- even where costs can be reduced by using accordion reeds, most of the work has to be done by hand.
Have you ever looked inside a concertina Ted? That should answer your question! Much more intricate, much more complicated, much higher tolerances.Admittedly not, though I know where I can have a look as a relative has an old beaten up one. I will have a look with great interest soon (:)
Like everything else in the world the price of concertinas will settle at the amount of money people are will to give for them.
Like everything else in the world the price of concertinas will settle at the amount of money people are will to give for them.
This conversation has centred around high end boxes. It is possible* to buy a new concertina for under £200. Similarly, Germany has pumped out many thousands of "export" boxes in varying qualities for much of the last century, many of which were affordable and did sterling work as instruments for ordinary people.Have you ever looked inside a concertina Ted? That should answer your question! Much more intricate, much more complicated, much higher tolerances.Admittedly not, though I know where I can have a look as a relative has an old beaten up one. I will have a look with great interest soon (:)
This conversation has centred around high end boxes. It is possible* to buy a new concertina for under £200. Similarly, Germany has pumped out many thousands of "export" boxes in varying qualities for much of the last century, many of which were affordable and did sterling work as instruments for ordinary people.
Construction and design follows accordion practice, which they were also banging out by the thousands.
So looking at an old beater won't necessarily tell you much about why a Dipper costs what it does.
Another factor is that the high end concertina makers put a lot of work into the design and craftsmanship of the whole instrument, fretwork and bellows. You have only to look at a high end concertina, a Dipper or a Wakker, several others these days, to see that you have not just a musical instrument but a work of art. And that's before you pick it up and feel the action... you have stopped wondering why they're expensive by this point.
Malcolm
*I said possible. I didn't say recommended.
Just wondering why, in some cases for example, if you sold a Mory (i.e. very expensive box) you still wouldn't have enough money to buy some concertinas?
Is it to do with age? Reed quality? I know it's a fast and loose question but I can't find why some small concertinas cost £4000 and up.
I am well aware of why, when it comes to a melodeon, that say a Castagnari costs more than a Hohner (workmanship, reed quality etc.) but concertinas are generally smaller than nearly all boxes and have one reed per note so less reeds overall (in general?).
Their size would dictate less materials needed, so I can't work out why they cost so much. Is it a fiddly instrument to construct? Much like a pocket watch is harder to make than a grandfather clock (sizewise)?
Just a general question, not having a go just genuinely interested :D
Adjusted for inflation this would be £4300 today. If this wasn't enough to make a decent living for a highly skilled craftman then, I doubt if it is now.
I disagree with your assessment of both the concertina and the recorder!
Adjusted for inflation this would be £4300 today. If this wasn't enough to make a decent living for a highly skilled craftman then, I doubt if it is now.
So it must get to a stage where the concertina as an instrument isn`t worth the expenditure in time and money for a master craftsman to make to a certain standard - I hate to say this but it`s only a concertina at the end of the day - rather like the £2500 recorder business, it`s not a Bassoon or an Oboe or a clarinet, it`s just a recorder .....
I guess this is another of those "out on my own" things again , I just don`t have the sentimentality for the Concertina to be able to even comprehend why someone would pay as much as a new car for one.
I bet Colin Dipper etc could make the worlds most expensive mouthie with individual reedplates, special valves, exotic materials too - OK there`s no where near as much in there as even the simplest Anglos but the same would apply in the time & build cost to "what it is" ratio
Adjusted for inflation this would be £4300 today. If this wasn't enough to make a decent living for a highly skilled craftman then, I doubt if it is now.
So it must get to a stage where the concertina as an instrument isn`t worth the expenditure in time and money for a master craftsman to make to a certain standard - I hate to say this but it`s only a concertina at the end of the day - rather like the £2500 recorder business, it`s not a Bassoon or an Oboe or a clarinet, it`s just a recorder .....
I guess this is another of those "out on my own" things again , I just don`t have the sentimentality for the Concertina to be able to even comprehend why someone would pay as much as a new car for one.
Adjusted for inflation this would be £4300 today. If this wasn't enough to make a decent living for a highly skilled craftman then, I doubt if it is now.
So it must get to a stage where the concertina as an instrument isn`t worth the expenditure in time and money for a master craftsman to make to a certain standard - I hate to say this but it`s only a concertina at the end of the day - rather like the £2500 recorder business, it`s not a Bassoon or an Oboe or a clarinet, it`s just a recorder .....
I guess this is another of those "out on my own" things again , I just don`t have the sentimentality for the Concertina to be able to even comprehend why someone would pay as much as a new car for one.
I bet Colin Dipper etc could make the worlds most expensive mouthie with individual reedplates, special valves, exotic materials too - OK there`s no where near as much in there as even the simplest Anglos but the same would apply in the time & build cost to "what it is" ratio
I disagree with your assessment of both the concertina and the recorder!
So looking at an old beater won't necessarily tell you much about why a Dipper costs what it does.
So looking at an old beater won't necessarily tell you much about why a Dipper costs what it does.
If you compare a good traditionally made concertina with a cheap one, the use of accordion reeds is an obvious difference.
Concertina reeds held by screwed saddles to individual brass (or is it steel?) plates and fitted flat to the reed pan surface combine to make a very expensive manufacturing process, but it doesn't sound like a concertina if you do it any other way.
Art is a totally different thing, a musical instrument is a device do perform a task .
| (http://www.theboxplace.co.uk/purchase/images/uploads/Anderson/Jeffries45/P1040897.jpg) (http://www.theboxplace.co.uk/purchase/jef45cg/prod_392.html) | So it all adds up. Colin, you should be charging There are still bargains to be had Saw this (http://www.theboxplace.co.uk/purchase/jef45cg/prod_392.html)on FB this afternoon Hey! That Theo's a bit quiet today ;) |
http://www.wakker-concertinas.com/making%20of.htm This is a photo reportage of the making of a Wakker anglo, for those that might be interested. Just follow the next page link there are several pages lovely stuff. AtB mory
and yes that is a CNC machine for the brass parts ;)
What seems to be missing from this conversation is any reference to the history of concertina pricing from, say, late 1960s to present.
This might include the (near) cornering of the used and new market at one stage, the decline in fashion for the English and subsequent fall in values, the rise of the Celtic Tiger Economy and droves of proud parents spoiling their children with (C) Jeffries Anglos to contest the championships.
We might add in the number of middle-aged men with money to spare who snapped up concertinas to hide in cupboards. This generation (I include myself) is now becoming arthritic if not worse. It's just a matter of time before that takes its toll on prices. Look at the number of instruments attracting no bids on eboy, low bids at auction or gathering dust on dealers' shelves.
When I bought my house in 1988, prices were going up on a weekly basis - "you'll never lose out with bricks and mortar" - over the next decade the house increased in value by just 10%. Now nothing like that could possibly happen again, could it?
Don't tell me it's different with musical instruments - it's all about fashion, passion and disposable income.
Oggie - it`s nothing to do with what`s cheap and what`s not - it`s to do with what`s ludicrously expensive (regardless as to WHY it`s so expensive) . Art is a totally different thing, a musical instrument is a device do perform a task .
Art is a totally different thing, a musical instrument is a device do perform a task .
I think the OP has his answer - complexity, time and skill to build, low build quantity, scarcity and so on.Indeed I do, but please keep this thread going admins as it is really interesting.
Something that may be overlooked in all this is the effect on the sound of the timbers used and their "coming of age". I don't for one moment believe there is no input in the sound other than the reeds, as some may proclaim. AtB moryYou can believe in little green fairies at the bottom of the garden if you want, but I won't believe they exist until I see proof as opposed to faith ;-)
I think the OP has his answer
For the record I do actually like single voice instruments very much, I`m a big fan of the Lilly and often play boxes with stops (even monsters like the Club Morino which also does 3 octave note separation) on one voice, I just don`t like two or more reeds dry tuned that`s all...I stand corrected :||:
Minefield alert!
The two are separate instruments with a surprising amount of similarity and a surprising number of differences. Comparing them in terms of better or worse risks a very long thread and more of Theo's hair than he can afford to lose ;D
The reasons were mentioend earlier - concertinas are of far more complex construction and are less easy to produce in factory conditions. For example, whereas a melodeon action is fairly uniform for all the buttons, with probably just 2 lengths of lever for the inner and outer row of buttons and the springs positioned in the same places, in a concertina every lever has to be customised to fit, and every spring has to be individually positioned. Also, as you have correctly pointed out, it is a smaller market.
There are relatively cheap factory-made models, but while they are suitable for beginners to get started on most players will eventually want to move on either to a vintage or a modern hybrid. These don't meet the requirements of more advanced players, let alone professionals. The better shops supplying these will fettle them first to overcome some of the inadequacies.
So making high quality concertinas is still a labour of love.
In the UK there is an aspect of tax law which makes it easier for a small scale (one pair of hands) operation to succeed financially. That is the VAT threshold. A business does not have to register for VAT if the annual turnover is less than about £65000. Since the cost of a traditionally made concertina is largely the craftsman's skill and time there is a strong incentive to keep the turnover below the VAT threshold. If you go over then prices have to rise to pay for the 20% VAT and there is an increase in administration time and cost. Only a small proportion of the inputs are bought in and include VAT so there is not much VAT that can be reclaimed on supplies. Result - almost 20% increase in prices, so you have to make a big step up in sales volume, which almost certainly includes taking on staff, to make it worth growing.
Wim Wakker uses CNC for his concertinas. I'm sure it can cut down on a great deal of the work to make the components, but they still have to be assembled by hand. I guess the CNC machinery doesn't come cheap.
Actually, good quality concertinas can be had for not much more than a top-end melodeon. Wim's anglos are priced at around $5000 which is in the region of £3200. A good melodeon will cost that. Prices of £5-£6k or even more are at the top end and are for very specific instruments in a very specific market (ITM). Or they're scams, as a great many advertised on ebay turn out to be.
The problem with concertina prices is not at the top end, where they are value for money, but at the lower end where there is a lack of good instruments at affordable prices.