Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: ether823 on August 14, 2013, 09:17:30 PM

Title: el cheapo melodeons
Post by: ether823 on August 14, 2013, 09:17:30 PM
I wonder if anyone can help. Should I invest a couple of hundred quid in a 2 row D/G Stephanelli or a Scarlatti or get a one row C Hohner (second hand) for about 130 quid? I`ve read that it is easier to learn on a two row than a one row. Money is quite tight at the moment.
Title: Re: el cheapo melodeons
Post by: pikey on August 14, 2013, 09:37:15 PM
Scarlatti 2row.  One rows are harder to learn ! If you can afford it, get a Black Diamond. Great value boxes, and well made.
Title: Re: el cheapo melodeons
Post by: deltasalmon on August 14, 2013, 09:38:48 PM
I'm guessing all this talk about one rows being difficult to learn is compared to fourth apart boxes? I've never played a fourth apart box but I'd say that a one-row is certainly easier to learn than a semi-tone box. Less options with bass and treble combinations means less chance of hitting clashing notes.
Title: Re: el cheapo melodeons
Post by: pikey on August 14, 2013, 09:47:59 PM
I'm guessing all this talk about one rows being difficult to learn is compared to fourth apart boxes? I've never played a fourth apart box but I'd say that a one-row is certainly easier to learn than a semi-tone box. Less options with bass and treble combinations means less chance of hitting clashing notes.

Yep, I meant a d/g. ,  c/f.

Anything is easier than a semitone box !!! Apart from a bandoneon.....
Title: Re: el cheapo melodeons
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 14, 2013, 11:00:59 PM
if you want to play solo, or in a few Special Places, East Anglia, or Louisiana, get the C  1-row, or D up North, or in Québec. Great fun in the right context.

If you want to play sessions:, D/G in UK, G/C in France or Belgium, C/F if you want to play with Bagpipes. 3 row to cover many bases in one, but not for £130!

Hope this helps. If the second hand price is fair, you can switch later and not lose out.

[edit].Irish players do brilliant stuff on B/C and other half tone kit.
Title: Re: el cheapo melodeons
Post by: Theo on August 14, 2013, 11:39:31 PM
Money spent on a Scarlatti is not an investment, but the Hohner one row, depending on its condition should hold its value.

While agreeing that a two row is easier to learn than a one row of similar quality,   I have to say that some of the very cheap boxes available these days can be quite discouraging because they are such hard work to play.
Title: Re: el cheapo melodeons
Post by: Anahata on August 15, 2013, 12:07:27 AM
It's a myth that everyone plays C one-rows in East Anglia, though there are some about and it's the mainstay of the Suffolk Old Glory Molly band (5 of them if they all turn up!). D/G will get you a lot further in most sessions.

However if you're not intending immediately to join in with your local tune sessions, a Hohner C one row is an absolutely wonderful thing to have and you'll learn a lot and enjoy playing it.

£130 is quite cheap though - I wonder if it's going to be in good playing condition. Even so, if it's playable at all it's probably worth having and getting fixed when you can afford it, while as Theo says, the Scarlatti will never be a good box.
Title: Re: el cheapo melodeons
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 15, 2013, 12:21:18 AM
It's a myth that everyone plays C one-rows in East Anglia, though there are some about and it's the mainstay of the Suffolk Old Glory Molly band (5 of them if they all turn up!). D/G will get you a lot further in most sessions.

The "playing with others" facet was my main point. But we don't know ether823's (is that ID real!)'s circumstances. Hence the wider speculation, admittedly very broad brush. eg Met my old friend Queenie Harris last year, she was on a "D"!
Title: Re: el cheapo melodeons
Post by: Frank Lee on August 15, 2013, 12:37:32 PM
Tried the cheaper Black Diamond and a Primo models, both Chinese built, in Sidmouth last week.  Without taking them apart to investigate build quality, external appearances of both were very impressive, the Black Diamond looking somewhat the better of the two, but the Primo having the (essential for my playing) advantage of a stop for removing the thirds from the bass chords. (Why the h*ll do they fit thirds if you can't remove them? It adds cost, weight, and effectively halves the usefulness of the box for general playing!).  Both are outside your budget but seemed very good value at the £450-ish price for either.  They have Italian reeds and sound great.  My formula for calculating the price of a melodeon is:-    Purchase price minus eventual sale price all divided by the units of enjoyment you (and to be hoped others) have had from your playing of it.  Very little in other words, and probably worth going into hock for the initial purchase price!  I stopped paying my TV license and spend my TV watching time playing my box - FAR more rewarding - and there's another £170+ towards the cost of your box!
Title: Re: el cheapo melodeons
Post by: Helena Handcart on August 15, 2013, 01:05:23 PM
As a relative beginner myself I just wanted to add weight to the 'buy the best you can afford' argument.  It's not worth buying a cheap box just because it is cheap or available, decide what you want to play, investigate the beginner options and buy the best you can even if it means waiting a bit longer. It will probably cost you less in the long run and there is more chance of the box keeping its value for resale. Also more chance of success for you in your learning. Which is nice  :|glug

For my *whispers* 40th birthday my husband bought me my first box. Having done my research I really wanted to begin with an old Pokerwork or Erica but ended up with a Delicia Popular Deluxe mainly because it was about £150-£200 cheaper and one was available. We never bonded, I made very little progress in 4 months, and decided the whole thing probably wasn't for me. Then came Peggy, my E-bay Pokerwork compared to the Delicia the build quality was best described as 'rattly' but oh how much lighter and smoother than the Delicia and 'she' used about half as much air  :|||:

I'm not saying the Delicia was a bad box, just not at all for me and if I'm honest not what I really wanted from the start, YMMV and all that.

End result, Delicia got sold old on while a year later the pokerwork gets played daily. I probably only lost about £30 on the Delicia all told but add to that the fact that I bought the pokerwork in decent-ish but unmodified condition then got it fettled and tuned I probably spent  £50-£75 more than just buying the finished article direct.

Conclusion: decide what you want, how much you can stretch to then talk to the experts, there are several on this forum.  Oh, and have lots and lots of fun too  :||: (:)



Title: Re: el cheapo melodeons
Post by: pikey on August 15, 2013, 01:26:04 PM
Like!!  (:)

I'm lucky to have started on a Pokerwork bought for my 18th birthday present. It still works, and still gets played, with minimal maintenance over the years despiet 1000s of hours hard playing in sessions, for dances, and outside for morris.  Ok, its battered , but so what!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2TXUgbajEFI

Hence if you can afford it, get a Pokerwork.
Title: Re: el cheapo melodeons
Post by: Tufty on August 15, 2013, 02:44:18 PM
Like!!  (:)

I'm lucky to have started on a Pokerwork bought for my 18th birthday present. It still works, and still gets played, with minimal maintenance over the years despiet 1000s of hours hard playing in sessions, for dances, and outside for morris.  Ok, its battered , but so what!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2TXUgbajEFI

Hence if you can afford it, get a Pokerwork.

Or better still an Erica. I have owned both and find the Erica MUCH more confortable to play. All the insides are petty much identical. However you will need £300 ish. Just be glad you don't want an anglo concertina!!!
Title: Re: el cheapo melodeons
Post by: Helena Handcart on August 15, 2013, 03:40:25 PM
Or better still an Erica. I have owned both and find the Erica MUCH more confortable to play. All the insides are petty much identical. However you will need £300 ish.

To be honest if had known then what I know now I'd plump for the Erica too.  In black preferably. I think £300 is an optimistic price though given what they have been going for on Fleabay recently. 

Of course if anyone out there in melnet land desperately wants to sell an Erica at around the £300 mark then I've got a mate that wants one to learn on  >:E
Title: Re: el cheapo melodeons
Post by: David J on August 15, 2013, 03:45:36 PM
I started with an £80 'no brand' Weltmeister bought off ebay. Not a bad Pokerwork equivalent, but trouble was it had to be repaired twice in the first 8 months of ownership. I was probably unlucky with this, but I certainly was very lucky to get my expenditure recovered when I disposed of it, again via ebay.

On the other hand I have had no problems in 3 years with a fairly battered Pokerwork, so like the others my advice would be to stick out for one of these via ebay (preferably a German-made one) and make sure it comes from a genuine melodeon player who can vouch for it being in tune and mechanically OK, and not the 'found in the attic/my Dad played it' type of seller. £300-350 should get you a reasonable one, and you won't regret it.
Title: Re: el cheapo melodeons
Post by: pikey on August 15, 2013, 05:38:31 PM
I started with an £80 'no brand' Weltmeister bought off ebay. Not a bad Pokerwork equivalent, but trouble was it had to be repaired twice in the first 8 months of ownership. I was probably unlucky with this, but I certainly was very lucky to get my expenditure recovered when I disposed of it, again via ebay.

On the other hand I have had no problems in 3 years with a fairly battered Pokerwork, so like the others my advice would be to stick out for one of these via ebay (preferably a German-made one) and make sure it comes from a genuine melodeon player who can vouch for it being in tune and mechanically OK, and not the 'found in the attic/my Dad played it' type of seller. £300-350 should get you a reasonable one, and you won't regret it.

Agree. My mate has just bought a 2nd hand german Pokerwork for £350 from our local folky shop (Red Cow Music) , with 12 months warranty. I road tested it for him before purchase to make sure it was sound.

My advice would be to contact the folk shops/sellers/repairers, and let them know you're after one. PM me if you want a list of them.

Cheers

Pikey
Title: Re: el cheapo melodeons
Post by: ether823 on August 15, 2013, 07:07:43 PM
Thanks folks for the info. I think I`ll try a hohner and to Chris Ryall, yes my ID is real, it is the first 4 letters of my surname and the 3 numbers are the last 3 of my army number.
Title: Re: el cheapo melodeons
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 15, 2013, 09:47:15 PM
I'll stick with the name my parents gave me in 1953 … and my family name, thanks.
Title: Re: el cheapo melodeons
Post by: pikey on August 15, 2013, 10:18:37 PM
I'll stick to the one the late Richard Atkinson from Ebor Morris gave me in 1975  ;)
Title: Re: el cheapo melodeons
Post by: ButtonBox21 on August 16, 2013, 12:49:21 PM
I think the first thing you need to do, is decide what kind of music you want to play. Once you decide, then look for the style box used in that genre. Many players use a two or two and a half row. Cajun and Quebecois will use a single row. Irish uses a two row. Three row is much more versatile and may be worth considering. Find an instructor in your area see what they say about a good starter box.  A good place to see and hear different models is YouTube.  I understand you desire to start on the cheap. I did the same thing when I learned Cajun music and bought a Hohner Arrietta. I kept it only five months and sold it for half what I paid. I was lucky to get what I did. Cheap Chinese junk will become a chore to play. Stiff bellows and cheap reeds will use a lot of air and after an hour practice you will be downright tired. Your left shoulder and your fingers will be stiff. Please, stay away from Chinese junk. Look for a good used box for your style of music. Try eBay in your country and visit as many accordion shops as possible. Look at what they offer and try a few models to see how they sound and feel. Above all, listen to what the experts on this forum have to say. There are several on this forum and they know all about button accordions, so you are in good hands. Good luck and good hunting. :||:
Title: Re: el cheapo melodeons
Post by: ether823 on August 17, 2013, 07:52:01 PM
Thanks for the advice "street cleaner".
Title: Re: el cheapo melodeons
Post by: Steve C. on August 18, 2013, 01:43:16 PM
Your first box, what ever it is, will never be your last.....
Follow the threads' advice as to what is most used in your area/type of music, make sure it plays, at least.
And just like a used car, most boxes will need something done, wax, pallets, tuning, etc., so likely you should budget for at least minor repair.
And like a used car, you gets what you pays for (usually) so no such thing as a good, cheap box.
Title: Re: el cheapo melodeons
Post by: Steve Morrison on April 04, 2020, 03:23:52 PM
I have been selling both Scarlatti and Stephanelli melodeons for many years and have found them trouble free. Many people buy them from sites like Amazon and EBay and none of these sites gives a monkey about its playability, it’s just about how many they can shift.
At Red Cow Music we check every instrument, cheap or expensive to insure the instrument arrives ready to play. We also have a great back up of our workshop and advise on how to cure those simple hick ups.
So before you buy think about where you are buying from and talk to a good melodeon retailer, there aren’t many left but the ones that are, are there for a reason, Satisfied Customers.
Title: Re: el cheapo melodeons
Post by: george garside on April 06, 2020, 07:40:48 PM
I started with a hohner double ray  60 years ago  , progressed to a trichord BCC.  later on when I started playing for morris I added a hohner DGand when I could afford it a hohner 3 row 96 bass .somewhere along the line a hohner 1 row in G came my way  so I obviously fing hohners very satisfactory boxes , but cant comment on the current Chinese veriety of pokerwork!
' 
I also have 2 'non hohner' boxes - a 3 row serenellini DG which I bought second hand at a bargain price  and like because its fairly wet tuned and is MML and a catagnari lilly DGwhich I bought new a few years ago  to keep for my 'old age'--it is the box I play least and keep thinking of flogging as my old age is always 10 years hence!!

george ( only 78)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal