Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Adam-T on August 16, 2013, 07:55:15 AM
-
I spotted this "Pre-1040" on E-Bay and thought it was very interesting - made before they got the metal action (from Koch?) and looks very much like a Klingenthal box on the outside (bass panel, bellows arrangement etc) but is very much a Hohner on the inside which didn`t really change even on the latest 1040s .. by this it seems that Hohner never used Unified reedplates, even for the chords in the bass end .
-
Interesting piece, i wonder how it could sound with these brass reeds.
-
Adam,
I have seen certain Hohner-labeled diatonics with multiple reeds on long zinc plates. But I don't think I've ever seen Hohner-labeled boxes with steel reeds on long aluminum plates (and with steel reeds combined on a common aluminum plate for triads), as with some of the Beaver Brand boxes.
PG
-
Thanks for joining in this Paul , I`m sure you`ll sort things out 8) .. that Box is in the USA
The only unified plate Hohner labelled boxes I`ve seen were "Takeovers" like the ones with the trumpet on the front - where Hohner bought the company and either labelled existing stock and/or existing parts made into boxes . but of course, my knowledge is patchy at best and there`s a hell of a lot more out there than I`ve seen .
I have to be honest that I`ve not seen steel reeds on unified plates at all outside current production of Bandoneons (Pigini and Polverini) . even later Saxony boxes (70s) I`ve opened with unified alluminium plates have had brass reeds on (Worldmaster 1040 clone, Scholer concertina), but again, I`ve only seen 1000th of what`s out there .. as for Beaver brand, was that another takeover ? , Theo had that very un-hohnerlike 2 row one but I`ve seen ones which look just like a 2915 presswood .
That box in the OP to me looks like a rare Pre-Koch 1040 - they`d got the innards set in stone but the mechanics / bellows setup etc just needed that Koch buyout to perfect ? ? :) Maybe
-
Theo had that very un-hohnerlike 2 row one but I`ve seen ones which look just like a 2915 presswood .
You are wrong about that Adam, if referring to this one (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,3921.msg48891.html#msg48891). It was like a Hohner in every way except for the name and the external finish. H reeds on individual plates, metal action, mushroom bass buttons, straps, fingerboard shape, even the Hohner style aluminium plate saying "Steel Reeds"
-
Must have got something mixed up then - I`m sure I saw one with very unhohner like reedblocks and the bass end triads on unified plates .....
EDIT - I Did - It was the Beaver brand PA in Pauls link in that thread ...... Doh...
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,12931
-
Must have got something mixed up then - I`m sure I saw one with very unhohner like reedblocks and the bass end triads on unified plates .....
EDIT - I Did - It was the Beaver brand PA in Pauls link in that thread ...... Doh...
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,12931
Hi Adam,
We can try to get this sorted out (at least the evidence on hand, of course more could be forthcoming). First let's back up a little. :-)
1) You make a good point in your OP (despite the exception I noted). Based on the boxes I've seen, I think in general that even cheap early models of Hohner tend to lack the long reedplates. Instead they tend to have "individual reedplates" (2 reedtongues to a plate, for press and draw) even in many of the brass-tongued and cheap models from the teens and twenties. IMO, YMMV etc.
2) But I have seen prewar Hohner 1-row boxes with steel reeds on long zinc plates. I have some of the parts from a wrecked example of one of them here in Miami so will try to photograph and post here in a few days. This is an awkwardly large box with 4 metal stops and an early version of gold-and-black pattern on the woodwork (somewhat similar in finish to the postwar HA series).
3) I agree with Theo that some diatonic boxes with the "Beaver Brand" label seem to be built just like Hohners -- I've seen his photos. But previous to seeing his pics, and since, here in the US I've seen many more Beaver Brands with very different construction (including steel reeds on long aluminum plates), such as the 2-row CF box that I illustrated in this older thread:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,3921
4) In the more recent thread, where I linked to a new ebay auction of a Beaver Brand PA, possibly made by Weidlich, the internal photo of the reedplates was from that same 2-row CF box, just repeated again for convenience.* I don't know what the insides of the PA look like but it wouldn't surprise me if they were similar to the CF.
Will try to get pics of those Hohner plates when I can,
PG
*
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,12931.0.html
-
Thanks Paul - could the unified reedplate Hohners you`ve seen possibly have been "buyins" or those made by companies they`ve taken over ? . I got mixed up over the Beaver brand 2 row photos with the PA insides .
Hohner have been doing the buyin thing quite consistently over a long period of time EG:- the Hohnica PAs aren`t made by Hohner (if I remember rightly, they used to be made in east germany, later China) also nowadays they badge the chinese toy PAs and the "Chanson" toy melodeons - You can bet your boots that the Ariette 4-stop isn`t even made in Hohners Chinese factory but made elsewhere etc .. T
there seem to be a lot more of the interesting 1 rows over your side than here .. The only bigger Enigma than Hohners machinations over the years is that of Paolo Soprani (and who made what and when) that`s interesting too
-
Hi Adam,
For sure Hohner bought other companies and leased production. In one of the earlier threads on Beaver Brand, I mentioned a large late-1920s Hohner catalog ("no. 700") that lists several of these companies and brands "taken over" by Hohner (by that point in time), by name. Kalbe, Gessner, Mira, Regal, Imperial, and Koch are mentioned specifically, but not Beaver Brand nor Weidlich.
PG
-
OK, here's an identifiable part of a pre-WW2 Hohner box that had steel melody reeds on 4 long zinc plates, and the triad reeds on a common plate as well. Have not found the plates themselves, but when I do I will add photos of them. The box was in C, and I think LMMH but possibly MMHH. Note that it is at least an inch taller and wider than the early-1950s HA 114 C, although that later box has "individual reedplates."
PG
edited to add: And sure enough, this model seems to be listed in that late - 1920s Hohner catalog "No. 700," on page 36, among the "Large size German type of Hohner models."
It is likely model "No. 724/10/4. Size 12 1/4 X 6 7/8 inches, 10 button keys with brass valves, 4 sets of s t e e l r e e d s, octave tuning, metal stops, 12 fold bellows with 2 center frames . . . "
The words "steel reeds" in the written description of this model are widely spaced, and I think that's because just before the catalog was printed the specifications of this model were changed from "steel bronze" to "steel" reeds. The illustration of 724/10/4 shows the accordion with lettering that reeds "STEEL BRONZE REEDS."
-
Fantastic find Paul !!. it`s got the identifiable Pokerwork design as well ! .. seems odd that they used steel reeds on unified plates there but brass reeds on individual plates on the pre-1040 .
My guess is that single plates made the close proximity of the fixed reedblocks easier to deal with for assembly (and save money too?) but do the steel reeds place that box later than the pre-1040 ? it looks more modern (as in like a Hohner) externally bar the stops
-
Fantastic find Paul !!. it`s got the identifiable Pokerwork design as well ! .. seems odd that they used steel reeds on unified plates there but brass reeds on individual plates on the pre-1040 .
My guess is that single plates made the close proximity of the fixed reedblocks easier to deal with for assembly (and save money too?) but do the steel reeds place that box later than the pre-1040 ? it looks more modern (as in like a Hohner) externally bar the stops
Hi Adam,
Thanks, the 724/10/4 is an interesting old machine, too bad it isn't in better shape.
The bellows were a wreck, one of the unusual pallets was missing, reedblocks broken, etc. Of course it could have been rebuilt at great expense and/or as a labor of love but the size and proportions seem awkward too. So it was a display piece in my old shop and then recently I think I sent the treble side casework down to Miami from storage in NY because I thought I might be able to use a part for a repair job. The bass side and the reedplates are likely still in NY but pics of those can be added to this thread someday.
IMO Hohner made and sold boxes with long-plate reeds and "individual reedplates" concurrently in the 1910s and 1920s. In fact, some of the very first Hohner 1-row boxes with the "1904" decorations had individual reedplates (with brass reeds).
I agree with you that 724/10/4 does have a family resemblance to some postwar Hohners, so it does indeed look modern in that sense. But let's consider the "old" features. My fragmentary example may give a false impression here, but the bellows had dividers for example. The gold and black pattern in various forms was in use very early in the 1920s on 1-row and 2-row boxes. Note in my pics that the 724/10/4 has exposed, decorated pallets, wooden button levers, metal-capped wooden buttons, decorative metal stops, and casework attached to the bellows frames with screws. Also, note in the photo below that the reedblocks were the "2 flat plus a vertical A frame" type, glued down with wooden sliders. The A frame reedblock is not present here.
PG
-
This is excellent info and (along with the Pre-1040) a pivotal point in Hohners early melodeon development .
it`s an amazing start to a metamorphosis of the trad German 4 stop with its two flat plates, two on blocks with zinc & Brass reedplates/tongues, pressed tin stops with logos on, open pallets, lever & wire action and sectioned bellows to the HA114 as we know it ...... this box you have is the traditional type with beginnings of Hohner-ism . Fantastic, I wonder how many stages it went through to get to the 114 as we know it ? .
-
Hi Adam,
You would enjoy looking through the old Hohner catalogs from 1900s - 1930s, their "accordion instructors" that also list and illustrate various models, and music dealer (and general-goods-dealer) catalogs that also listed Hohner instruments. If those are hard to find in the UK, you can often find them on ebay either as separate items or in the box with accordions. Sometimes I've seen scanned copies being sold on a dvd, and the Musica Viva website (which is down at present but promises to return) has offered a lot of the catalog images and descriptions.
PG
-
I`ll have a look for that ! . I don`t know why but it`s been Hohner and Paolo Soprani which have interested me historically , probably because the former bought so many companies up and the latter (the Name anyway) changed hands so many times ..
-
Here are 4 to watch for. Ca 1906 (?), 1926, "No. 700 (192?)," 1929. I think the last one was reprinted in the 1930s also. The earliest one shown is priced for the UK (priced 6d), others look to be for the USA.
I'm sure you have already seen the common, postwar book by Valentine ("The art of playing HOHNER diatonic accordions"), that illustrates some models. Different printings updated the appearance of these, but the earliest one I have here is dated 1951.
PG
-
Yeah - it`s the 1900s-1940s era where the most mystery is .
-
Hi Adam,
Here's one a little later (I think) than in your original post, still wooden action but with bellows pins instead of the wide bellows frames and hooks:
http://www.ebay.com/itm/VINTAGE-ANTIQUE-HOHNER-ACCORDION-MELODEON-4-10-BUTTON-OLD-SMALL-ACCORDIAN-WORKS-/171107792423
Just FYI, not mine and likely not economical to restore.
A photo for future reference:
-
What a strange cross-development - we have this which has the modern 1040 belows setup but the pre-Koch open action but then have 2 rows with the modern action and wide frames like my own "Original Hohner" Koch 2 2 row...
there must have been a reason for keeping the 2 row boxes on wide B-frames longer , I doubt its ease of service as the reedblocks come out - whereas you`d think the 1040 would benefit from the wide B-Frames / narrow end pieces due to the fixed Pan setup .. strange .
-
Adam, you may be interested in this one to throw into the mix. It's a Koch 1 row four bass, it has the bellows extensions but fitted together with four long screws not the fancy hooks. Open wooden keyboard, unified reed plates, with what looks to my untutored eye to be brass (yellow) treble reeds, but with steel reeds(?) in the bass on individual plates stamped with the Koch goat.
Unlike the pre-1040 it has a completely flat bass side (which doesn't perform terribly well at present, tho the treble is OK). It's in D, and stamped D on the side of the keyboard which suggests that's the original key.
The spring for the airbutton is on the outside. It has no mountain goat logo on the case, but an elephant instead (why? is this a shop logo?).
Does anyone think it's a pre- or post-hohner Koch?
Steve
-
Adam, you may be interested in this one to throw into the mix. It's a Koch 1 row four bass, it has the bellows extensions but fitted together with four long screws not the fancy hooks. Open wooden keyboard, unified reed plates, with what looks to my untutored eye to be brass (yellow) treble reeds, but with steel reeds(?) in the bass on individual plates stamped with the Koch goat.
Yeah, that`s an "orthodox pattern" box treble end like the Klingenthal makers used right through to modern times though probably better made (I had a 70s Worldmaster still made the same way despite being disguised to look like a closed fingerboard) .. the Pre-2915 doesn`t have the goat logo, just KOCH where it would say Hohner in very Hohner like text . I`m sure i`ve seen pics of Hohner era Kochs with the goat on posted here in times past, could be mistaken of course .
I`m sure your box will be very much Pre-Hohner
-
Interestingly, the Hohner catalog No. 700 (late 1920s?) lists a couple of pages of Koch-labeled diatonic button accordions / melodeons. Where the reed metal is specified, these are steel-reeded. A couple of the models are similar to the one that penn just posted, in having one row of buttons and four basses (and the sheet metal air lever), but none are exactly the same as penn's and none have the elephant logo.
I wonder if the brass reed tongues (treble side) and the elephant together on penn's box might be related to an intended export market in the tropical latitudes? Just a speculation.
Yes, Adam, one of these Koch-labeled boxes offered for sale by Hohner in Hohner's catalog No. 700 does have a goat logo on the pressed-wood design.
PG
-
Thanks Paul. Do you have any idea when steel reeds started to become the norm? Presumably there was a time when Steel was considered to be modern and technically advanced and so maybe brass ones helped to keep the price down on some of these low-end boxes?
There's definitely a mash up of features on the 20-30's Koch and Hohner boxes. I've nothing to back it up but I imagine that period would have been a boom time in Trossingen, and I'd imagine the makers would farm out work to those who specialised in certain areas just to keep up with demand. Is that perhaps why Hohner absorbed Koch? Koch had some technology that Hohner wanted?
All pure speculation tho of course.
Steve