Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: deltasalmon on July 08, 2013, 08:57:29 PM
-
I recently purchased the album "Ego Trip" by MacDara O'Raghaillaigh (here (http://www.amazon.com/Ego-Trip/dp/B004VUTN80/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1373313495&sr=8-2&keywords=ego+trip+macdara), with free samples). It is hands down my favorite album to listen to right now. It's a solo fiddle played live, completely unaccompanied (except the tapping of a foot) and played at a steady pace and not ripping away like a lot of modern ITM musicians.
I was wondering if there were any such albums made by an accordion player. I know Tony MacMahon's first album was like that and his album "In Knocknagree" with Noel Hill is similar (with the addition of a concertina) but both I think are played at a pretty fast tempo from start to stop (with exception to the slow airs).
There are a few fans of ITM on this website, does anyone know of an album by an accordionist that fits this description?
-
I've been listening a lot to that album myself recently - it's just lovely, isn't it? There was a thread about this very thing recently, here:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,12198.0.html
.... but I think the general answer to your question would be, Topic Records and Veteran Records' source recording releases of traditional players apart, no. There are solo albums, such as Riccardo Tesi's, but steady pace they are not. And there are steady, musical albums like Stephane Delicq's, but unaccompanied, they are not (although, irritatingly his live shows often were, and they were some of the finest box playing I've ever heard - but that's not how he chose to record).
*Slightly* off topic, I would say the closest I have heard recently is Jack Talty & Cormac Begley's album "Na Fir Bolg", concertina duets. It has the same quality as Macdara's album, beautifully played at a steady pace, and some lovely material. Playing to aspire to on any instrument I think.
Both albums on Spotify by the way.
[[[ Oh, sudden thought. I've really enjoyed John Gannon's solo album, simply called 'Melodeon', recently. It's not unaccompanied, but the other musicians are remarkably sensitive to the point that you often forget they're there. ]]]
Cheers,
Clive
-
This might be what your looking for
Brendan Begley -- It Could Be A Good Night Yet
or this
Tom Doherty - Dance Sean Nos
this one has piano on it , it's one I need to get !
[[[ Oh, sudden thought. I've really enjoyed John Gannon's solo album, simply called 'Melodeon', recently. It's not unaccompanied, but the other musicians are remarkably sensitive to the point that you often forget they're there. ]]]
Cheers,
Clive
[/quote
There's something about the pulse or timing of his playing that I really enjoy too!
-
does anyone know of an album by an accordionist that fits this description?
Possibly … anything by Philippe Bruneau >:E
-
*Slightly* off topic, I would say the closest I have heard recently is Jack Talty & Cormac Begley's album "Na Fir Bolg", concertina duets. It has the same quality as Macdara's album, beautifully played at a steady pace, and some lovely material. Playing to aspire to on any instrument I think.
I've heard great things of this album lately. I'll have to add it to my wish list. Thanks.
-
Brendan Begley -- It Could Be A Good Night Yet
or this
Tom Doherty - Dance Sean Nos
this one has piano on it , it's one I need to get !
I listened to the samples of the Brendan Begley album and it definitely seems pretty interesting. It seems to be played at a faster tempo than the Macdara album but it is solo and unaccompanied.
Piano accompaniment isn't really what interests me but I'll probably get the first one.
-
*Slightly* off topic, I would say the closest I have heard recently is Jack Talty & Cormac Begley's album "Na Fir Bolg", concertina duets. It has the same quality as Macdara's album, beautifully played at a steady pace, and some lovely material. Playing to aspire to on any instrument I think.
I've heard great things of this album lately. I'll have to add it to my wish list. Thanks.
Just had a listen on Spotify - the opening track is just utterly sublime. Wonderful mix of normal and baritone concertina, and played with such a wonderful lilt. How Irish music should be played! Here's a video - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iYsJ22JdPqk
Many thanks for flagging this up. (:)
-
Almost any recording by East Clare accordion player Andrew McNamara is generally moderately paced. "Open Hearth"" with Mary McNamara on concertina and "Flagstone Memories" especially come to mind.
-
There's this one as well - http://open.spotify.com/album/1jlxLk2a3cbnSNkWSbUhEO
-
How Irish music should be played!
::) I can't wait for the Irish to start telling each other how English music should be played.
-
Steve, we wouldn't dream of lecturing ethnic Irish, particularly West Coast on how to play their music, (though political correctness might now be fair game) ;) Britain's problem is a large body of locals who feel that if fast is good, faster is better.
Thought it was just us, but was rudely awakened (literally) in East Flanders yesterday by young Belgians belting out Canal en Octobre, and a few others at least double speed. As they included a bombard player in there I gave up all hope of sleep and mosied over for a beer, it was only 5am (:). One tried to convince me how "goed" it was; but failed ::)
I find the steady stuff they play in Clare, entrancing. But it's a long way from there to Flanders?
-
...played at a steady pace....
Perhaps - Retrospect (Danny O Mahony) or Fonnchaoi (Verena Commins & Julie Langan)
-
I love how these two are giggling though it all and wonder what the joke was?
anyway good video and it had me laughing in the end. funny how infectious laughter can be.
-
Steve, we wouldn't dream of lecturing ethnic Irish, particularly West Coast on how to play their music, (though political correctness might now be fair game) ;) Britain's problem is a large body of locals who feel that if fast is good, faster is better.
Thought it was just us, but was rudely awakened (literally) in East Flanders yesterday by young Belgians belting out Canal en Octobre, and a few others at least double speed. As they included a bombard player in there I gave up all hope of sleep and mosied over for a beer, it was only 5am (:). One tried to convince me how "goed" it was; but failed ::)
I find the steady stuff they play in Clare, entrancing. But it's a long way from there to Flanders?
That's the point, Chris. People on here seem to be prepared to like Irish music as long as it's slow, steady and bouncy. (Which I suspect may mean, at a pace with which they might have a chance of keeping up with it? >:E)
But there are other ways of playing it that are just as valid. Everyone is entitled to their taste. But saying how any music "should" be played, particularly when you don't play it yourself, strikes me as lying somewhere along the continuum, if there is one, between fatuous and utterly irrelevant.
It's a long time since I was in a Irish session in England, during which time my own abilities and tastes have developed enormously, so I cannot express an opinion on how it might or might not be played in such sessions. But I think we should all be wary of formulating a considered opinion along the lines of "Irish music in England is always far too fast and therefore not correct" and trotting it out at every opportunity.
-
And to add another, possible revealing, view on the attitude to "Irish" music as played in England: I've frequently heard the epithet "fast Irish" applied to certain sessions that I have been present in when most of the music was in fact Scottish!
Yes speed is very much a personal thing, and in mainland Britain (England Scotland and Wales) I can discern a speed trend that is related to latitude. The generally accepted tempo for dance music is slower in the south of England than it is in the north, and is a bit faster again in Scotland. If you are accustomed to one speed then someone else's is noticeably different. It doesn't make either good or bad.
-
I'm a huge fan of Clare music, and the recommendation of Andrew Mac is spot on. My favourite lately has been Pat O'Connor and Eoghan O'Sullivan's Conversation at the Crosses. Lovely, lovely box playing, great tune selection and just nice all-round music. Some of it is played in C I think on an old Paolo, and some is played in D on a Saltarelle.
That being said, MacDarra isn't so much a Clare player, and he in fact is playing pretty quick on most of the tracks, its just that he gives a feeling of space in his playing, and there is no thrashing guitar or bouncing piano to fill in that space. It really lets you hear his timing and swing, and he has no rushedness to his playing. Its fantastic.
Another great one is A Moment of Madness by Caoimhin O'Raghallaigh and Brendan Begley. Again, its fiddle and box, but its great.
-
How Irish music should be played!
::) I can't wait for the Irish to start telling each other how English music should be played.
What I meant was, it's actually played with a sense of musicality, at a sensible speed (which is by no means 'slow'), rather than being bashed out at 150mph, which (to my ear) makes it considerably more listenable! I didn't mean that all Irish music 'should' be played in this style, but it would be nice if people were to play this music with the same level of thought and musicality as these two.
-
Steve, we wouldn't dream of lecturing ethnic Irish, particularly West Coast on how to play their music, (though political correctness might now be fair game) ;) Britain's problem is a large body of locals who feel that if fast is good, faster is better.
Thought it was just us, but was rudely awakened (literally) in East Flanders yesterday by young Belgians belting out Canal en Octobre, and a few others at least double speed. As they included a bombard player in there I gave up all hope of sleep and mosied over for a beer, it was only 5am (:). One tried to convince me how "goed" it was; but failed ::)
I find the steady stuff they play in Clare, entrancing. But it's a long way from there to Flanders?
That's the point, Chris. People on here seem to be prepared to like Irish music as long as it's slow, steady and bouncy. (Which I suspect may mean, at a pace with which they might have a chance of keeping up with it? >:E)
But there are other ways of playing it that are just as valid. Everyone is entitled to their taste. But saying how any music "should" be played, particularly when you don't play it yourself, strikes me as lying somewhere along the continuum, if there is one, between fatuous and utterly irrelevant.
It's a long time since I was in a Irish session in England, during which time my own abilities and tastes have developed enormously, so I cannot express an opinion on how it might or might not be played in such sessions. But I think we should all be wary of formulating a considered opinion along the lines of "Irish music in England is always far too fast and therefore not correct" and trotting it out at every opportunity.
Right on the button, Steve.
This ritual 'fast Irish'-bashing is one of the few irritating traits on this otherwise excellent and broad-minded forum.
-
IMO, Irish music should be played at the speed the dancers want you to play!!!
Otherwise, there is no basis for a standard and the argument is moot. This is dance music, after all.
For example, "session musicians" invariably play an (Irish) hornpipe way too fast for any human dancer. Also with slip jigs. And don't think its a matter of skill or experience. I have seen, in performance, a 20-something dancer tell Billy McComiskey and Brian Conway (inargueably excellent musicians) that they were playing at an inappropriate speed (jigs, BTW, and they were too slow). And they complied to the dancer's wishes.
My point is that the only value judgements applied should be with regard to the purpose for which the music is intended.
There, I have shown my trad-materialist-determinist roots.
-
IMO, Irish music should be played at the speed the dancers want you to play!!!
Otherwise, there is no basis for a standard and the argument is moot. This is dance music, after all.
But what happens when there are no dancers present which is surely more common. I don't understand the idea that because the tradition began as dance tunes it has to remain wedded to a set metronomic standard. I admit to being a session novice but I've actually never been to one where someone dances more than a cursory fling.
The tradition moves on and develops as new generations put their stamp on it and that may include tinkering with the tempo. Sometimes slower, sometimes faster than 'dance' speed, but as long as it's within the competence of the musicians doing it, what's the problem? There seems to be acceptance that the dots are just a guideline and variations and improvisations are welcome, so why is it different with tempo? If it's to do with people playing 'too fast' for their own ability or to prevent others joining in, that's an entirely different matter, but the discussions here are about skilled players deciding to crank up the speed because they like it that way.
-
Yes, but more often than not, it sounds awful. Music is nothing without space and gaps between the notes, and this is something that is often missing. It becomes a blur of notes and ornaments, and it's not nice to listen to.
-
Yes, but more often than not, it sounds awful. Music is nothing without space and gaps between the notes, and this is something that is often missing. It becomes a blur of notes and ornaments, and it's not nice to listen to.
It is times like these that make me wish SMF forum software had a facebook like "LIKE" button
-
Thanks for the advice in albums to check out that are similar to Ego Trip.
The thread seems to have drifted into a "how fast should music be played" thread so I'm going to lock it.
Thanks again!