Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: katesfolly on June 07, 2013, 05:27:52 PM
-
So....I've seen/heard people on diatonics doing a trick I'd like to emulate, but I'm not sure what to call the technique or how to accomplish it on my somewhat uncooperative equipment.
They're getting the same note sounded 3, or more, times in rapid succession as an ornament to the melody. It looks like it's usually index-middle-index finger or ring-middle-index finger for a triple. I would call that a 32nd, a triplet, or a shiver, but my terms come from local fiddle tradition--Is there a different name for this on b-box? I can't really search for help without knowing what to call it.
I'm playing a two-row hohner, and trying to accomplish this I run into the crazy key travel, plus generally slow response. Anybody know some tricks I could try?
-
Which ever fingers you use to get the (ornamentation), for want of a better word, you will need to develop a very light style of fingering. Only use just enough pressure to make the notes sound, if your box has strong button return springs on it, this can make it more difficult. As you develp the light fingered approach, the dups and trips should start to become easier with practice.
-
You could call it a one-button triplet. It's probably copied from fiddling, and in fiddling it can be called anything - triplet, treble, shake and probably lots of other things.
Popularized in Irish music in the 1970s by Jackie Daly, probably inspired by what Scottish piano-accordion players had started doing.
Further developed by Sharon Shannon and the younger generation who have compressed it into an impossibly short little brrp. I just can't do that - but I can do the more leisurely Jackie-Daly style - here's a clip to demonstrate two ways of fingering it (http://youtu.be/RmJnJUmQ5Nw).
PS Unlike Tom, it seems, I tend to whack the buttons pretty hard.
-
Peter Browne has a DVD that explains how to do lots of techniques including the 1-note triplet and shows different methods, using two fingers alternating or using three fingers.
The button box (http://www.buttonbox.com/learn-to-play-accordion.html) sells it for $28. Might be able to find it somewhere else also.
-
I generally use 3 (ring/middle/index) fingers flicking the top of the button in a fast roll. The main alternative is middle/index/middle which somehow seems stronger. Can't say could ever hit either 100% of the time :-\ Clever buggers eg Pignol (seen) and Cutting (claimed) can do it all with a single finger. I've also seen John Kirkpatrick roll a note continuously .. .. AFAIR using 3 finger method. Believe he had forgotten the words to his song, and was awaiting inspiration ;)
If you are tripletting (another new word for Lester ;D ) eg D or E on a D/G you can spread it over 2 buttons using the 2 rows, rather easier but somehow lacks oomph.
-
So....I've seen/heard people on diatonics doing a trick I'd like to emulate, but I'm not sure what to call the technique or how to accomplish it on my somewhat uncooperative equipment.
They're getting the same note sounded 3, or more, times in rapid succession as an ornament to the melody. It looks like it's usually index-middle-index finger or ring-middle-index finger for a triple. I would call that a 32nd, a triplet, or a shiver, but my terms come from local fiddle tradition--Is there a different name for this on b-box? I can't really search for help without knowing what to call it.
I'm playing a two-row hohner, and trying to accomplish this I run into the crazy key travel, plus generally slow response. Anybody know some tricks I could try?
Having recently gone from a Hohner Erica to a Castagnari Hascy, I can tell you that in my experience, 'tripleting' is infinitely easier on a higher end box (for me anyways). I normally go middle index middle, but it means having to think extra about hand positioning as its not something I can do without thinking about it at the moment.
-
So....I've seen/heard people on diatonics doing a trick I'd like to emulate, but I'm not sure what to call the technique or how to accomplish it on my somewhat uncooperative equipment.
They're getting the same note sounded 3, or more, times in rapid succession as an ornament to the melody. It looks like it's usually index-middle-index finger or ring-middle-index finger for a triple. I would call that a 32nd, a triplet, or a shiver, but my terms come from local fiddle tradition--Is there a different name for this on b-box? I can't really search for help without knowing what to call it.
I'm playing a two-row hohner, and trying to accomplish this I run into the crazy key travel, plus generally slow response. Anybody know some tricks I could try?
Having recently gone from a Hohner Erica to a Castagnari Hascy, I can tell you that in my experience, 'tripleting' is infinitely easier on a higher end box (for me anyways). I normally go middle index middle, but it means having to think extra about hand positioning as its not something I can do without thinking about it at the moment.
I agree. I always play cleaner triplets when I'm in an accordion shop than when I'm playing the ones I own... Maybe I should upgrade?
-
I find they work just fine on any old Hohner!
-
I generally use 3 (ring/middle/index) fingers flicking the top of the button in a fast roll.
On the rare occasions when I use a triplet on a single note, that's what I do too. Most of my triplet ornaments use two notes and two fingers (I'm sure there's a technical term for that, but I just do it because it sounds OK).
Graham
-
I'm a first and middle finger man myself and have no problems playing single button triplets on my Hohner Ericas or my 1 Row 4 Stop. Restricting the action on Ericas/Pokerworks certainly helps with triplets.
Many examples in my blog address below.
-
Sounds like there are several approaches that work, and probably which works best somewhat depends on the physical limitations of the box.
I've had more luck using a single finger and working the button right at the edge of making sound, probably due to the key travel on my old, leaky (but juicy-sounding) Hohner. Sounds like i could improve that by restricting the travel on the keys, which might also dampen the incessant key clattering, which is not, really, as one of my fiddlers called it, "charming". If I "flicked" the key tops like ChrisRyall, all you'd hear is key-slap. I'll head over to the repair forum and see what I can dig up.
Sounds like when I get off work, I need to go lost-weekend on YouTube a little. :)
-
Sounds like there are several approaches that work, and probably which works best somewhat depends on the physical limitations of the box.
I've had more luck using a single finger and working the button right at the edge of making sound, probably due to the key travel on my old, leaky (but juicy-sounding) Hohner. Sounds like i could improve that by restricting the travel on the keys, which might also dampen the incessant key clattering, which is not, really, as one of my fiddlers called it, "charming". If I "flicked" the key tops like ChrisRyall, all you'd hear is key-slap. I'll head over to the repair forum and see what I can dig up.
Sounds like when I get off work, I need to go lost-weekend on YouTube a little. :)
The bulk of the clacking from the treble end of Hohners is the pallets closing when you release the key due to the v thin facing Hohner use. Replacing it with nice felt/leather material quietens it down.
-
This is a video by a tex-mex player, but the second technique he teaches is the one your asking about. Very interesting.
http://youtu.be/Tx_yTGQB1nQ
-
Totally! ::) I think it has at least doubled my understanding in Tex-Mex in one 5 minute video! Suspect any melnetter who doesn't live on the Rio Grande will get at least something from that little cracker ;D
-
@GaryChapin
Thanks for the link, that's rather awesome! I watched several of his videos. (I love conjunto).
@Chris Ryall
I think "cracker" must mean something rather different where you are (the UK?)...what does it mean?
@Lester, I am sure you're right re: the clacking--I took my box apart last night and there's very thin, hard leather on the, um, pallets. I have some felts left over from doing work on my piano that might be appropriate...I'll take a look over in the repair forum. I replaced four or five leathers last night, because they were curled up rather dramatically.
I'm deeply jealous of those of you in the UK and elsewhere who have relatively easy access to repairmen. Support them, or they'll disappear!
-
I think "cracker" must mean something rather different where you are (the UK?)...what does it mean?
It means something exceptionally good of its kind in the UK; does it mean something different in the US?
Graham
-
It has a lot of subtle gradings sometimes it's equivalent of "white redneck." Very often it is used by African-Americans and latinos as a term for "white people." It's not a term of affection.
-
Well there you go - you learn something every day. Thanks for the explanation.
Graham
-
Sorry, 'bout that! :|bl Two races, divided by a single language, as they say ...
-
Sorry, 'bout that! :|bl Two races, divided by a single language, as they say ...
Ah, but we had it first! >:E ;D
Graham
-
I took my box apart last night and there's very thin, hard leather on the, um, pallets. I have some felts left over from doing work on my piano that might be appropriate...
Kate - as a pallet-facing material, felt on its own is not recommended as it will not give you a sufficiently air-tight seal. There is proper stuff available for this job which consists of a felt backing faced with fine Persian leather. You can get this from an excellent supplier, Charlie Marshall, CGM Musical Services (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Welcome.html), who is based in Scotland but will ship world-wide. He is very reliable and many of us here on this forum use his services for spares and replacement parts.
This (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Felt_Leather_Pallets.html#3) is the stuff you need. It will improve the noisy action of a Pokerwork/Erica no end.
There are various threads on this forum which describe the methodology for re-facing the pallets and it is worth searching for them, as there are hints and tips which are very useful. Try a search using the words 'pallet facing'
Here's (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,8637.msg107122.html#msg107122) one post in a useful thread which includes a link to Lester's useful photos. (:)
-
Many thanks for the shove in the right direction, Steve!
@Graham and others: Thanks for the clarification. Variations in English are fascinating, huh?
-
So how fast does a triplet have to be to be a triplet, and not 3 of the same notes? :|bl
-
So how fast does a triplet have to be to be a triplet, and not 3 of the same notes? :|bl
A triplet is equal length quavers (eighth notes) played in the duration of a crochet (quarter note). So three quavers in the time you would normally play 2 quavers.
-
thanks ! so are these triplets? played on one finger
http://youtu.be/hIp8kGhD8QQ
i mean the ones i play in the A music
thanks !
-
Tommy, a triplet usually refers to three notes played in the space of two... what you are doing sounds like a note repeated three times without any special timing. If we wrote your tune out in jig time, or six-eight march time, the notes in the first phrase would go something like:
long-short long-short | short-short-short long-short | etc. (or crotchet-quaver or quarter-eighth or whatever you please) where the bits in red are the repeated notes.
The kind of triplets we are talking about in this topic (at least the ones I'm talking about (:)) usually occur in reels rather than jigs and involve scrunching three notes into the space of a crotchet or quarter-note. In the above example you'd have to squeeze another note in like this:
long-short long-short | extrashort-extrashort-short-short long-short | which might not sound that clever...
Hope this helps!
Edit PS for the musicologically picky I realize that extrashort-extrashort-short doesn't describe a true three-into-two triplet in the classical sense, where the three components are equal in length at one-third of the long note they are replacing, but what people in Irish and Scottish trad actually play most of the time is semiq-semiq-q or 16th-16th-8th and not 3.333-3.333-3.333 !
-
Ideal :D
-
What fingering I use when doing a single note triplet depends upon which finger the note is sitting at the time.
I tend to favour two finger triplets:
4-3-4, 3-2-3, 2-1-2 ... unfortunately you run out of fingers and try as I might I never been able to persuade the 1-2-1 combination to work reliably so on the occasions that there's a triplet that has to be done on the first finger it has to be a 3-2-1.
Doing two finger triplets leaves your hand and fingers back where they were, as does a 3-2-1 triplet for the index finger position. I think this is important for putting this ornamentation into a tune, it should not impede the general flow of the playing, they just "pop out" so to speak.
Right, I'm off to our session (:)
-
I use 3 fingers for a three (same note) triplet fingers 123 at right angles to keyboard and held tightly together. the fingers then resemble a segment of a cogwheel and by passing the 'segment' rapidly across the appropriate button you get a very fast triplet. takes a bit of practice outside of the tune but can be done on either row.
george
-
I generally use 3 (ring/middle/index) fingers flicking the top of the button in a fast roll. The main alternative is middle/index/middle which somehow seems stronger. Can't say could ever hit either 100% of the time :-\ Clever buggers eg Pignol (seen) and Cutting (claimed) can do it all with a single finger. I've also seen John Kirkpatrick roll a note continuously .. .. AFAIR using 3 finger method. Believe he had forgotten the words to his song, and was awaiting inspiration ;)
If you are tripletting (another new word for Lester ;D ) eg D or E on a D/G you can spread it over 2 buttons using the 2 rows, rather easier but somehow lacks oomph.
I can say that Mr. Cutting can indeed 'trill' with 1 finger- I saw it with my own eyes! >:E >:E >:E
-
I have heard this technique referred to as the "rapid fire technique". You can hear Jackie Daly play this on "Mulqueens Reel" (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D6sPWV5_o1U), and Finbar Dwyer plays this extensively on the "Waltz of the Birds". This technique is used in all types of diatonic accordion music. I use it a lot in Italian music. Mostly you will use your index and middle finger, but in some tunes you can use all four by dragging them across the button. This takes a lot of practice but the result is worth the effort. I generally use the index and middle finger and this works fine for me. Start slowly on different buttons and as you become more accurate, speed will come. Hope this helps. Good luck :||: