Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: jventola on June 07, 2013, 09:08:13 PM
-
"I grow old, I grow old.
I shall wear the bottom of my trousers rolled.
I searched for "posture" and "ergonomics" and learned that the decision about number of fingers to use on the left hand will affect posture.
I do not find a discussion of ergonomics of the accordion. I do understand that there are no rules, and all you post-modernists can relax.
Still, all those Alexander Technique folks can't be crazy. So the question arises: given the basic structure of human bodies, the decision to use four fingers on the bass side, the desire to play both sitting and standing, what's a good way to begin finding the most relaxed and least stressful posture?
(This question is for me somewhat moot, since I lack the discipline to practice for long hours and do not bring an accordion to a session. But I have know musicians who did serious injury to themselves by ignoring the issue.)
I have Pignol and Milleret's Methode and for sitting they suggest one method a) using one shoulder strap, b) raising the left foot (with a footrest or by crossing the legs) and c) pressing the rightmost part of the treble side against the outside of the left thigh (for resistance).
Others suggest keeping both feet on the ground. A non-player but expert in ergonomics reported being shocked at an Irish concert by the accordion player's keeping the instrument way over to the left. This person thought it was because of the music stand and proposed an ergonomic accordion music stand.
I know some players of the big boxes syand and use a support stick that goes from the accordion to the floor, to lend support.
Standing, I find the two straps work fine. (I like the cool look of one strap, and your left leg out in front and to the side, Tex-Mex style. I like a standning posture with the buttons invisible to my eye because I am leaning over and letting the bellows descend by gravity. But I wouldn't do that for long.)
I think the major long-term concerns would be a)fingers and wrists and b) lower back and shoulders.
What say ye experienced ones?
-
Several threads have followed this theme, it seems. As another with the inevitable rolled trouser legs, I feel the fundamental answer to your search may be found in physics, rather than ergonomics - IMO to play with attack, the right hand side must somehow be held still, and without the right hand being held in too restricted a posture, because it needs to be able to dart about a bit.
-
Agree with Chris re the need to keep the keyboard from moving around. As to how many fingers are used on the left hand I don't think it matters as far as posture etc is concerned. I found the emost strain /ache free posture is to sit or stand up straight with shoulders back ( which also helps to keep the box firm) . When doing the sitting a dining chair or stool rather than an armchair is better as it encourages a good stance or the seated equivalent. In other words in military terms sit or stand to attention!
Leaning or bending forward or to left or right and waving fully extended bellwos from floor to ceiling is not good for the joints or muscles
george
-
Both Pignol and Milleret play 75% or more on the pull. Norbert would say to put almost no energy into the left arm, unless you are setting up a dynamic. Hold the right end securely, and let the left fall away under its own weight. In actual performance, they both have a low stress action. Both wear 2 straps. They don't do the gyrations that Le Tron or Laloy offer onstage, OK Stéph might wish he'd been a Rock star ;)
Personally (FWIW) I like it cool too, but am nevertheless a 1 strap chap. Mainly I'd blame Andy Cutting. but my first proper box was a Lilly, I think it only came with one strap.
-
My personal point of view is ...
I see melodeon playing as a "contact sport" - for me, I have to be viscerally attached to the instrument at every point feeling the abrupt stop when I take my fingers off the buttons and the sharp jolt in the firm change of bellows direction. I feel that it comes through in the music I make and I feel that is a good and joyful thing.
I understand that from a posture/long-term health aspect that the best way to play the melodeon is probably in the complete opposite manner from the way I do. But I also find that following all the common-sense advice means that I find the playing to become joyless and non-physical. I find that a little stress in my muscles an entirely good thing for my playing. In the past - I have been lucky enough to be offered the occasional free full back massage at the backstage areas of certain festivals ... whenever I have taken them up on the offer, I have had comments on quite how tense my upper back and shoulders are, but after the massage I have felt in a completely "wrong" physical condition to play the box in earnest. I no longer accept these kind offers.
But I expect that may just be me and my pig-headed push-pull approach to box playing.
-
I have been lucky enough to be offered the occasional free full back massage at the backstage areas of certain festivals ...
Woohooo: melodeon groupies? (:)
-
I'd echo Squeezey's implied advice. Much, actually most?, of the dynamic or our instrument comes from the bellows and the "English style" is very different from what is taught to learners in France. As a player gets better and learns more tricks they tend to merge, but I think his approach will always, and in my view intrinsically, have more guts.
I started off that way, and my back really started to ache once I moved up to a Mory. I actually ran massage classes one summer at François Heim's week, up in Cevennes, no shortage of volunteer recipients, their backs were full of knots!
You pays your money, you takes your choice in this? I have to say that the concept of massage making the music floppy is new on me, but can understand how. English style (probably Québécois too, no experience yet) has "attitude", albeit counter-topic in this particular thread.
So how to prevent backache playing it as a contact sport? ;)
-
Of course, Smiley has one big asset in all this - youth!
-
Of course, Smiley has one big asset in all this - youth!
I think Chris meant to say Squeezy has one big asset in all this - youth
I don't have to look in a mirror to know that he didn't mean me ... ::)
-
Oops, yes thank you Smiley, I did indeed! Looks like it's not just physique that deteriorates with age.
And what's more, I confess to deteriorating reading skill - I'm sorry to confess I speed-read Squeezy's post first time round with a 'p' instead of an 'm' in the word 'massage', and imagined it to have been a really scary gig!
-
Personally (FWIW) I like it cool too, but am nevertheless a 1 strap chap. Mainly I'd blame Andy Cutting. but my first proper box was a Lilly, I think it only came with one strap.
Thanks for this tip...hadn't tried playing with a single strap but I'm finding it much more comfortable when sitting. Is playing standing with a single strap also commonly done then...? It's only a compact melodeon.
-
Contact sport! never thought of it like that. But I am extremely active when playing. Always prefer standing, moving about, stomping my foot into the stage, very theatrical, exaggerating every move. I am a gardener so all the muscles are still firm. Started playing when I was 24 and 43 years later still going strong without an ache. (wish I could say that about the gardening.) I did have a few problems with tennis elbow and carpel tunnel, plus a new knee to stomp with, but that was work and motorcycling.
-
I agree that playing is a very physical activity, and Squeezy does have the advantage of youth! I'm nowhere near as an experienced player and I'm a lot older but I still aim to have the same sort of dynamic in playing one day, and I'm working towards that end. A while ago I had to stop playing for a bit, injured the shoulder Morris dancing. I thought I might give up the melodeon and just play a concertina, but much as I love the concertina I missed my melodeon.
So my New Year Resolution is to find an experienced Pilates teacher who is also a qualified Physiotherapist - take my box along, show them how I play, tell them the aches etc and get them to devise an exercise programme that will give me the strength where I need it. We'll see if it works!!
Sue
-
When I'm playing folk music I sit down. When I'm playing rock and roll, reggae or zydeco, I stand up.
I do not have youth or common sense on my side. Feel the pain! ;)
-
The advantage of age is that you do feel the pain! The worst thing for me is to stand still - everything just seizes up! So, the more you can move whilst playing the better. It might extend to the rather elaborate expressive movements of a solo concert violinist or maybe just a gentle swaying or rocking, but it all helps. I admit I do sometimes play completely immobile, but that seems to be when my mind is wandering to other things (Will the pub still be taking food orders when we finish? Is that gorgeous lady actually with the gorilla? etc)
Rob.
-
George has the essential germ of truth here: whatever keeps the box (treble end) from moving around.
The human variation + the box variation + the style variation = to many variables to recommend any specific technique.
I mean: look at some of the great players on YouTube playing left handed (upside down), 1, 2 and (OMG) 3 strap players, standing, sitting, dancing, 1, 2, 3 and/or 4 fingers on the bass, etc. etc.
I think, though, jv, if you can do it the way some of the methods suggest, you cannot go wrong, they usually suggest doing it for a reason.....
(example: back in the dawn of time, could not figure out why Mally always said "don't use the same finger twice in a row...")
-
I've been getting pains from playing lately too, lower left hand side of my back is tender after a long stint of playing a heavy paolo. Maybe I should adopt Tony MacMahon's 2-strap stance.
-
whatever keeps the box (treble end) from moving around.
I don't find this an absolute... so long as the treble end is moving in conjunction with the natural movement of the hand playing it, it's OK. Witness DTN's demonstrations of slamming the edge of the keyboard with the heel of the hand to really emphasise the rhythm. It gives great punch and attack to the notes affected! Mind you, although this will always work with a Hohner slung low on a single strap as you do a "Shadows" stomp, no matter how tight and convolute your strapping system, there will always be enough slack to get the effect.
Rob.
-
Sues comment about taking the box in to her physiotherapist is a good one.
When I was re-jabbing a knee injury a few years ago (not related to melodeon playing-HA) over a period of a few months there were several musicians in there with their various instruments getting advice (I assume) on just these issues, playing ergonomics, etc. related to, or working around, injuries, or preventing them.
Good idea. Might even try it.
-
Yes, take your kit into outpatients. I needed a (fortunately temporary) stoma last year and took my VdAa in to meet my surgeon. The technical stuff was nicely placed and I had no problem playing melodeon over the summer. Same applies to physios in my view. Don't expect them to understand unless you show them
-
I don't have ergonomic posture problems but something just as bad. I can't even get through Constant Billy without being totally out of breath. Having had tests, it's not heart or lungs. The tests continue.
Shouldn't this be under the Dear Marge thread.?
PS Playing "Getting up Stairs" is even worse :'(
-
I've posted some of this on another thread in the past, but it bears repeating and there is now a bit more to it.
Throughout nearly two decades of playing, I have always had trouble keeping the keyboard still (Steve-freereeder criticised me for it, quite correctly, at Witney a couple of years ago). It didn't matter whether I stood up, sat down, used two straps (with or without a connector across the back) or just one strap: the damn thing still waggled about like a demented jellyfish. I also had to have frequent visits to a chiropractor due to problems with my back.
Then I had a pacemaker fitted that precluded having a strap resting on my left shoulder, so I took the advice of a friend and lifted the strap over the top of my head so that it sat on my right shoulder (this requires a longer left strap). Two unexpected bonuses of this were that this immediately cured my 'demented jellyfish' syndrome, giving me a firm and stable playing position, and that my back problems were cured almost instantly - although, buying a memory-foam bed probably also contributed to curing the back pain.
Now I just need to find a more stable way of playing my one-row boxes, which only have one strap... :(
-
Bob, I only 'play' one row, and I've started to put the strap over my head onto my left shoulder. I THINK its more stable, but I tend to be forever changing my mind on the strap position debate.... :||: :-\
-
Thanks for the suggestion, Brian. I should have thought of it myself because it is a logical corollary of how I play my other boxes that have two straps, but I didn't! ::)
I've just spent a couple of hours trying it out whilst playing both English and Cajun tunes, but I don't think it is going to suit me because it alters the position of the box so that it is not only closer to my body (not, in itself, a bad thing) but also tends to twist the box into an uncomfortable playing position. I tried varying the length of the strap, but I couldn't find a position that I found comfortable. Maybe it is just a case of more experimentation until I find a position that suits me.
-
I don't have ergonomic posture problems but something just as bad. I can't even get through Constant Billy without being totally out of breath. Having had tests, it's not heart or lungs. The tests continue.
Shouldn't this be under the Dear Marge thread.?
PS Playing "Getting up Stairs" is even worse :'(
Does Billy mind? Plus playing whilst navigating stairs is very risky, you might catch your bellows on the banister.
I suspect you have confused the Charles Atlas Bullworker with a melodeon. Try playing using as little air as possible - fix the top strap to keep your bellows movements tight. Let me know if that helps!
-
Bugger off ! ;)
-
Shouldn't have said that. >:E
-
(:)
No a fence taken (:) btw comment about amount of air was serious.
-
"And he lay in an ergonomic posture, wi' t' shade of his face on the bars.
Young Albert 'ad 'eard about Lions ..." >:E