Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: Andrew Culwell on July 04, 2013, 04:57:30 PM

Title: Irish but divine!
Post by: Andrew Culwell on July 04, 2013, 04:57:30 PM
http://vimeo.com/31135924
Title: Re: Irish but divine!
Post by: John C on July 04, 2013, 05:36:14 PM
Wow, very nice - I enjoyed watching this

Thanks for posting

Title: Re: Irish but divine!
Post by: tedrick on July 04, 2013, 07:05:26 PM
first class!
Title: Re: Irish but divine!
Post by: Stiamh on July 04, 2013, 07:37:28 PM
Did you mean Irish and divine?

Or American - but still Irish, and still divine?
Title: Re: Irish but divine!
Post by: Keithypete. on July 04, 2013, 09:06:27 PM
Very nice indeed.

I wonder - is that a new Paolo Jubilee grey box?
Title: Re: Irish but divine!
Post by: tedrick on July 04, 2013, 10:43:53 PM
no - pretty sure it is an older grey - Sean has been playing this box for a while -
R
Title: Re: Irish but divine!
Post by: deltasalmon on July 05, 2013, 02:37:49 AM
Very nice indeed.

I wonder - is that a new Paolo Jubilee grey box?

How can you tell its not a red box with the greyscale video ?  ;)
Title: Re: Irish but divine!
Post by: deltasalmon on July 09, 2013, 01:19:31 AM
Anyone know the tune name(s)?
Title: Re: Irish but divine!
Post by: Stiamh on July 09, 2013, 02:15:07 AM
Anyone know the tune name(s)?

The Torn Jacket (composed by Connie O'Connell) & Come West along the Road
Title: Re: Irish but divine!
Post by: deltasalmon on July 09, 2013, 02:18:16 AM
Anyone know the tune name(s)?

The Torn Jacket (composed by Connie O'Connell) & Come West along the Road

Darn, I should have held back from posting. I made it this far trying to pick it up by ear:

Code: [Select]
X:1
T:Gan Ainm
M:4/4
L:1/8
K:D
A2G2|F2FA d2ed|cAAB cde2|F2FA d2ed|cAGE EDD2|
F2FA d2ed|cAAB cdec|dcde
Title: Re: Irish but divine!
Post by: Cooper on July 09, 2013, 11:38:59 AM
http://vimeo.com/31135924

I've watched the whole thing. Like it sometimes is difficult to see the difference between 100 Chinese when you are not CHinese yourself, i fail to see why this is divine and other Irish is not. But i am very interested to hear what it is for you (and others) that makes this divine. Would you mind bringing light to some poor soul in the dark?
:-)
W
Title: Re: Irish but divine!
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 09, 2013, 12:29:18 PM
Wouter, you sensibly went home from Brabbant on Sunday night I think, but I was woken at 5am Monday by the Flemish youth clique, 2 loud drums, Irish and Bourbonnais stuff at about double dansable speed; their Bombarde (!) player was dancing on the table when I got there. I stayed cool and *Maredesous makes quite a pleasant breakfast 8)

Hope this helps clarify "not divine" end of the spectrum  .. and shall we say that not all Dutchmen look or sound the same any more  ;)
*my latest Belgian beer discovery
Title: Re: Irish but divine!
Post by: Stiamh on July 09, 2013, 01:36:18 PM
i fail to see why this is divine and other Irish is not. But i am very interested to hear what it is for you (and others) that makes this divine.

Speaking as one of the "others"....

a) he may have meant, as I implied earlier, Irish and divine. I'd go along with that (the playing is accomplished, and the spontaneity and intimacy is touching) and this would imply no judgment about the divinity or otherwise of other offerings.

b) if the "but" was intentional, perhaps he meant "Irish music that you lot might like given that you don't seem to like it when it's fast" - see my comments under the Ego Trip thread.  (:)
Title: Re: Irish but divine!
Post by: Cooper on July 09, 2013, 06:58:25 PM
Wouter, you sensibly went home from Brabbant on Sunday night I think, but I was woken at 5am Monday by the Flemish youth clique, 2 loud drums, Irish and Bourbonnais stuff at about double dansable speed; their Bombarde (!) player was dancing on the table when I got there. I stayed cool and *Maredesous makes quite a pleasant breakfast 8)
Sunday morning actually so it pains me to hear what i have missed out on ;-)

Hope this helps clarify "not divine" end of the spectrum  .. and shall we say that not all Dutchmen look or sound the same any more  ;)
*my latest Belgian beer discovery

Maredsous is one of my favorite not-that-heavy-ones too, but it doesnt really clarify :-)
W
Title: Re: Irish but divine!
Post by: Cooper on July 09, 2013, 07:01:00 PM
i fail to see why this is divine and other Irish is not. But i am very interested to hear what it is for you (and others) that makes this divine.

Speaking as one of the "others"....

a) the playing is accomplished, and the spontaneity and intimacy is touching

why accomplished when compared to other Irish music that i might know? The intimacy i can see, and yeah, i quite like that too,
W
Title: Re: Irish but divine!
Post by: Stiamh on July 09, 2013, 07:10:04 PM
i fail to see why this is divine and other Irish is not. But i am very interested to hear what it is for you (and others) that makes this divine.

Speaking as one of the "others"....

a) the playing is accomplished, and the spontaneity and intimacy is touching

why accomplished when compared to other Irish music that i might know? The intimacy i can see, and yeah, i quite like that too,
W

Who is making comparisons apart from you?

Or are you looking for a sign - stigmata perhaps - as proof of divinity?  ;)
Title: Re: Irish but divine!
Post by: Cooper on July 09, 2013, 07:53:56 PM
i fail to see why this is divine and other Irish is not. But i am very interested to hear what it is for you (and others) that makes this divine.

Speaking as one of the "others"....

a) the playing is accomplished, and the spontaneity and intimacy is touching

why accomplished when compared to other Irish music that i might know? The intimacy i can see, and yeah, i quite like that too,
W

Who is making comparisons apart from you?

Or are you looking for a sign - stigmata perhaps - as proof of divinity?  ;)

That would be so awesome :-)

But let's get rid of the word divine. I AM trying to find out something real. Apparently some people like this video with Irish music a lot. I am assuming they like it better than other videos with Irish music, or they would have put those on here with nice words.

I don't get hot or cold from this video, actually i was getting quite bored after the first 30 secs or so ("one of those again"), but i thought to myself "well, apparently this is good, so let's try and find what others saw and heared."

I couldnt. so here i am trying to find out what it is i am missing that other people do hear. Like i said, i am not that much into Irish music, so it isn't unlikely at all i am missing those subtle nuances that make this so good. And perhaps that isnt possible to put into words so simply, or you actually must have heared all the other Irish music to find out why this is good.

And it could all be taste ofcourse, in that case it is going to be a fun discussion with no consensus in the end :-). We've got this saying in Dutch: "over smaak valt niet te twisten" somthing like "you cant argue about taste". I completely disagree with that saying, i think it is a lot of fun to do so :-). You probably cant persuade someone to change their taste though :-).

W
Title: Re: Irish but divine!
Post by: Stiamh on July 09, 2013, 08:07:20 PM
The French have the same saying, "Des goûts, on ne discute pas". The English version is a little more cynical - "There's no accounting for taste".

I think you're looking for confirmation of something that you suppose is there in this video, but isn't really. To my eye whole thing is utterly unpretentious - a snapshot of two musicians enjoying the moment. Why look beyond that? Sean McComiskey is a very good box player indeed, and I have no doubt that the young lady is a skilled player too.

But neither is trying to show off. Just to play the tune nicely with the other musician present, to blend in a way that satisfies them and anyone else who knows that style of music, which is really what most people playing Irish music are trying to do. And not to impress people who aren't "into Irish music". So it's really no surprise to me if you aren't impressed.

Now can you tell me why I (for example) should not be bored by the melodic meanderings of (for example) Didier Laloy? No, I didn't think so.  ;)


Title: Re: Irish but divine!
Post by: Cooper on July 09, 2013, 08:53:23 PM
The French have the same saying, "Des goûts, on ne discute pas". The English version is a little more cynical - "There's no accounting for taste".

I think you're looking for confirmation of something that you suppose is there in this video, but isn't really. To my eye whole thing is utterly unpretentious - a snapshot of two musicians enjoying the moment. Why look beyond that? Sean McComiskey is a very good box player indeed, and I have no doubt that the young lady is a skilled player too.

But neither is trying to show off. Just to play the tune nicely with the other musician present, to blend in a way that satisfies them and anyone else who knows that style of music, which is really what most people playing Irish music are trying to do. And not to impress people who aren't "into Irish music". So it's really no surprise to me if you aren't impressed.

Now can you tell me why I (for example) should not be bored by the melodic meanderings of (for example) Didier Laloy? No, I didn't think so.  ;)

The fact that they do not show off is actually very much to my liking, but i guess i started this question on the wrong video then.

I am not a big Laloy adept either, but in general (and Laloy is a good example) i tend to like the music a lot when it gives some more insight into the one who it is playing the tune. Or on the conversation (and this definitly does NOT have to be impro) the musicians have musically, the story telling. And it is odd, because when i hear an Irishman tell (or sing) actual stories i am usually a lot more impressed.

W
Title: Re: Irish but divine!
Post by: Cooper on July 11, 2013, 02:01:44 PM
Hey, i was sure i saw a response to my message earlier, with lots of good stuff said that i had to chew on for a bit more. Where did it go? (general idea was "know the music better and you will hear the nuances, right?)

W

Title: Re: Irish but divine!
Post by: Stiamh on July 11, 2013, 04:32:22 PM
Hey, i was sure i saw a response to my message earlier, with lots of good stuff said that i had to chew on for a bit more. Where did it go? (general idea was "know the music better and you will hear the nuances, right?)

I thought my pontificating was verging on the pretentious, so I removed it. But yes, you retained the essence correctly. I'd say you can't truly appreciate any genre of music unless you are willing to spend a bit of time getting to know its history and subtleties.
Title: Re: Irish but divine!
Post by: Cooper on July 11, 2013, 07:51:10 PM
Hey, i was sure i saw a response to my message earlier, with lots of good stuff said that i had to chew on for a bit more. Where did it go? (general idea was "know the music better and you will hear the nuances, right?)

I thought my pontificating was verging on the pretentious, so I removed it. But yes, you retained the essence correctly. I'd say you can't truly appreciate any genre of music unless you are willing to spend a bit of time getting to know its history and subtleties.

I don't mind being lectured, if it is good stuff i get lectured about :-)

I agree with you up till a certain level. I am even less into classical music, or pop, then into Irish, yet, i can feel more "story" when done right then i feel here. I just watched and listened to it again. And i can see the two having fun together, but i don't hear them having fun at those moments. To me they are just playing the same tune together. And, dont get me wrong i can see they've got a good control over both their instruments as over the tunes. But i would say this is more "craftsmanship" than art.
W
Title: Re: Irish but divine!
Post by: Gromit on July 11, 2013, 09:30:14 PM
Quote
But i would say this is more "craftsmanship" than art.

Interesting - do you have an example of accordian playing that is art?
Title: Re: Irish but divine!
Post by: Cooper on July 11, 2013, 10:22:52 PM
Quote
But i would say this is more "craftsmanship" than art.

Interesting - do you have an example of accordian playing that is art?
Andy Cutting? to stay on common ground here :-) Ofcourse it is all a bit subjective.

The difference for me is: craftsmanship: being able to use a great number of techniques without much hassle, regardless of speed etc. Also craftsmanship: doing your job properly (such as playing the dancetune in a way that all dancers are happy, or playing an accompinment in such a way that the singer can sing his song nicely)

art: all of the above but chosing which technique to use when in order to get the effect you want. All in service of whatever story/message/feeling you want to be heared. And succeeding in that getting heared.

W
Title: Re: Irish but divine!
Post by: Gromit on July 12, 2013, 12:00:48 AM
Quote
Andy Cutting? to stay on common ground here :-) Ofcourse it is all a bit subjective.

Fair enough he's a good player, is his playing art compared to Sean McComiskey? not to me but as you say it is all a bit subjective. I would be surprised if either of them thought about their music in that way - after all it's only folk music ;)
Title: Re: Irish but divine!
Post by: nfldbox on July 12, 2013, 08:34:01 PM
Perhaps a musicologist might see it differently but I cannot for the life of me see how one form of music is inferior to another. Some I like, some I don't. An "expert" in a certain genre can tell you why one performance is better than another or why one composition is better than an another. As an outsider I am often impressed by complexity or dexterity and then someone who knows more than I will point out why that complexity is contrary to the genre being performed. And then of course there is the inevitable controversy even among the "experts." Which is why so many of us who play Irish gave up on thesession.org.
Title: Re: Irish but divine!
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 12, 2013, 10:23:52 PM
I'm entirely with you wrt "forms of music" but I hope I know good stuff when I hear it. I'd say the same about "crap", but the less I understand the genre the more cautious I try to be.

I'd offer our recent Caucasian thread as an example of music initially rather startling to the ear, and getting better and  better with a bit of exploration.

That's to say that say that within whatever genre there is the good, the bad, and the manifestly ugly.
Title: Re: Irish but divine!
Post by: Andrew Culwell on September 15, 2013, 02:02:14 AM
Not sure why my little title inspired such debate.  The wording had no special meaning or code, Mel.net is dominated by players of box music mostly British and Continental with an emphasis on British folk. Ergo my statement that the piece is Irish, I like occasional hyperbole so I stated divine.  Is the piece actually divine, hardly!  I'm a fan of young Mr Mcomiskey (not to mention Mcomiskey the elder) and I find his youth and musicality inspiring.  Pardon my hyperbole and enjoy the playing....or not. 
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal