Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Other Free Reed Instruments => Topic started by: EastAnglianTed on August 11, 2013, 11:52:14 PM

Title: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: EastAnglianTed on August 11, 2013, 11:52:14 PM
    Just wondering why, in some cases for example, if you sold a Mory (i.e. very expensive box) you still wouldn't have enough money to buy some concertinas?
    Is it to do with age? Reed quality? I know it's a fast and loose question but I can't find why some small concertinas cost £4000 and up.
    I am well aware of why, when it comes to a melodeon, that say a Castagnari costs more than a Hohner (workmanship, reed quality etc.) but concertinas are generally smaller than nearly all boxes and have one reed per note so less reeds overall (in general?).
    Their size would dictate less materials needed, so I can't work out why they cost so much. Is it a fiddly instrument to construct? Much like a pocket watch is harder to make than a grandfather clock (sizewise)?
    Just a general question, not having a go just genuinely interested  :D
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Theo on August 12, 2013, 12:01:49 AM
I don't think there is one simple answer, but a big factor is that in a quality concertina many of the parts that are machine made in a melodeon would be hand made, this applies particularly to the reeds.  Even the pars that are machine made are made in smaller quantities and so the economies of scale work in favour of making melodeons cheaper.  Then the small size actually makes the construction more demanding.  Sure there are fewer reeds, but the mechanical parts are just as numerous.  Finally, the best concertinas are nearly all vintage instruments and are not being made any more, so there is a very limited supply.

And I'd just add that for top instruments even concertinas are cheap.  I don't think I've ever seen a concertina offered for sale for over £10,000, and yet with violins or guitars the most prized instruments are many many times more - and they are just a wooden box and a stick, with some bits of wire stretched over. >:E
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 12, 2013, 12:22:06 AM
I think Theo has got it spot-on. All I will add is that nearly all of the high-quality traditional reeded instruments being made today are being built by individual makers, or a very small dedicated team. For example, Geoff Crabb works entirely on his own and makes every component, while Colin Dipper works with his wife Rosalie who makes the bellows, plus one other person who shares the reed-making work. Such high intensity, individual working is always going to command a high price.

By contrast, even the high-end Italian melodeon makers such as Castagnari have cottage-industry scale factories employing quite a few people, and components such as bellows, reeds, buttons, etc., are out-sourced to specialist manufacturers often based in the same geographical area. So their overall production rate is much higher and therefore the final product is inevitably cheaper.

I guess that an individual melodeon maker such Doug Briggs (http://www.briggsaccordions.com/) (basic instrument price £5100) is comparable with one of the bespoke concertina makers.
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Adam-T on August 12, 2013, 07:30:53 AM
I`m probably alone on this but here goes .... although I like the sound of Concertinas as much as the next squeezer (hate trying to play them however) I think there`s a point where the thing as an instrument fails to be worth the price - £5000-£6000 for a single voice free reed instrument is IMO way beyond sanity, I think you`d be hard pushed to pay 6 grand for a melodeon (as in small box up to 3 rows not a 6 row steirische) unless you got Doug Briggs, Valentin Zupan or Hermann Jamnik to do a custom job and you get one hell of a high end PA or CBA for that kind of cash ..

The same applies to the simple descant recorder where a crap one is £3.99, a decent one is £25 and a top of the range one is £250 but if you`re clinically insane you can pay £2500 for one !

EDIT - The big diff between Freereeders & Recorders compared to string instruments of course is that special seasoned woods aren't needed for resonant soundboards etc so none of the rigmarole which goes with that .
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 12, 2013, 09:04:23 AM
£5000-£6000 for a professional-quality instrument is not actually a lot of money.  However the price for some anglos does seem to have been inflated by worldwide demand from players of Irish music, who seem to believe that to be taken seriously they have to play a vintage Jeffries - instruments of similar quality but without the magic Jeffries name can often be significantly cheaper.  English system concertinas tend to be cheaper, and duets even more so, because there isn't the same demand.

The real issue is why even 'cheap' concertinas are so expensive, and it's for the same reasons that Theo has given - even where costs can be reduced by using accordion reeds, most of the work has to be done by hand.  It also requires a lot of specialised tools.

Geoff Crabb has produced a list of all the components in a concertina - I forget the exact figure but IIRC it was around 4000.
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Chris Brimley on August 12, 2013, 09:39:57 AM
Are the economies of scale also involved in this issue?  Maybe I'll be taken to task for this comment, but aren't there many fewer concertinas around?
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Rob2Hook on August 12, 2013, 12:02:47 PM
- even where costs can be reduced by using accordion reeds, most of the work has to be done by hand.

It seems such a shame to produce 4,000 parts to be build a concertina and then ruin the whole thing by fitting accordion reeds - makes it sound like a Lilly!  For those who think I'm joking, perhaps you have never heard a really good concertina?  I was playing with my mate the other day and he decided to buy a Jefferies to replace his ex-SA Lachenal before he got too old to play it.  The sound is only slightly different from the Lachenal, but the speed of the action means he can leave me for dead.

Rob
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Owen Woods on August 12, 2013, 12:38:04 PM
Have you ever looked inside a concertina Ted? That should answer your question! Much more intricate, much more complicated, much higher tolerances.
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: oggiesnr on August 12, 2013, 12:42:11 PM
Quality, rarity, fashion and lack of modern production all play a part.

The prices of top quality concertinas are not out of line with those of most quality instruments the main exception being stringed instruments (which are a law unto themselves).

If you want insane, I recently played two double basses.  One was a modern instrument, yours for £15,000. The other was an older instrument, 300 years older, for the price tag was well in excess of six figures!

Personally I can understand the price of vintage Jefefries or a Dipper or Crabb a lot more than I can understand the prices of many of the melodeons coming out of Castilfardo.

Steve
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: EastAnglianTed on August 12, 2013, 01:05:36 PM
Have you ever looked inside a concertina Ted? That should answer your question! Much more intricate, much more complicated, much higher tolerances.
    Admittedly not, though I know where I can have a look as a relative has an old beaten up one. I will have a look with great interest soon  (:)
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Lester on August 12, 2013, 01:06:02 PM
Like everything else in the world the price of concertinas will settle at the amount of money people are will to give for them.
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: oggiesnr on August 12, 2013, 01:12:21 PM
Like everything else in the world the price of concertinas will settle at the amount of money people are will to give for them.

Bit like Grey Paolo's really :)

Steve
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on August 12, 2013, 01:21:57 PM
Like everything else in the world the price of concertinas will settle at the amount of money people are will to give for them.

Fully agree Lester, books and paintings fall into the same category.
A book dealer customer of mine many years ago was compiling his catalogue and amongst his valuable and rare books he added an old beaten up paperback (worthless ) priced at £40.00.
Asking why, he said some mug will buy it, books are only worth what people are prepared to pay for them. Sure enough it did sell.
Anyone want to buy a Fettled Chanson @ £4,300 ?
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: malcolmbebb on August 12, 2013, 03:35:16 PM
Have you ever looked inside a concertina Ted? That should answer your question! Much more intricate, much more complicated, much higher tolerances.
    Admittedly not, though I know where I can have a look as a relative has an old beaten up one. I will have a look with great interest soon  (:)
This conversation has centred around high end boxes. It is possible* to buy  a new concertina for under £200. Similarly, Germany has pumped out many thousands of "export" boxes in varying qualities for much of the last century, many of which were affordable and did sterling work as instruments for ordinary people.
Construction and design follows accordion practice, which they were also banging out by the thousands.

So looking at an old beater won't necessarily tell you much about why a Dipper costs what it does.

Another factor is that the high end concertina makers put a lot of work into the design and craftsmanship of the whole instrument, fretwork and bellows. You have only to look at a high end concertina, a Dipper or a Wakker, several others these days, to see that you have not just a musical instrument but a work of art. And that's before you pick it up and feel the action... you have stopped wondering why they're expensive by this point.

Malcolm
*I said possible. I didn't say recommended.
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Owen Woods on August 12, 2013, 03:49:48 PM
This conversation has centred around high end boxes. It is possible* to buy  a new concertina for under £200. Similarly, Germany has pumped out many thousands of "export" boxes in varying qualities for much of the last century, many of which were affordable and did sterling work as instruments for ordinary people.
Construction and design follows accordion practice, which they were also banging out by the thousands.

So looking at an old beater won't necessarily tell you much about why a Dipper costs what it does.

Another factor is that the high end concertina makers put a lot of work into the design and craftsmanship of the whole instrument, fretwork and bellows. You have only to look at a high end concertina, a Dipper or a Wakker, several others these days, to see that you have not just a musical instrument but a work of art. And that's before you pick it up and feel the action... you have stopped wondering why they're expensive by this point.

Malcolm
*I said possible. I didn't say recommended.

This.
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: IanD on August 12, 2013, 04:09:04 PM
    Just wondering why, in some cases for example, if you sold a Mory (i.e. very expensive box) you still wouldn't have enough money to buy some concertinas?
    Is it to do with age? Reed quality? I know it's a fast and loose question but I can't find why some small concertinas cost £4000 and up.
    I am well aware of why, when it comes to a melodeon, that say a Castagnari costs more than a Hohner (workmanship, reed quality etc.) but concertinas are generally smaller than nearly all boxes and have one reed per note so less reeds overall (in general?).
    Their size would dictate less materials needed, so I can't work out why they cost so much. Is it a fiddly instrument to construct? Much like a pocket watch is harder to make than a grandfather clock (sizewise)?
    Just a general question, not having a go just genuinely interested  :D

When Hilda had her 39 key G/D Crabb made in 1979 it cost the then huge sum of £1000. I talked to Neville at great length (as you invariably did) and he said that he'd worked out the number of hours it took them to make such a box, and that he couldn't make a living out of it even at that price, but that the market wouldn't pay a more realistic sum -- the only thing that kept Crabb in business was repairs and refurbishments for which the hourly rate was considerably higher.

Adjusted for inflation this would be £4300 today. If this wasn't enough to make a decent living for a highly skilled craftman then, I doubt if it is now.

Even Doug Briggs buys high-quality reeds in from the Italian factories, and his melodeons are over £5000. So allowing for the truly hand-made reeds in concertinas, I suspect a proper market value for one nowadays would be somewhat higher than this to make a living out of it, maybe £6000 or so.

But then as Neville complained to me, folkies always were skinflints as far as high-quality instruments were concerned  ;)
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Adam-T on August 12, 2013, 04:22:07 PM
Adjusted for inflation this would be £4300 today. If this wasn't enough to make a decent living for a highly skilled craftman then, I doubt if it is now.

So it must get to a stage where the concertina as an instrument isn`t worth the expenditure in time and money for a master craftsman to make to a certain standard - I hate to say this but  it`s only a concertina at the end of the day - rather like the £2500 recorder business, it`s not a Bassoon or an Oboe or a clarinet, it`s just a recorder .....
I guess this is another of those "out on my own" things again , I just don`t have the sentimentality for the Concertina to be able to even comprehend why someone would pay as much as a new car for one.

I bet Colin Dipper etc could make the worlds most expensive mouthie with individual reedplates, special valves, exotic materials too - OK there`s no where near as much in there as even the simplest Anglos but the same would apply in the time & build cost to "what it is" ratio
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Owen Woods on August 12, 2013, 04:32:46 PM
I disagree with your assessment of both the concertina and the recorder!
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Lester on August 12, 2013, 04:33:28 PM
I disagree with your assessment of both the concertina and the recorder!

Correct  (:)
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: IanD on August 12, 2013, 04:35:36 PM
Adjusted for inflation this would be £4300 today. If this wasn't enough to make a decent living for a highly skilled craftman then, I doubt if it is now.

So it must get to a stage where the concertina as an instrument isn`t worth the expenditure in time and money for a master craftsman to make to a certain standard - I hate to say this but  it`s only a concertina at the end of the day - rather like the £2500 recorder business, it`s not a Bassoon or an Oboe or a clarinet, it`s just a recorder .....
I guess this is another of those "out on my own" things again , I just don`t have the sentimentality for the Concertina to be able to even comprehend why someone would pay as much as a new car for one.

I bet Colin Dipper etc could make the worlds most expensive mouthie with individual reedplates, special valves, exotic materials too - OK there`s no where near as much in there as even the simplest Anglos but the same would apply in the time & build cost to "what it is" ratio

But the simple fact is that a concertina made with accordion reeds really sounds nothing like a concertina with traditional concertina reeds -- the difference is much bigger than (for example) a mid-priced versus an expensive recorder, which are basically built the same way with similar materials but with a more or less skilled (or highly paid) maker.

Concertinas were conceived in a time when labour was cheap and there was no need to minimise the number of hours it took to make one, so that's how they were designed and built, especially the reeds. With modern CAD tools it ought to be possible to get the same (or maybe even better) result more cheaply, but then you'd have to invest in the tooling and setup which wouldn't make sense unless you made a lot of instruments -- and you'd have to convince the stick-in-the-mud "handmade is best" market (which is probably most of it...) that your "handmade-by-machine" instrument was actually better, so good luck with that ;-)
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: oggiesnr on August 12, 2013, 04:40:42 PM
Adjusted for inflation this would be £4300 today. If this wasn't enough to make a decent living for a highly skilled craftman then, I doubt if it is now.

So it must get to a stage where the concertina as an instrument isn`t worth the expenditure in time and money for a master craftsman to make to a certain standard - I hate to say this but  it`s only a concertina at the end of the day - rather like the £2500 recorder business, it`s not a Bassoon or an Oboe or a clarinet, it`s just a recorder .....
I guess this is another of those "out on my own" things again , I just don`t have the sentimentality for the Concertina to be able to even comprehend why someone would pay as much as a new car for one.


By this reasoning why spend money on anything made by a craftsman?  Furniture, pottery, carpets, anything you want can be had cheap somewhere.  Why spend more than £6,000 on a car, it will still get you from A to B as well as one costing £60,000, might even be cheaper to run.

In my next incarnation I'm not going to be a craftsman, I'm going to be an artist, they seem to be able to get away with charging the earth for a few daubs :)

I've just cut a concertina end.  At the prices my local garage charges for repairs it would be over £500.  No way can I charge that yet garages get away with it without anyone blinking.

Steve
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: LDbosca on August 12, 2013, 04:41:31 PM
Adjusted for inflation this would be £4300 today. If this wasn't enough to make a decent living for a highly skilled craftman then, I doubt if it is now.

So it must get to a stage where the concertina as an instrument isn`t worth the expenditure in time and money for a master craftsman to make to a certain standard - I hate to say this but  it`s only a concertina at the end of the day - rather like the £2500 recorder business, it`s not a Bassoon or an Oboe or a clarinet, it`s just a recorder .....
I guess this is another of those "out on my own" things again , I just don`t have the sentimentality for the Concertina to be able to even comprehend why someone would pay as much as a new car for one.

I bet Colin Dipper etc could make the worlds most expensive mouthie with individual reedplates, special valves, exotic materials too - OK there`s no where near as much in there as even the simplest Anglos but the same would apply in the time & build cost to "what it is" ratio

Thankfully, music/art cannot be judged in terms of viability/being worthwhile in the same way as business or economic concerns. The concertina is special and unique and so is always going to be around. There's nothing else that can do what a concertina can do and taking it away would leave a hole in music, it would remove a form of expression. Musicians value artistic expression over monitary concerns; that's why we put up with being pretty poor a lot of the time. At the end of the day the main thing musicians have is whether or not they can get it out sounding like they want to and meaning something.

I would argue that there's nothing sentimental about it.

Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: pgroff on August 12, 2013, 04:44:54 PM
Hi all,

I agree with the excellent observations above by Theo, Steve, Howard, oggiesnr, ukebert, Ian, etc.

To anyone who thinks traditionally-constructed concertinas are a rip-off:  *you* make one that works and sounds as well, is as durable and beautiful, and of course you ought to be able to offer it for less, to support your argument.

Actually, one relative newcomer to concertina-making used to go on internet forums and argue that the antique concertinas were overpriced.  Now that he is making concertinas with traditional reeds, I note that he prices his own new instruments at a minimum of "several thousands" of US dollars.   His new concertinas may perhaps be just as good as the best of the old ones, but from the few examples that I've seen, when they appear on the market second-hand, the concertina players do not seem to value them as highly as some vintage instruments.

Of course in any market some items will be overpriced or poor value.  Some individual antique concertinas are very poor value in my opinion, and I don't much like some new ones or the way some old ones have been repaired.  But I don't think that's the point of Ted's question, which I take to be "why are the ones that are truly excellent rarely cheap?"

Actually some antique concertinas (especially some englishes and duets) are truly underpriced in my opinion, because it would cost much more to reproduce them today than to buy an old one and have it restored.  That situation used to hold for the best anglos as well and I think it created distorted expectations among a generation or two of amateur musicians especially in England.

I would actually turn the question around (agreeing with Theo that the most expensive concertinas seem strangely low in price compared to almost any other handcrafted complex instrument), and ask "Why are the very best concertinas so inexpensive?"  See for example this recent short essay I posted for an interesting comparison that has nothing to do with Stradivarius or Steinway:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,12904.0.html

I think the answer to *my* question is that there have been very few professional concertina players in the last half-century, and those few have been very poorly paid. Their audience is a relatively small, niche market who don't really spend much money to support the pros (compared for example to football fans, either type, either side of the Atlantic).   Some pro concertinists may have been able to buy a house, but not enough of them are really prospering to push up the demand for great instruments well beyond the availability of pro-quality concertinas surviving from the last century.  When I was making a modest living as a concertina player and teacher (and not a home- or car-owner), I was proud to be able to commission a new Dipper to be made for me, not only to have new design features created but also to support the livelihood of great craftspeople in my generation.  However, there are still many century-old concertinas playing so superbly that most of the relatively few pro players might be able to get by without any modern makers at all (assuming they did have a support system of great restorers).

True that many of the most expensive banjos, violins, electric guitars, etc are not owned by pros, but IMO the pros set the standards and then in a very robust musical community there are serious amateurs and collectors who begin to chase after the same most highly prized instruments.  That's how you can have the most expensive examples of some of those instruments sell for 100 times or more the cost of very similar instruments that perform almost as well.* ( In the other thread linked above, I showed an example of an inventory of banjos at asking prices ranging from around $1000 to $100,000).  But we are not even close to that kind of market with concertinas, and in fact my view is that the concertina market is skewed in the other direction:  it has sometimes seemed to me (as suggested by Ian's post) that concertina makers may often be offering a sort of charity to their customers, in effect subsidizing the production of these beautiful instruments that in some cases are purchased by those much wealthier than the makers themselves.

PG

* especially for the purposes of the musician of average ability
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Adam-T on August 12, 2013, 04:45:49 PM
I disagree with your assessment of both the concertina and the recorder!

Yup, I fully expected you (and many others) to  :-X  ....  I guess it depends on how "special" an instrument is to whoever is deciding ..

Oggie - it`s nothing to do with what`s cheap and what`s not - it`s to do with what`s ludicrously expensive (regardless as to WHY it`s so expensive) . Art is a totally different thing, a musical instrument is a device do perform a task .
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Anahata on August 12, 2013, 04:54:31 PM
So looking at an old beater won't necessarily tell you much about why a Dipper costs what it does.


If you compare a good traditionally made concertina with a cheap one, the use of accordion reeds is an obvious difference.

Concertina reeds held by screwed saddles to individual brass (or is it steel?) plates and fitted flat to the reed pan surface combine to make a very expensive manufacturing process, but it doesn't sound like a concertina if you do it any other way.

Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Owen Woods on August 12, 2013, 04:59:02 PM
And dovetailed in, don't forget that bit!
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: IanD on August 12, 2013, 05:09:47 PM
So looking at an old beater won't necessarily tell you much about why a Dipper costs what it does.


If you compare a good traditionally made concertina with a cheap one, the use of accordion reeds is an obvious difference.

Concertina reeds held by screwed saddles to individual brass (or is it steel?) plates and fitted flat to the reed pan surface combine to make a very expensive manufacturing process, but it doesn't sound like a concertina if you do it any other way.

Indeed. Since most of the cost is labour (material cost is very small in comparison) and it's been said by at least two makers that 2/3 of the cost (and time) in making a concertina is the reeds, out of £6000 this means £4000 for the traditional reeds (and dovetails) and £2000 for making the rest of the concertina -- including those fiddly leather bellows -- at decent-UK-wage-for-a-skilled-instrument-craftsman rates.

If this is correct a concertina traditionally-made in the UK or Europe or USA (except for having accordion reeds) should be about £2000, which is directly comparable with a good melodeon using the same reeds.

One made in China where the labour rates are at least 5x lower should be about £400, again the same as a Chinese melodeon.

So it all adds up -- Colin, you should be charging £6000 for a high-quality traditionally-made concertina :-)

(and hoping that the Chinese don't decide to compete with you -- which they won't because the volume is too small for high-end concertinas...)
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: mory on August 12, 2013, 05:21:40 PM
http://www.wakker-concertinas.com/making%20of.htm  This is a photo reportage of the making of  a Wakker anglo, for those that might be interested. Just follow the next page link there are several pages lovely stuff. AtB mory

and yes that is a CNC machine for the brass parts  ;)
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: LDbosca on August 12, 2013, 05:37:10 PM
Art is a totally different thing, a musical instrument is a device do perform a task .

There's no other musical instrument that can perform the same task as the concertina.
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 12, 2013, 06:05:01 PM
(http://www.theboxplace.co.uk/purchase/images/uploads/Anderson/Jeffries45/P1040897.jpg) (http://www.theboxplace.co.uk/purchase/jef45cg/prod_392.html)   
So it all adds up. Colin, you should be charging
£6000 for a high-quality traditionally-made concertina

There are still bargains to be had

Saw this  (http://www.theboxplace.co.uk/purchase/jef45cg/prod_392.html)on FB this afternoon

Hey! That Theo's a bit quiet today  ;)
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: IanD on August 12, 2013, 06:12:23 PM
http://www.wakker-concertinas.com/making%20of.htm  This is a photo reportage of the making of  a Wakker anglo, for those that might be interested. Just follow the next page link there are several pages lovely stuff. AtB mory

and yes that is a CNC machine for the brass parts  ;)

I knew Wim was using CNC, but only for some of the parts. Taken to the limit, it ought to be possible to use it for cutting out nearly all the parts (reeds, frames, levers, posts, reed pans, end plates), but the time and effort to set all this up would be huge, as would be the cost if you needed different CNC machines for different tasks...
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: dunlustin on August 12, 2013, 06:17:32 PM
What seems to be missing from this conversation is any reference to the history of concertina pricing from, say, late 1960s to present.
This might include the (near) cornering of the used and new market at one stage, the decline in fashion for the English and subsequent fall in values, the rise of the Celtic Tiger Economy and droves of proud parents spoiling their children with (C) Jeffries Anglos to contest the championships.
We might add in the number of middle-aged men with money to spare who snapped up concertinas to hide in cupboards. This generation (I include myself) is now becoming arthritic if not worse. It's just a matter of time before that takes its toll on prices. Look at the number of instruments attracting no bids on eboy, low bids at auction or gathering dust on dealers' shelves.
When I bought my house in 1988, prices were going up on a weekly basis - "you'll never lose out with bricks and mortar" - over the next decade the house increased in value by just 10%. Now nothing like that could possibly happen again, could it?
Don't tell me it's different with musical instruments - it's all about fashion, passion and disposable income.
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: pgroff on August 12, 2013, 06:31:07 PM
What seems to be missing from this conversation is any reference to the history of concertina pricing from, say, late 1960s to present.
This might include the (near) cornering of the used and new market at one stage, the decline in fashion for the English and subsequent fall in values, the rise of the Celtic Tiger Economy and droves of proud parents spoiling their children with (C) Jeffries Anglos to contest the championships.
We might add in the number of middle-aged men with money to spare who snapped up concertinas to hide in cupboards. This generation (I include myself) is now becoming arthritic if not worse. It's just a matter of time before that takes its toll on prices. Look at the number of instruments attracting no bids on eboy, low bids at auction or gathering dust on dealers' shelves.
When I bought my house in 1988, prices were going up on a weekly basis - "you'll never lose out with bricks and mortar" - over the next decade the house increased in value by just 10%. Now nothing like that could possibly happen again, could it?
Don't tell me it's different with musical instruments - it's all about fashion, passion and disposable income.

Hi Dunlustin

I agree with you, demography and fashions are very important.  Prices definitely can and do drop due to changes in demand.  That's why the used London-made concertinas became so artificially inexpensive (relative to the cost of making them new) after the 1930s, a situation which still prevails IMO for the big duets and englishes of high quality.

Vintage piano accordions are a gross example today of loss in value, and as I mentioned in the thread on banjos, their prices have turned south in recent years.  The generations to come may include fewer players and fans who are willing to spend more than $100K on a prewar Gibson flathead.  Demographic changes have hurt the demand for english concertinas in the past ten years too, at least in the US where fewer new players seem to be starting.  I don't know that prices of the best ones have dropped, but they certainly don't sell as quickly.

I'm not sure that the prices of *good examples* of vintage Jeffries anglos will drop, because they are great concertinas and there are many new, young, serious students of the anglo concertina coming up every year.  Some of the vintage anglos that were "restored" in earlier decades (especially if hastily repitched more than once, as my first Jeffries was, before sold to me by a famous english dealer) may or may not be good value at current prices and may or may not keep value in the future.  But I guess we'll have to wait and see.

The "Stradivarius bubble" has had a pretty long run so far. . .  so even when inexpensive instruments are abundant (as with violins), very desirable examples of those instruments may keep high values over a long term.

PG

Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: oggiesnr on August 12, 2013, 06:57:07 PM

Oggie - it`s nothing to do with what`s cheap and what`s not - it`s to do with what`s ludicrously expensive (regardless as to WHY it`s so expensive) . Art is a totally different thing, a musical instrument is a device do perform a task .

This is the nub of the problem, you regard top end concertinas as ludicrously expensive, I don't, I just wish I could afford one.

Steve
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 12, 2013, 08:46:12 PM
Quote
Art is a totally different thing, a musical instrument is a device do perform a task .

But how well it performs that task depends on to a considerable extent on the quality of the instrument.  Sure, a good player can make a poor instrument sound OK, but that's not a reason to accept poor quality instruments.  Good players will always go for the best they can afford, or can persuade a wealthy benefactor to lend them. 

If you don't put that value on a concertina yourself, then don't buy one.  That doesn't make the price wrong, because other people do value them.  Personally, I wouldn't give you anything for an oboe or a bassoon (which are just sticks with holes in, aren't they?) but I don't play them and don't aspire to.  As an amateur, I count myself fortunate that top-quality instruments are not way beyond my price range - yes, they are not cheap and they are an indulgence which I can't really justify in financial terms (although they've probably held their value better than some investments).  If you compare it with the violin, or even oboe or bassoon, I doubt any but the wealthiest amateur could afford an professional-quality instrument.
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: malcolmbebb on August 12, 2013, 09:10:51 PM
I think the OP has his answer - complexity, time and skill to build, low build quantity, scarcity and so on.

From there the conversation has been largely driven by Adam's coolness towards concertinas, and his particular method of expressing his views.
Adam has, on numerous occasions, expressed his strong preference for wet tuned tremelo, which is a scarce commodity on concertinas and in particular better ones. Similarly, as Howard has pointed out, it is hard to perceive significant value in an instrument which - if you'll pardon the expression - doesn't press your personal buttons.
At which point the thread moves away from cost and quality into personal preference, at which point, perhaps, "valuable" changes to "expensive".

As an aside I have noticed, quite recently at Dartmoor FF for instance, that the presence of a decent concertina in the mix at a session could be noted from afar. Long may it remain so.
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: mory on August 12, 2013, 09:16:32 PM
Something that may be overlooked in all this is the effect on the sound of the timbers used and their "coming of age". I don't for one moment believe there is no input in the sound other than the reeds, as some may proclaim. AtB mory
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: EastAnglianTed on August 12, 2013, 10:17:48 PM
   
I think the OP has his answer - complexity, time and skill to build, low build quantity, scarcity and so on.
    Indeed I do, but please keep this thread going admins as it is really interesting.
    The small thread drifts are making it even more interesting to me to be honest and people are posting some very interesting posts  (:)
    I did realise very early on that my post was very vague. I had just assumed that a concertina was second best to a melodeon, but I now know this was bollocks rubbish.
    This thread has set me straight and I have become very intrigued by these little squeezeboxes.  (:)
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: pgroff on August 12, 2013, 10:46:29 PM
Ted,

I should be the first one here to say that melodeons aren't second best to a concertina either in the quality of music they make.

In fact, I can often get more enjoyment these days playing a Hohner 1-row box than an english made concertina that might be worth ten times as much.  I also enjoy cheap german concertinas sometimes available for under $100 US. The latter are not as durable as a Hohner or a Jeffries, but great fun. 

You'll see the differences mentioned in this thread very clearly though, as you learn more about them.

PG
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: malcolmbebb on August 12, 2013, 10:55:04 PM
Minefield alert!
The two are separate instruments with a surprising amount of similarity and a surprising number of differences. Comparing them in terms of better or worse risks a very long thread and more of Theo's hair than he can afford to lose ;D

Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: IanD on August 12, 2013, 10:57:51 PM
Something that may be overlooked in all this is the effect on the sound of the timbers used and their "coming of age". I don't for one moment believe there is no input in the sound other than the reeds, as some may proclaim. AtB mory
You can believe in little green fairies at the bottom of the garden if you want, but I won't believe they exist until I see proof as opposed to faith ;-)
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: oggiesnr on August 12, 2013, 11:28:29 PM
I play melodeon, anglo, harmonica and bandoneon.  The only thing they have in common (apart from reeds etc  (:) ) is that they play a different note on the push and pull (pedant note- not always true on all notes of the bandoneon).  After that they are totally different animals are produce different musical effects even when playing the same tune.  Horses for courses, I can (and do) play the same tune on each and it will sound very different as the characteristics of each take effect, I can't play left hand counter melodies on a melodeon, I can on a concertina, I can only get a three octave seperation of notes on a bandoneon, etc etc.  None is better or worse than the others they're just different and each has a unique capability.

If concertinas aren't your thing then fine, by the same token I would find it hard to justify the cost of a new Casta, worth it to someone else but not to me.  Doesn't mean it's too expensive, just that I'd spend the money differently :)  But then I wouldn't spend more than £10K on a car but other people would.

Steve
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: EastAnglianTed on August 13, 2013, 02:17:02 AM
    I know it was ignorant of me, but I always had an idea in my head that a concertina was, in essence, a melodeon treble end split in half, each half being stuck on different ends of a smaller set of bellows and stripped down to a single reed.
    I now know this isn't the case. That was why I used to compare the two as I assumed that it was a melodeon treble end but modified. That was where I drew the comparison, that it was half of a fuller instrument. I see now that that certainly isn't the case.
    As that old saying goes, to ASSUME makes an ASS out of U and ME (much more the former  ;D)
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Adam-T on August 13, 2013, 07:06:44 AM
I think the OP has his answer

A good Summary BTW Malcolm   . For the record I do actually like single voice instruments very much, I`m a big fan of the Lilly and often play boxes with stops (even monsters like the Club Morino which also does 3 octave note separation) on one voice, I just don`t like two or more reeds dry tuned that`s all...

I didn`t think my opinion on the value of top priced concertinas (those over about £2500 where my coolness comes in) would be shared by anyone else here, I never did run with the pack on these kind of matters but Hey, Ho, takes all dun't it .....
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: malcolmbebb on August 13, 2013, 07:28:24 AM
For the record I do actually like single voice instruments very much, I`m a big fan of the Lilly and often play boxes with stops (even monsters like the Club Morino which also does 3 octave note separation) on one voice, I just don`t like two or more reeds dry tuned that`s all...
I stand corrected  :||:
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on August 13, 2013, 08:21:34 AM
An interesting discussion. I had a similar one with a concertina playing friend the other day.

In the end I think that the answer is sociological and economic, rather than technological.

The question from me was, why had there not been the concertina equivalent of the Hohner Erika/Pokerwork. An instrument cheap enough for the popular masses and yet good enough for the professional player. An instrument that has also lasted and is still in demand.

I think that the answer is that the concertina never really broke through into the mass market. They have always been produced at relatively low volumes and there is an even smaller market these days than in its relative heyday.

Melodeon players have also been lucky to have had the Italian accordion makers who were able to turn back to making the diatonic accordion when its resurgence of popularity came.

I don't see anything technological that would really have prevented concertinas being produced at a Hohner Pokerwork type quality for the mass market. If it were not for the comodification of accordion parts (including reeds) then the modern melodeon maker would face precisely the same issues that the modern concertina maker faces.
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 13, 2013, 09:06:09 AM
The reasons were mentioend earlier - concertinas are of far more complex construction and are less easy to produce in factory conditions.  For example, whereas a melodeon action is fairly uniform for all the buttons, with probably just 2 lengths of lever for the inner and outer row of buttons and the springs positioned in the same places, in a concertina  every lever has to be customised to fit, and every spring has to be individually positioned.  Also, as you have correctly pointed out, it is a smaller market.

There are relatively cheap factory-made models, but while they are suitable for beginners to get started on most players will eventually want to move on either to a vintage or a modern hybrid.  These don't meet the requirements of more advanced players, let alone professionals.  The better shops supplying these will fettle them first to overcome some of the inadequacies.
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 13, 2013, 09:39:57 AM
Minefield alert!
The two are separate instruments with a surprising amount of similarity and a surprising number of differences. Comparing them in terms of better or worse risks a very long thread and more of Theo's hair than he can afford to lose ;D

Tend to concur.

Would anyone else support our admins negotiating a transfer of his little deliberation to the Other Place our sister forum at concertina.net. While we continue our celebration of the superb quality and value for money offered by melodeons …  >:E
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Bobtheboat on August 13, 2013, 09:49:07 AM
Hi, I find the debate on relative value interesting. Before I came back into the musical fold 3 years ago I would have considered the price I paid for my new Rik to be astronomical. (Although self importing saved a packet!). Using the new comparison method developed on this thread it cost me more than twice what I've ever spent on a car! Now ,however, I consider it to be a bargain. My instruments give me a LOT of pleasure and joy not to mention a refuge from my frenetic work life, which in itself is priceless!
Two further thoughts:
My guitar/mandolin playing brother when appreciating my new box asked what you'd pay for a pro' instrument!
A pal of mine whose other half is a harp player was bemoaning the 18 grand he'd had to find to buy her a new 'jobbing' harp!! Bob
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on August 13, 2013, 09:49:53 AM
Good idea. Chris. Although I have learnt a lot from the topic.
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 13, 2013, 10:06:30 AM
i've never lost money selling on a melodeon. But my Wheatstone Linota had appreciated from £360 to £2700 in the 20 years I had it (inflation approx 2.5x).

It made a handy down payment on the Gaillard ;) but also suggested to me that there may be a rarity effect in the market for a decent 'tinas?
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: brianread on August 13, 2013, 10:42:14 AM
My Jeffries (made by Crabb!) 38 key went from £250 to £3500 in about 2 years, paid for my original Mori (s/h) and a couple of paragliding holidays in Slovenia.
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Sage Herb on August 13, 2013, 10:54:34 AM
The sale of my two Crabbs and my Jeffries paid for the renovations to my house. And two of the instruments were bought by friends, so they still visit me occasionally.

Steve
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: IanD on August 13, 2013, 10:55:09 AM
The reasons were mentioend earlier - concertinas are of far more complex construction and are less easy to produce in factory conditions.  For example, whereas a melodeon action is fairly uniform for all the buttons, with probably just 2 lengths of lever for the inner and outer row of buttons and the springs positioned in the same places, in a concertina  every lever has to be customised to fit, and every spring has to be individually positioned.  Also, as you have correctly pointed out, it is a smaller market.

There are relatively cheap factory-made models, but while they are suitable for beginners to get started on most players will eventually want to move on either to a vintage or a modern hybrid.  These don't meet the requirements of more advanced players, let alone professionals.  The better shops supplying these will fettle them first to overcome some of the inadequacies.

If the levers were CNC cut from flat sheet every one could be different with no additional cost -- the same for reeds and reed chambers/reed pan including all mounting holes, added complexity or variation  is "free" once the machine is set up. Since such machining takes no manual intervention once started, this can be done while the craftsman is doing something which needs doing by hand like instrument assembly, reed mounting/tuning, finishing/polishing and so on. My guess is that this would reduce the total cost of a UK-made instrument by at least 2x-3x if a reasonable number were made, even allowing for setup costs and remaining hand-work, which would bring the cost of a good concertina down to something similar to a good melodeon -- not surprisingly since they're basically similar apart from how they're currently made.

Of course for all this to be worth doing you'd have to then sell at least 3x as many to make the same income. I suspect this is quite possible, going by melodeon sales lots of people are willing to pay a couple of grand for an instrument, certainly hugely more than will pay five grand for a new (or top-quality old) concertina. But it would need someone with the right technical skills who was willing to put all the time and effort into setting everything up (with no income in the meantime) and take the risk of trying to create a new market segment, with no guarantee of success...
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Theo on August 13, 2013, 11:08:56 AM
So making high quality concertinas is still a labour of love.

In the UK there is an aspect of tax law which makes it easier for a small scale (one pair of hands) operation to succeed financially.  That is the VAT threshold.  A business does not have to register for VAT if the annual turnover is less than about £65000.  Since the cost of a traditionally made concertina is largely the craftsman's skill and time there is a strong incentive to keep the turnover below the VAT threshold. If you go over then prices have to rise to pay for the 20% VAT and there is an increase in administration time and cost.   Only a small proportion of the inputs are bought in and include VAT so there is not much VAT that can be reclaimed on supplies.  Result - almost 20% increase in prices, so you have to make a big step up in sales volume, which almost certainly includes taking on staff, to make it worth growing.
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Owen Woods on August 13, 2013, 11:41:01 AM
That's interesting Theo. Didn't know that, but it helps to explain perhaps why musical instrument manufacters in this country tend to be small scale.
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 13, 2013, 12:02:36 PM
Frans van der Aa is small scale, but still uses laser cutting etc in his facture. Specifically grille, selector plates and fondo.

WRT work involved, all the wires/links in my 'black' box are hand made, and curve differently. Holland has VAT/TVA as do all EU luthiers and (I guess) a similar threshold effect as Theo discusses may  apply to most of them. If you multiply a €4000 typical price by "one per month" … you would seem to remain below likely thresholds?

Another laser user incidentally seems to be Olav Bergflodt. No idea what the tax system is in Norway, but it won't be cheap ;)
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: oggiesnr on August 13, 2013, 12:20:30 PM
So making high quality concertinas is still a labour of love.

In the UK there is an aspect of tax law which makes it easier for a small scale (one pair of hands) operation to succeed financially.  That is the VAT threshold.  A business does not have to register for VAT if the annual turnover is less than about £65000.  Since the cost of a traditionally made concertina is largely the craftsman's skill and time there is a strong incentive to keep the turnover below the VAT threshold. If you go over then prices have to rise to pay for the 20% VAT and there is an increase in administration time and cost.   Only a small proportion of the inputs are bought in and include VAT so there is not much VAT that can be reclaimed on supplies.  Result - almost 20% increase in prices, so you have to make a big step up in sales volume, which almost certainly includes taking on staff, to make it worth growing.

Been there, done that and got the scars.  When I eventually recovered I made two decisions about the business, never again to become VAT registered and never again to employ staff.

If you hit the VAT limit you need to blast through it, it's no good going from £75K to £85k, you need to pretty well double your turnover and even then you'll probably find that you're making no more money than when you were a one man band.

Steve
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Howard Jones on August 13, 2013, 12:28:17 PM
Wim Wakker uses CNC for his concertinas.  I'm sure it can cut down on a great deal of the work to make the components, but they still have to be assembled by hand.  I guess the CNC machinery doesn't come cheap.

Actually, good quality concertinas can be had for not much more than a top-end melodeon.  Wim's anglos are priced at around $5000  which is in the region of £3200.   A good melodeon will cost that.  Prices of £5-£6k or even more are at the top end and are for very specific instruments in a very specific market (ITM). Or they're scams, as a great many advertised on ebay turn out to be.

The problem with concertina prices is not at the top end, where they are value for money, but at the lower end where there is a lack of good instruments at affordable prices.
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: IanD on August 13, 2013, 12:53:44 PM
Wim Wakker uses CNC for his concertinas.  I'm sure it can cut down on a great deal of the work to make the components, but they still have to be assembled by hand.  I guess the CNC machinery doesn't come cheap.

Actually, good quality concertinas can be had for not much more than a top-end melodeon.  Wim's anglos are priced at around $5000  which is in the region of £3200.   A good melodeon will cost that.  Prices of £5-£6k or even more are at the top end and are for very specific instruments in a very specific market (ITM). Or they're scams, as a great many advertised on ebay turn out to be.

The problem with concertina prices is not at the top end, where they are value for money, but at the lower end where there is a lack of good instruments at affordable prices.

Exactly what I said -- unlike melodeons, with concertinas there are only really Rolls-Royces at the top end (fantastic quality and price to match) and Trabants at the bottom end (cheap for a reason), there aren't any Fords or VWs in the middle (good quality, sounding like a "real" concertina, and affordable).
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: dunlustin on August 14, 2013, 10:49:37 AM
Coming back to the OP and having been there, I'm surprised that nobody dwells on the irrational passion people have for these instruments. That passion is what moves people to pay unspeakable amounts of money for something they dearly wish to own. It can be a Gibson guitar, a Selmer sax or an Anglo by a praised maker.
It's about the market - when cornered in the 70s that's why mostly only rubbish was  available in the shops and my Anglo went up by 50% six months after I ordered it.
I really don't understand how a 5 - 7 year wait (as I read) - even 4 years come to that -  can be seen as a business proposition. It's a self-indulgence on both sides and that's why there is no real reason for prices. This is even harder to justify when some professionals can carve out a 50 year career with just one instrument - and not top of the range at that.
You can buy a world class CBA for the price of an Anglo - that did not used to be the case and it still makes no objective sense.
Title: Re: Why are some Concertinas so expensive?
Post by: Theo on August 14, 2013, 02:16:58 PM
Original question has been thoroughly answered, now into territory more suited to concertina.net.  Please support that site for further concertina discussion.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal