bb?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3GXKS3Dd3vk&feature=youtu.be
This fellow teaches too, and from his materials it seems he may have both 2 -row 8 bass, and 3 -row 12 bass versions of these classic Paolos, with stepped boards and mushroom keys. You'd need this non-ET tuning to get that wet harmony sound.
http://www.action-musica.ca/concertina.htm
(great video clip on the above page, incidentally demonstrating the sound of his 2 -row which looks MMM).
http://toronto.kijiji.ca/c-buy-and-sell-musical-instruments-other-Partituras-Folclore-Aprenda-a-Concertina-W0QQAdIdZ266409483
PG
-
I've thought about getting a D melodeon tuned to just intervals, from what you say it sounds like it might be a winner. From what I understand of unequal temperaments there'd be a variety of choices; if I recall correctly, different highland bagpipes are tuned to different just ratios. I find temperament etc fascinating; unfortunately, after a sleepless night reading about the topic, most music sounds out of tune to me now!
That Portugese music is interesting, are Paolos the standard box for that music generally I wonder? The way many consider them to be for Irish.
Sorry to bend your ear about the red grey thing again, but, do you know is there a way to visually tell if old Paolo reeds are likely to be from a red (like a blue or red badge) or an older grey? I'm still about puzzled about my black Paolo; it's definitely a red painted black but it sounds pretty special, and it was sold to the man I bought it from as a grey. That could have been a plain old fib but there's been a good bit of tinkering on it and you're re-reeding with paolo reeds talk got me thinking...
Thanks, it's aways interesting to read your replies.
Luke.
-
I've thought about getting a D melodeon tuned to just intervals, from what you say it sounds like it might be a winner. From what I understand of unequal temperaments there'd be a variety of choices; if I recall correctly, different highland bagpipes are tuned to different just ratios. I find temperament etc fascinating; unfortunately, after a sleepless night reading about the topic, most music sounds out of tune to me now!
That Portugese music is interesting, are Paolos the standard box for that music generally I wonder? The way many consider them to be for Irish.
Sorry to bend your ear about the red grey thing again, but, do you know is there a way to visually tell if old Paolo reeds are likely to be from a red (like a blue or red badge) or an older grey? I'm still about puzzled about my black Paolo; it's definitely a red painted black but it sounds pretty special, and it was sold to the man I bought it from as a grey. That could have been a plain old fib but there's been a good bit of tinkering on it and you're re-reeding with paolo reeds talk got me thinking...
Thanks, it's aways interesting to read your replies.
Luke.
Hi Luke,
I'm not much of an accordion tech so not the best authority on Paolo reeds. But I have examples of some different types through the years here. I have a feeling that the early reeds in great Paolos lack "hammer marks" on the rivets and had a short scale. The 1940s (?) 12 bass box in my original post actually had mostly zinc-plate reeds on the bass side too, I guess they might have been chosen for their tone quality or possibly were leftover (prewar?) inventory. Good topic for another thread.
Just intonation for Irish music, another good topic for another thread. Works for the pipers (more or less)! "Cajun tuning" includes some approximately just intervals so might be a good starting point if you are trying some 1-row boxes.
Re: the brands of boxes in Portugese music. I don't know much about it, but have some records (one a gift from a Portugese-American ex). Some of the button accordions are Hohners, 1-row and more (again called "concertinas"). And as I mentioned in the earlier thread linked above, I have records of Portugese folkloric musical groups featuring several red 1960s Paolos: 2 coupler, 2 row (21 key), 12 bass like the box in the three pics I posted from an ebay sale.
Here's a guy offering Pedrosinis for the Portugese (-American) market:
http://www.pedrosiniusa.com/
PG
-
Here's a red paolo with curved grille for reference. It was originally G/C, LMM pitched quite high, with high 4ths and low 3rds, if my memory serves me well. It's now D/D# MMM, and fitted with old paolo reeds.
It's the second of this model I've had, and both have been extremely nice. Much brighter tone than a 'common' red paolo, and when played with no grille, it sounds better than my pepperpot (that also has old Paolo reeds) IMO. It has a metal bass plate, wooden soundboard and big bass buttons, like a red paolo. Another detail is the pink bellow cloth, which I've not seen on other models.
Edit: picure won't upload from ipad, I'll try to get it on later.
As for reeds, there's a quick trick that's not very accurate, but is a point towards the source of reeds.
Most of the old paolos, 40's, had quite thick plates for the low bass reed. When the reds came along, the plate was thinner. The heavy, thick bass reed plate was also used in some of the paolos made for busilacchio, some of the grey-reds (silver coloured 'reds' such as the 5 coupler that was recently on ebay), and some pepperpots.
Now, this is NOT a direction towards what reeds were better. In my opinion it's more important how much the reeds have played. More playing = sweeter sound. I have reeds from these 'thick bass reed' boxes in two of my paolos, and they are radically different in tone, despite being otherwise identical, both old D/D# sets.
-
Thanks lads!
-
I'm wondering if anyone here would prefer to play it in its striking and beautiful original tuning and with the original stepped board? And if so what would be its best musical use as an original box -- Portugese or Italian traditional music, or maybe songs with those wonderful just-tuned harmonies? If someone wants it just as it is, I might be open to very interesting trades.
Am I alone in thinking with the musette tuning that this would be a great box for French tunes? Is there any way we could hear what it sounds like? It sounds like a fun box to have and though a relative beginner, I think I prefer low notes to accidentals, and it seems there are not many MMML melodeons tuned nice and wet. It seems with all the melodeons out there already tuned dry and to the other specifications you mention that it might be a shame to mess with it. Of course I am new to this, and this is only my inexperienced opinion.
-
The LMMM wet ones tend to be older (1980s and before) and usually Chromatic such as C/C# and B/C Primatonas, Gaelic IVs etc .
Unfortunately even most of the 2 row Italian 4V boxes available here are Chromatic too, I lucked out and landed what now called the Baffetti Irish-1 in Native D/G build (not a re-reed) and its nice and wet and a fantastic box to play as it`s only a bit bigger than a corso and not heavy - there are a few Paolo Sopranis kicking about from the 80s in D/G (so likely A/D and G/C too) but beware the 9 coupler ones, whereas the outer row sounds wonderful and lively, the inner row sounds like a Piano accordion with socks stuffed under the grille - the 2 coupler baffettis are far better and the row difference is about the same as a Hohner Primatona.
Easy options easy to get in LMMM are the Hohner Club Boxes - the Ouverture-IV being the cheapest but a large proportion of them are in C/F/Acc and a few rarities turn up in Bb/Eb/Acc - 5 Voice (LMMMH) Ouverture-5s and the expensive (but absolute best) Club Morino are also mainly C/F/Acc. playing English folk stuff on them is like wrestling an angry Hippopotamus , never tried french stuff.
EDIT - You could always lose the L reed and get a Corso , Corona-III or Vallenato, they`re nice and wet
-
I'm wondering if anyone here would prefer to play it in its striking and beautiful original tuning and with the original stepped board? And if so what would be its best musical use as an original box -- Portugese or Italian traditional music, or maybe songs with those wonderful just-tuned harmonies? If someone wants it just as it is, I might be open to very interesting trades.
Am I alone in thinking with the musette tuning that this would be a great box for French tunes? Is there any way we could hear what it sounds like? It sounds like a fun box to have and though a relative beginner, I think I prefer low notes to accidentals, and it seems there are not many MMML melodeons tuned nice and wet. It seems with all the melodeons out there already tuned dry and to the other specifications you mention that it might be a shame to mess with it. Of course I am new to this, and this is only my inexperienced opinion.
Hi Grape Ape,
I don't know much about French traditional music but I know some good players in that style so will ask around. It seems that a lot of tunes and styles depend on more than 8 notes in the scale, although I bet there are some older tunes too with more limited scales.
This G/C without accidentals of course has the notes C, D, E, F, F#, G, A, B available on the melody side (with slight pitch variations in the duplicates of some of those). But those eight notes are really sweet! I myself enjoy playing 1 row box and 2 row concertina, so a constrained repertoire of notes available on a good instrument doesn't bother me, but I understand it does bother others. Years of playing piano with 88 keys and 12 notes to each octave taught me that often quality in music has to do with the notes you don't play, and cured me of the anxiety many box players have about the notes that might be missing from their button layout.
I agree with your penultimate sentence and am leaning toward keeping this box original in keyboard, pitch and tuning. But its sound and the way it handles overall are on a level with some superb and very valuable Irish-style Paolos . . . so converting it to a semitone system and a flat keyboard to facilitate that style of playing is very tempting also.
Adam,
Thanks as always for your comments too! Do you have a shop somewhere -- like me you seem to have some experience trying to help customers find a good box to match their needs?
PG
-
[Adam,
Thanks as always for your comments too! Do you have a shop somewhere -- like me you seem to have some experience trying to help customers find a good box to match their needs?
I don`t have a shop Paul but I researched & listened to melodeons for years before I actually started playing from Festivals, through archives, internet and opinions / info on this forum and its predecessor (as well as sites like Reyes etc). I get things wrong (we`re only as good as our information) but there`s always someone here to fill in the Gaps.
I wish I`d started playing a lot longer ago but have in the short time I have, thanks to this forum mainly learned a lot about fixing up boxes so have been able to try an awful lot in a short space of time .. I`m sure you`ve forgotten more than I know Paul, you and other experienced Boxoholics (all with specialist areas) are the most valuable resource Melnet has and it`s also excellent to have seasoned fettlers like Theo willing to impart advice .
-
Easy options easy to get in LMMM are the Hohner Club Boxes - the Ouverture-IV being the cheapest but a large proportion of them are in C/F/Acc and a few rarities turn up in Bb/Eb/Acc - 5 Voice (LMMMH) Ouverture-5s and the expensive (but absolute best) Club Morino are also mainly C/F/Acc. playing English folk stuff on them is like wrestling an angry Hippopotamus , never tried french stuff.
EDIT - You could always lose the L reed and get a Corso , Corona-III or Vallenato, they`re nice and wet
Adam it is without irony that I thank you for the useful information. Unfortunately I cannot say the same when I "thank" you for introducing me to the Club Morino. I spent last night watching multiple videos of them being played, and then watching them again, and now "thanks" to you, I must have one. As I just purchased a Lilly, already have a Galaad, and am lusting after a Serafini, this is not going to sit well with my wife. It doesn't help that just a year and a half ago I had never even held a melodeon, until I bought a now traded in Panther. I know, I know, I am clearly sick, and MAD has passed from the bloodstream and into my bones. That said, know anyone looking to unload one in GC or CF?
-
LOL Grape - The Club Morino is awesome , try to play Morris stuff on it and it`s a handful but for a lot of other stuff it`s one sweet and flexible box which sounds Glorious and thanks to the Design efforts of Mr Morino & Our Jimmy Shand, the Rows all sound Identical (none of the severe Row difference nonsense which afflics other boxes inc some Hohners to a degree) .......
I really wish the inner row was a proper Bb Row instead of weird noises (better known as accidentals) as I tend to play Melodeon stuff on Melodeons and don`t expect to play Grieg, Stravinsky or Chopin on the thing (so don`t need all the fill in notes) sadly, being 5 voice it`d cost a fortune to turn that inner row into Bb . nothings perfect but if you want the heaviest, best built and most Opulent Melodeon Hohner ever made Then the Club Morino is it (In diatonics only the Shand Morino is bigger & Heavier and going by the Shand pics in Owen's Blog - it`s not as well made inside) ..
-
Hi aradru,
The box with the "Bobby Gardiner" grille? Any modifications are on hold for now. It actually plays pretty well as a G/C, though after some playing, a few of the leathers for the lowest reeds are misbehaving. Not surprising at nearly 60 years. I haven't wanted to change anything beyond touch up of a crack or two in the original wax. At some point it ought to go to the right player who wants it as is, or otherwise it will likely have some kind of reversible conversion done if it stays here.
It's a heavy box though for Irish style playing, with those 12 basses -- though I think it's a bit smaller and lighter than the other 12 bass one with the "grey" style grille.
PG
-
Here's a much more recent version of this kind of Paolo on ebay now:
http://www.ebay.com/itm/PAOLO-SOPRANI-BUTTON-ACCORDION-ACCORDIAN-HAVE-SHIPPED-TO-IRELAND-65-WORLDWIDE-/261264210114
Anyone interested should confirm details with the seller, but my own impressions are
--it's a GC
--it's probably a 4 voice box in LMMM (despite the "Folk III" name, and despite the markings on the couplers which might suggest a voicing of LMMH)
PG
-
It's a heavy box though for Irish style playing, with those 12 basses -- though I think it's a bit smaller and lighter than the other 12 bass one with the "grey" style grille.
PG
A friend of mine has a 4 voice, 12 bass pepperpot that weighs in at a very neat 4 Kg.
What weight is your Paolo, would you say?
Hi aradru,
The "Bobby Gardiner grille" G/C with LMMM, 2 couplers, and 12 basses is 4.874 kg (without shoulder straps) by my new scale (not yet checked for calibration however).
I am curious about that weight difference, if your friend's pepperpot is really a 4 voice. It could mostly be in the wood of the case, but just comparing the differences in visible features . . . maybe the pepperpot grille itself is lighter . . . then there would be more material in the stepped aluminum keyboard than in the flat one, and in the mushroom buttons with screws rather than the simple celluloid ones . . . then, it's possible the bass mechanism in your friend's box (slanted 2 X 6?) is lighter, and might that one have the low bass reeds removed? Finally of course, B reeds would be slightly lighter than G reeds.
As noted in another thread*, a late-1950s horse-shoe grille, blue-badge Paolo Soprani with 21 keys, stepped board, and 12 basses, recently sold on ebay. That makes several of these stepped-board boxes, made over several decades, that came up for sale this year
PG
*
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,13518.0.html
-
Here's an example of a slightly later 1960's red badge, originally exported to the Swedish market, but spent its life in Denmark. LMMM G/C 12 bass. The 12 bass versions are extremely rare around here, so I was quite surprised when I stumbled upon this.
-
And another (?) horseshoe-grille example:
http://www.ebay.com/itm/Vintage-Paolo-Soprani-Italian-Meledeon-Button-Accordion-NICE-NO-RESERVE-/301044223123
-
I just randomly bought this from an antique shop in France, seems to be similar to what you all are talking about in this thread. It's currently being shipped to me. Any insight into what it could be? It was very cheap. I'm hoping it has a sound even faintly resembling a grey. I'll make a vid when I receive it. Any info would be great thanks. Is it a pepperpot?
-
Hi Chris,
Nice find!!
It does look like a pepperpot , but I'm no expert.
good luck with it!
-
I just randomly bought this from an antique shop in France, seems to be similar to what you all are talking about in this thread. It's currently being shipped to me. Any insight into what it could be? It was very cheap. I'm hoping it has a sound even faintly resembling a grey. I'll make a vid when I receive it. Any info would be great thanks. Is it a pepperpot?
Well done! If it sounds like the ones in the original post, you'll love it. You might find the bass side a little heavy. Probably has the melody rows tuned a fourth apart, so you may want to change the reeds for one row, and may want to have someone convert the keyboard to a flat one. That last is very tricky to do really well, but IMO this box deserves investing in the best quality workmanship, so I would recommend that you don't go cheap on the conversion -- if you decide to alter it.
Congratulations!
PG
-
I just randomly bought this from an antique shop in France, seems to be similar to what you all are talking about in this thread. It's currently being shipped to me. Any insight into what it could be? It was very cheap. I'm hoping it has a sound even faintly resembling a grey. I'll make a vid when I receive it. Any info would be great thanks. Is it a pepperpot?
Looks like a very nice box - I had an 8 bass version of this very model a few years back, nice machine.
-
Thanks for the feedback guys. Yeah depending on the sound ill make the decision to convert the keyboard. Do you know anyone that converts keyboards from stepped to flat? Did you do all the work on your one Lars? I'm really hoping its in a/d because I already have a b/c. The plan would be to convert this to c#/d and flat keyboard.
-
Hi odonovanchris, its the same grill like my paolo. :D and with a converted keyboard.
(http://casu-irishmusic.com/Box/Pepperpot.jpg)
-
Hi odonovanchris, its the same grill like my paolo. :D and with a converted keyboard.
Thanks greasecurlies! Yours looks really nice! Where did you get the keyboard converted? And what tuning is it? Do you know what year it was made? That would help me date mine. Cheers!
Chris
-
I bought it from Anders Trabjerg, Galway. I think he has done the job. The Tuning is B/C , you can switch between 2 or 3 Voice, the original 50`s paolo reeds.
The Box are from the early fifties. (51-53) , The feet a integrated in the casework, not in the bass cover. That is a sign for a early model i think.
-
Cool, are they the original bellows? I thought it would have white trim on the gasket with a black stripe. How does it sound? Any videos? ;)
-
Hi, they smell like the original bellows :-). Tomorrow i will send you a sound file if you want.
Can you send my you mail address via pm?
-
Sent, thanks.
If anyone else has further info on these boxes and keyboard replacement please post. Thanks.
-
Can you send my you mail address via pm?
You can email a member via the email link at the left of his post
Theo with admin hat on
-
Ok thank you (:)
-
Do you know anyone that converts keyboards from stepped to flat? Did you do all the work on your one Lars?
Yes, I did the work myself, and has done it to other stepped keyboard boxes as well. It's a big job, and it can't be reversed, so you'd want to make sure you're doing it right the first time. I don't do conversions for others, and I'm not sure any of the repairpeople do that kind of job. Worth asking them, though, as it really will be a great box when converted:)
-
Do you know anyone that converts keyboards from stepped to flat? Did you do all the work on your one Lars?
Yes, I did the work myself, and has done it to other stepped keyboard boxes as well. It's a big job, and it can't be reversed, so you'd want to make sure you're doing it right the first time. I don't do conversions for others, and I'm not sure any of the repairpeople do that kind of job. Worth asking them, though, as it really will be a great box when converted:)
Do you just work on your own boxes then lars? I was under the impression you were a repair man :) Where abouts did you source buttons for the keyboard? Do you know where I could get white ones that are the same as Paolos from that era? I think I'll work on getting it tuned first, then later on I'll tackle the keyboard, I'd love to do the keyboard myself and put red celluloid over it to keep it looking original.
-
I rarely do work for others - studying by day, working on boxes at night. I just like working on them, using various projects as a way to collect experience and new ideas.
I'm just finishing one where I put red celluloid over the keyboard plate, looks neat for some models, whreas others look better in the raw. I get buttons from www.cgmmusical.co.uk - but they are pearl. I've not yet found a source of plain white 13-14 mm buttons with the right shape.
-
Interesting, thanks for the link! It looks like I could get the celluloid off him too. There must be a place to get the buttons if modern boxes have them. The pepperpot I ordered didn't arrive yet, I'm getting excited now, I hope it sounds similar to a grey paolo.
-
The buttons that cgm sells are pretty much all from Carini I think. Carinis new website is quite good now, would be worth a look. I suspect that any button available in pearl would also be available in white, though there could be a rather large minimum order if they have to be made specially.
-
Did anyone ever buy an old accordion just to salvage the parts? If only I could find an old scrap paolo soprani to get buttons for my stepped keyboard pepperpot... or is that a sin? :|||: >:E
-
But if you could find an old Paolo Soprani with a flat keyboard you would want to keep it wouldn't you? If you are doing a conversion just use new parts. It's a conversion, it will never be an exact replica of a different instrument. It's playing qualities are surely more important than details whether the buttons are plain white or pearl?
I do think you have to keep a sense of perspective about these things.
-
But if you could find an old Paolo Soprani with a flat keyboard you would want to keep it wouldn't you? If you are doing a conversion just use new parts. It's a conversion, it will never be an exact replica of a different instrument. It's playing qualities are surely more important than details whether the buttons are plain white or pearl?
I do think you have to keep a sense of perspective about these things.
I think it's okay to salvage parts from wrecks, but like Theo says - why not work on the wreck instead, if thats nice?
I have found plain white buttons in various shapes and sizes from old 5-rows, but not with the right shape. I think Paolos should have rounded edges (unlike for example Hohner buttons, which are nice on a Hohner but not on a Paolo), and I'd rather use new buttons with the right feel, rather than use old buttons just for the looks. I have only ever heard of one red paolo being stripped for parts - nice buttons, but severely damaged in all other aspects. From what I gathered, it was dropped out of a car driving around south Galway... Bumpy roads, but hard enough to beat the life out of an old Paolo.
-
But if you could find an old Paolo Soprani with a flat keyboard you would want to keep it wouldn't you? If you are doing a conversion just use new parts. It's a conversion, it will never be an exact replica of a different instrument. It's playing qualities are surely more important than details whether the buttons are plain white or pearl?
I do think you have to keep a sense of perspective about these things.
Yeah you're right, the sound is much more important than the looks. I'm probably going to fit the pepperpot with a flat keyboard and pearloid buttons at some stage so. Still waiting for it to arrive...shipping takes so long! Now if I could only afford Ray's old grey on Donedeal....hmmm
-
Well lads I arrived home from work today with a lovely pepperpot waiting for me. I immediately checked her out and found that she's a G/C, 4 voice LMMM pepperpot with 12 bass. She's got a wooden soundboard and a lovely sweet tone. Badly in need of a complete overhaul though, I don't think she's ever been tuned, so needs new valves, wax etc. There's a tiny little bit of rust on some reeds. The soundholes are square unlike grey paolos. Check out the pics. Interesting note that the legs are part of the body...all in one and the feet studs seem to have been hand-hammered into place. It's weird that the bellows strap doesn't reach the clip to keep the bellows closed...yet it fits perfect on the storage clip.
Would anyone be able to put a date on this box? I'm guessing early 50s from what I read on this site. She definitely needs a bit of work but I'm sure she'll sound gorgeous when she's finished! It will be a nice project. I'm looking forward to hearing all yer feedback :)
-
more pics...
-
and more...
-
a few more...
-
last of the pics...
-
It's weird that the bellows strap doesn't reach the clip to keep the bellows closed...yet it fits perfect on the storage clip.
Hi Chris,
Congratulations again! Wow, what a beautiful accordion. I have to tell you, even though it does play differently, I haven't had the heart to convert my most recent stepped-board example (the box on right in the first pic in this thread). If you get all the rest of the accordion working and sounding well, you might want to leave the keyboard conversion to last. I do not prefer stepped boards in general but this box is very original and works and sounds amazing as an original box -- and I found that I can get some nice music out of it despite the stepped board, that actually encourages me to play in a different way. Not a bad thing to have an interesting different "extra box," since the initial cost was reasonable, and of course the keyboard conversion could always be done later.
About the bellows strap not reaching -- it looks like all the reeds are in place from what I can see. Is there anything else (like a wood spacer block) lodged in one of the bellows folds? If not, the leather strap might have shrunk a little. You might be able to stretch it out.
Are *all* the airways square?
I'm as curious as you about the dating. To me it has a lot of early features including the way the feet are made. But it does have the black & white piping, the "Italia" badge, and the round air button.
The experts will probably share all their knowledge some day, but at this point I'm guessing that each change in constructional features that we notice in these Paolos was not applied simultaneously to every box built at that time. If that is so, we can't line them up chronologically based on our simplest comparisons among what look like "evolutionary" changes in their features. I would guess that some older bodies hung around the shops and were finished and shipped at a time after other, "newer" types were being offered. Or maybe what look like "earlier" type and "later" type bodies were actually being built concurrently on different production lines, to make different models of box. I would also guess that different factories that built for Paolo Soprani went through different chronological series of changes in the features of the boxes that they shipped.
PG
-
Are you going for B/C? That would be a relatively straight forward conversion, tuning wise.
Have you put her on the scales yet, any idea of the weight?
Yeah I'll definitely be converting her to B/C. I need to source reeds for this though, would you be able to suggest a course of action? This will be my first melodeon restoration project so I've yet to even source the tools for the job. But I've messed around a lot with a few cheap accordions and learned a lot in the process. I've also read a lot on this forum....what an invaluable resource!
She weighs in at 4.9kg. The bass side feels slightly heavier than what I'm used to but not bad enough to cause a strain or anything.
About the bellows strap not reaching -- it looks like all the reeds are in place from what I can see. Is there anything else (like a wood spacer block) lodged in one of the bellows folds? If not, the leather strap might have shrunk a little. You might be able to stretch it out.
Are *all* the airways square?
I'm really puzzled about the bellows straps, I'm thinking that if the straps shrunk then they wouldn't fit on the storage clips either. I found no wood spacer block from my brief inspection of the bellows yesterday, although I'll take another look later. My guesses about this are as follows:
1) The bellows may not be original....although the piping seems to be original which seems to rule that out. Also I can see that the bellows have been re-taped in several places and there's a strong musty smell from them...so they're obviously old.
2) The gaskets on the bellows seem new and may be thicker than the original.
3) Can the bellows' dimensions change due to humidity?
As for the airways, I believe they're all square yes.
Where would be the best place for me to source new bellows? I took a look at Galassi Bellows and they seem good, but I'm sure they're expensive. Any other suggestions? Thanks!
Chris
-
She weighs in at 4.9kg. The bass side feels slightly heavier than what I'm used to but not bad enough to cause a strain or anything.
As for the airways, I believe they're all square yes.
Chris
Hi Chris,
Had to ask - though I noticed your photo with the raised G-row pallet that all the airways under that one were square.
So the weight of yours is similar to my unconverted one:
The "Bobby Gardiner grille" G/C with LMMM, 2 couplers, and 12 basses is 4.874 kg (without shoulder straps) by my new scale (not yet checked for calibration however).
Thanks again for the great photos. I'm heading in to a busy spring of teaching, but when I get a chance I'll post some interior pics of mine.
PG
-
Either replacing bellows tape or new bellows can explain the straps not fitting.
Both Gallassi and Marconi make good bellows and for similar prices. Beware of buying poor quality bellows, they are a crucial part if the instrument.
For your reeds I would strongly advise using the existing reeds, again they are a crucial part of the instrument and play a key part in getting the sound you want. Putting in new reeds would be like fitting a new modern engine to a classic vintage car. The C row reeds will just need the pull note on the first button to be re-tuned, and most of the G row reeds can be used with some re-tuning. If you have not done reed work yourself this is the one task that you should put out to a trusted reed person. There are a number in Ireland who specialise in this sort of thing on old Paolos.
-
Agree with Theo that you might want to have an experienced tuner work on this accordion.
Also that -- for a B/C -- you could keep your C row reeds and possibly most of the basses could be re-used depending on your preferences there. But aside from retuning the G row reeds to B (by moving each reed up one position), as Theo suggests, another option would be to find an inexpensive unrestored "parts donor" B/C Paolo in 4 voice, with decent reeds, and borrow the B row reeds from it. Then there would likely be less retuning of any of the tongues, and along the B row all the reeds would match very well. There will usually be a slight difference in sound between the C row and B row on these boxes anyway, even on a B/C with all original reeds, so the difference in sound of an unoriginal B row might be tolerable. You could save the original G row reeds aside and that way the box could be put back in the original keys. Another issue would be reducing the sizes of the chambers in the outside-row reedblocks, if you are replacing the G-row reeds with smaller reeds for a B row.
PG
-
Another issue would be reducing the sizes of the chambers in the outside-row reedblocks, if you are replacing the G-row reeds with smaller reeds for a B row.
Thanks for the great advice PG and Theo, how would I go about reducing the size of the chambers? Would I just be better off sourcing donor reedblocks for this?
Also I've found a working 4 voice B/C weltmeister for relatively cheap that I could scavange for reeds. Is there a big difference between german and Italian reeds?
-
Hi Chris,
I'm not sure how easy it would be to *find* spare reedblocks that will fit your box. I was lucky to find another Paolo whose blocks fit one of my G/Cs, but actually the reedblocks of the two red boxes shown in my first post above are not interchangeable.
If you are in Ireland, I wonder if Martin Connolly, would take on the job to make up a set of spare blocks for you to fit your Paolo? I've often thought of having this done myself with certain accordions.
I don't know whether other box restorers in Ireland would be set up to make reedblocks. But in England, I seem to remember Theo suggesting he might take on such a job.
See photo below of a G/C 12 bass 4 voice Paolo with register switch behind the keyboard, whose reedblocks are interchangeable with the reedblocks on the 1940s red box with the "Tony McMahon type" aluminum grille. But again, neither of those boxes have reedblocks interchangeable with the red box on the right in the photo of the two.
PG
-
The reeds are an important part of what gives you the sound and playability of your box. I am very doubtful that you would be happy with the Weltmeister reeds, unless the Welty plays and sounds as you would like the PS to?
If it was my box I would use the original GC reeds, some retuning of the G row is needed to make B, and some additional reeds needed for the top end. Finding another set of old BC reeds is not going to be easy. You could of course treat yourself to a set of top quality new Italian reeds, you would certainly get great response and tone, but again a different sound form the originals.
Reducing the size of reed chambers is easily done by gluing in small blocks of wood to fill some of the space at the top of the chamber. You can use quite soft wood so it can be cut easily with a sharp knife. I usually use western red cedar, you could use balsa.
-
This just arrived on my doorstep... ;D
LMM, G/C, In pristine condition, I've never seen an accordion ~70yrs old looking this good, the bellows are mint, reeds look excellent and the previous owner said it was mostly unplayed since it was bought after the war. It's got the most lovely raspy sound and is suprisingly in relatively good tune for its age considering it was never tuned since it was originally bought.
Can anyone put an exact date on it? I'm guessing mid to late 40s since after the war but not sure when this grille pattern first appeared?
-
Hi Chris,
Great looking box! I know what you mean about how nice they can sound if the wax, valves, and tuning have miraculously held up. The later of the two boxes in my original post is like that -- original reed leathers each stamped with the name.
If I had to guess, yours would be early to mid 1950s.
I think Shane Mulcair had a very similar (maybe identical) model that has been converted to a flat keyboard box.
Maybe he will have gotten some history with his example, or a good idea from Charlie Harris or other experts of its exact date.
Congratulations!
PG
-
"Ca. 1953-4, but we'll never know for sure", a quote from Stephen Chambers.
Me and Stephen were sitting in a lovely session earlier this year, when a mutual friend came in and showed his red Paolo identical to yours to us. Identical up until it was converted to flat keyboard from the original stepped like yours, and the original G/C LMM setup was changed to D/D# MMM using old Paolo Soprani reeds.
There has been some discussion regaring that model, and those close to it, and the general things to note, is:
1953-4, based on catalogs, original purchase-reciepts of old boxes close to this one in the timeline of Paolo Sopranis. The thing to note is the timeline, as this is one of the number of models made after the famous Greys of the 40's, and the equally famous reds from the 50's. Below is the timeline I find most likely, not the correct one, but I think this is the most often accepted cronologic order of the models - I stress the fact that there is massive overlap on some models, and I think it's important to remember that the business model of Paolo Soprani was totally based on subcontracting after the war, following the damages to their facilities in WW2. They were forced to have others make not just parts for them, but entire accordions in order to even stay in business, and it did prove profitable. Around that time, special workshops making special parts was already a long time established standard, and it is known that brands (speaking in the interest of Irish style boxes here) such as Paolo Soprani, Casali, Busilacchio, and Calvi were somehow involved with each others' work in the 50's and 60's. Other makers were probably also involed, depending on the models and markets the boxes were made for.
After the Greys came the silver greys: Light grey celluloid, rounded grille front with various patterns, wooden bass side panel covered in celluloid.
And after the silver greys came the first reds: The pepperpots (thin, finely perforated metal grilles, and celluloid covered wooden bass side panel), boxes like yours (celluloid covered grille, wooden bass side panel covered in celluloid), and the first 'Blue Badge' models that still had rounded front corners on the grille, but now had a stamped metal cover on the bass side.
And THEN came the well known 'Blue Badge' reds, where it started to have squared corners on the front side of the grille, which now mounted in a slot in the front of the cabinet along the full length.
Now back to the point: Yours would now place in between the last dark grey boxes (likely up until ca. 1950), and the first Blue Badge models that had the grille mounted in a slot (ca. 1955). Are you still with me?
But! There's overlaps. Lots of them. I know of a grey paolo made in red - one of only a very few reds with the famous grey-style grille. And there's red style boxes made in silver grey with the grille mounted in a slot. And there's red badges mounted on blue-badge style grilles. And there's some made with a slightly different grille pattern - and no badge at all.
Confused? There's also the different style logos (a couple of models from that period had celluloid-logos, not aluminium). And when did they start to put "Italia" on the bass side? When did they start to put those REALLY big bass buttons on them? And the bellows, oh my, the bellows. Dark red. Light red. Burgundy, and they even made some with pink cloth. Piping is a whole chapter for itself: Black, white, white-black-white striped, small and large corner trims. And some silver greys has some bellow strap-brackets just like the first early reds! And the screw-in buttons on the stepped keyboard ones came in at least three different variations! Okay, this might be going into very fine detail, but it sort of proves the point:
There was a LOT going on with the Paolo Soprani models at this time, so it's hard to say what the precise timeline is for these models made in the transition from all-grey to an almost all red production, and finding the right subcontractors until the production of the typical reds of the 60's that did not change THAT much apart from slight changes to the grille design. But I think the 1953-4 range is pretty well backed up by catalogs and proof of original purchase date in Ireland - I don't think anyone has been able do find out much from other markets (USA, Scandinavia and South America where there was an import of Paolo Soprani in this timeframe. And even if you find a reciept in an old case, you still don't know how long it has been in the store, and how long it took from it was made to it was delivered at the shop.
Congrats on finding a very nice Paolo Soprani - the two I have seen of this specific type were both very nice boxes, though they had been worked on recently.
-
"Ca. 1953-4, but we'll never know for sure", a quote from Stephen Chambers.
Piping is a whole chapter for itself: Black, white, white-black-white striped, small and large corner trims. And some silver greys has some bellow strap-brackets just like the first early reds! And the screw-in buttons on the stepped keyboard ones came in at least three different variations!
Congrats on finding a very nice Paolo Soprani - the two I have seen of this specific type were both very nice boxes, though they had been worked on recently.
Thanks for the age estimate Lars, I must say you are quite the expert on these boxes! That's great info. It's interesting you mentioned the piping colour. The other paolo I posted about in this article had three black stripes on the front piping, and another box my friend owns is a 1949 grey with the criss-cross celluloid grille similar to what Martin Donohoe had for sale a while back; that one had just plain white piping. So I think the piping is a good age indicator.
Yes this box definitely has the best tone of any box I've ever owned although it's a pity about the stepped keyboard and tuning. I'm looking into having it converted to B/C but it's hard to decide on the setup. I like that it's light and would work well as an MMM but I also want to preserve it's original character by keeping the LMM....decisions decisions! Also I need to find someone willing to convert the fingerboard to flat who will do an excellent job. Any suggestions?
The later of the two boxes in my original post is like that -- original reed leathers each stamped with the name.
Thanks for the info Paul, what do you mean about the leathers being stamped? My reeds only have a diagonal line scribed on them to indicate the outward face.
-
The later of the two boxes in my original post is like that -- original reed leathers each stamped with the name.
Thanks for the info Paul, what do you mean about the leathers being stamped? My reeds only have a diagonal line scribed on them to indicate the outward face.
Hi Chris,
Sorry, that sentence wasn't very clear. I meant that you rarely find a never-overhauled box from the 1950s or earlier that still has its original tuning with very well functioning wax and valves, no rust or dust, so that it seems not only "unplayed" but close to sounding like it did when new. One of the 2 accordions in my original post in this thread was like that (although after some playing, some of the original leathers are acting up and I will have to re-do them). And in the case of that box, the original leathers are stamped "P. Soprani" in red ink, something that I haven't seen often. Even when the leathers are original, you don't usually see that stamping -- but when it's present, that adds to my confidence that all the leathers are original. Will add a photo.
PG
-
Thanks for the age estimate Lars, I must say you are quite the expert on these boxes!
... So I think the piping is a good age indicator.
No an expert at all - just picking up what I hear along the way, and put my own experiences into the pot. I've only been really into boxes for around 10-12 years, and those with far longer experience are a great source of information. I think the most important thing is to be open about what you know, and keep in mind the things you don't know - to put as much information as possible together, without spreading popular opinion that might turn out to be false.
I don't think the piping can be used as a correct age indicator - there is too much overlap. But I've heard it mentioned that it could be a good indicator of the people involved with making that particular box. For example, Pancotti used broader white-black-white piping in much of their production, and they have been mentioned as a possible maker of some of the Paolo Sopranis of the early 50's.
Wide bellow frames to accomodate wide piping versus the narrower type seen on some black-piping boxes would also point towards the frames being routed on different machines, perhaps at different factories. It could also be, that they just used whatever they had around, and just adjusted the routers for what piping they felt like using for that batch.
-
Hi niels nielson told me many years ago pancotti made grey paolos after the war as paolo factory was bombed and they had loads of orders to fill they took what they could in the way of templates ect and made them for a while until factory was rebuilt
-
Reviving this old thread to post another example ca early to mid 1950s, made by Paolo Soprani but labeled / sold by the Italian Accordion Manufacturing Company, Chicago. This one has every reed leather ink-stamped "P. Soprani" like the similar box I posted above. This one was also decorated (probably by the customer) with the letters "GCB." Those may be the player's initials. But, although this accordion is a 2 row box in GC, it's possible that the player also played the "GCB" system of 3-row box and thought of this box as another GCB, but to be played on the outside rows. I've often seen accordions labeled by the player with their keys, especially when the player might be not very musically literate and owned several instruments.
And better yet: here's a great video clip of a similar model being played:
https://www.facebook.com/yolands.maidana/videos/263674067057090/?hc_ref=ARQB8EF5GaElEXTgUVuXsmG-s8d2U6Ta4a-mM7LPEEFGiYA0Icq0AqcjI0CL48reMAE&pnref=story
And another (posted before on another thread), John Williams playing an example converted to flat keyboard (by Benedict Koehler, I think):
https://www.facebook.com/ciarank1/videos/10154515943474125/
PG
-
This Paolo Soprani Pepperpot 3 voice in G/C landed last Friday. It is in brilliant condition. Lovely player even with the stepped keyboard. Hoping to get it converted to flat. I understand it can be done but not the easiest of tasks? Anyone have any previous experience of getting a keyboard conversion done in Ireland?