Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: deltasalmon on June 09, 2013, 07:34:52 PM
-
After playing the melodeon for nearly a year, I decided I should learn how to properly hold the instrument. I noticed in this post
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,12446.msg152903.html#msg152903
People mentioned leaning the melodeon away from the body at an angle. Is this what most people do? When I hold mine i have the back of the melodeon flat against my chest. Are there any advantages holding it further away from my body or leaning it on an angle? I've noticed recently other people holding it at an angle like in the video in the post I linked above. Maybe not as extreme as that but I notice more people holding it at an angle than flat against them.
-
The extreme tilt is fairly rare in my experience but playing seated with the melodeon well away from your body is quite common, both Andy Cutting and Lester of this parish play with the box a long way out on the left thigh. gmatkin who is also of this parish takes it a step further and doesn't even use a shoulder strap.
Look at this video of Naragonia (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vnRkdpe608U) which shows the box held well away from the body. If you stand to play this isn't an option of course!
-
Having the box away from the body allows the right arm to adopt a more natural position. With the instrument in contact with the body the right elbow is probably bent more than 90º, and the wrist is flexed to quite an angle too, bout of which can lead to discomfort.
-
There is also less friction when you hold the instrument away from your body, which makes it easier to use the bellows sensitively.
-
After playing the melodeon for nearly a year, I decided I should learn how to properly hold the instrument. I noticed in this post
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,12446.msg152903.html#msg152903
People mentioned leaning the melodeon away from the body at an angle. Is this what most people do? When I hold mine i have the back of the melodeon flat against my chest. Are there any advantages holding it further away from my body or leaning it on an angle? I've noticed recently other people holding it at an angle like in the video in the post I linked above. Maybe not as extreme as that but I notice more people holding it at an angle than flat against them.
I've certainly been guilty of holding a melodeon angled like that in the past; it's something I've tried to undo though. The main reason being that sitting down, it muffles the sound, not least for the player, and makes it harder to hear what you're playing in a noisy environment. I would prefer, sitting anyway, to have it on the left knee too - the further left the better within reason. Almost the first thing I do on picking up a new box is to lengthen the strap as far as it will go! Playing standing up is different though; I tend to anchor a large box to the chest, although something smaller like a pokerwork I'd probably just hold it strongly both ends, use a single strap, and not worry too much if the treble angles away from the body (which it will).
Cheers,
Clive
-
The extreme tilt is fairly rare in my experience but playing seated with the melodeon well away from your body is quite common, both Andy Cutting and Lester of this parish play with the box a long way out on the left thigh. gmatkin who is also of this parish takes it a step further and doesn't even use a shoulder strap.
Look at this video of Naragonia (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vnRkdpe608U) which shows the box held well away from the body. If you stand to play this isn't an option of course!
I play like that, I emigrated (from a kid) from playing tilting the box and playing in between my legs (like Jon Looms in some of his videos) but found that personally, on the left thigh everything seems more open, free and natural.
Still, I do get crticised as apparently to some people, playing on the left thigh isn't all that typical of English D/G players (more the chromatically minded)?
-
It may sound odd (I'm sure it looks odd) but when I've had bouts of bursitis in my left shoulder I've been unable to hold up the bass end normally, so on those occasions I rest it on my left knee. Sometimes I rock my upper body to work the bellows. On such occasions, I tend to do whatever I have to just to keep playing, and the devil with how it looks.
TBV
-
I always thought the answer to this question was rigidity - holding the box away from the body allows its weight to assist in keeping the top strap tighter, and therefore reducing wobble. It is crucial IMO to keep the RHS of the box rigid, in all directions, if you want to play accurately and tightly.
There are so many axes of movement going on here, that it can be difficult to describe what's happening, but here goes:
By angling the box with the (physically, not musically) highest end towards the left of your body, you also tighten the top strap. By tightening the top strap, the movement of the RHS is significantly less. This means you can hit the right buttons more reliably, and change bellows direction much more quickly, giving your playing so much more tightness and attack. The top strap being angled away from your body also improves the rigidity of the highest point on the box in another axis, which is the wobble away from and towards your body.
The next point is that it allows you to steady the RHS with your right thigh held against a point near the middle of the top of the grille, rather than the end of the top of grille which is nearest the floor.
I also find that I can get the same improved rigidity with my 'second half-strap under the left armpit' system.
I'm not sure I agree with Theo's point - I prefer my strap system to get the box rigid. if you angle the box away from you, it seems to me that it twists the wrist unnaturally, which to me is more uncomfortable, or you hold the fingers at an angle to the keyboard, which I don't find all that good. Also, it means you can't see the buttons. Now for the vast majority of the time, that is no problem, because you learn the physical finger movements by feel rather than by sight. But there are undoubtedly times, particularly when you've got a long jump between buttons, or when checking a starting position, when being able to see them really helps. For example, if I'm doing the intro to the dance, you have to be spot on immediately without any faffing about, so I look at the music to check what the first note is, work out which finger I should be on to play it. Then when the caller suddenly turns round and says 'Here's a short intro', you can start playing suddenly, and it will be as clean as a whistle.
-
I thought this was the correct way to hold a melodeon....
-
;D new meaning to "bellows" form Bruno le Tron
or is it an old one? ;)
-
As I spend all of my working day seated at a PC or a G5, I've always played the melodeon standing up, using two shoulder straps. The bass side strap had a habit of sliding off my shoulder but I've cured that by tying an elastic band around the upper straps where they attach to the melodeon. It works a treat! Proper length of the straps and suitable tension adjustment in the hand strap to suit your playing style, is essential. Seated? I don't know. If I played seated I would probably have to use my PC and G5 standing up and induce repetitive strain injury which would certainly add a new dimension to my playing technique - maybe even improve it!
-
I am of the Ed Rennie school of squeezeboxes and have always been taught (and practiced) box tight to the chest with two shoulder straps. Personally I also use a back strap to stop shoulder straps slipping. I also prefer playing standing up as I feel it opens everything up. As I mainly play for Morris sides, playing upright and al fresco is the norm. The other technique Ed teaches is minimal bellows movement with lots of use of air-button. This keeps everything under-control.
I also play an Irish B/C box which I try and play "Irish-style" with single long strap and box on the left leg. Always feels strange and un-controlled to me.
Notice how John Spiers plays these days - two straps on chest. Better for the spine also.
-
I play "Irish-style" with a single strap and the box on my left leg but I have trouble with stability unless I shorten the strap and have it tight against my chest.
I see that most Irish players don't do this and it's something I'm working on but until I figure it out I'm keeping with holding it tight to my body.
-
I thought this was the correct way to hold a melodeon....
Only for the old "knees up" style playing, not so popular anymore as one tends to crack the fingerboard against one's chin.
-
I play sitting down with one strap...but then as a girl i have certain....features that do not allow for the box to lay 'flat' with two straps.
-
The bass side strap had a habit of sliding off my shoulder but I've cured that by tying an elastic band around the upper straps where they attach to the melodeon. It works a treat!
That's a great idea. I always use 2 straps playing for morris, and the left strap has a habit of coming adrift when I start jigging with the music. I don't want one of those cumbersome back straps designed for bigger accordions, so I'll give this a go!
-
. It is crucial IMO to keep the RHS of the box rigid, in all directions, if you want to play accurately and tightly.
I agree totally with Chris and others who advocate two straps. I always advise beginers to use two straps for the simple reason that it makes life easier by leaving the fingers and hand to get on with playing the notes rather than holding the keyboard in place. I also agree with the straps being tight as again this contributes to the steadyness of the keyboard.
A useful set up to start with is right strap a notch or two longer than left strap so as ato move the box slsighlty to the left ( this enables the right arm to be more or less down ones side rather than imitating flying lessons) once the right left adjustment is something like adjust both straps by the same amount to bring the top of the box roughly a stretched hands width bellow the chin when standing aand looking straight ahead. From there make small adjustments over a period of time until it feels most comfatable.
Two strap playing as above works just the same standing or sitting. It may not look flash like waving the bellwos around from knee to nose level whilst hanging on like grim death to the edge of the keyboard-- but does that really look 'flash'? It certainly does not facilitate fine control of the bellows.!
george
[[edited to show the quite correctly]]
-
. It is crucial IMO to keep the RHS of the box rigid, in all directions, if you want to play accurately and tightly.
I agree totally with Chris and others who advocate two straps. I always advise beginers to use two straps for the simple reason that it makes life easier by leaving the fingers and hand to get on with playing the notes rather than holding the keyboard in place. I also agree with the straps being tight as again this contributes to the steadyness of the keyboard.
A useful set up to start with is right strap a notch or two longer than left strap so as ato move the box slsighlty to the left ( this enables the right arm to be more or less down ones side rather than imitating flying lessons) once the right left adjustment is something like adjust both straps by the same amount to bring the top of the box roughly a stretched hands width bellow the chin when standing aand looking straight ahead. From there make small adjustments over a period of time until it feels most comfatable.
Two strap playing as above works just the same standing or sitting. It may not look flash like waving the bellwos around from knee to nose level whilst hanging on like grim death to the edge of the keyboard-- but does that really look 'flash'? It certainly does not facilitate fine control of the bellows.!
george
[[edited to show the quite correctly]]
I almost 100% disagree with both of you as a single strap or thumb strap player, but I defend your right to be wrong!
You do not need two straps "to keep the RHS of the box rigid, in all directions, if you want to play accurately and tightly" see any of my videos.
-
I do try to keep the box rigid as possible, I don't use two straps to do that but I do keep the box tight to my body. This thought started when someone mentioned angling the melodeon away from the body and I noticed a lot of Irish players keep the melodeon a little bit away from the body and at varying degrees of an angle instead of straight up and down.
I tried playing like this and I'm sure I just need to keep trying and figure it out, but when I try I always end up getting less stability especially on the pull unless the box is balanced against my body.
-
I've always felt that having the box tight up against my chest put my right arm in a cramped and tiring position, even with the box to the left of midline. Having the box out away from the body a bit and angled slightly helps put the right arm in a relaxed position, at least for me. But I do have rather long arms.
-
When I first learned to play both Cajun and Irish accordion, I played with one strap and rested the box on my left thigh like most players I saw at the sessions I went to. After a few months, this proved to be extremely uncomfortable and caused extreme pain in both wrists as well as in the left shoulder. I went to a two strap setup on both types of boxes and found it much more comfortable to play. The two strap setup tends to stabilize the box which is very helpful when playing C#D or Cajun where you are constantly pumping the bellows in and out. It also takes the strain off the left shoulder. My arms are at a natural bend and my wrists are straight when playing. No more pain. I can play for a couple hours and not have any discomfort in my left shoulder. I know two straps on a single row melodeon is odd and almost unheard of, but do consider it. I would not be playing now if I didn't go to two straps. :||:
-
I almost 100% disagree with both of you as a single strap or thumb strap player, but I defend your right to be wrong!
Actually, this isn't really my position, I just say that whatever technique you adopt, RHS rigidity is crucial if you want to play with attack and feel, because it leaves the right hand free to do whatever it wants. I'm a 1 and a half strap player myself. But I agree that others have different styles and interpretations, nothing wrong in that. I'd like others just to have a go at the 1 and a half strap technique, simply because it transformed my own playing overnight, but that was just my take on it. Naragonia's style uses a carefully controlled LH bellows action, I notice, but it still keeps the RHS very rigid.
-
I think the whole "holding the melodeon" thing is very personal - and is a balancing act between 3 things: 1st - the box needs to be held rigidly enough to make sharp bellows changes without any play in the setup, 2nd - the right hand has to be in a position where the fingers can play the buttons with the least stress in the tendons that control the fingers (basically as close to the body as possible and as far to the player's left and as low down as possible without compromising the 1st point) and 3rdly - the left hand needs to be able to extend the bellows as far as will be necessary in normal playing plus a little bit for error.
All 3 points contradict eachother and only a player's individual physiology can determine where the box ends up. For me it is fairly high and central with 2 straps but I could also have gone down the route of 1 strap and low down to the right and have been fine.
Nobody should ever be worried about experimenting though - at any point in their playing journey.
-
All 3 points contradict eachother and only a player's individual physiology can determine where the box ends up.
I couldn't agree more. The length of my straps have been going up and down as much as my bellows have been going in and out since I started playing. Being slight of frame, I have currently settled on two straps with the left-hand one being as short and tight as I can make it, which brings the keyboard slightly to the left of centre, and the right-hand strap is adjusted to hold the box firmly onto my chest. This just about stops the rocking motion that used to distract me when playing. I don't have abnormally long arms so this position is comfortable and doesn't put any undue stress on my arms/wrists, and I can practice for hours on end without any problem. It works for me.
I would think that the larger the instrument the more likely you are to use two straps; there is no way that I could use the FR-18 with only one. Also could the condition of the bellows have some bearing as to whether you could use one or two straps ? When I first bought my box, although second-hand, it was relatively unused and the bellows were very stiff, but ten months down the line I now notice that they are beginning to soften slightly, giving less resistance, making playing much easier. Hmmmm, maybe it's time to try one strap !
-
I play sitting down with one strap...but then as a girl i have certain....features that do not allow for the box to lay 'flat' with two straps.
Like the kids are fond of saying these days, I think you're holding it wrong:
(http://thumbs.dreamstime.com/thumblarge_615/1309361688eFbHjH.jpg)
;)
I'd keep the box close up to the chest if I could, as it takes all the slop out of the system, but my right side doesn't like it - I've got those long arms as well it seems. So out on the knee/thigh; one thing I do is to put a block of foam in between the case and my chest to stabilize things a bit. I've tried tying the case to my thigh, too. Might give that another shot with some leather cord, bootlace stuff. Before was using luggage straps. Hate it when the accordion rocks around. Why is it that you can play these huge piano accordions and CBAs right up against the body no problem but on a button box it just doesn't seem to work? Must be these smaller cases.
My Casta's winging its way here and am hoping and praying that it will play so much better than the Hohner that all this stuff won't be an issue anymore!
I've lost count of how many different instruments I can "play," with some of those, fiddle for one, I can merely knock a tune out of them; with the fiddle I just never feel comfortable holding the thing - I can feel muscles tense up simply from rotating the left hand, even without holding the violin neck - and I really do believe some people just aren't physically constructed in the ideal manner to really get the most out of some instruments. The flute's a good example, I've read that it's the least ergonomic of all instruments, how some people cope with really terrible pain from trying to hold the things, no matter how much they attempt to relax or try different grips and postures, etc. Me, I've never twinged anything playing the flute, excepting maybe my 170 year old Wood and Ivy boxwood 4 key, which has warped over the centuries into almost a 'C' shape. That thing does sting a bit, but hey. Playing instruments that aren't comical in appearance has never bothered me though. Same could perhaps be true for some people attempting to get music out of the button accordion, sad to say.
-
Two things have occurred to me, whilst playing today, regarding the rocking motion of the box. Doh !
1. PA's can be big, note for note, compared to the melodeon. Big means heavy, generally, so its mass keeps it from moving around, regardless as to how it's supported. The very nature of its size, small, means the melodeon will move around when pushed or pulled unless it is anchored in some way, either on the knees, or by elbow, or shoulder, strap support in conjunction with the hand/thumb on the keyboard .
2. The straps are generally supported on an "L" shaped bracket which the box will naturally pivot around; it's always going to move about that axis.
A question for you Theo and all the other box builders/fettlers. So, given the above, is it not possible to support the straps from two points on the box further apart from each other ? Say, one where it is generally found on the main frame and a second on the keyboard edge. This might at least give greater support where it's needed, or has this already been tried and failed to catch on, for whatever reason ?
Another thought about this issue of movement; is this just a problem that the novice player learns to overcome with the passage of time, similar in a way to the use of the air-button ?
Ian
-
Two things have occurred to me, whilst playing today, regarding the rocking motion of the box. Doh !
1. PA's can be big, note for note, compared to the melodeon. Big means heavy, generally, so its mass keeps it from moving around, regardless as to how it's supported. The very nature of its size, small, means the melodeon will move around when pushed or pulled unless it is anchored in some way, either on the knees, or by elbow, or shoulder, strap support in conjunction with the hand/thumb on the keyboard .
2. The straps are generally supported on an "L" shaped bracket which the box will naturally pivot around; it's always going to move about that axis.
A question for you Theo and all the other box builders/fettlers. So, given the above, is it not possible to support the straps from two points on the box further apart from each other ? Say, one where it is generally found on the main frame and a second on the keyboard edge. This might at least give greater support where it's needed, or has this already been tried and failed to catch on, for whatever reason ?
Another thought about this issue of movement; is this just a problem that the novice player learns to overcome with the passage of time, similar in a way to the use of the air-button ?
Ian
You can undoubtedly fit two brackets as far apart as possible which may or may not make a difference.
If you look at my video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jj1CtZ022rU (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jj1CtZ022rU) I can be seen playing a one row and a two row with no straps at all and still getting drive/lift etc. It is all a matter of bellows control and not yanking/snatching etc which comes with practice.
-
Thank you Lester, but I don't really want to have to learn "Speed the Plough" just to be able to use one strap ! (:) :D ;D
-
Thank you Lester, but I don't really want to have to learn "Speed the Plough" just to be able to use one strap ! (:) :D ;D
Other tunes are available ;)
-
I totally agree with Lester about ''yanking and snatching'' being the cause of instability ( and of a lot of other problems!) Yanking and snatching ( sounds like two oriental gentlemen presumably from Wan.... -hm better not go there!) However to be seriarse about it yanking and snatching is peculiar to small push/pull boxes and rarely if ever occurs on 120 bass boxes as they are just too heavy so to do.
It therefore follows that if accurate and delicate bellows control is developed early on in the learning process the problem of box stability is less likely to be a problem whether playing with no straps, one strap or two straps.
george
-
As a life-long single strapper, standing and sitting, I recently had a Eureka moment trying to tame a light-weight, single-row, 4 stopper. I stuck my head through the strap (previously lengthened) so it went diagonally across my body and there it stayed firmly for both push and pull, even at a distance from my chest. I don't think it works at all for 2 rows or more, but could be worth a try if you find you have a bit of 'waggle' going on! ;D Tony
-
Is the thumb position going to affect this as well? I normally play with my thumb on the edge but I've noticed through experimentation that I get more stability when the thumb is on the back of the keyboard. I, however, then feel that my fingers are more limited in their reach with my hand being further back.
-
Great video demonstrations, Lester! - what they showed to me is that you've developed a range of techniques for keeping that right hand side steady, and it looks like you've achieved it largely by making sure the bellows pressure is in line with the strap direction. I'm reminded of Ginger Baker's famous quote - 'After a bit, you're not playing the drums, they're playing you'.
-
I posted before without watching the video fully. The strap above the elbow as opposed to over the shoulder is something I haven't tried. I'll give it a whirl when I get home.
I also like LDT's idea in the comments of putting velcro on your knee... :D
-
I posted before without watching the video fully. The strap above the elbow as opposed to over the shoulder is something I haven't tried. I'll give it a whirl when I get home.
I also like LDT's idea in the comments of putting velcro on your knee... :D
To be honest the strap over the shoulder thing started when I was somewhat more rotund than I am now and the strap would not go over my shoulder and all the way round my gut, now I just find it better. ;)
-
You should take up motorcyling ;) My permanently dislocated right clavicle acts as the perfect 'hook' - and the compo from the responsible car driver paid for my Oakwood!
-
Squeezy's comments got me thinking and it's what I aim to do but never sure if I actually achieve it!
Have always felt more comfortable resting the box on my right leg, but today, realised why it's always suggested on the left leg - it keeps the keyboard far to the left so keeping the right wrist as straight as possible.
Have just tweaked my straps and will persevere resting the box on my left leg.
After playing now for ~ 3 years, I find it useful every so often to go back and review things like position and make sure it's still correct - or could be improved.
Delta salmon: the thumb position has previously drawn huge threads as a topic in it's own right!
I use the edge and right from the start it felt right and has always been a firm anchor point and reference point for my hand/fingers.
What I'm finding recently is that now I'm getting to grips with the set of tunes I play, I'm tying to be more expressive in my playing. With a straight arm leading directly into contact with the box through the thumb on the keyboard grove, a gentle flick through the thumb can give sudden emphasis to a note without having to use a whole 'left arm's worth' of push if that makes sense!
Whether it's more stable with a thumb behind I do not know, but I'm beginning to discover a thumb's very useful for emphasis on the keyboard grove.
Q
-
"Expressive" play is an art form (Naraginia are geniuses at it) but does require a responsive instrument. I think you're on the right track. Try and avoid tension in the body and "express" with the digits. Other techniques are the litle flick of the bellows, or a tiny cut/anacrusis notes from adjacent "in scale" buttons.
Also practice holding a note and fading it to nothingness, or waggling a single left finger during the note, it gives a surprisingly subtle and controllable vibrato (best in single voice).
Power to your (everything except!) elbow ;)
-
funnily enough I have been waggling a left finger randomly, though some might say that's all I do :|bl
Dunno what but last few weeks have somehow become a bit 'playful' and having the odd aimless twiddle as opposed to concerted practice, and experimenting with short sharp taps of bass, or just chords, maybe both, but very stuccato. Quite a different effect.
Yep, can se what you mean by using digits not whole lumps of arms. Makes sense.
But ( coming back nicely to topic!! ) as previously mentioned the box has got to be stable or any subtle movement in one direction will just propel it in the opposite direction as opposed to transferring the movement into meaningful noise.
Must revisit Naraginia and take a proper look........
Q
-
( looks like whilst I replied to a comment it's been removed? )
???
Q
-
It's been moved to a new topic. The question acme up about which makes are considered responsive, which seemed to deserve its own thread.
Its here http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,12602.0.html
-
Just uploaded my avatar, so that's me in standing up mode: I like 2 shortish straps too: can play either sitting or standing equally comfortably. The time that both bellows control and playing became difficult was during the Sport Relief Mile down Edinburgh's Royal Mile: trying to play and walk at a brisk march both at the same time!
I tried the over-the-left knee way when I started but it was giving me tendinitis in the left shoulder. I was told you'd wear your bellows out quicker if you didn't hold them away from you, but my tutor said they were more robust than that!
-
Ah! Fair enough, Thanks Theo.
-
I've found that as a one strapper, it's a case of bracing your right shoulder against the melody buttons
With your right hand, thumb on the edge or even behind. I've noticed that Lester wears the strap half way down his right arm. Fine for sitting down, but not sure for standing up.
I've found that if you keep that tension between shoulder and melody buttons it should work whether standing or sitting .
-
I wear it over the shoulder when stood up with thumb behind the keyboard.
-
I wear it over the shoulder when stood up with thumb behind the keyboard.
Sorted ;D
-
I am sure I have mentioned this before in another thread, but bear with me because I have something new to add....
Since having a pacemaker fitted a few months ago, I have been unable to play wearing two straps in the conventional manner because one of the straps presses down on the pacemaker. Therefore, I adopted a two-strap style that I picked up from Hugh Taylor, who posts here occasionally. It involves putting one strap over each shoulder as normal and then lifting the strap off the left shoulder and over my head so that it sits on my right shoulder along with the other strap. This provides a great deal of stability and also solves the problem I used to encounter whereby the left strap had a tendency to fall off my shoulder. However, there are certain problems with this method: it moves the melodeon over to the right and it raises it up nearer to the chin, which places the right arm in a slightly uncomfortable position with the elbow sticking out at an angle (especially for somebody with long arms, like me). Even when extended fully, the left-hand strap is also a bit tight, causing the strap to bite into the side of my neck.
The solution was fairly obvious. I contacted Charlie Marshall for some longer straps and, after a short discussion about the length of various straps, I ordered some Castagnari-style 120-bass accordion straps. Problem solved! The straps are long enough for the melodeon to sit lower on my chest and further to the left so that the melody keyboard sits in a conventional and comfortable position. The 'Dracula strap' problem has also been solved because it no longer bites into my neck.
I can recommend this system as providing a stable way of holding the melodeon whilst eliminating the risk of the left strap falling off the shoulder, but if anyone chooses to adopt it, take my advice and replace the melodeon straps with 120-bass accordion straps.
-
Just to qualify what Bob has said, the method that he describes above was showed to me by Steve Tomlinson, who posts as McGrooger. Thanks Steve, a great method of holding the box.
-
Here's a physically demanding style which may suit some:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-0zSRFI1HA (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-0zSRFI1HA) (Alan Morrisroe - My Grandmother's Favourite Jigs).
-
That's exhausting, even just to watch.
-
I bet the thing leaks like a sieve :||:
-
As a new player I am finding this aspect of the box hard to sort out.
I would really like to get my right thumb on the edge but find it gets strained after a while. I think I am pushing my thumb to make the strap over my right shoulder tight thus causing tension.
I have begun with sitting with the box on my left knee and have also tried the idea of bracing against the left leg [French style?]. I just don’t get this idea....I can’t seem to position it in a way which keeps it still.
Still not getting a stable and still keyboard though. I’m going to try 2 straps next. I really want to get my right hand relaxed and focused on playing the keys easily.
Left hand also hurts after playing but I am assuming this is normal until you get used to it? One reason was because the strap was waaaaay too tight. Now the pad under my thumb is sore...again I need to find out how to relax my grip somehow.
It would come as no surprise to find this is all quite normal...I’ve only been playing for 2 weeks. I’ve had similar issues when learning other instruments. But holding seems quite fundamental and I fear if I don’t get this right I may fail quite early on in my new venture.
So focus on doing it right or just go for what just feels comfortable?
-
Welcome aboard Tony!
There is often a massive debate on exactly how you should hold the melodeon, and essentially there are no rules.
That doesn't help you though at the moment!
If I can tell you how I hold mine, there will be a shed load of others giving their advice and so options for you.
I use two straps. For me that means the weight of the melodeon is held on my shoulders if stood up, or 'supported by them' if sat down.
Standing up, I've tweaked the straps so that the right hand keyboard is about a hand span below my chin, and slightly nearer my right hand, not absolutely dead below my nose/centre of my chest. The left hand bellows end is slightly angled down, allowing gravity to help with the bellows.
When first starting I tried several positions, all roughly the same, and then settled on this. Recently, Theo of this parish said he'd changed his position after 20 years so..... try it, feel free to change it!
For me in this position, my thumb runs along the groove in the fingerboard
It is for me an anchor and point of reference for my hand when playing. In this position I find it comfortable and relaxed, certainly not straining or pushing hard. Merely 'firm' to act as a reference point whilst playing.
Whatever you end up trying, I think you also want to try and keep your fingers slightly arched on the fingerboard in a relaxed natural manner, straight-ish lines through the wrist, elbows relaxed. Essentially whatever feels good for you but try and steer clear of very bent fingers, wrist or elbows. I try and keep it all relaxed and as straight possible to prevent tight angles that over time will wreck tendons etc.
That's me, others will have different takes on position. The straps are all adjustable so feel free to adjust!
Good luck
Q
-
My thoughts, others will disagree
www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jj1CtZ022rU (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jj1CtZ022rU)
ps Welcome aboard!
-
Good advice from Lester and Q so far, and I agree pretty much with both of them.
My summary:
1. There are no rules. We all have different body shapes and sizes. Do what feels comfortable and which works for you. Experiment!
2. Having said that, the aim should be to keep the RH end as steady as possible. If it is wobbling around a lot, you are wasting energy moving the end of instrument around when it should be moving air through the reeds.
3. If you have two straps, check to see if they are both the same size, or if they are different lengths. Some pairs of straps are designed with one longer than the other. If this is the case, the shorter strap usually goes best over the left shoulder. But see 1. above. Also, be aware that different clothing can affect the friction on the straps. If your LH strap tends to slip off regardless of adjustment, try wearing a different top and see if it makes a difference*.
Edit:
* See my avatar picture to the left. The black Lizzie Dripping t-shirt (part of our kit) is notorious for allowing the strap to slip off, as it is about to do in the photo! :|bl
-
Hi Tony,
Welcome to the MAD house.
Learning to hold the box was a challenge for me too.
I don't (as a dodgy player of about two years inexperience) know why your left hand is hurting. I just remember that the muscles of my chest ached for the first month or so.
The type of melodeon you have has quite a large effect on it's stability- two row boxes have wider case work than one row types and having a wider contact strip against your body tend to yaw less as you push and pull on the bellows.
-
Thanks folks, good to be here. I feel very excited as my first box arrives at the weekend (borrowing one at the moment).
I’ve bought a Hohner D/G Morgane. Some really interesting and helpful advice. Like other instruments I play I understand there are as many ways to do this as there are players. I just know that if it hurts I am almost certainly doing it wrong!
Lester....saw your video last week...thanks. I have defaulted to what you do at 2.20 (strap round elbow). You mention how the thumb is just maintaining tension though is not strained ....this is where I’m going wrong I think. I must be pushing too hard with my thumb which is why it hurts! It seems like this is a good thumb position as I can see how the hand is more free to move (I play piano a bit and this position seems most like that hand shape).
I also notice your box appears tilted forward, almost balancing on a corner rather than flat on your knee earlier in the video. Is this what I’m missing?
I’m going to post a video of me playing in the beginners video section in a few days....perhaps that will reveal my points for improvement?
MAD House.....LOL...sounds like I’m in the right place😉👍🤪
-
You mention how the thumb is just maintaining tension though is not strained ....this is where I’m going wrong I think. I must be pushing too hard with my thumb which is why it hurts! It seems like this is a good thumb position as I can see how the hand is more free to move (I play piano a bit and this position seems most like that hand shape).
I suspect that part of your problem is that you have only been playing two weeks, in this time everything tends to be tensed up. Your brain is tense from all the thinking and your muscles then tense up from all the thinking and joining up of though to action. I still get this when learning new tunes. Once you get 'muscle memory' everything frees up and becomes easier.
I also notice your box appears tilted forward, almost balancing on a corner rather than flat on your knee earlier in the video. Is this what I’m missing?
I tilt the box to give a more natural shape to my arm and wrist position.
-
Steve mentions the material can affect strap slippage.
The other variable for me is seat height.
At home I always practice on a stool and adjust the straps so the box is comfortable and secure at this height.
In those far off days when we got out to play in sessions, I found sometimes the chairs would be lower causing the straps to have less tension and could slip off mid tune as they were loose.
If it was causing a real problem, my straps have a buckle half way along their length and a quick tighten a hole would keep the overall balance and position the same but just tighten it a tad.
I long for those times to return, as do we all I'm sure.....
Q
-
Welcome to this splendid group!
I’ve played for just over 4 years.
I’ve tried loads of different positions and strap settings.
Some things worth trying :-
Different set ups for different boxes - they vary in weight and balance.
Try different air button types. I’ve found the rocker types suit my left hand better.
Watch yourself on video - I’ve got a tendency to waggle my head and stick out my left pinkie.
Am working on these habits.
We are all constructed differently- eg arm length, strength and posture. I’m quite tall so
I look out for videos of tall players.
Standing to play is good for me - you can sway and tap your foot which helps with expression.
Try a foot rest - I use a guitarist’s footrest sometimes.
Personally I don’t like the bass/chord end to be too far away.
I’m amazed had how many wonderful players can manage with their left hand far away from them.
Try to stay relaxed - I’m terrible for hunching and building rigidity and tension, especially when learning
new tunes.
-
Here's a physically demanding style which may suit some:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-0zSRFI1HA (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-0zSRFI1HA) (Alan Morrisroe - My Grandmother's Favourite Jigs).
This video is private?
-
Greg, clicking on it I too get 'this video is private' message though it is old so might have gone......
-
I'm pleased that I'm not the only one who was intrigued by the "physically demanding style" of 17 years ago!
As well as the "private" message, it said to sign in to view it. But when I did, it just said that it wasn't there. Too old, I imagine; as TB said.
-
Here's a physically demanding style which may suit some:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-0zSRFI1HA (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-0zSRFI1HA) (Alan Morrisroe - My Grandmother's Favourite Jigs).
This video is private?
Try this
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nAM4devBbMk
-
How not to bellow
www.youtube.com/watch?v=7fZL-WA1EUY
-
fwiw
When playing out I spend part of the time playing stood (for the convenience of dancers) and the rest sat down (for the convenience of drink ;D )
I wear two straps for both.
Sat down both straps go over my right shoulder. Seems to work fine. Can't see any reason to change. Bear in mind that I was, towards the end of my working life, a black belt industrial engineer, who's responsibilities within the company covered tool change time reduction. Zero changeover time was always the target.
Zero set up time = more time for playing and beer.
Stood up one goes on each shoulder but, after spending a couple of years with the left hand one falling off, at the most awkward moments, I wear a back strap. This makes it a lot easier to relax. Didn't take long to get used to, either, once I got the knack of slipping the straps over my head with the back strap already done up.
-
Many thanks to boxcall, it was worth the wait.
-
fwiw
I wear two straps for both.
Sat down both straps go over my right shoulder. Seems to work fine. Can't see any reason to change. Bear in mind that I was, towards the end of my working life, a black belt industrial engineer, who's responsibilities within the company covered tool change time reduction. Zero changeover time was always the target.
Zero set up time = more time for playing and beer.
Stood up one goes on each shoulder but, after spending a couple of years with the left hand one falling off, at the most awkward moments, I wear a back strap. This makes it a lot easier to relax. Didn't take long to get used to, either, once I got the knack of slipping the straps over my head with the back strap already done up.
I always use two shoulder straps ( on both shoulders) seated or standing and a back strap if playing lead box in a ceilidh band. the only exeption is the 4 stop one row which i only play seated using just the thimb strap
george
-
I always use two shoulder straps ( on both shoulders) seated or standing and a back strap if playing lead box in a ceilidh band. the only exeption is the 4 stop one row which i only play seated using just the thimb strap
george
Now George mentions it, I only use one strap on my one row and only play sat down.
-
I always use two shoulder straps ( on both shoulders)
Is that 4 straps ;)
-
So the good news is that;
1. My box arrived today.
2. It already feels easier to play because;
.its bigger
.the bellows are easier
.the air button is a slidey button
.the keys are mushrooms not buttons
I only have one strap which is on the last hole at each buckle and could do with just a teeny bit more length.
So next question....what straps do I get which would fit a Hohner Morgane G/D ? Where is best to get them from. It think I need two so I can try wearing it standing up and have the option to play sitting.
Thanks so much for the really helpful replies and the lovely welcome here.
I am at the beginning of a very enjoyable journey.
-
I always use two shoulder straps ( on both shoulders) seated or standing and a back strap if playing lead box in a ceilidh band. the only exeption is the 4 stop one row which i only play seated using just the thimb strap
george
Now George mentions it, I only use one strap on my one row and only play sat down.
I only use 1 shoulder strap on my 1040 and play standing up. That box lives in the kitchen and usually gets played when something is on the stove or the kettle is on. Instant pick up/ put down. Vital if the chip pan goes up. What do you mean chips aren't a health food?
-
I always use two shoulder straps ( on both shoulders)
Is that 4 straps ;)
Everyone loves a smart arse (:)
-
So the good news is that;
1. My box arrived today.
2. It already feels easier to play because;
.its bigger
.the bellows are easier
.the air button is a slidey button
.the keys are mushrooms not buttons
I only have one strap which is on the last hole at each buckle and could do with just a teeny bit more length.
So next question....what straps do I get which would fit a Hohner Morgane G/D ? Where is best to get them from. It think I need two so I can try wearing it standing up and have the option to play sitting.
Thanks so much for the really helpful replies and the lovely welcome here.
I am at the beginning of a very enjoyable journey.
I will leave it to others to suggest where you can get straps from, but with something as light as a Morgane you don't need padded straps - or even broad straps unless you wear only very flimsy shirts. I have found Belti straps from Poland very good - but you do need to make sure that your strap brackets are big enough for the fairly chunky tails to fit through.
-
So next question....what straps do I get which would fit a Hohner Morgane G/D ? Where is best to get them from. It think I need two so I can try wearing it standing up and have the option to play sitting./quote]
Charlie at CGM Musical Services has a large selection of different straps and items ordered used to arrive the following day.
May take a tad longer due to Covid.
-
Yes, another vote for CGM.
A well respected purveyor of all things melodeon!
-
I only play sitting down these days and I'm a one strap chap. It usually ends up somewhere between the shoulder and the elbow.
-
When buying straps it helps to know exactly what you want. There are a lot of options out there. I find "melodeon" straps tend to be on the short side.
-
😂😂Some of your Forum names are hilarious...
Squeaky Pete!
Tone Dumb Greg!
😂😂
Going to have to think of something to go with Tony!
......ohhhhh got it....how about because I’m a beginner ......Tuneless Tony? Atonal Anthony?
I fear if I began a survey you folks would be too good at this!
Seems to be lots of straps available called Bass straps which I assume are for bigger boxs / accordions?
-
Not that I'm a strap expert (anything expert come to that) but I believe the bass strap is the one through which your wrist goes to hold the bass end of the instrument.
-
In less interesting times, Tony, it is easy to get good one to one advice from the right sort of tutor, or at the right sort of shop, so you can see stuff and try it out. Things being what they are, this might be tricky. Whereabouts are you? Someone might be able to help.
so far as a nom de keyboard goes, when you find your voice, Glasshopper, you will will know who you are.
-
how about because I’m a beginner ......Tuneless Tony? Atonal Anthony?
Don't give yourself a bad name - you'll encourage yourself to live up to it!
-
In less interesting times, Tony, it is easy to get good one to one advice from the right sort of tutor, or at the right sort of shop, so you can see stuff and try it out. Things being what they are, this might be tricky. Whereabouts are you? Someone might be able to help.
so far as a nom de keyboard goes, when you find your voice, Glasshopper, you will will know who you are.
Wise words Sensei! (Begins to trek over barren lands, in scorching wind, across seeming impassable mountain ranges only to find he was exaggerating the landscape of Greater Manchester!)
Oldham is much less interesting than it seems!
how about because I’m a beginner ......Tuneless Tony? Atonal Anthony?
Don't give yourself a bad name - you'll encourage yourself to live up to it!
More wise words......’Atonal Anthony’ does sound somewhat rude somehow!
-
;D
Tony, I see you are getting the forum vibes!!
-
If you're looking for a regionally inspired pseudonym; how about "I told 'em!". Pinched, of course, from the old TV advert for the once famous "Oldham Batteries". (Or am I just an old fart with a long memory?)
-
Not that I'm a strap expert (anything expert come to that) but I believe the bass strap is the one through which your wrist goes to hold the bass end of the instrument.
True Dat, as I believe the young people say.
Mally Straps (from Dave Mallinson Music) come highly recommended by various members here...but I've never used one. Didn;t someone recently say that had a selection of used ones available? Possibly Pete from Acorn?
-
Mally Straps (from Dave Mallinson Music) come highly recommended by various members here...but I've never used one. Didn;t someone recently say that had a selection of used ones available? Possibly Pete from Acorn?
I'm sure they're good, but I am more comfortable with Italian straps (so long as they're not too wide).
-
Practising tonight I now I had to wrap a flannel round the left hand strap to make it tight enough to pull on.
I’ve adjusted the wheel thingy to as tight as it goes.
Realised I was wearing a jumper last night and not tonight!
Ahhh. The pitfalls of clothing!
-
Practising tonight I now I had to wrap a flannel round the left hand strap to make it tight enough to pull on.
Hmm...that doesn't sound right. Accepting of course that there is no firm right or wrong with how you approach the melodeon if you're adjusting the strap that tight and using it to pull the melodeon bellows out you may well be setting yourself up for an injury as well as restricting your ability to reach all the bass buttons comfortably. Did I understand that right, you're relying on the bass strap to pull the bellows out?
-
Practising tonight I now I had to wrap a flannel round the left hand strap to make it tight enough to pull on.
I’ve adjusted the wheel thingy to as tight as it goes.
Realised I was wearing a jumper last night and not tonight!
Ahhh. The pitfalls of clothing!
Tight enough to pull on?......... well you may need to have a think about your use of the air button and your bellows control.
I have always marvelled at Ed Rennie's sublime technique.
He keeps the bellows almost closed nearly all the time. His thumb is just caressing the air button continuously.
It looks effortless !!
https://youtu.be/ad3YskV7w_I
-
I've always been surprised at how sensitive I am about the tightness of left hand bellows strap.
My old 'go to' box has a wheel on top of the box to tighten the strap, the top of the strap emerging from inside the bass end.
At the top of the strap the leather has two rivets holding the end of the leather where it fold over and goes into the innards, slacken the wheel and the strap loosens and the rivets move away from the box, turn it the other way and it tightens onto your hand and the rivets disappear into the case.
I realised after a while that the difference between 'loose' and 'just right' was minimal.
For my 'just right' setting I noticed that the rivets holding the leather were half way out of the case. By that I mean the edge of the casework came across the centre of the rivet head.
After playing for a while, the strap would slacken as there's play on the wheel tightening it.
When the rivet heads were almost clear of the casework, I will notice that the strap is too slack.
The difference in strap length is ~ 3mm!
If I feel it is too loose, then I'm loosing control of the bass end and my hand is slipping around.
Too tight is uncomfortable and restricting my movement.
'Just right' is a very slender adjustment of the bass strap!
Not sure how others feel, but the bass strap length is a very precise feeling for me.
Q
-
Practising tonight I now I had to wrap a flannel round the left hand strap to make it tight enough to pull on.
Hmm...that doesn't sound right. Accepting of course that there is no firm right or wrong with how you approach the melodeon if you're adjusting the strap that tight and using it to pull the melodeon bellows out you may well be setting yourself up for an injury as well as restricting your ability to reach all the bass buttons comfortably. Did I understand that right, you're relying on the bass strap to pull the bellows out?
Thanks, kind of. I’m not sure really how to draw the bellows if I’m not doing it with the back of my hand against the strap? Should I be pulling with my fingers somehow? This seem quite fundamental so I need to get it right.
I’m on the verge of posting a video in the beginners section so perhaps that may make my technique issues clearer.
Sincerely thanks for commenting.....it’s really good to discuss it and I appreciate you taking the time.
-
It helps if your bellows end is slightly lower than the treble end. Then the bass end gets a gravity assis downwards!
Only slightly though.....
Yes you use the back of your hand to pull them, and I think its the bottom of your thumb/heel to push.
I think what Helena was referring to was the use of a flannel!
You don't need it too tight to stop you being able to reach the bass buttons and move around the bass end, or too loose that your hand keeps slipping in the strap. Beyond that, the tightness is down to your personal preference.
If it is so slack you are padding it out, perhaps you need to tighten it a touch and experiment?
-
Thanks, kind of. I’m not sure really how to draw the bellows if I’m not doing it with the back of my hand against the strap?
Hi Tongle
I think what concerned me was your description of feeling you needed the strap so tight to achieve this that a flannel was needed - that doesn't sound comfortable for the hand.
I had to just go and pick up a box and try it out to see exactly how this all hangs together. The back of the hand certainly does pull against the bass strap but the whole hand is involved in moving the box, with a fair share of the work being done by the fingers and thumb.
I have the bass strap resting very close to the wrist joint so that most of my hand is free to move around the bass end - so the back of the hand isn't under any real pressure and the bass strap can be worn quite loose. I do remember my early days of playing though when I felt like I had to be strapped in to the box and the fixed bass strap on my Pokerwork felt alarmingly loose. I've also seen this tendency in other beginners since.
I am not suggesting that the way I do it is the 'right' way of course, it's merely that what you described sounded too restrictive and might cause injury. Everyone finds their own way and you will certainly find yours, it'll probably take a bit of experimentation along the way. Either way enjoy the journey.
-
The good news is that the thing with the tightness of the bass strap will come naturally as you play more. I suspect that what goes on in practice wrt holding the bass end has subtleties that we are unaware of. I think it's one of the things you can't force. It will happen. It's closely related to how you control the air button as well. The same thing happens with that, to the extent that you become unaware of how you're doing it, you just know it's happening.
It helps if your bellows end is slightly lower than the treble end. Then the bass end gets a gravity assis downwards!
Only slightly though.....
Mind you, some of us like a steeper drop than others.
This is me, about two years in
-
I think Helena and Greg reflect my experience.
I too had it tighter to begin with, and now find it looser.
Over time as you play more you relax more and strap position, box position etc. become less prominent in your mind. You settle on a position and concentrate more on the playing.
As Helena says, it's all part of the journey (:)
-
I think Helena and Greg reflect my experience.
I too had it tighter to begin with, and now find it looser.
Over time as you play more you relax more and strap position, box position etc. become less prominent in your mind. You settle on a position and concentrate more on the playing.
As Helena says, it's all part of the journey (:)
That is absolutely spot on!
-
...and be aware that, when you take the plunge and buy yourself a box with a twelve button, or more, bass the problem will come straight back at you. The cure is the same, though. Play it a lot.
-
Practising tonight I now I had to wrap a flannel round the left hand strap to make it tight enough to pull on.
I’ve adjusted the wheel thingy to as tight as it goes.
One of the finest players of the Irish persuasion Ms Sharon Shannon uses what looks like a gurt big car washing sponge...not recommending...just saying :|glug
-
.... but from what I understand, she simplifies things by removing the buttons. Is that right Baz???
-
Surely, buttons would scratch the car's paintwork?
-
...and be aware that, when you take the plunge and buy yourself a box with a twelve button, or more, bass the problem will come straight back at you. The cure is the same, though. Play it a lot.
Exactly. And given the possibility of M.A.D., you may well discover that every instrument differs, straps are never quite right - apparently changing length daily, and some types of clothing are better whilst playing one instrument or another - which has been commented on already I think. In my early playing days, I seemed to be always wearing holes in favourite jumpers with the bellows on my pokerwork - and waistcoat buttons are still problematic !
At the moment I'm sitting with three boxes in reaching distance as I'm trying the same tune on each, and I'm sure I hold each slightly differently - partly because of the different size and weight, but also because of instrument layout - G/C versus D/G, number of basses and so on.
Julian
-
.... and as Julian says, as boxes differ in size and weight, they balance differently so hang differently even if the straps are identical lengths.
Q
-
It is actually very reassuring that there appears to be so much variation and different advice.
In fact, I’ve been trawling through the videos on FB and YT and note that even the same player can vary their grip / strap position / balance point etc...depending on the box they are using or tune they are playing.
This means that, although there are some basic key points to consider, it seems ok to find a way which works for you. I love this more open and flexible approach. Some instrument I’ve learned seem quite formal and restrictive or at least there are minor tweaks to try.
Going in to my 3rd week of playing I’m feeling really motivated and excited to explore and discover. I’m also close to feeling like adding a video here in the beginner’s section and would greatly welcome more of the very helpful, honest and generous advice offered so far.
Thanks folks!
-
while of course its each to his own I advocate '' wearing'' rather than ''holding' the melodeon ( or button accordion from 2 row 8 bass to 3 row 96 bass. this leaves the left hand entirely free to provide delicate bellows control to make changes of volume (dynamics) easy and also facilitates playing with relativaly small bellows opening much of the time ( depending of course on the particular part of a particular tune.)
holding rather than wearing the treble end of theinstrument can only result in bellows movement dragging the treble end back and forth with absolutely no benefit whatsoever.
( one row playing can and usually is different)
george
-
.................I had to just go and pick up a box and try it out to see exactly how this all hangs together. The back of the hand certainly does pull against the bass strap but the whole hand is involved in moving the box, with a fair share of the work being done by the fingers and thumb.
I have the bass strap resting very close to the wrist joint so that most of my hand is free to move around the bass end - so the back of the hand isn't under any real pressure and the bass strap can be worn quite loose. I do remember my early days of playing though when I felt like I had to be strapped in to the box and the fixed bass strap on my Pokerwork felt alarmingly loose. I've also seen this tendency in other beginners since.
The left hand so far through that the strap is on your wrist? You may just have explained to me why I find it so awkward to do anything other than a two button bass with my fingers barely peeping round the corner of the box to just reach the bass buttons. (admittedly playing a 6 bass may not help).
-
tonight I found myself arching my hand to make contact with the strap. I really think I need to shorten the strap somehow.....must have skinny hands......so that it is snug but not tight.
May also try this wrist idea but not sure I could reach the air button.
Still need to find out what straps I need to buy so I can wear the box standing. Emailed Eagle music in Huddersfield but no reply yet!
-
Paedar: I just picked up the box to check exactly where the strap comes bearing in mind I have very small hands.
I find the back edge of the strap comes just in front of my wrist joint lump! This means the edge of the casework comes at the point where the fingers join my palm. Therefore my fingers stretch out across the buttons.
Tongle: yep, sounds like you need to tighten your strap!
I might have missed it, but what do you play, and how does your strap fix?
-
The left hand so far through that the strap is on your wrist? You may just have explained to me why I find it so awkward to do anything other than a two button bass with my fingers barely peeping round the corner of the box to just reach the bass buttons.
Hmmm... not quite. The strap sits just on the wrist joint rather than on the wrist proper. I play (mostly) three finger bass as my left little finger suffered a snapped tendon injury some years ago and never fully recovered. With this strap position I can reach all 8 (or 12 buttons) with the three fingers.
I certainly didn't start out playing like this and I recall it was Andy Cutting who persuaded me to try putting the hand through that little bit more. His demonstration convinced me it was worth the bit of re-learning required.
-
Still need to find out what straps I need to buy so I can wear the box standing. Emailed Eagle music in Huddersfield but no reply yet!
Intrigued now - what strap(s)* are you wearing to play the box sitting down? If your shoulder strap(s) aren't correctly adjusted this could explain part of the problem with the bass strap as you may be taking too much of the weight on the hand leading to this feeling that you need to pull harder with the left hand.
CGM (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Shoulder_Straps.html)is a good place to look for straps.
* Opinions vary on the correct number.
-
Another strap option:
The late Chris Ridley who plays a Hohner Corona 3 for Trigg Morris has a shoulder strap mounted on both ends of his box. Mind you he is the only one I have ever seen with it.
(http://www.triggmorris.co.uk/images/chris%20ridley-1.jpg)
-
If you do look at CGM, he also sells velcro adjustable bass straps. Something I was advised to do when having my old Hohner set up, but probably inappropriate if it's not an old Hohner!
-
Ah Lester's just posted:
I think I met the gentleman in the photo at an Ollie King workshop across the border about 3 years ago. He had another 2 row 8 bass Hohner then with the same type of strap arrangement.
He said something along the lines of when he started playing he'd not seen a melodeon before, had no idea about straps etc. so attached one to each end as he knew no different.
It seemed to work for him!
-
If you do look at CGM, he also sells velcro adjustable bass straps. Something I was advised to do when having my old Hohner set up, but probably inappropriate if it's not an old Hohner!
I think the OP has a box with a rotella bass strap so the velcro ones may not be compatible.
-
Ah thanks Helena, therefore please ignore this comment!!
-
If you do look at CGM, he also sells velcro adjustable bass straps. Something I was advised to do when having my old Hohner set up, but probably inappropriate if it's not an old Hohner!
I'm intrigued that velcro isn't more widely used on straps (not just bass ones). Is it seen as less secure? I'm always worried about strap buckles scratching the instrument. Even with covers over the end buckles, the middle buckle can do some real damage when the box is in its case.
Can't quite see from the photo but Mr Ridley's arrangement looks a bit like what players of heavier concertinas do, taking the weight but allowing movement of both sides of the instrument.
-
I'm intrigued that velcro isn't more widely used on straps (not just bass ones). Is it seen as less secure? I'm always worried about strap buckles scratching the instrument. Even with covers over the end buckles, the middle buckle can do some real damage when the box is in its case.
I recently took delivery of a lovely new G/C Serafini R2D2 from Marc Serafini and its shoulder straps use velcro to attach to the instrument, rather than buckles. They are very secure. There is still one buckle joining the two halves of the strap, but it is easy to keep that out of the way on the rare occasions it has been put in its gig bag :)
-
I used a velcro bass strap on a Hohner Amatona box and it was really good. Easily adjusted if necessary. I made my own sleeves for the buckles from
7cms wide elastic from a Haberdashery. Perfect for the job and only cost a few pence.
-
Can't quite see from the photo but Mr Ridley's arrangement looks a bit like what players of heavier concertinas do, taking the weight but allowing movement of both sides of the instrument.
Like this?
http://www.concertinaconnection.com/neck_cord.htm
[Ah, found it... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kSsBwO2PTVE]
-
That's it. One of our ECs has inserts ready to take screw-in hooks for such an arrangment. Anne Gregson used to play this way for morris - maybe her baritone. Interesting video thanks. I was relieved his trousers didn't fall down.
-
Can't quite see from the photo but Mr Ridley's arrangement looks a bit like what players of heavier concertinas do, taking the weight but allowing movement of both sides of the instrument.
I guess it makes more sense on the concertina where the box is smaller and lighter and (generally) held further away from the body - also the bellows tend to be moved through a wider range of motion. On the larger melodeon with more fixed bellows movement it could impede the movement of the bellows. As ever, each to their own and all that.
One of the most refreshing things about playing melodeon is that there is no defined right and wrong while one of the most frustrating things about playing melodeon is that there if no defined right and wrong ::)
-
One of the odd things about Chris Ridley's strap arrangement is that it conflicts with the natural asymmetry of the melodeon and the convention that the RH end of the instrument is held steady while the LH end makes all the movement. The arrangement of the bass strap makes it quite clear that the LH end is the one you are
supposed expected to waggle around to work the bellows.
Concertinas are obviously much more symmetrical, at least in size, shape and weight of ends and way of holding them.
-
If you do look at CGM, he also sells velcro adjustable bass straps. Something I was advised to do when having my old Hohner set up, but probably inappropriate if it's not an old Hohner!
Thanks....mine is a Hohner Morgane ii so not very old. Certainly seems I need it at least a bit tighter. I read that you can open the box and take a small slice off the strap to make it shorter. May investigate this.
I’ve ordered some shoulder straps for Squeezboxmarketplace which may do the trick. It was suggested I try wearing it rather than holding it so I’m going to give that a go.
Interestingly, the more I’m playing the more relaxed I’m getting and it seems easier though I have to remind myself to relax. It will take some more experimentation but a cloth under my hand is also helping a lot.
-
Interestingly, the more I’m playing the more relaxed I’m getting.
Not that I told you so but
I suspect that part of your problem is that you have only been playing two weeks, in this time everything tends to be tensed up.
(:)
-
Still need to find out what straps I need to buy so I can wear the box standing. Emailed Eagle music in Huddersfield but no reply yet!
Intrigued now - what strap(s)* are you wearing to play the box sitting down? If your shoulder strap(s) aren't correctly adjusted this could explain part of the problem with the bass strap as you may be taking too much of the weight on the hand leading to this feeling that you need to pull harder with the left hand.
CGM (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Shoulder_Straps.html)is a good place to look for straps.
* Opinions vary on the correct number.
I’m just using the single strap it came with which is approx 100cm long. I have it across my elbow as I’ve seen other do and there is what feel like a suitable amount of tension (not too much, not too little).
I just feel that there is too much air between the back of my hand and the bass strap even though it is fully tightened. It isn’t a padded bass strap so maybe that’s part of the problem.
-
Interestingly, the more I’m playing the more relaxed I’m getting.
Not that I told you so but
I suspect that part of your problem is that you have only been playing two weeks, in this time everything tends to be tensed up.
(:)
Well exactly Lester...I had you in mind when I posted that. It was sound advice and very gratefully received!
-
... I read that you can open the box and take a small slice off the strap to make it shorter. May investigate this...
There is some relevant discussion in this thread:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=17842.0
-
:|||:
... I read that you can open the box and take a small slice off the strap to make it shorter. May investigate this...
There is some relevant discussion in this thread:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=17842.0
Great thanks...I’ll go check it out!👍
-
In the meantime, stick a sponge or a flannel over the back of your hand. Good luck over the next part of the learning curve.
-
An offcut of plastic foam pipe insulation slipped over the bass strap is a nice comfortable way to get a snug fit from a loose strap.
-
An offcut of plastic foam pipe insulation slipped over the bass strap is a nice comfortable way to get a snug fit from a loose strap.
Now that’s a damn fine suggestion! B&Q opens till late tonight! ;D
-
An offcut of plastic foam pipe insulation slipped over the bass strap is a nice comfortable way to get a snug fit from a loose strap.
Now that’s a damn fine suggestion! B&Q opens till late tonight! ;D
Or for something a bit tidier you could try a car seatbelt cover (https://www.amazon.co.uk/GAMPRO-2-Pack-Comfortable-Shoulder-Children/dp/B07WDP7DCP/ref=sr_1_1_sspa?adgrpid=53572632136&dchild=1&gclid=CjwKCAiAlNf-BRB_EiwA2osbxaqS38WH3Y6S2D0Y8v_8lmsMyX-eyfRxrOX21YrU3EmmWaqvr2AHdxoCflQQAvD_BwE&hvadid=259012175028&hvdev=c&hvlocphy=1006490&hvnetw=g&hvqmt=e&hvrand=5475272299045729592&hvtargid=kwd-488672872512&hydadcr=7262_1812241&keywords=car+seat+belt+pads&qid=1607875115&sr=8-1-spons&tag=googhydr-21&psc=1&spLa=ZW5jcnlwdGVkUXVhbGlmaWVyPUFBV0VDN0RUWDRPRjQmZW5jcnlwdGVkSWQ9QTAzMjUwMDMzUTZGRkRLMTJYN1oyJmVuY3J5cHRlZEFkSWQ9QTA5MzE3NDIzU1pUNFJSVjBWNDVOJndpZGdldE5hbWU9c3BfYXRmJmFjdGlvbj1jbGlja1JlZGlyZWN0JmRvTm90TG9nQ2xpY2s9dHJ1ZQ==)
-
I have used the seat belt pad cover idea and it works perfectly. I think I first heard the recommendation here on this forum a while back. Great because with the velcro fastening you can easily transfer it from box to box should you get another box that needs it. Takes up the needed space and cushions the back of the hand. Nice for arthritic hands 8-)
-
Whatever will you folks think of next....car seatbelt cover indeed!
Great idea!