Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Adam-T on August 11, 2013, 11:50:57 AM

Title: Recommended Reed files ? ?
Post by: Adam-T on August 11, 2013, 11:50:57 AM
My standard needle files aren`t tough enough to tune reeds, I was wondering what is recommended and available in the UK  .. I managed to successfully downtune a Melodeon A:B Reed to A:A (for my little 2915 PA) but it took ages due the lame file so would like a proper file for these little touchups - the rest of the box is basically in tune but with varying trem on some notes etc ..
Title: Re: Recommended Reed files ? ?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 11, 2013, 12:13:20 PM
My standard needle files aren`t tough enough to tune reeds, I was wondering what is recommended and available in the UK  .. I managed to successfully downtune a Melodeon A:B Reed to A:A (for my little 2915 PA) but it took ages due the lame file so would like a proper file for these little touchups - the rest of the box is basically in tune but with varying trem on some notes etc ..
I've been using these very fine diamond-coated needle files (click for picture (http://www.arceurotrade.co.uk/imagecache/e7fd6a5d-4935-4372-9801-d1f8b832bc5e_320x98.jpg)) in 400-grade grit size. They are extraordinarily good and amazingly cheap - £4.40 for a set from Arceurotrade (http://www.arceurotrade.co.uk/Catalogue/Diamond-Tools/Diamond-Needle-Files). Scroll about half-way down the page to find this particular product.

Product code is 070-010-00230 Diamond Needle Files 2x100mm - #400 - 5pc Set

The files are small enough to allow precise working and the 400 grit is gentle but efficient. You do not need to exert much pressure on the reed tongues.


Title: Re: Recommended Reed files ? ?
Post by: Adam-T on August 11, 2013, 12:19:21 PM
Thanks Steve - just what I was looking for ! .. Right price too  ..
Title: Re: Recommended Reed files ? ?
Post by: Prestidigitator on August 11, 2013, 02:02:10 PM
I use Swiss Vallorbe files, in different sizes, shapes (flat, triangular, bent etc.) and "cuts", as used by watchmakers and the like.

They aren't especially cheap, but they're "as hard as the hobs of H??l". Several years ago, I was lucky enough to drop on to several on eBay, the property of an amateur horologist.

The main thing with any files is to keep them apart, so that they don't blunt each other. Not a problem if you have a wallet or neat block or stand to stick them in but, if like me, you have to, or prefer to, keep them together in a box, then I give each its own thick cardboard scabbard.

The other tool I've found very good as a "scratcher" is a diamond-tipped, wood and brass scriber which I think was used for marking fibre optic cables. Care is needed with this, as "a little goes a long way".
Title: Re: Recommended Reed files ? ?
Post by: diatonix on August 11, 2013, 02:19:18 PM
i quite agree with Prestidigitator: nothing beats Swiss made Vallorbe-Grobet files. I also had some excellent Swedish Öberg files once, but I don't think these are available today.
Title: Re: Recommended Reed files ? ?
Post by: Prestidigitator on August 11, 2013, 02:46:36 PM
i quite agree with Prestidigitator: nothing beats Swiss made Vallorbe-Grobet files. I also had some excellent Swedish Öberg files once, but I don't think these are available today.

I think that Öberg, who had that rather nice "Man in the Moon" trademark, became part of Sandvik Bahco. Looking at eBay UK, they seem to still make them with the Öberg name, but they all seem to be large size engineers files. I had a couple of original large Öberg files in my fishing vessel's toolkit (still have them) and they are the equal of the Swiss.
Title: Re: Recommended Reed files ? ?
Post by: blafleur on August 11, 2013, 04:56:22 PM
I also cast my suppor of good quality Swiss files. After trying all sorts of gadgets, and piles of cheap files, I finally invested in some good Swiss files from Brownell's, a gunsmity company, and I can say the difference is drastic.  Much better control, they can cut fast or slow, and a fine finish.  I also, on the advice of some on this forum, now use those small woodworking sanding sticks, with the small sanding belt.  I don't like them as much because they leave sanding material behind to blow off, but they get to some angles hard to with the files.  I've also tried power rotary tools, but gave up on them a long time ago. 
Title: Re: Recommended Reed files ? ?
Post by: Graham Spencer on August 11, 2013, 08:59:24 PM
By and large, with files as with everything else, you get what you pay for. I too have some Vallorbe Swiss files that have been with me for many years - LONG before I started investigating the innards of melodeons - and they are lovely little tools. Having said that, I shall try a set of the diamond files recommended by Steve: I'm always prepared to be pleasantly surprised!  I just hope they're better than the set of Chinese "diamond" core drills currently collecting dust in my "why-did-I-buy-this" box ......

Graham
Title: Re: Recommended Reed files ? ?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 11, 2013, 11:59:49 PM
Having said that, I shall try a set of the diamond files recommended by Steve: I'm always prepared to be pleasantly surprised!
I admit I was rather sceptical when I saw how cheap they were. So far I've used them on a couple of tuning jobs (I don't do much of it). Mostly I use the flat-section file and it seems to have come through unscathed and still as good as new. In the longer term, if the files prove to be a pig-in-a-poke, at only £4.40 for the set at least I haven't spent a lot of money. 
Title: Re: Recommended Reed files ? ?
Post by: Adam-T on August 12, 2013, 07:18:08 AM
I`m hardly training for box-tuner of the decade either, just want to kick a few notes into shape here and there when needed - the experiment turning an A:B Melodeon reed into an A:A Unisonoric worked beautifully (rather like DeGleichtoning in reverse ;D) but showed my files weren`t up to it ... so a set (or even a single file) for a Fiver is what the Doctor ordered
Title: Re: Recommended Reed files ? ?
Post by: Lester on August 12, 2013, 07:39:11 AM
I`m hardly training for box-tuner of the decade either, just want to kick a few notes into shape here and there when needed - the experiment turning an A:B Melodeon reed into an A:A Unisonoric worked beautifully (rather like DeGleichtoning in reverse ;D) but showed my files weren`t up to it ... so a set (or even a single file) for a Fiver is what the Doctor ordered

To take a reed down a full tone (B -> Bb -> A) I would apply solder to the reed tip and then file it up to the required note, requires a lot less filing and consequential weakening of the reed.
Title: Re: Recommended Reed files ? ?
Post by: Adam-T on August 12, 2013, 07:55:04 AM
Sorry - It was an A:G reed I raised to A:A not an A:B down to A:A - Don't even Ask how I typed all that wrong ! ..... anyway the reed had its tip filed to raise the pitch to the A one

yes I`d have loaded the tip with solder to do the lowering  - this I`ve actually done a few times in the past year, I`d not have severely weakened a B reed at the base (they snap under pressure)
Title: Re: Recommended Reed files ? ?
Post by: Adam-T on August 14, 2013, 09:16:27 PM
I`ve ordered a set of the "Freereeders"  8) . as I said, I`m not going into this as a hobby or profession, just to kick a few notes into shape so exotic swiss made files would be overkill  ..... thanks for all the input ..
Title: Re: Recommended Reed files ? ?
Post by: Adam-T on August 15, 2013, 02:00:59 PM
The "Freereeder" Files arrived  and they work just fine 8) ......  I`ve tickled two 2915s back into shape already, the C/F Koch and Soloist (Student-1) PA, both were basically in tune but with a few notes with different trem amount  - I`m never going to do a lot of this (only for this kinda work) so these budget files are ideal , I was hoping I could use the pointy one as a scratcher but it`s none too effective at that as you`d expect .

Thanks again Steve
Title: Re: Recommended Reed files ? ?
Post by: Theo on August 15, 2013, 02:12:51 PM
, I was hoping I could use the pointy one as a scratcher but it`s none too effective at that as you`d expect .


Charlie Marshall sells scratchers, they are not expensive.
Title: Re: Recommended Reed files ? ?
Post by: Adam-T on August 15, 2013, 09:35:08 PM
Thanks Theo, I`ll have a look .
Title: Re: Recommended Reed files ? ?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 16, 2013, 10:04:17 AM
Thanks Theo, I`ll have a look .
I made my reed scratcher from an old circular-section needle file. I ground away the file teeth for about 4 cm at the tip end using a carborundum stone (by hand - I didn't want excessive heat to destroy the temper of the steel). The reason for grinding away the teeth is so that you don't damage the sides of the reed frame slot when using the file. I also made a wooden handle out of a piece of dowel to slip over the tang end of the file for safety and comfort in use. At the other end of the dowel handle I drilled a smaller diameter hole to fit over the tip of the scratcher to protect it in my tool box when not in use.

Any reed scratcher needs to be kept sharp during use by frequent touching up on an oil-stone.
Title: Re: Recommended Reed files ? ?
Post by: Adam-T on August 16, 2013, 10:28:42 AM
I thought commercially made scratchers were diamond tipped (so unsharpenable) , A good idea for a DIY one though I think I`ll just get one of Charlie's (when he comes back off Holiday) ......

I`ve tuned the treble end of the Arietta PA into the ball park now, I`ll fine tune it after I`ve attempted the bass end (Chords are OK m it`s the bass reeds which are all over the place for some reason) sad bit is that block is fixed .
Title: Re: Recommended Reed files ? ?
Post by: Theo on August 16, 2013, 11:32:46 AM
I thought commercially made scratchers were diamond tipped (so unsharpenable) ,

No, the ones sold by Hohner, and the ones sold by Carini are not diamond tipped, just a very, very  hard tool steel.   You do need to keep sharpening them, for which I find a fine grit diamond sharpening plate is excellent, but probably costs more than the scratcher.
Title: Re: Recommended Reed files ? ?
Post by: Adam-T on August 16, 2013, 11:38:20 AM
I`ll grab a diamond tipped one - thanks  ........ as for the Arietta bass end, Phew - Both blocks come out of this one (I`d not taken the bass end off the bellows so didn`t see the screw) ..
Title: Re: Recommended Reed files ? ?
Post by: Adam-T on August 27, 2013, 09:49:31 AM
Just thought I`d post an update - I`m gradually getting into tuning, I`ve got the Arietta 72 bass PA into the ballpark (now very playable) without ANY "Backwards and forwards" tuning (filing too sharp then having to flatten it - I got it right on the one pass) at both ends and will fine tune it later on...
Got the Koch presswood singing sweet (Trem Varied between notes)
The Soloist (2915 PA) is now also singing sweet (was all over the place)

On the to do list is to perfect the Arietta and tame some overenthusiastic notes on the very wet G/C Presswood I got recently (did the wax/Valves of the treble end yesterday, doing the bass end today, did the treble pallets on Friday inbetween work) .

as I said, I`ll never be a Theo let alone a Nielsen but the ability to get boxes into a very playable state of tune is going to be invaluable, I don`t know why I left it so long, I`ve been doing pallets, wax and valves for over a year now (in my small capacity)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal