Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Theo on June 24, 2013, 09:23:42 AM
-
Prompted by the recent posting from Mel Biggs (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,12594.0.html) I'm thinking it would be a good idea to add a list of teachers to the front page, along with the links to dealers, repairers etc. This would make the information easier to find than in the current rather lengthy "Melodeon tuition Network" thread in here.
Is this a good idea?
What information would be useful to include?
-
Great idea Theo. I'll have a think about what I'd like to see. Maybe price of tuition should be hidden as this could prove awkward for individual teachers.
Maybe a map of the UK showing teachers, dealers and repairers - with appropriate icons - might be nice?
Les
-
I am pro this change, also willing to teach.
I have a "melodeon" Facebook page, that basically refers people here rather than competes. Got its first "need a teacher" PM 2 weeks ago. Hope he took my advice, but yes, the "network" it is quite well hidden. :|glug
I also think we should cross reference what is being said in the price of instruments thread to this one somehow. They are sort of linked?
-
Prompted by the recent posting from Mel Biggs (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,12594.0.html) I'm thinking it would be a good idea to add a list of teachers to the front page, along with the links to dealers, repairers etc. This would make the information easier to find than in the current rather lengthy "Melodeon tuition Network" thread in here.
Is this a good idea?
What information would be useful to include?
Yes, I think this is a good idea. I teach melodeon and concertina and would be happy for my name to appear in a listing, along with the instruments I teach and the level/standard (e.g. melodeon and anglo concertina, beginners/intermediate).
The more difficult part would be to decide what degree of personal contact details should appear on the listing. I guess some people would be happy with more information than others. For me, an e-mail address and general location would be fine, but I wouldn't want an address or phone number to be listed.
Rees (of this forum) provides a Noticeboard on his website where tuition is offered by people.
http://www.melodeons.com
(scroll down toward the bottom of the page)
-
Seems easy enough. Want debutants to tune into this forum anyway (maybe not the Limerick thread ;) ) so the section should invite registration, then we make arrangements by PM. Didn't we discuss this when the "network" idea was launched?
Good luck getting clarinet pupils form here incidentally, but hope springs eternal! ;D
Whoops, Steve didn't mention his top instrument! Btw - emails best kept off robot readable web pages, surely? Isn't that what PMs are all about?
And should the front page just be for professional teachers, I wouldn't be interested in money, and happy to stay in the network. This was the original concept.
-
Would be useful to include some idea of styles available, for instance I teach beginner/intermediate but only in English/Morris/Ceilidh not cross row style.
Disagree with Chris re email addresses, my melodeon based addresses are freely available on the net and I get little of no more spam on them than on my more restricted addresses.
-
Would be useful to include some idea of styles available, for instance I teach beginner/intermediate but only in English/Morris/Ceilidh not cross row style.
Yes, good point, Lester!
-
Very sound suggestion; I haven't had any luck in finding a teacher in Brighton to sharpen me up when I move there next week. Hope springs eternal.... :||: ::)
-
As one who teaches the box I am duty bound to second everything everybody has said - count me in please!!!
george ;)
-
Very sound suggestion; I haven't had any luck in finding a teacher in Brighton to sharpen me up when I move there next week. Hope springs eternal.... :||: ::)
Have you tried LJC http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4132.20.html
-
I'd be happy to be included, but I don't think I'll get many takers wanting to learn English-style melodeon in Cyprus........
-
Good question about contact details - I suggest that it should be the teacher decision what contact details to give, with the advice that private addresses should not be published.
-
It all seems good to me, though I like the cost to be apparent before following up with personal contact - it can be awkard to say' thanks, but no thanks' once you know the cost.
-
It all seems good to me, though I like the cost to be apparent before following up with personal contact - it can be awkard to say' thanks, but no thanks' once you know the cost.
Hmmm... I think cost is something to be negotiated in private. I also tend to be flexible regarding what I charge, usually according to the attitude and ability of the person to pay. 'Poor but keen and willing to practice' will tend to get more sympathy from me than 'affluent and can't be bothered to do any work'. :o
I usually offer a new student a free or low-cost initial trial lesson (perhaps half-length), so we can both see if we are going to get on and want to continue at the full rate, whatever it might be.
-
There would be some practical difficulties with posting prices, pricing can vary depending on the type of teaching. Individual, group, one-off, series, teachers location or students. There is also a risk of starting a price war. I think the most important thing we can do is to provide contact information, comments here suggest there is a need for that. There are ways if asking for prices that can avoid embarrassment. "I'm just making a general enquiry..." Etc
-
It all seems good to me, though I like the cost to be apparent before following up with personal contact - it can be awkard to say' thanks, but no thanks' once you know the cost.
On the other hand, those of us who basically do it for peanuts, do not want to feel that they are taking out the ones who do it "professionally". I'd certainly want to advertise the "Slow and Steady" session and associated tuition, but not at professional rates.
-
Thanks Theo, I've pm'ed LJC. Fingers crossed... (:)
-
I strongly agree with the idea of a list of instructors and dealers/repairers. This would be a win win situation for everyone. I am sure that the teachers and dealers would like some free publicity and those of us who seek their services will have a much easier time locating them. A list of builders might also be welcome. Simply ask the instructors, builders and dealers/repairers to send in basic info about their services along with simple contact info. Keep it organized by instructors, builders and dealer/repair and alphabetize it and that should work very nicely. :||:
-
Brian, I've got LJCs details - he was my teacher before I moved.
Not sure how often he logs melnet, so if silence, be happy to put you in touch. You'll also find him in the small ads on Rees's page.
If I remember things right (unusual) he might even be in tottering distance of you.
-
.
Hmmm... I think cost is something to be negotiated in private. I also tend to be flexible regarding what I charge, usually according to the attitude and ability of the person to pay. 'Poor but keen and willing to practice' will tend to get more sympathy from me than 'affluent and can't be bothered to do any work'. :o
I
When I lived in a densely populated area ( before moving to Anglesey) I often visited would be students to discuss their requirements and to try to ascertain whether we could work well together etc. If there was a brand new Range Rover or similarly expensive bit of kit parked outside I adjusted my price accordingly!
george
-
I strongly agree with the idea of a list of instructors and dealers/repairers. This would be a win win situation for everyone. I am sure that the teachers and dealers would like some free publicity and those of us who seek their services will have a much easier time locating them. A list of builders might also be welcome. Simply ask the instructors, builders and dealers/repairers to send in basic info about their services along with simple contact info. Keep it organized by instructors, builders and dealer/repair and alphabetize it and that should work very nicely. :||:
We already have a list of builders, though we've used the word maker instead it is the same thing.
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,makers.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,makers.html)
-
Lyra, you're very kind. Could you pm me with LJC's contact address? :||: ;D
-
I agree with others that this is a good idea. However, it may be worth having two sections in the list of teachers. Section 1 would be for 'professional' teachers and those who regularly teach at workshops, festivals, etc. Section 2 would be for those, like myself, who do not teach on a regular basis but who responded to the suggestion made on a thread a few years ago to set up a national network and offered our services, such as they are, to cover geographical areas that are not covered by the 'professional' teachers. Dividing the list into these two sections would enable prospective students to see at a glance whether a teacher they are considering is a regular or professional teacher or someone who does not claim to perform or teach at a high level but is willing to help those are are not as far along the learning curve as themselves.
-
I think that Bob's suggestion is a workable one.
-
It all seems good to me, though I like the cost to be apparent before following up with personal contact - it can be awkard to say' thanks, but no thanks' once you know the cost.
On the other hand, those of us who basically do it for peanuts, do not want to feel that they are taking out the ones who do it "professionally". I'd certainly want to advertise the "Slow and Steady" session and associated tuition, but not at professional rates.
I likewise would not want to tread on a professionals heals, but am very happy to pass on my incredibly bad habits free gratis. If anyone in my area would like to come around for an hour or two of total mayhem, they are most welcome.
Malcolm Bebb, don't start! >:E
-
I think the idea is good.
Primarily I would want to know location, then style - e.g someone who teaches or coaches English style in Poole/Bournemouth, or something like that.
Don't see a great need to split professional/non-professional as it could be difficult to clarify the boundaries. Anyone prepared to host slow sessions should also be included.
So:
1) Location - crucial
2) Style(s) - most helpful
3) Date of posting - may be updated at will, but helpful to identify out of date info. Mandatory.
4) Type of learning - free form, but e.g: by the hour, informal coaching, slow session etc. Include price, or not, optional.
5) Link to web site or non-melnet contact info. Phone and email at advertiser's risk. Optional
6) Link to melnet PM - Mandatory, but presumably easy.
Then for some:
7) List of bad habits - only legal ones. (PM for the others ;) )
-
Not trivial is it? BTW I find 'makers' more intuitive than 'builders' - my builder's called Bob ;)
-
Lyra, I've made contact with Luca. Thanks..... (:)
-
Yay! I hope you get on.
I miss my lessons :(
-
Yes please Theo - I like Malcolm's suggested list of information (though not sure my list of bad habits would fit neatly within the character limit ;) )
I, personally, would be happy with publishing my email and phone number, as it is already available on Rees' website.
Maybe is prospective teachers/repairers/craftspeople PM Theo with the info they want published?
On another note, I taught a BA pilot today his first melodeon lesson! He came to me interested in learning a portable instrument and after hearing a family member play the box, he chose the melodeon. Considering today was the first time he'd ever held one, he did incredibly well and even managed to successfully use the air button WHILST PLAYING! Other beginner's I've taught go into some sort of spasm when they try and use the air button. Must be something to do with him being used to lots of buttons and levers in his cockpit... :)
-
I looked through the Melodeon Tuition network thinking I could start using details from there, but a lot of it is quite old so I've set up this topic (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,12614.0.html)where you can submit details if you are a teacher and want to be included in the listing.
-
Good evening, have you ever thought to offer for online classes? With the resources available today is not so difficult to make a video or simply a recording of the performance, and send it to the teacher. Maybe you should think of a list of teachers willing to teach online. I think many players away from your country might be interested (and of course for a fee)
-
Thank you for the details submitted so far. I've edited the information quite considerably. Please take a look at the Teachers page (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,teachers.html) and check that I've not altered the meaning of your information. I have taken out references to fees.
-
Good evening, have you ever thought to offer for online classes? With the resources available today is not so difficult to make a video or simply a recording of the performance, and send it to the teacher. Maybe you should think of a list of teachers willing to teach online. I think many players away from your country might be interested (and of course for a fee)
Good point, but this really is a separate topic.
-
All those who gave their details as teachers have now been added to the Teachers page (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,teachers.html). Any more?