Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: george garside on January 19, 2009, 11:25:46 AM
-
not sure whether this posting should be here or under instrument construction but here goes. Prompted by recent postings under teaching & learning re 12 bass systems ( and for that matter 8 bass as well) has anybody come up with - whether built or just at present a 'good idea' something a bit different..either to give overall improvement over the standard systems or perhaps for some specialised use.
To start the ball rolling an idea I have toyed with and which should be 'makeable' would be to have 12 bass in the normal 2 rows but with 7 on one row and 5 on the other, These would be single notes pitched as a continuation down from the low notes on treble end and laayed out so the 'white' notes were on the '7' row and the 'black' noteson teh '5' row i.e. exactly the samae as on a piano keybord. The bass notes would be same on suck & blow. In theory & with a bit of practice it would be possible to either play the tune on the bass end an octave lower than on the treble or play a wide veriety of chords using the required combination of buttons
This is just in the 'daft ideas' department at the moment - any more daft ideas out there
george
-
Isn't that a variation on a free bass accordion (usually set out like a CBA keyboard though?)
Not sure I can see the point though for a DG although I suppose you could have the same bass end for all quint boxes. Would make more sense (to me at least) for a CbC or a DbD box ;D. However, if I played one of these semi-tone boxes I'd thought of having all the notes in a 2x6 matrix although I hadn't got as far as which note goes with each button.
-
Isn't that a variation on a free bass accordion (usually set out like a CBA keyboard though?)
Not sure I can see the point though for a DG although I suppose you could have the same bass end for all quint boxes. Would make more sense (to me at least) for a CbC or a DbD box ;D. However, if I played one of these semi-tone boxes I'd thought of having all the notes in a 2x6 matrix although I hadn't got as far as which note goes with each button.
was thinkin in terms of semitone (chromatic) boxes but forgot to say so! & yes similar but different to free bass!
george
-
I made a replacement bass reed block that gave me same-both-ways single note
C C# D E F# G A B on the 8 bass buttons (so I had all the notes of D and G.) It had two reeds in octaves on each button.
Obviously single notes were playable as well as the triads and two note "chords."
I played with it for a while, but compared with the convenience of bass/chord buttons it didn't convince and I took it out.
(Obviously there were issues of chord inversions, which I hoped the octave reeds would minimise, but inversions are surely inherent in Stradella bass?)
Tom
-
Emmanuel Pariselle has a very nifty compromise arrangement with 12 bass buttons. The middle 8 buttons are set up with the standard bass and chord layout. There are two "extra" buttons at each end of the rows that have just additional basses. I don't have a record of the notes to hand, but those 4 extra buttons can be set up with different notes on in and out which is sufficient to give a chromatic bass plus two more reversals. The Saltarelle Tramontane (no longer made) had a 14 bass configuration along the same lines but with a couple of extra chords too. I fancy that model may have been designed by Emmanuel.
-
Hiya Theo. Salterelle got me to design a layout for that 14 bass instrument. Unfortunatley i dont have the layout anymore but i met someone who bought one and loved it.
-
That's very interesting Andy. Did Emmanuel get the idea from you do you think?
-
Andy,
I don't know who thought up the idea, but I was told it was you, and brilliant it is. On my two D/G Tamontanes, one of which Theo has fettled from the French layout, the 13th and 14th buttons are all bass accidentals, giving full LH chromatography. But the great thing is that you can then easily play them with your pinky, and achieve the thirds (F# push, C# pull) in the D row. Real Rock and Roll! Plus, all the limitations of the non-chomatic layout vanish, with a bit of practice. My philosophy of the D/G box has been to play the LH constantly, as if it was Piano accordion, and then get the RH to fit, and your layout made it possible.
But I'm perplexed, why didn't you take it up as the obvious answer? Georges Roux seemed reluctant to make me another one, and I think that is because the there is a technical prob with the LH third removal button. Is that it? If so, I'm sure it can be solved.
Chris Brimley
-
... 12 bass in the normal 2 rows but with 7 on one row and 5 on the other, These would be single notes pitched as a continuation down from the low notes on treble end and laayed out so the 'white' notes were on the '7' row and the 'black' noteson teh '5' row i.e. exactly the samae as on a piano keybord. The bass notes would be same on suck & blow.
Yes, it's been done - Frans Van der Aa has built one like this for Brendan Doyle... (http://www.mijnalbum.nl/GroteFoto-QMBYSYPC.jpg)
Frans will accomodate all manner of individual ideas, like a 16 Stradella bass end (http://www.mijnalbum.nl/GroteFoto-LNVING7E.jpg) for Dominique Colpaert, or the 18 Stradella bass (http://www.mijnalbum.nl/GroteFoto-EN3COLJK.jpg) Cóndor (which has a 4 voice, 2+2 key-switching R/H end). I presume the chords are set up as neutral/thirdless...
Ed J
-
My Dony is a standard D/G with extras but it came with the bass layout nearest the knee with the four extra basses nearest the chin. It was very difficult to play so I considered the order of descending flats ala Stradella. I moved the normal 8 buttons toward the chin and the four extras toward the knee. It became both easy and intuitive to play.
I've recently got a three row Sterishe from Udo Schneeburg with the German key layout, unisonic notes in the right hand and offset basses. If I had learned to play this from the beginning it may have been a better layout than standard quint but I find it very difficult to naturally go where I haven't been going for more than 30 years. So no matter how good a new layout may be, transition can be painful.
Martin
-
Andy,
You mentioned you didn't have the 14 bass layout any more - I think this is it, isn't it?:
Amaj/Emaj A/E Dmaj/Amaj D/A Gmaj/Dmaj G/D F#/C#
Basses:
A#maj/Fmaj A#/F Bmaj/Emin B/E Cmaj/Cmaj C/C D#/G#
The three rows:
E/D D#/F A#/G# C/A# E/D D#/F A#/G#
G/C B/E D/F# G/A B/C D/E G/F# B/A D/C G/E
D/G F#/B A/C# D/E F#/G A/B D/C# F#/E A/G D/B F#/C#
My second Tramontane has one extra button on each end of the RH third row, which Theo set up as C/A# at the low end and the top end.
Chris
-
Yes, it's been done - Frans Van der Aa has built one like this for Brendan Doyle... (http://www.mijnalbum.nl/GroteFoto-QMBYSYPC.jpg)
Ed J
looks good, so much for my attempt to re-invent the wheel
george ;)
-
Possibly far more useful than re-inventing the wheel. Some near forgotten inspiration has been brought to a new public! Well done!
-
Another approach for halfstep boxes is this one (lifted from Han Speek's page (http://www.xs4all.nl/~hspeek/irishbox/basses.html)).
Joe Derrane's D/C# Gaillard box with 14 basses
(top of instrument)
outside inside
bass F#/F# C#/C#
chord B/B E/E
bass B/B E/E
chord A/A D/D
bass A/A D/D
chord F/C G/G
bass F/C G/G
All chords in this setup are without 3rds.
In between being a teenage melodeon prodigy in the 1940s and 1950s and a rediscovered veteran from the 1990s onwards, Derrane spent many years as a professional piano accordionist, which doubtless explains his liking for the unisonorous bass setup (except for the F/C pair) and his very creative use of same.
As I understand it André Bouchard asked Saltarelle to build a custom box with Derrane's Gaillard layout, which they later made a production model - the monstrous Atalante (http://www.saltarelle.com/sterling_range_accordeon.htm#atalante). I don't know what bass layout they would give if you ordered a D/G...
-
I made a replacement bass reed block that gave me same-both-ways single note
C C# D E F# G A B on the 8 bass buttons (so I had all the notes of D and G.) It had two reeds in octaves on each button.
Tom
I've dabbled with this too - I've got the following layout programmed as one of the layouts in my streb...
--- top ---
b eb/eb g#/g#
e bb/bb c#/c#
l f/f f#/f#
l e/e a/a
o b/b d/d
w c/c g/g
s
.. all as single notes. And like you, I haven't really made proper use of it as yet,
but that's one of the joys of the streb - you can try wacky things like this out.
My favoured bass layout is (push/pull)
--- top ---
b f#m/f a/a
e f#m/f a/a
l bm/em d/d
l bm/em d/d
o c/c g/g
w c/c g/g
s
which I think gives a nice compromise between covering the chords you usually need
for a D/G, the ability to play drones (hold down G note with little finger as you
play others), and compatibility with a normal 8 bass layout (pull chords are
one position to the right of where they'd normally be, all push chords are where
you'd expect them to be, so learning the new system takes very little time).
I've just come up with the following wacky layout, that I've asked Steve to program
into the Streb for me... any guesses what it does?
--- top ---
b f/bb a/a
e f/bb a/a
l bm/bm d/d
l bm/bm d/d
o c/c g/g
w c/c g/g
s
... it's designed to play in D, and Dm. The plan is to have a treble end of D/C (yep, that's C natural, not C sharp), with a half row in F. You then have a layout that plays in D and Dm easily, complete with chords, meaning minor/major tunes are now rather easier. Yes, I know if I learned to play a few non-standard keys on a D/G box I could achieve much the same effect, but I do prefer the easier route sometimes. ;D
Clive