Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Stewartkent on August 16, 2013, 09:04:30 AM
-
Hi I'm Stewart age 66 never played a musical instrument in my life and can't read music! But been to a few sessions in Cornwall and am really taken by the Melodeon. A really nice guy has hired me one for 6 months DG Hohner. Can I succeed at my age! How long before I can play a tune! So many books CD's out there any recommendations folks?
Cheers!
-
You will do better with a teacher, even a 2row offers several ways of fingering a tune, and these can be a bit bewildering until you have internalised a few "ways". After the first few pieces are working it tends to be more about stringing pre learned segments together. Your tutor will also hopefully be into local session repertoire
if you haven't anyone in mind, suggest you post your town location here. There is often someone commutable who is willing to help you get going. do also consult the pinned list, top of this "board"
… or if you fancy an expedition to Whitby, beginners' hero George Garside runs morning sessions aimed at "first 3-4 tunes". I hope to assist him, it starts this Sunday :|glug
-
Can I succeed at my age!
Yes!
How long before I can play a tune!
Not long! Pick a simple tune - watch someone playing it on a DG box online, figure out how to play the basic chords on the left hand, play the melody on the right hand, then work on fitting them together. Initially you will be confused by the push/pull aspect, but you should quickly get the hang of it. The melodeon is inherently a simple instrument designed to make it easy to play simple tunes with minimum of fuss.
-
Try contacting Ed Rennie at Devon Squeezebox foundation.
-
Can I succeed at my age!
Yes!
How long before I can play a tune!
Not long! Pick a simple tune - watch someone playing it on a DG box online, figure out how to play the basic chords on the left hand, play the melody on the right hand, then work on fitting them together. Initially you will be confused by the push/pull aspect, but you should quickly get the hang of it. The melodeon is inherently a simple instrument designed to make it easy to play simple tunes with minimum of fuss.
I know its a hackneyed tune, but Three Blind Mice is a good one to start with! Or 'Twinke, Twinkle, little star'.
Personally, I'd forget about the left hand until you can play a tune confidently on the right.
If you want a more 'folky' tune, then start with The Keel Row.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xXB4y4tEe4U
It's also worth just practising scales - up and down - until you are confident about where your fingers go and how to do the 'push/pull' bit.
Do full octave scales (all 8 notes) starting at the bottom of the scale, then come all the way back down. Do the same, but starting at the top of the octave, go all the way down, then all the way back up again.
Then do Octave plus 1 note - 9 notes in all, starting at the bottom, and coming all the way back down.
Then practice 3 note arpeggios, 3 notes up and 3 notes down, using just Push, then using just Pull.
Also check out the videos by Daddy Long Les, one of our regulars!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P5L3fBXGL48
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kJ7N_2TsNsY
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zu0m0JPQyx0
Always remember that we were all in the same position as you once! Practice and perseverance is all you need! ;)
Cheers
Pikey
-
Try contacting Ed Rennie at Devon Squeezebox foundation.
Ed's tutor book with accompanying CD and DVD highly recommended. I found this particularly good because you can use the DVD to see both ends of the box in action, this was invaluable for me compared to just reading from a book and trying to match the sounds I was making with the sound of a CD.
Mind you I started playing at the incredibly early age of just 40 ;) :||:
Other tutor books are of course available. Most of them can be found on E-Bay, including 'The Melodeon Tutor'.
-
Stewart, I started in my 70's and I'm fairly competent after 18 months or so. Get stuck in and just enjoy... :||: ;)
-
I started at the age of 50 and used The D/G Melodeon Absolute Beginners book and CD by Dave Mallinson. I was playing a couple of tunes hesitantly within a week, using the right hand only and had begun to add a simple bass accompaniment within a couple of months.
A student I taught a couple of years ago started in his mid-70s and made good progress. The key to success is regular practice - at least an hour a day and preferably more. If you are enjoying it and have sufficient self-discipline to keep to a regular practice regime, there is no reason why you shouldn't succeed. Help from a good tutor, like Ed Rennie in Devon, would be a definite advantage, but it is not essential. Living in a remote area with no access to tutors when I began, I worked entirely from tutorial books and CDs for the first couple of years. Nowadays, there are DVDs available, which can provide additional visual support. You can also seek advice on this forum.
Go for it!
-
The key to success is regular practice - at least an hour a day and preferably more.
Like (:)
Also don't be afraid to ask 'silly' questions, you'll probably find 10 other beginners wondering the same thing but afraid to ask. There are no silly questions (although you might get the odd silly answer) Box players tend to be a helpful and friendly lot.
-
Hi I'm Stewart age 66 never played a musical instrument in my life and can't read music! But been to a few sessions in Cornwall and am really taken by the Melodeon. A really nice guy has hired me one for 6 months DG Hohner. Can I succeed at my age! How long before I can play a tune! So many books CD's out there any recommendations folks?
Cheers!
Hi Stewart and welcome to melnet and the wonderful world of melodeons. I started two years ago aged 58 and although I am a musician (guitarist) by trade, I did find it hard at first but, trust me, it does get easier. All of my stuff relating to the melodeon can be found on my website www.daddylongles.com
Watch as many videos as you can on here just to get a general feel of how it's done. Don't go too mad with the practising at first as this can lead to aches and pains - gently does it at first!
I wish you lots of joy on your journey
Best Wishes
Les
-
Hi Les
Thanks so much for your support......and yes I'm already viewing you on Youtube!
Stewart
-
Hi Les
Thanks so much for your support......and yes I'm already viewing you on Youtube!
Stewart
PS You WILL ache a bit as your muscles get used to doing things they haven't done before. Stick with it!
-
Yes, it does get some getting used to, but, compared to most instruments, the initial learning curve is relatively fast - it's much easier to produce a clean note with a melodeon than with a stringed instrument, or a woodwind or brass instrument.
-
Hello Stewart
I'm another who started post-70 (doncha know that once you hit 60, it's best to stop counting?) and I taught myself as buttonbox players in my neck of the woods are few and far between. So <Can I succeed at my age!> Sure you can. <How long before I can play a tune!> As many have said already, pretty soon. It is not a great question to ask because if someone says you will be able to hack out a tune in, say, three weeks, and you fail to match that, you begin to have self-doubts. Everyone learns at a different pace. If it takes you three months to learn that tune, who cares?
One thing is certain, there is tons of good advice on this site.
My 2-1/2 cents worth.
Michael
-
Hi Stewart I'm 58 and started playing DG just over 3 months ago I've joined a local Morris side and am busy learning lots of new tunes.My advice would be , go for it ,try and find a tutor if you can and in my experience players are more than happy to offer advice and encouragement. I wish you every success you're in for some great fun. Oh! And with reference to MichaelM's reply..when I hit 60 I intend to start counting.......backwards!
-
Welcome to the forum, and the wild and crazy world of button accordion Stewart. If possible, please go to an instructor. Not only will an instructor teach you the proper fingering but they will also give you tunes to play that are at your skill level. For example, a simple Irish jig, "Tripping up the Stairs", can be played on four buttons on your D row. When you self teach, you will hear a tune you like, and not realizing it's difficulty, you try in vain to learn it. I have done this many, many times. I eventually learned the tunes but I wish I had a good instructor at the time. It would have saved a lot of frustration. Don't worry about your age, you are never too old to learn and playing music is good exercise for the brain. Anything you need to know can be found here as there are many expert players and repairers who know all about melodeons on this forum. You are in very good hands here. So go ahead and enjoy your new pride and joy. Good luck and keep squeezin'. :||:
-
Beautifully put! ;D
-
First of all, may I echo everyone else's welcome, and no, you're definitely not too old to be starting. Now I may be going against the general flow of opinion here, but I don't think a teacher will necessarily be the right route for everyone. I absolutely accept that for many - maybe even most - learners a teacher may well suit, but I never ever had a teacher and I'm very glad I didn't. It left my mind open to all manner of styles, tricks and techniques that I picked up along the way. There are lots of ways to approach a tune, and I would dispute that there is any such thing as "proper fingering"; the proper fingering is the one that suits you. If you feel you need a teacher, there are many excellent ones about and I am confident you will benefit greatly from their services; I would never actively DISCOURAGE anyone from going to a teacher. Just be aware that there are no hard and fast rules in melodeon playing, so take the route that works for you.
All the best - look forward to your first Tune Of The Month posting!
Graham
-
Graham's right. A tutor is not necessarily the way to go.
For me it was hanging around with other melodeon players and picking up all their good/bad habits.
GPS is also correct saying, there is no right or wrong way to play the machine, if you can't find other players then YouTube is a Godsend.
-
Welcome to the forum, and the wild and crazy world of button accordion Stewart.
I seem to have made a terrible mistake. I didn't know this was a button accordion site - I thought it was a limerick writing site. >:E
-
Welcome to the forum, and the wild and crazy world of button accordion Stewart.
I seem to have made a terrible mistake. I didn't know this was a button accordion site - I thought it was a limerick writing site. >:E
;)
-
Graham's right. A tutor is not necessarily the way to go.
For me it was hanging around with other melodeon players and picking up all their good/bad habits.
GPS is also correct saying, there is no right or wrong way to play the machine, if you can't find other players then YouTube is a Godsend.
I agree that a tutor is not right for everyone. I'm hopeless and being taught, but pretty good at learning from putting together bits and pieces and making something of them. YMMV - I imagine that individuals learn in different ways.
In any event, it's not too late. Good luck.
Cheers
Steve
-
Opinion seems to be against tutelage, though I'd still advocate a mentor in the initial stages. Others might be able to de-contextualise how to hold the box, that certain LH chords go against certain RH "phrases" etc from youtube, but I feel a bit of sound advice early on avoids embedding really bad habits, eg working out some rational but non melodeonic fingering for a tune, and then wondering why you can't find chords to work against it ???
Thereafter, well yes, we do all have our own journey "depending on what you like". I fondly recall the previous poster who once said to me "y'know Chris, right through that tune your bellows were going … the opposite direction from mine"! ;)
When I started up on melodeon there was no one to hand. In contrast my earlier steps on guitar were much assisted by Dave Wood, who incidentally ran Whitby's first Folk Week. Moved me from strumming to picking, and was a useful start in music.
-
Opinion seems to be against tutelage,
Oh, I don't know - it seems reasonably evenly divided to me! A teacher will suit some and not others - it will depend on how you learn, how intuitive a musician you are, whether you have any previous musical experience on any other instrument. If it's your bag, I'm all for it; if it's not, then it's fine to do without.
Graham
-
Opinion seems to be against tutelage,
Oh, I don't know - it seems reasonably evenly divided to me! A teacher will suit some and not others - it will depend on how you learn, how intuitive a musician you are, whether you have any previous musical experience on any other instrument. If it's your bag, I'm all for it; if it's not, then it's fine to do without.
Graham
No, I agree with Graham's summary. I was only questioning the automatic assumption (which is prevalent in many walks of life) that everything is best formally taught. If that's the way that you're happy to learn, then of course it's fine.
Cheers
Steve
-
The best advice I was given when I first started playing 18 months ago was to never put my melodeon away in it's box! It means that because it is in sight (usually sat on the floor by the sofa) I pick it up and play - sometimes only for 5-10 minutes - every time I walk past. The practice soon adds up when you are doing that all day!
-
The best advice I was given when I first started playing 18 months ago was to never put my melodeon away in it's box! It means that because it is in sight (usually sat on the floor by the sofa) I pick it up and play - sometimes only for 5-10 minutes - every time I walk past. The practice soon adds up when you are doing that all day!
Very true and it's been said many times, a few minutes every day etc. however I'm not sure leaving it out of its case is a good idea. They are quite vulnerable to being tripped over. In the case with the lid open is a far better option. ;D
-
My opinion , for what it's worth, is that practise is the main thing. Whether or not you go to a tutor is a matter of personal choice.Personally, because I am an awkward sod, I never had any formal training because I was determined to do it my way. I have, however, had some fantastic help along the way from people too numerous to list here.I also started at 10
-
Sorry-Sent unfinished!!
I also started at 10 so I suppose that's a bit different.
Regarding the practising-You will be amazed the difference it makes. I got to the point where I probably only picked the box up for about 3 weekends a year and thought that was perfectly fine. Suddenly I realised that my playing was going down the pan.Fortunately this realisation coincided with obtaining a new(to me)box,albeit via a sad death,which gave me the "excuse" to play a bit at home.
I was so amazed at the difference it made(although others will probably say differently)that I now seldom go more than a couple of days without a 5 min "bash".
So buy earplugs for the rest of the family and practise like mad!!!
-
;D
-
Hi all,
I'm a total novice who has wanted to play the melodeon for some time now. I am without instrument at the moment, so any advice re make and key of melodeon would be helpful, as I intend to buy one very soon. Some say that BC is good for Irish and Scottish Tunes, I'm not sure how much truth there is in that but that type of tune is what i would want to play mostly. I live in the Carmarthen area and ideally would need some tuition, at least to get me started. I'm in my early 50's, many thanks
-
Do you want ultimately to be able to play in sessions with other musicians in your area or perhaps play for a morris side? If so, it would be a good idea to contact these people and see what keys they play in most often. I suspect the answer will be D and G. These keys are possible on a B/C box, but they are easier on a D/G. I suggest you research the local scene before you commit yourself.
-
Hohner or Black Diamond.
B/C is hard to pick up from scratch ,and you'd need someone to teach you.
Best bet is a D/G , you can play Irish on it, and Scottish , and English, and Welsh, and it wil make life easier if you want to play with others at some stage (and you will!).
-
Plus wot Bob said....... ;)
-
Try your hardest to make it to a festival or day event if you can. Most run a begginers workshop, and most folk festivals have friendly boxplayers. I've never met a box player who said they didn't want to show me a trick/teach me a tune etc.
Generally speaking folkies are a brilliant bunch, and its very rare I (in my experience) have ever met a box player who thinks they are superior to anyone else/damns a beginner or criticises anyone during a session.
Trust me, you bang out your first tune (even if its one hand or with simple basses) in a session, people should support you (you still lead hopefully) and you should get a big round of applause. Great feeling and really encouraging.
Some people feel like their playing is rubbish if they sit in a session with another boxplayer that knows every tune, fiddly fingering bits and has perfect bellows control. Instead they should talk to that person and extract as much information as they can. As I say most boxplayers would be pleased to chat about boxes and techniques (geek alert :D) These people don't see that all boxplayers are really eternal leaners. ;)
To the layman, even playing one hand looks bloomin' hard (:)
Also, buy a nice £5000 box as an incentive to play it and not leave it sitting unplayed. ;) >:E
And you can try out boxes at festivals too. New, used, different keys and (if they let you) other peoples boxes. Great asset.
-
We do have an absolute beginners to "toddlers" session going on in Evesham at the end of November called Melodeon Playgroup - we did one last year which went down well, so we're doing it again. :)
If any of you are interested, have a look at the thread in Events, find the Facebook event or give me a PM.
-
Another vote for Mally's "Absolute Beginner" book.
One step at a time, at your own speed, with CD/MP3 for reality check, good tune selection.
-
Opinion seems to be against tutelage, though I'd still advocate a mentor in the initial stages. Others might be able to de-contextualise how to hold the box, that certain LH chords go against certain RH "phrases" etc from youtube, but I feel a bit of sound advice early on avoids embedding really bad habits, eg working out some rational but non melodeonic fingering for a tune, and then wondering why you can't find chords to work against it ???
Thereafter, well yes, we do all have our own journey "depending on what you like". I fondly recall the previous poster who once said to me "y'know Chris, right through that tune your bellows were going … the opposite direction from mine"! ;)
When I started up on melodeon there was no one to hand. In contrast my earlier steps on guitar were much assisted by Dave Wood, who incidentally ran Whitby's first Folk Week. Moved me from strumming to picking, and was a useful start in music.
I knew Dave! He ran a kids folk weekend when I was 15 !